Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Hours issues at work due to childcare

61 replies

SuzieQ2024 · 08/02/2024 08:24

Hello lovely ladies! Have been a Mumsnet lurker for years and really appreciate the common sense and sisterhood of the posts through infertility, new motherhood etc. So here goes my first one!

Basically I have Mon to Thurs childcare at nursery all year. Fridays I have preschool 9-3 in term-time. I've had issues with workplaces saying they are flexible, it will be fine, and then saying it's not fine/complaining. I 100% absolutely understand the importance of having things in writing but they often won't do this, citing not fair on rest of team.

I've started a new job, still on probation. I couldn't have been clearer about my childcare, work in admin, and can always catch up in evening/weekend if needed. Issue is this was verbal, they wouldn't put it in contract. Now they say I have to take leave on Fridays out of term time, won't let me take unpaid leave as this needs to be in blocks, and are extending my probation because of this to see if it suits the business needs of the team. AIBU to think that this is unfair? I understand that they will have clauses to justify such things. Any similar experiences? Thanks in advance and best wishes to all X

OP posts:
Tracker1234 · 08/02/2024 10:12

God, I remember one women not in my team who always blocked out 1500-1600. After that you rarely heard from her until the next day....she would send the odd email at say 1900 but only to show she was 'working'. Honestly - we arent fools!

Tracker1234 · 08/02/2024 10:10

Thing is I am not surprised they didnt put in writing. The hours are 0900-1730 apart from if you are Jane who has two children and works reduced hours for xx reason but 'works extra' to make it up. Then there is Alison who moved house during Covid and saved loads on childcare. She is now 2 hours from office so lets give her flexibility. As a PP says - before you know it is a nighmare to manage.

YouveGotAFastCar · 08/02/2024 10:09

I feel you - I accepted a full-time job with a company I used to consult with at the end of last year. I was really clear about what days I had childcare, and what days would need to be more flexible. They sent me endless emails about how I could be flexible, they needed to support more women and mums eventually, etc... We agreed I'd be available in emergencies on Fridays, but otherwise wouldn't work it, but I often have to work a weekend day, and when that's not the case, I work longer hours - which works in my industry, it's not 9 - 5, so it doesn't put me at odds with anyone else. I'm also senior enough that it doesn't put anyone out when I work, I could do my hours at 2am and it'd make no difference.

Client is thrilled with me, I work well over my hours, and I get a lot of praise - but my manager has still advised me to be "more visible" on Fridays.

Tracker1234 · 08/02/2024 10:07

Childcare I agree is a shocking price - fortunately that is all behind us now but I wouldnt dream of having a child with me when working. Others have no such issue and additionally they know other people will do their work for them. Its very selfish behaviour. Women (and its almost always women) treating some of us like fools and pretending that they will do 'a few hours to make up'. They wont. And I am not calling someone at 1930 because they are trying to catch up (they wont be doing the extra hours anyway!).

Ensuite · 08/02/2024 10:01

If you were very clear on your setup and they told you this was fine etc then this is ridiculous! Can you say this is not working and you want to revert to your previous role & previous arrangements?

MidnightPatrol · 08/02/2024 10:01

@SuzieQ2024 can you just put them in nursery full time?

MidnightPatrol · 08/02/2024 09:59

Tracker1234 · 08/02/2024 09:43

There are a number of theads like this asking for xx hours off, not working school run hours (but making up hours etc etc).

As a manager in a FTSE company for many years it becomes impossible to keep track of what people are doing and when. Dont call Mary because she is doing the school run, ifs its a Monday during school holidays dont worry about kids answering the phone, noise in the background etc.

People have taken the pXXs now and Covid taught them how useful it is to be working from home (and saving on childcare). That is why employers now want people back in the office.

My experience is that people will stretch and stretch what they can get away with and sadly others will pick up the slack. I had one team member who always seemed to have some reason why they couldnt make a team call i.e traffic on the way back from school run, blocked road so needed to leave earlier to get kids etc. Never accepted calls after 1600. I took some advice from HR as others were complaining about her but she left to join another team and then I left so it was never addressed.

Putting my tin hat on btw!

I hate to have to agree with you, but I do.

We have had the same issue - I want to be flexible to help people, but it always descends into chaos

The ‘WFH so I don’t need childcare’ issue is one I’m seeing more of. Requests to WFH during half term (how much work are you doing with a 3 and 6 year old at home all day?). ‘Meetings’ in at 3-4 every WFH day because they’re going to collect from school.

Incredibly difficult to know how to manage., given I have huge empathy on the challenges and cost of childcare.

underneaththeash · 08/02/2024 09:57

Just work 4 days a week and scrap the preschool on a Friday?

SuzieQ2024 · 08/02/2024 09:52

Thanks Tracker for employer perspective, and I hear you. I suppose everyone would say this but I don't take the piss and actually answer emails if needed out of hours, offer to cover an evening event if they are stuck etc etc.

OP posts:
Tracker1234 · 08/02/2024 09:43

There are a number of theads like this asking for xx hours off, not working school run hours (but making up hours etc etc).

As a manager in a FTSE company for many years it becomes impossible to keep track of what people are doing and when. Dont call Mary because she is doing the school run, ifs its a Monday during school holidays dont worry about kids answering the phone, noise in the background etc.

People have taken the pXXs now and Covid taught them how useful it is to be working from home (and saving on childcare). That is why employers now want people back in the office.

My experience is that people will stretch and stretch what they can get away with and sadly others will pick up the slack. I had one team member who always seemed to have some reason why they couldnt make a team call i.e traffic on the way back from school run, blocked road so needed to leave earlier to get kids etc. Never accepted calls after 1600. I took some advice from HR as others were complaining about her but she left to join another team and then I left so it was never addressed.

Putting my tin hat on btw!

Gazelda · 08/02/2024 09:35

acquiescence · 08/02/2024 09:31

I do as a poster above suggested- I take 2/3 weeks parental year for holidays and use the annual leave that this frees up to take off odd days.

This sounds like a good plan. You'll need to give plenty of notice for your parental leave request. And remember that they don't have to authorise it. Shoe some flexibility and willingness to adapt - this will build you a positive reputation.

acquiescence · 08/02/2024 09:31

I do as a poster above suggested- I take 2/3 weeks parental year for holidays and use the annual leave that this frees up to take off odd days.

SuzieQ2024 · 08/02/2024 09:30

Also nobody would ever cover, I would always be on email just FYI thanks

OP posts:
SuzieQ2024 · 08/02/2024 09:28

Just to add the kind of role I have I will always do the hours +, but yeah this is work life eh! Where is that Greek island 😜

OP posts:
PuttingDownRoots · 08/02/2024 09:25

So there are 13 days a year you have no childcare. You don't mention a partner... but is there one you can share these Fridays with?

Plus when is your child due to start school? You will need to cover all the holidays then... have you got a plan for that?

ZenNudist · 08/02/2024 09:22

For me if they couldn't put it in contract then I wouldn't accept the job so I said YABU as its not unfair if the business wants to check it won't work for them.

I don't think it's unreasonable to expect you to take leave outside of term time.

Depending on the job flexibility on a Friday should be OK but even that can be hard if other people are picking up your slack.

Justmadness · 08/02/2024 09:18

Yeah I'm feeling like your posts feel a bit vague, don't know if that's just me so apologies if it is. But it sounds like they have agreed the shorter working on Fridays but not the missing 13 or however many Fridays a year that they are off school. That's a lot of missing days and exceptionally flexible if they were to allow that.

Mynewnameis · 08/02/2024 09:16

Do they offer parental leave? I think they have to offer it actually.
I would use that for a block of leave for your holidays and then annual leave for the Fridays you need for childcare.
I'm assuming there are increasing options for clubs etc as uour child gets older, so it's a short term problem?

fitzwilliamdarcy · 08/02/2024 09:14

I'm on the opposite side of this - my workplace has hired 3 people in the last year (we're horribly understaffed) to do a full time job and then it turns out that the person actually wanted to work around the school runs which inevitably means they're working 9.30-2.30 and then maybe an hour between 4-5, and they want all of the school holidays so essentially term-time only. It makes everyone else's life much harder but management just turns a blind eye as as far as they're concerned they've filled the vacancy and they're scared to sack the person and risk a discrimination claim.

I haven't really got any advice but I really agree with you and other PP that these things should be in writing

SuzieQ2024 · 08/02/2024 09:14

Thanks all, sounds like most think they assumed I'd sort something else in holidays. Good to know re unpaid leave annoying paperwork wise. I thought it was a fair suggestion to enable me to have enough annual leave to use when I want, just for a few Fridays but hey ho. Cheers

OP posts:
LolaSmiles · 08/02/2024 09:09

they said they were happy for me to work on Fridays as I can with the preschool care
I'd have taken that to mean they're happy you have childcare 9-3 on term time Fridays and you'll make up the other hours elsewhere in your week, which is them being flexible.

My guess is they would expect you to have some sort childcare during the school holidays, which is reasonable so they're happy to be flexible but they're not ok with you basically taking most Fridays off out of term time and just doing what you can.

LIZS · 08/02/2024 09:08

You either need to adjust Fridays to termtime only or find a childminder who will do wrap around care, with pick up from preschool and schools holidays. What is your plan from September if they are starting school?

Justmadness · 08/02/2024 09:07

How much time are you missing on a Friday? What time do you start/finish?

RatatouillePie · 08/02/2024 09:04

SuzieQ2024 · 08/02/2024 08:39

Thanks - they said they were happy for me to work on Fridays as I can with the preschool care.

It sounds to me like they assumed you had alternative childcare arrangements for school holidays.

YABU to expect them to meet this request. It's a lot of paperwork and effort for the salary team to keep calculating days of unpaid leave, hence they're requesting you take it as holiday.

You either need to find school holiday childcare on a Friday, take holiday on the Friday to cover it (It's only 13 days of your holiday), or perhaps only work Monday to Thursday.

Would it be possibly to condense your working week into 4 days?

SuzieQ2024 · 08/02/2024 09:01

Thanks all! Idea was out of term I would work a bit from home on Fridays and make up time. Childcare availability v v limited with waiting lists. Issue with using annual leave is don't have enough then!

OP posts: