Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Alien/space creature day at school

187 replies

VGY3 · 08/02/2024 09:48

We were informed a few weeks ago that school is doing it today. The memo was to 'be creative' and 'make' something to come to school in.. as an alien or space creature.

Me and DS worked together to make his. He was proud as punch and excited to show his friends.. until we got to school and saw that most of the other children in the class were in shop bought (proper) costumes. He then felt "silly" about his costume not being a "real one" and didn't want to wear it anymore.

I know people can be pushed for time, I am too, 3 kids and work ft, but we've had weeks. How hard is it to stick some googly eyes on a piece of card?

There was some hand made ones available in the class for children who's parents didn't participate, so nobody would feel left out. There was no need to go out and splurge on pricy costumes.

AIBU to feel a bit peeved?

OP posts:
VGY3 · 08/02/2024 14:56

OrionStridesIn · 08/02/2024 14:53

Weird. Where do you draw the line about rules that you can just ignore and actual rules that make society function properly?

Yes, so important, I've always thought that buying a costume for a reception class dress up day rather than hand making one as specified by the school is akin to drink-driving or burglary

Hmm

You're missing the point.

Would you encourage your child to use a calculator for mathematics just because it saves time and effort?

OP posts:
Heather37231 · 08/02/2024 14:56

ClaudiaWankleman · 08/02/2024 14:51

She doesn't have to teach them anything more than 'you're being silly, why are you upset?' OP acknowledging her child is right to be upset only serves to reinforce the child's idea that their own work/ costume is rubbish.

Yes, telling children that they are silly to feel genuine emotions, that is the way to do it.

Laiste · 08/02/2024 14:56

Heather37231 · Today 14:47

Weird. Where do you draw the line about rules that you can just ignore and actual rules that make society function properly?

I don't teach my child they can chose which rules to ignore. I help them understand that it's not their burden when others don't. That was the point.

OrionStridesIn · 08/02/2024 14:53

Weird. Where do you draw the line about rules that you can just ignore and actual rules that make society function properly?

Yes, so important, I've always thought that buying a costume for a reception class dress up day rather than hand making one as specified by the school is akin to drink-driving or burglary

Hmm
Needmorelego · 08/02/2024 14:51

@ColleenDonaghy yes they don't see the value. It's a shame that the creative side of education isn't valued.
@ClaudiaWankleman I am just going by the million different threads I read on Mumsnet about children and how many hours of homework they should be doing, their clubs and activities, doing "family time" with their parents, the pressure of "passing" their SATS etc.
But god forbid their parents should help and encourage a bit of time with some cardboard and glue.

ClaudiaWankleman · 08/02/2024 14:51

Heather37231 · 08/02/2024 14:35

So OP has to teach her child to have the expectation that the school will set rules for costume days and other parents will completely ignore those rules?

In other words, her child must learn that the way your family works is with selfish disregard of the rules. But that’s her problem. Nice.

She doesn't have to teach them anything more than 'you're being silly, why are you upset?' OP acknowledging her child is right to be upset only serves to reinforce the child's idea that their own work/ costume is rubbish.

ColleenDonaghy · 08/02/2024 14:51

Heather37231 · 08/02/2024 14:47

Weird. Where do you draw the line about rules that you can just ignore and actual rules that make society function properly?

Definitely long before school dress up days.

SouthLondonMum22 · 08/02/2024 14:49

Heather37231 · 08/02/2024 14:44

The option was make something or send child in to use a costume provided by school.

Option 2 requires zero effort by parent.

There was no “buy a costume” option.

That was for if the child came with no costume at all. I imagine they wouldn't have had lots of spares and some children may want to pick their own costume.

Heather37231 · 08/02/2024 14:47

Laiste · 08/02/2024 14:44

So OP has to teach her child to have the expectation that the school will set rules for costume days and other parents will completely ignore those rules?

Erm, yes. It's the way the whole of society works! Some folks follow the rules and others don't - but it's for us to be happy and content with what WE've done and to maybe understand it doesn't matter so much what other's are doing.

If nothing else, this could be one thing to be learned out of fucking dress up days.

Weird. Where do you draw the line about rules that you can just ignore and actual rules that make society function properly?

ColleenDonaghy · 08/02/2024 14:47

Needmorelego · 08/02/2024 14:42

I am curious why some parents will help their children with their spelling, maths and reading homework.
Will send them to swimming lessons.
Will hire tutors for 11+/SATS.
Will take them to museums.
Sign them up for all sorts of activities and clubs.
But school gives them some craft homework to do (because that's what this is) they are all "we're not doing that....I'm far tooooo busy".

Really? Because they're already doing all the other shit you listed and don't see the value in the craft. Some DC will love it, some won't care and even if the parent is willing it'll be like pulling teeth. Some parents will have time for crafting this month but not next month. Some will have the budget next month but not this month.

Everything we do has an opportunity cost and crafting with an unwilling child would be something I would give up in a heartbeat to achieve the other things you've listed.

I can't imagine the teachers care either as long as the parents are typically engaged with their DC's education.

ClaudiaWankleman · 08/02/2024 14:46

Needmorelego · 08/02/2024 14:42

I am curious why some parents will help their children with their spelling, maths and reading homework.
Will send them to swimming lessons.
Will hire tutors for 11+/SATS.
Will take them to museums.
Sign them up for all sorts of activities and clubs.
But school gives them some craft homework to do (because that's what this is) they are all "we're not doing that....I'm far tooooo busy".

Well they don't? The whole premise of your post is made up - there's no indication that anyone here is doing all (or any) of those things. You're the only person who has brought it up.

I think it's called a false dichotomy - someone correct me if I'm wrong. It's been a long time since my English GCSE.

Laiste · 08/02/2024 14:44

So OP has to teach her child to have the expectation that the school will set rules for costume days and other parents will completely ignore those rules?

Erm, yes. It's the way the whole of society works! Some folks follow the rules and others don't - but it's for us to be happy and content with what WE've done and to maybe understand it doesn't matter so much what other's are doing.

If nothing else, this could be one thing to be learned out of fucking dress up days.

Heather37231 · 08/02/2024 14:44

SouthLondonMum22 · 08/02/2024 14:42

So OP has to teach her child to have the expectation that the school will set rules for costume days and other parents will completely ignore those rules?

Considering how many children will continue to turn up with bought costumes, yes.

The school can set costume rules all they like, it's going to be so low down the priority list for so many busy parents that the bought costumes will continue.

If school want to insist on handmade costumes, they can have the children make them at school.

The option was make something or send child in to use a costume provided by school.

Option 2 requires zero effort by parent.

There was no “buy a costume” option.

Thepowerhouseofthecell · 08/02/2024 14:42

This reminds me of the time my child's school did Lords and ladies day when they were learning about castles and Kings etc... and I bought him a flouncey shirt with frills and things off amazon, only to get to school and see all the other boys in normal button up shirts. I felt terrible but luckily he isn't the type to embarrass easily. I've gone a bit more low key since then.

Needmorelego · 08/02/2024 14:42

I am curious why some parents will help their children with their spelling, maths and reading homework.
Will send them to swimming lessons.
Will hire tutors for 11+/SATS.
Will take them to museums.
Sign them up for all sorts of activities and clubs.
But school gives them some craft homework to do (because that's what this is) they are all "we're not doing that....I'm far tooooo busy".

SouthLondonMum22 · 08/02/2024 14:42

Heather37231 · 08/02/2024 14:35

So OP has to teach her child to have the expectation that the school will set rules for costume days and other parents will completely ignore those rules?

In other words, her child must learn that the way your family works is with selfish disregard of the rules. But that’s her problem. Nice.

So OP has to teach her child to have the expectation that the school will set rules for costume days and other parents will completely ignore those rules?

Considering how many children will continue to turn up with bought costumes, yes.

The school can set costume rules all they like, it's going to be so low down the priority list for so many busy parents that the bought costumes will continue.

If school want to insist on handmade costumes, they can have the children make them at school.

OrionStridesIn · 08/02/2024 14:41

@VGY3 that post wasn't even at you, it was replying to Heather, who wanted to disregard other efforts that parents make because apparently school 'rules' are more important than everything else.

Skinhorse · 08/02/2024 14:41

I think schools should stop trying to dictate what families do in their own time and concentrate on teaching the kids.

ColleenDonaghy · 08/02/2024 14:40

VGY3 · 08/02/2024 14:35

Of course, but at the point of realising how many children were in 'proper' costumes it was time to go in. I will absolutely be having a chat about it after school and hopefully he will feel better about it, but he's had the whole day there feeling self conscious and embarrassed.

I guess it's a learning curve for main stream primary school. It genuinely did not occur to me that people would be buying from shops/online as the fliers specifically said to make something.

The important thing to learn is that parents are under pressure, many of them won't have spent more than ten minutes thinking about this. If you made something and you and your son got something out of it then great.

You have to understand that there will be other areas of parenting where other parents don't take the same approach as you because they think a little more effort will be beneficial for their family. They would be out of line to expect you to adjust your decisions on screen time/treats/activities/healthy diet/exercise/language/sleepovers in order to make their lives easier and reduce their DC's disappointment.

You're placing far too much importance on the actions of others.

TinyTear · 08/02/2024 14:39

VGY3 · 08/02/2024 14:36

I was being sarcastic to a poster who had been repeatedly snippy to me, of course I realise people have time/financial constraints.

Ok, I just am useless at crafting and would rather pull my eyebrows out one by one.

Your child is in Reception from what you say, do make sure to teach them that everyone does different things - some make some buy...

good luck 👽

VGY3 · 08/02/2024 14:38

OrionStridesIn · 08/02/2024 14:32

I know they made no effort to read and follow the rules set by the school. Don’t really care about what other effort they’re putting in elsewhere.
*
Do these parents also just hand in whatever homework they fancy their kid doing, instead of what the school actually sets?*

You're a charmer, aren't you?

I know single mothers are still social pariahs, but you 'don't really care what other effort they are putting in elsewhere'. Interesting that you can give no credence to the point I made about the effort it takes to effectively be two parents with all that entails, and why hand making costumes would be more than an irritation.

Funnily enough, as well as school dress-up days, their homework isn't high on my agenda either. Given that I work full time myself, run the house by myself, and do everything else for them by myself. Oooh aren't I a terrible mother!

They know they can ask me for help with homework btw but other than that it's down to them.

I am a single parent.

OP posts:
OrionStridesIn · 08/02/2024 14:38

@VGY3 I'm sure he hasn't had the whole day feeling upset and embarrassed, I hope not anyway. I hope he brightened up once there and enjoyed his day and I'm sure he'll have had nice comments from his teacher and friends.

VGY3 · 08/02/2024 14:36

TinyTear · 08/02/2024 14:30

I work full time, my DH works full time, we have swimming and other activities. I am not making a stupid costume for a dress up day.

If it's a play or a proper activity I will try and help (made a gorgon's head one year) but often buying is the best option

Stay on your high horse, hope the weather is lovely up there... and you have space for a your lovely crafts which some people hate with a passion

no one will ever say i have made my kids homework for them as i hate crafts!

I was being sarcastic to a poster who had been repeatedly snippy to me, of course I realise people have time/financial constraints.

OP posts:
Ineedanewsofa · 08/02/2024 14:36

I’m shit at crafts and I hate the mess, so we never “homemade” anything for the ridiculous dress up requirements our school pulled from the ether! However I’m also really tight, so all costumes are pulled together from items of clothing we already own - notable exception being the £3 lion gilet from vinted for “safari day” (wtf?!). DC has complained that costumes are not the amazon ones others wear, they get told that different people have different budgets, different priorities and different skills and that in the grand scheme of things no one is going to remember what you wore on safari day/roman day/space day. If I were you I’d minimise it, if you don’t each one of these is going to be a nightmare for you.

Heather37231 · 08/02/2024 14:35

SouthLondonMum22 · 08/02/2024 14:32

Distress is reaching a bit. He was disappointed which is a perfectly normal emotion to feel and OP's job is to manage that as his parent, as well as future expectations when it comes to costume days.

Different families work in different ways and school is the perfect way to learn that.

So OP has to teach her child to have the expectation that the school will set rules for costume days and other parents will completely ignore those rules?

In other words, her child must learn that the way your family works is with selfish disregard of the rules. But that’s her problem. Nice.