Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Alien/space creature day at school

187 replies

VGY3 · 08/02/2024 09:48

We were informed a few weeks ago that school is doing it today. The memo was to 'be creative' and 'make' something to come to school in.. as an alien or space creature.

Me and DS worked together to make his. He was proud as punch and excited to show his friends.. until we got to school and saw that most of the other children in the class were in shop bought (proper) costumes. He then felt "silly" about his costume not being a "real one" and didn't want to wear it anymore.

I know people can be pushed for time, I am too, 3 kids and work ft, but we've had weeks. How hard is it to stick some googly eyes on a piece of card?

There was some hand made ones available in the class for children who's parents didn't participate, so nobody would feel left out. There was no need to go out and splurge on pricy costumes.

AIBU to feel a bit peeved?

OP posts:
Yesnosorryplease · 08/02/2024 10:52

VGY3 · 08/02/2024 10:36

In our case it's because the theme for the term is outer space. They've been to the science museum, learning about planets etc. This is tied into it.

They could read, "Whatever Next" and re-enact that. All you need is a cardboard box, a colander or sieve and some wellies! We've played having a picnic on the moon many times here.

Or read/watch the Button Moon stories and make wooden spoon creatures / aliens

Or use bottles to make rockets, thinking about what features would help them fly

There's so many ways to actually benefit the learning around the topic, and I produce creativity, without the stress and upset dressing up causes.

ColleenDonaghy · 08/02/2024 10:41

VGY3 · 08/02/2024 10:36

In our case it's because the theme for the term is outer space. They've been to the science museum, learning about planets etc. This is tied into it.

Yeah but a dress up day doesn't hugely add to that. Loads more interesting and easily accessible ways to get parents and children working together. In P1 we did a lot of A4 posters which are great because most houses will have some paper and markers so it's early to access and the ones who love crafty stuff can go all out if they want.

Dress up is just a pain.

Needmorelego · 08/02/2024 10:39

@MissyB1 well we need the next generation of clothes and costume designers to learn these skills don't we?
It's all education - if actually done at school!

VGY3 · 08/02/2024 10:36

MissyB1 · 08/02/2024 10:35

I’m another one who thinks wtf was this alien dress up day all about? What was the learning? Why do schools keep coming up with more and more dress up days? Surely it’s a pita for the staff as well? Kids end up
un totally impractical clothes that aren’t fit for the playground/weather/going to the toilet. Inevitably during the day they lose bits and get uncomfortable.

In our case it's because the theme for the term is outer space. They've been to the science museum, learning about planets etc. This is tied into it.

OP posts:
TeabySea · 08/02/2024 10:35

It was ever thus. Whatever the theme was for dressing up, the parents who weren't creative/worked full time/cba would just buy costumes. A handful of people made things.
We explained to DC that some people don't have time to make things, or don't feel confident about it, so they buy them.

MissyB1 · 08/02/2024 10:35

I’m another one who thinks wtf was this alien dress up day all about? What was the learning? Why do schools keep coming up with more and more dress up days? Surely it’s a pita for the staff as well? Kids end up
un totally impractical clothes that aren’t fit for the playground/weather/going to the toilet. Inevitably during the day they lose bits and get uncomfortable.

MrsSkylerWhite · 08/02/2024 10:34

I finally learned after days and days making a where the wild things are fake fur costume from scratch: parents will look at a homemade and think that’s great. Kids: that’s rubbish, I want to be shop bought Mike from Monsters inc. like my friend 😁

VGY3 · 08/02/2024 10:32

Peeved in general, It's just shit for the children who do go wearing homemade as, like PP said, they feel bad because 'proper' costumes are perceived as much cooler and better despite their own effort.

I'm certainly not annoyed with the children themselves. We're talking about reception age children.

I think making the costumes/masks as an art class in school and using those is a really good idea so everybody is on an even keel. The environmental points made are also spot on.

OP posts:
Needmorelego · 08/02/2024 10:32

I mean space creature is easy - just wrap some tin foil around the kid.
If children aren't learning how to be creative at school - then how are they going to make costumes for their future children?
Campaign for more art and crafts at school!

ColleenDonaghy · 08/02/2024 10:31

KreedKafer · 08/02/2024 10:25

I'm sorry, but YABU. I agree that in an ideal world it would be really nice if every parent spent lots of time with their child crafting a costume from scratch. But plenty of parents just don't have a clue where to start with that sort of thing - and not all kids are particularly interested in getting involved in making things, either. You are lucky that you and your son had fun together working on this and that you had the time and the creative brain for it. But not everyone does, and that doesn't make them a worse parent than you and it isn't really any of your business.

Not everyone can get to grips with the Blue Peter approach of making something out of a cereal packet and a yogurt pot. Plus, I know from friends who actually are very creative that they often end up having to spend more money to make a costume than they do to buy something from eBay. People don't necessarily have lots craft materials sitting at home ready to use. There's only so much you can do with a packet of kids' felt-tips, some printer paper and a Pritt stick.

Also, not all the costumes you saw would have been bought new anyway. Plenty will have been in the cupboard ever since the last fancy dress party/Halloween/previous dress-up day at school that the kids went to, or that their older siblings or cousins or neighbours went to.

Ultimately, it's not as if other parents bought costumes to be competitive or to spite your child, so being 'peeved' is a very unreasonable reaction.

You said it better than me, this is what I meant.

ColleenDonaghy · 08/02/2024 10:29

I just can't imagine getting worked up about a fancy dress day at school. If DD had an idea she wanted to do, then I'd do my best with what time I had and what materials we had in the house (i.e. it would be shit). If she wasn't bothered or didn't like arts and crafts then I'd be ordering something.

Parents are busy enough these days as it is, a fancy dress day will be way down the list of priorities.

SisterMichaelsHabit · 08/02/2024 10:27

Wasbedeudetetdas · 08/02/2024 10:05

I'd most likely have to buy something and feel guilty that the other mums were judging me for not being the perfect mother.

@SisterMichaelsHabit I feel that it's sad that some children don't get the chance to make things at home, but I wouldn't judge anyone not knowing their circumstances. I do think people underestimate how 'good' home made costumes have to be though, they don't have to be elaborate (in fact I can envisage a bin bag with some adornments easily becoming an alien costume....).

Before buying things I always raid the house but we rarely have anything that we could use for the random specific thing they want this week. I cut up one of my maternity dresses to give him an elf costume for Christmas when I was pregnant with his sister as we had no Christmas jumper for nursery. I look forward to when we can finally buy a house and set up an area where we can leave things to dry/set/not get destroyed by a toddler. Or even put our table up!

We've never had aliens though. I must admit I wouldn't have tried a plastic bag (bin or otherwise) as DS is a very young 4 and knowing him he'd get stuck in it unable to breathe, but when the kids are older I think it's easier. I saw on here that there used to be 5 packs of T-shirts from H+M that were great for costumes but when I went to buy a set the colours were naff and the set was quite expensive.

Having said that, our costumes never end up in landfill. We reuse them as many times as we can. Everything gets passed down to DD and the kids love dressing up at home. People often mistake DD for a boy as she's usually in boys' clothes. 🤣

This thread has been really thought provoking as we've been debating smaller house with lower mortgage or bigger house with more mortgage, and I think we need a bit more space to do things like this after being crammed into this tiny rental since we came to this country.

KreedKafer · 08/02/2024 10:25

I'm sorry, but YABU. I agree that in an ideal world it would be really nice if every parent spent lots of time with their child crafting a costume from scratch. But plenty of parents just don't have a clue where to start with that sort of thing - and not all kids are particularly interested in getting involved in making things, either. You are lucky that you and your son had fun together working on this and that you had the time and the creative brain for it. But not everyone does, and that doesn't make them a worse parent than you and it isn't really any of your business.

Not everyone can get to grips with the Blue Peter approach of making something out of a cereal packet and a yogurt pot. Plus, I know from friends who actually are very creative that they often end up having to spend more money to make a costume than they do to buy something from eBay. People don't necessarily have lots craft materials sitting at home ready to use. There's only so much you can do with a packet of kids' felt-tips, some printer paper and a Pritt stick.

Also, not all the costumes you saw would have been bought new anyway. Plenty will have been in the cupboard ever since the last fancy dress party/Halloween/previous dress-up day at school that the kids went to, or that their older siblings or cousins or neighbours went to.

Ultimately, it's not as if other parents bought costumes to be competitive or to spite your child, so being 'peeved' is a very unreasonable reaction.

Yesnosorryplease · 08/02/2024 10:18

But the dressing up isn't the learning experience is it?

So either they make it in school so that they all do the art part, or they mandate it has to be homemade and risk some kids not doing it/some parents having a meltdown (me)

But there's no need to keep having topic days where the end result is loads of people ordering tat off Amazon.

WandaWonder · 08/02/2024 10:18

Whatever schools do it would be wrong, people will always find things to complain about

Should be home made, don't have time so buy then the home made people cry 'it has to be home made' then people complain as 'it's just another thing I have to organise' then they forget so their child gets up 'now my child is crying they need to ban it'

Is anyone happy ever?

Needmorelego · 08/02/2024 10:17

Suggest for next time they make the costumes as their art class.

TouseMrap · 08/02/2024 10:17

Some people always does this, I bet he looked great and I'm sure he had fun making it. That's awesome the school has some bits for children who's parents have done nought.

Wasbedeudetetdas · 08/02/2024 10:14

@Yesnosorryplease speaking from my/DC perspective, the learning experience was definitely in terms of creativity - both in imagination and in actually doing it. Of course I helped but I certainly didn't do it for him. DS still remembers making things together as a child.

Wasbedeudetetdas · 08/02/2024 10:12

SouthLondonMum22 · 08/02/2024 10:10

Yep.

I'm never going to be the DIY, everything homemade mum and it simply isn't my priority to be one when I have other things going on that take up more of my time.

Well, clearly it's up you what you prioritise, and for fear of repeating my earlier comment we will leave it there.

ICanSeeMyHouseFromHere · 08/02/2024 10:11

For a start, our school gives a lot of notice of this sort of thing. Then, there's not actually any pressure - some kids (like my oldest) never like costumes, so they never do it at all. Finally, we have a mix of home-made and bought, and they reflect that in the 'best dressed' prizes - there's one for bought costumes, and one for home-made ones (but again, it's all done in a friendly manner, no-one feels like they're missing out)

New2024 · 08/02/2024 10:11

Oh, but I’m more worried they are teaching them their are aliens out there 😂

Yesnosorryplease · 08/02/2024 10:11

I think school should have done the mask making it something in school and then they'd all have something of a similar standard.

I think there's a few issues with these dress up days.

A - what is the learning benefit? What do the kids actually get out of being too hot/cold/itchy for the day? Is it a better learning experience than if they were just wearing their normal uniform etc.

B - I would love to be a "make it" mum but I have 3 DC, a DH who works away and I work ft myself. Craft makes me want to hide. I feel overwhelmed by the mess and very underwhelmed by the results. My DC end up distressed by how rubbish our output looks and we all cry.

C - many people will end up buying off Amazon in desperation. This costs money and is bad for the environment. Takes me back to point A.

There's a school near us where they dress up All. The. Time. Every single topic they do has an associated dress up day. This just results in multiple posts on local parent FB groups looking for a Victorian/evacuee/Mayan/Roman/Tudor/Greek outfit and they all buy a prepackaged kit off Amazon or each other . I cannot see the point at all and genuinely think that parents of DC at that school must spend hundreds of ££ more than the rest of us do over the primary school years.

New2024 · 08/02/2024 10:10

Our first primary usually made it slightly competitive - ie best costume gets a certificate and a chocolate - in order to encourage people to make their own or (more likely) get parent to 😂

SouthLondonMum22 · 08/02/2024 10:10

Wasbedeudetetdas · 08/02/2024 09:59

Even though the memo stated to 'be creative' and 'make something'?

Yep.

I'm never going to be the DIY, everything homemade mum and it simply isn't my priority to be one when I have other things going on that take up more of my time.

Wasbedeudetetdas · 08/02/2024 10:05

I'd most likely have to buy something and feel guilty that the other mums were judging me for not being the perfect mother.

@SisterMichaelsHabit I feel that it's sad that some children don't get the chance to make things at home, but I wouldn't judge anyone not knowing their circumstances. I do think people underestimate how 'good' home made costumes have to be though, they don't have to be elaborate (in fact I can envisage a bin bag with some adornments easily becoming an alien costume....).