Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Newborn around smoking friend

86 replies

Overthebow · 07/02/2024 23:12

A friend who smokes came round today, he didn’t smoke in the house but could strongly smell cigarettes on him and he probably had one before he came into the house. I let him hold my baby for a while, and didn’t really think about it until afterwards but now I’m worried my baby will have been affected by this and am worried about sids. Do you think it’s ok and if not is there anything I can do? Aibu to be worried about this?

OP posts:
Thedogscollar · 09/02/2024 01:38

I have no idea. It is however common sense given the toxins that cling to the smoker after having a cigarette.
Other NHS staff have been on this thread stating exactly the same advice.

TomeTome · 09/02/2024 01:34

@Thedogscollar so why do you think that isn’t the guidance given by the nhs?

Thedogscollar · 09/02/2024 01:29

I think given the facts about third hand smoking already given on this thread it's just common sense, and almost a sense of decency to remove the top you have been wearing whilst smoking, and thoroughly wash your hands before handling a baby.

Baby's depend on the adults to protect them from danger whatever that might be. I'd say 4000 toxins in cigarettes are dangerous.

TomeTome · 09/02/2024 00:27

@EmilyTjP I can’t see where that advice is in the link you provided. Who told you that this was what should be done and why isn’t it listed on the nhs website or on the lullaby trust you linked to? I’m really intrigued as to why it’s being presented as known advice but isn’t easily findable.

TomeTome · 08/02/2024 22:42

No I don’t smoke, or drink for that matter but neither is really relevant. It’s a mistake to think anyone disagreeing with you on this subject is some sort of pro smoking maniac.

Whoopaday · 08/02/2024 21:56

@TomeTome are you a smoker?
I’ll still stick with no smoker is holding my baby unless they’ve washed hands and changed clothes, but even then I don’t think I would let them hold them.

TomeTome · 08/02/2024 21:29

Whoopaday · 08/02/2024 21:24

Current guidelines is to remove the top layer of clothing/change it if you are a smoker before holding a baby, as the residue on your clothes is harmful enough. Wearing lots of perfume to mask the smell just makes things worse and I don’t let people wearing strong perfume to hold my baby,

But these AREN’T the current guidelines. The nhs suggests that people don’t smoke inside or in the car.

Whoopaday · 08/02/2024 21:24

BobbyBiscuits · 07/02/2024 23:21

I am not aware that just the actual smell of smoke off someone could harm others? Just the smoke itself I presumed? It's a little unpleasant and I guess you don't want your baby to start smelling of smoke! Maybe tell him if he needs to smoke before seeing the baby would he mind chewing gum afterwards to minimise the smell? Otherwise I guess let him see the baby but minimise close contact/ holding. I smoke and my friends with babies never minded me holding them/ kissing them etc (I never smoked near the baby of course) but I totally see your point.

Current guidelines is to remove the top layer of clothing/change it if you are a smoker before holding a baby, as the residue on your clothes is harmful enough. Wearing lots of perfume to mask the smell just makes things worse and I don’t let people wearing strong perfume to hold my baby,

Jc2001 · 08/02/2024 21:20

whatsitcalledwhen · 08/02/2024 00:30

And people have to walk on roads. They don't have to let particular people hold their child. One isn't a realistic choice. The other is. They aren't comparable.

There are things in you can control and things you can't. You can't avoid going outside.

You can control who holds you baby, and even it the health risks are absolutely negligible, having you baby smell of smoke is gross and something you can avoid.

Edit. Quoted the wrong poster. Sorry.

SnapCrackleandStop · 08/02/2024 21:17

Of course I would move my baby away from an area that smelt like engine oil or woodsmoke.
I don’t burn my food. It’s not comparable.
Smell means particles of whatever it is are getting up your nose to your smell receptors. They are not necessarily harmless.
I don’t understand how you don’t see that medical opinion is very much on my side?
Look, obviously this was a one off incident for OP. If he’s not a regular visitor and she doesn’t have other smokers in the family or among her friends then the risk of this one time thing is not worth her spending more time worrying about. But yeah, having a blanket policy on how to deal with smokers in your life you want to see your baby is just sensible. And more important for those who will be seeing your child more regularly.

TomeTome · 08/02/2024 21:09

I not sure it’s “weird” to discuss what drives behaviour or ideas. You seem very het up about the smell of smoke, do you feel the same doubts/worries about the smell of cooking or even strong scent? What about the smell of woodsmoke or engine oil? Feelings come from somewhere and I’m not suggesting you do anything you’re not personally comfortable with but I also think if you present that as accepted medical opinion then you should be able to back that up with facts.

SnapCrackleandStop · 08/02/2024 21:02

TomeTome · 08/02/2024 20:45

I was interested in what was a reasonable response to the risk. Lots of posters including one claiming to be an nhs midwife were advocating what to me seem quite extreme levels of concern and subsequent behaviour. There seems to be a lot of extrapolating from one situation and response to another. It’s interesting how these things develop into official advice.
I’m not sure removing outside clothes and washing your hands before handling a newborn is reserved for smokers. Personally I would be more concerned about germs.

I think when you don’t smoke you’re just so much more aware of how smoke residue lingers. It smells really strong. And smell means particules are still present. As a non smoker discussions about the dangers of smoking (and not just to the smoker) are really frustrating because smokers usually have massive denial or cognitive dissonance about the health risks of smoking. It gives you cancer. It ruins your ability to breathe. It can harm the ability to breathe of the children and babies around you which can sometimes be fatal. To be honest I don’t really understand why anyone thinks it’s ok to keep doing it whatsoever.
So to me, asking visiting smokers to take off their coat or change their shirt, wash their hand and not smoke just before they arrive or during the visit is not extreme at all. Extreme would be refusing to see them whatsoever. Making a fuss about the idea of smokers changing their shirt when you’d happily make them do that anyway to reduce transmission of disease is very weird to me.

TomeTome · 08/02/2024 20:45

I was interested in what was a reasonable response to the risk. Lots of posters including one claiming to be an nhs midwife were advocating what to me seem quite extreme levels of concern and subsequent behaviour. There seems to be a lot of extrapolating from one situation and response to another. It’s interesting how these things develop into official advice.
I’m not sure removing outside clothes and washing your hands before handling a newborn is reserved for smokers. Personally I would be more concerned about germs.

2mummies1baby · 08/02/2024 20:38

It always amazes me when people come straight to mumsnet with health questions rather than doing their own research. OP, Google 'thirdhand smoke babies'. You absolutely should not be letting a smoker hold your baby. Make sure you wash the clothes she was wearing before she wears them again.

SnapCrackleandStop · 08/02/2024 20:28

TomeTome · 08/02/2024 20:05

It says fathers and smokers are more likely to believe THS isn’t harmful? I’m not sure what point that is making?

You don’t seem to believe that thirdhand smoke is an issue. I don’t understand why it’s so hard to believe. The taking your coat off and washing your hands before holding a baby is just an obvious way to lessen the quantity of thirdhand smoke that a baby will be exposed to.

TomeTome · 08/02/2024 20:05

It says fathers and smokers are more likely to believe THS isn’t harmful? I’m not sure what point that is making?

SnapCrackleandStop · 08/02/2024 18:46

TomeTome · 08/02/2024 18:25

I don’t think many of those links actually said that you should do more than smoke outside. There’s one that suggests bfing mothers might cover their clothes/hair when smoking but I’m still not sure a guest smoking before they arrive is a massive risk. This wouldn’t worry me unduly, but I have lived with much more significant risk.

How’s this for a study.
Heavy smokers are less likely to believe their child’s dr telling them that Thirdhand smoke is harmful.
https://www.ajpmonline.org/article/S0749-3797(12)00523-5/fulltext

BananaPyjamaLlama · 08/02/2024 18:44

I think........ this once, your baby will be totally fine. But I wouldnt be letting him hold your baby again. Or being in the same room if hes stinky tbh. Smoking is grim in all ways.

TomeTome · 08/02/2024 18:25

I don’t think many of those links actually said that you should do more than smoke outside. There’s one that suggests bfing mothers might cover their clothes/hair when smoking but I’m still not sure a guest smoking before they arrive is a massive risk. This wouldn’t worry me unduly, but I have lived with much more significant risk.

SnapCrackleandStop · 08/02/2024 18:19

TomeTome · 08/02/2024 18:11

Thanks for linking I will have a read. I don’t think anyone was saying “passive smoking” wasn’t a thing, it was more if it was nhs advice to go to the lengths described and what had lead to this idea that parent should require visiting smokers to change their clothes etc etc.

Definitely have a read about ´third hand smoke’. That seems to be the term that’s most used to describe residue left behind on clothes and surfaces.

Zanatdy · 08/02/2024 18:18

I used to be paranoid when my one smoker friend held my babies too. I’m sure it will be fine - a one off. One thing that really helped me was a breathing alarm, I had bad paranoia about SIDs as my eldest was a baby around time Anne Diamonds baby died and the whole back to sleep campaign so it used to play on my mind a lot

SnapCrackleandStop · 08/02/2024 18:17

Spinet · 08/02/2024 15:19

I can't find this statistic anywhere. I'm not condoning smoking at all - it clearly is not good for babies to be around smokers - but 'almost every single baby' simply doesn't seem to be supported as a statistic.

People who don't smoke should still follow the other SIDS advice like feet to foot, nothing in cots etc.

https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0378378207001296
So the full article is behind a paywall but enough is public to get the main points.
So for example, it seems like it used to be that the mother smoked during pregnancy in 50% of SIDS cases but that the number has risen since - to more like 80% whenever the data was collected for this study which was published back in 2007.

This is because safe sleep advice is working. The total number of SIDS deaths has fallen a lot because we’ve identified one of the major contributing factors and people have taken that advice on board. BUT there is a theory that maternal smoking during pregnancy and/or exposure to tabacco after birth mess with a baby’s abilty to regulate their breathing when their C02 levels get too high.

So smoking is a huge contributing factor to SIDS and now that fewer babies are being put down to sleep in riskier position (on their side or tummy), a greater percentage of SIDS deaths are being caused by smoking than in the past.

TomeTome · 08/02/2024 18:11

SnapCrackleandStop · 08/02/2024 14:45

@TomeTome Info on 3rd hand smoke
https://www.thelancet.com/pdfs/journals/ebiom/PIIS2352-3964(22)00594-1.pdf Discussion of implications on health following a study proving third hand smoke passed through the skin has negative affects on the body.
https://scienceblog.cincinnatichildrens.org/many-children-still-exposed-to-tobacco-smoke-pollution-even-in-smoke-free-homes/
Cincinnati Children’s hospital suggest even living in a home previously occupied by a smoker carries a risk to kids.
https://www.plunket.org.nz/being-a-parent/family-and-whanau/family-life/being-smoke-free-around-your-child/
Plunket is a well respected charity in New Zealand that work to improve health and safety of children under 5. Their recommendations for what breastfeeding mothers who smoke should do are exactly what @Thedogscollar has been explaining about smokers holding babies - wear a coat you remove before touching the baby, wash your hands thoroughly, ideally have leave an hour between smoking and holding the baby close.

https://www.nhs.uk/conditions/baby/caring-for-a-newborn/reduce-the-risk-of-sudden-infant-death-syndrome/#:~:text=Babies%20exposed%20to%20cigarette%20smoke,your%20baby%20into%20smoky%20places.
NHS clearly states the links between SIDS and smoking and gives this as a reason to avoid your baby being around people who are smoking.
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5716630/
Medical Research review paper summarizing all the different studies we have on third hand smoke exposure. We know cigarette residue is carcinogenic and have done since the 1950s. We also know it gets everywhere. Even in places like the NICU where no has ever smoked.

Thanks for linking I will have a read. I don’t think anyone was saying “passive smoking” wasn’t a thing, it was more if it was nhs advice to go to the lengths described and what had lead to this idea that parent should require visiting smokers to change their clothes etc etc.

SnapCrackleandStop · 08/02/2024 17:57

Thedogscollar · 08/02/2024 17:18

@SnapCrackleandStop thankyou for posting the links re second /third hand smoking.
I have no idea how to include links in a post.

No problem. I just copy the URL from the page I want to link and paste it into the message box when I’m writing a mumsnet post.