Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Alien/space creature day at school

187 replies

VGY3 · 08/02/2024 09:48

We were informed a few weeks ago that school is doing it today. The memo was to 'be creative' and 'make' something to come to school in.. as an alien or space creature.

Me and DS worked together to make his. He was proud as punch and excited to show his friends.. until we got to school and saw that most of the other children in the class were in shop bought (proper) costumes. He then felt "silly" about his costume not being a "real one" and didn't want to wear it anymore.

I know people can be pushed for time, I am too, 3 kids and work ft, but we've had weeks. How hard is it to stick some googly eyes on a piece of card?

There was some hand made ones available in the class for children who's parents didn't participate, so nobody would feel left out. There was no need to go out and splurge on pricy costumes.

AIBU to feel a bit peeved?

OP posts:
VGY3 · 08/02/2024 14:35

ColleenDonaghy · 08/02/2024 14:26

Completely agree that his reaction is fair enough for a 4 year old, but it's your job to teach him how to understand that different families have different abilities and priorities as well as how to handle disappointment which is far more important than making sure he never experiences it.

It's not your job to make sure all the other parents parent in the way that you would like in order to minimise disappointment in your son.

Of course, but at the point of realising how many children were in 'proper' costumes it was time to go in. I will absolutely be having a chat about it after school and hopefully he will feel better about it, but he's had the whole day there feeling self conscious and embarrassed.

I guess it's a learning curve for main stream primary school. It genuinely did not occur to me that people would be buying from shops/online as the fliers specifically said to make something.

OP posts:
SouthLondonMum22 · 08/02/2024 14:32

Heather37231 · 08/02/2024 14:28

It’s not about “making a random child happy”. It’s about not causing distress to a classmate.

Presumably you’d care if your child’s behaviour was causing distress to a classmate?

Shame you can’t own it when it’s your behaviour causing the distress.

Distress is reaching a bit. He was disappointed which is a perfectly normal emotion to feel and OP's job is to manage that as his parent, as well as future expectations when it comes to costume days.

Different families work in different ways and school is the perfect way to learn that.

VGY3 · 08/02/2024 14:32

Everanewbie · 08/02/2024 14:26

Interesting question OP. I really don't feel you are unreasonable to feel peeved. You worked hard with your child, having fun and lovely moments along the way, only for the day to arrive and your child felt like they had the worst costume. You did great, you are a great mum and I can understand that you feel deflated.

It is the easiest thing in the world for (most, accept some people are hard up before anyone jumps down my throat) a parent to just get their debit card out, and it must be hard to hear complaints when you've genuinely tried your best.

I don't think you're really hating on parents who didn't have the time or the skills, you've just seen your efforts and a beautiful memory go unappreciated. While a parent that gets their purse out in Tesco is a hero. One day you'll laugh about like the time I complained to my mother about the fact I didn't have a childminder and had never tried a pot noodle, life is so unfair!!!

Thank you for such a kind post ❤️

You've hit the nail on the head.

OP posts:
OrionStridesIn · 08/02/2024 14:32

I know they made no effort to read and follow the rules set by the school. Don’t really care about what other effort they’re putting in elsewhere.
*
Do these parents also just hand in whatever homework they fancy their kid doing, instead of what the school actually sets?*

You're a charmer, aren't you?

I know single mothers are still social pariahs, but you 'don't really care what other effort they are putting in elsewhere'. Interesting that you can give no credence to the point I made about the effort it takes to effectively be two parents with all that entails, and why hand making costumes would be more than an irritation.

Funnily enough, as well as school dress-up days, their homework isn't high on my agenda either. Given that I work full time myself, run the house by myself, and do everything else for them by myself. Oooh aren't I a terrible mother!

They know they can ask me for help with homework btw but other than that it's down to them.

TinyTear · 08/02/2024 14:30

VGY3 · 08/02/2024 11:33

If you can't be arsed to do an activity with your child then just say that 🙄🍪

I work full time, my DH works full time, we have swimming and other activities. I am not making a stupid costume for a dress up day.

If it's a play or a proper activity I will try and help (made a gorgon's head one year) but often buying is the best option

Stay on your high horse, hope the weather is lovely up there... and you have space for a your lovely crafts which some people hate with a passion

no one will ever say i have made my kids homework for them as i hate crafts!

Everanewbie · 08/02/2024 14:30

Oh and by the way OP, ignore some of the mean comments on here. If you started ranting and raving to every parent in the playground about how hard you worked and how they took the easy option and they're shit and responsible for your child being upset, yes, you'd be unreasonable. To to have a moment of disappointment to yourself, where you are upset and crestfallen. No. Anyone who says this is unreasonable, to me, feels like they're the ones that take the easy option and resent you signposting it to them.

VGY3 · 08/02/2024 14:29

SouthLondonMum22 · 08/02/2024 14:22

It would absolutely be because it isn't a priority to me unless my DC had an idea and insisted it be homemade but more likely, it would be bought. Funnily enough, my choices aren't going to revolve around what may or may not make a random child in the class happy.

Your choices are clearly not going to resolve around what the school requested either.

They asked people to make things, not buy.

If you're not going to do as asked then just don't participate. Your child will still get to enjoy the experience when they get there as school makes surplus masks etc. for children who don't come in wearing anything from home.

OP posts:
SonyaBoot · 08/02/2024 14:28

This reply has been withdrawn

Withdrawn at OP's request.

Bythefireside · 08/02/2024 14:28

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Did you not read her post she didn’t sneer once. She was gutted her son felt his costume wasn’t as good that’s it.

Heather37231 · 08/02/2024 14:28

SouthLondonMum22 · 08/02/2024 14:22

It would absolutely be because it isn't a priority to me unless my DC had an idea and insisted it be homemade but more likely, it would be bought. Funnily enough, my choices aren't going to revolve around what may or may not make a random child in the class happy.

It’s not about “making a random child happy”. It’s about not causing distress to a classmate.

Presumably you’d care if your child’s behaviour was causing distress to a classmate?

Shame you can’t own it when it’s your behaviour causing the distress.

ColleenDonaghy · 08/02/2024 14:26

VGY3 · 08/02/2024 14:20

Christ. This is me focusing on my child, as the whole thing is about how my child feels.

My child was NOT being precious, how dare you? His reaction is perfectly proportionate for a child of 4.

Completely agree that his reaction is fair enough for a 4 year old, but it's your job to teach him how to understand that different families have different abilities and priorities as well as how to handle disappointment which is far more important than making sure he never experiences it.

It's not your job to make sure all the other parents parent in the way that you would like in order to minimise disappointment in your son.

Everanewbie · 08/02/2024 14:26

Interesting question OP. I really don't feel you are unreasonable to feel peeved. You worked hard with your child, having fun and lovely moments along the way, only for the day to arrive and your child felt like they had the worst costume. You did great, you are a great mum and I can understand that you feel deflated.

It is the easiest thing in the world for (most, accept some people are hard up before anyone jumps down my throat) a parent to just get their debit card out, and it must be hard to hear complaints when you've genuinely tried your best.

I don't think you're really hating on parents who didn't have the time or the skills, you've just seen your efforts and a beautiful memory go unappreciated. While a parent that gets their purse out in Tesco is a hero. One day you'll laugh about like the time I complained to my mother about the fact I didn't have a childminder and had never tried a pot noodle, life is so unfair!!!

Needmorelego · 08/02/2024 14:25

@Heather37231 yes that was the character 🙂

OneTC · 08/02/2024 14:25

YANBU and please tell me what space creature you went for 👏

VGY3 · 08/02/2024 14:25

ColleenDonaghy · 08/02/2024 14:21

Her son's feelings are for OP to manage. It's hard enough for parents to ration their resources (i.e. time and money!) for their own DC, I don't think they need to factor in other DC's disappointment as well.

Factor in other DC's disappointment? Or just following the instruction set by the school which was to make something.

Buying a costume undermines the whole purpose which was to be creative.

If you haven't got the time or finances to make something then fine, that's not a problem, school provided hand made things for children in those circumstances.

OP posts:
Heather37231 · 08/02/2024 14:24

OrionStridesIn · 08/02/2024 14:19

Well when other people’s lack of effort, disregard of the brief and rampant consumerism results in her child being unhappy and made to think his home made costume is shit I think she has every right to care what other parents did.

You have no idea of other people's circumstances @Heather37231. Don't accuse them of 'lack of effort' when you have no idea of the effort they may be making on a daily basis. I have to put in the effort of two parents to do everything for my kids, whilst working a stressful full time job, having health concerns etc. I'm never impressed when schools make requests like these and am glad mine has cut back on it.

I know they made no effort to read and follow the rules set by the school. Don’t really care about what other effort they’re putting in elsewhere.

Do these parents also just hand in whatever homework they fancy their kid doing, instead of what the school actually sets?

SouthLondonMum22 · 08/02/2024 14:22

Heather37231 · 08/02/2024 14:07

Well when other people’s lack of effort, disregard of the brief and rampant consumerism results in her child being unhappy and made to think his home made costume is shit I think she has every right to care what other parents did.

It would absolutely be because it isn't a priority to me unless my DC had an idea and insisted it be homemade but more likely, it would be bought. Funnily enough, my choices aren't going to revolve around what may or may not make a random child in the class happy.

Heather37231 · 08/02/2024 14:22

Part of the issue is the widespread availability of “shop bought” costumes. You couldn’t buy much more than a witch’s hat when I was a kid in the eighties and everybody’s costume was home made. (I bet the North American Tribal costume mentioned by pp from 1971 was brought back by some relative from America).

I refuse to spend a penny on shop bought costumes, it’s obscene to me. There are loads of ideas online for adapting things from clothes or household stuff the family already has, with no sewing. Anyone can Google, just as quickly as they can find a costume for sale online.

And any child who dares bully another about their costume should be dealt with very severely by the school.

I really feel for your child OP. And for you.

ColleenDonaghy · 08/02/2024 14:21

Heather37231 · 08/02/2024 14:07

Well when other people’s lack of effort, disregard of the brief and rampant consumerism results in her child being unhappy and made to think his home made costume is shit I think she has every right to care what other parents did.

Her son's feelings are for OP to manage. It's hard enough for parents to ration their resources (i.e. time and money!) for their own DC, I don't think they need to factor in other DC's disappointment as well.

VGY3 · 08/02/2024 14:20

Farwell · 08/02/2024 14:17

So all parents have to do homemade to prevent one child that is precious about it from being unhappy? Maybe all those other kids would be unhappy in homemade costumes? Is that ok, as long as OP's child is happy?

She needs to focus on her own child not the rest of the class.

Christ. This is me focusing on my child, as the whole thing is about how my child feels.

My child was NOT being precious, how dare you? His reaction is perfectly proportionate for a child of 4.

OP posts:
OrionStridesIn · 08/02/2024 14:19

Well when other people’s lack of effort, disregard of the brief and rampant consumerism results in her child being unhappy and made to think his home made costume is shit I think she has every right to care what other parents did.

You have no idea of other people's circumstances @Heather37231. Don't accuse them of 'lack of effort' when you have no idea of the effort they may be making on a daily basis. I have to put in the effort of two parents to do everything for my kids, whilst working a stressful full time job, having health concerns etc. I'm never impressed when schools make requests like these and am glad mine has cut back on it.

Farwell · 08/02/2024 14:17

Heather37231 · 08/02/2024 14:07

Well when other people’s lack of effort, disregard of the brief and rampant consumerism results in her child being unhappy and made to think his home made costume is shit I think she has every right to care what other parents did.

So all parents have to do homemade to prevent one child that is precious about it from being unhappy? Maybe all those other kids would be unhappy in homemade costumes? Is that ok, as long as OP's child is happy?

She needs to focus on her own child not the rest of the class.

Heather37231 · 08/02/2024 14:08

Needmorelego · 08/02/2024 13:22

@lostonmars I am not sure quite what you mean by that. I was meaning if the parents creative skills aren't up to much.
One of the best World Book Day costumes I ever saw was some tin foil stuck to cardboard shapes and then stuck to the child (Enid Blyton character - I forget the name). A simple easy to make costume.

Saucepan man from Faraway Tree.

Heather37231 · 08/02/2024 14:07

Prinnny · 08/02/2024 11:35

I think it’s weird you’re so bothered about what other parents chose to do with their child. Stop being so judgey not everyone is artistic or has the time or resources to hand make a kids costume. You do you and stop concerning yourself with how others live their life 🙄🙄

Well when other people’s lack of effort, disregard of the brief and rampant consumerism results in her child being unhappy and made to think his home made costume is shit I think she has every right to care what other parents did.

Shadowsindarkplaces · 08/02/2024 14:06

1971, I was in the school fete fancy dress costume as a daisy 'flower girl' DGM made my costume, I looked like a giant daisy, complete with petals.
I came second to a North American Tribal girl. ..in a bought costume, it was very obvious. DGM was fuming. She held on to that for years! 🤣