Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Newborn around smoking friend

86 replies

Overthebow · 07/02/2024 23:12

A friend who smokes came round today, he didn’t smoke in the house but could strongly smell cigarettes on him and he probably had one before he came into the house. I let him hold my baby for a while, and didn’t really think about it until afterwards but now I’m worried my baby will have been affected by this and am worried about sids. Do you think it’s ok and if not is there anything I can do? Aibu to be worried about this?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Justrolledmyeyesoutloud · 09/02/2024 18:13

My friend is a smoker and if she held my baby afterwards (l was unaware this was a nono), the baby screamed and screamed. Almost like she knew! Op am sure baby is fine but be aware for next time x

Brbreeze · 09/02/2024 18:02

For what it's worth, I had a baby 2 years ago and on the hospital discharge from the midwife was explicitly told to ask any visitors to change their clothes and wash hands thoroughly after smoking, or not allow smokers to hold a newborn.
Having chatted to our NCT group about it at the time, we were all given the same advice across 3 hospitals.
So just because it isn't on the NHS generic info page doesn't necessarily mean it is "chinese whispers" or not current standard advice.

Thedogscollar · 09/02/2024 16:57

@TomeTome You are quite right not everyone has agreed with me. I did not think I was trying to dominate, so apologies if that's how I came across.

I am very passionate about every baby having the very best start in life and the right to not being exposed in any way to carcinogenic toxins that are in cigarette smoke. I know we cannot protect them from everything but in this I passionately believe we can.

In my field, still birth and fetal growth retardation are well researched subjects and with recommendations that have come from research the stats on this are, thank goodness, improving.

Having been to many midwifery study days involving both medics and midwives from various NHS Trusts, this seems to be the advice given by all.

I will always advocate for any sensible advice on what we know to date about passive smoking, especially around growth retarded, premature and vulnerable infants.

In my opinion, fwiw, with the knowledge we have re the toxicity of cigarette smoke/residue then I will continue to advise parents as I have previously discussed on this thread.

It's good to discuss and get others views and yes we can disagree amicably.

TomeTome · 09/02/2024 15:15

Thedogscollar · 09/02/2024 13:59

I think we will all have to agree to disagree with you on this one.
Sometimes science like this is glaringly obvious, if you want to see it. You are the type of person that unless it's written down it's not true and that's ok.

We will continue to do what we as HCP do and think and you likewise

we will all have to agree to disagree with you well it won’t be all of you because several posters have said they feel it’s an unnecessary reaction/rule. I wouldn’t be particularly bothered if my thoughts were different to the majority though. Your opinions can stand on their own you don’t need to try and dominate in this way.

You are the type of person that unless it's written down it's not true and that's ok. that’s kind of you to say but you don’t actually know what kind of person I am. I’m fairly staunchly in favour of science rather than opinion especially when advising young mothers on how to care for their children. I’m not sure why you find that so offensive.

You seem to be taking this discussion very personally. It’s absolutely fine to disagree.

TomeTome · 09/02/2024 15:05

SnapCrackleandStop · 09/02/2024 13:59

This is an interesting paper that demonstrates that people do transport thirdhand smoke with them.
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7056301/#:~:text=THS%20originates%20from%20the%20direct,not%20include%20airborne%20primary%20particles.
I get what you’re saying @TomeTome about waiting for recommendations but in this case the risk of the proposed harm reduction measure seems tiny or non existent. What harm is there in changing a shirt?

Apologies I haven’t read the link yet. I think in this instance my guess would be the harm would be social/emotional rather than physical. New mother experiencing increased anxiety, baby experiences reduced contact with wider group, mother considered neurotic/controlling….

The analogy that springs to mind is the idea that was widely adopted without much scientific backing (so a theory that was adopted rather than proved) that “refrigerator mothers” caused autism in young children. It was observed that the mothers of autistic children damped down their emotions and were less responsive to their children. We know now that autistic children often have hair-trigger reactions to others emotions and their mothers would have been used to reducing that stress by remaining stoically calm. What then happened was that mothers shouldered much of the guilt and pain, some were instructed to force their children to hug for extended periods (holding therapy) causing enormous distress, in some countries (eg France) children and there siblings were removed from their families to try and protect them.

I am not suggesting anything like that would happen in this instance but I am suggesting that advice is not given lightly and the fact it hasn’t been issued isn’t an oversight but more there simply doesn’t appear to be the evidence to support it.

SnapCrackleandStop · 09/02/2024 14:10

This one is also interesting. The vast majority of the participants in this study are non smokers and still they found nicotine on their fingers from 3rd hand smoke exposure. The authors suggest NICU units might in future consider storing and laundering scrubs in the hospital to help reduce transmission to neonatal patients, or looking at stricter anti-smoking measures for parents and other visitors.
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6662774/

Thedogscollar · 09/02/2024 13:59

TomeTome · 09/02/2024 12:38

@SnapCrackleandStop prematurely adopting rules that are not based in sound robust research isn’t without risk. I’m happy for you not to agree with that or to bring different experience to the discussion. I’m less relaxed about the repeated claims that this is recommended because I can’t see that it is.

I think we will all have to agree to disagree with you on this one.
Sometimes science like this is glaringly obvious, if you want to see it. You are the type of person that unless it's written down it's not true and that's ok.

We will continue to do what we as HCP do and think and you likewise

TomeTome · 09/02/2024 12:38

@SnapCrackleandStop prematurely adopting rules that are not based in sound robust research isn’t without risk. I’m happy for you not to agree with that or to bring different experience to the discussion. I’m less relaxed about the repeated claims that this is recommended because I can’t see that it is.

SnapCrackleandStop · 09/02/2024 12:27

TomeTome · 09/02/2024 08:42

I think if there was genuine risk then it would be firmly in the guidelines. Again that last link doesn’t work and certainly none of them have backed up the advice some of you are suggesting. It’s really important to be able to quantify risk and understand evidence based guidance as apposed to feelings or opinion. That’s doubly important when it surrounds our children.

No in this case the research is there, and the guidance is starting to catch up.
So you are concluding that asking visitors to a newborn baby to remove their coat/change shirt after smoking is extreme and not based in medical fact because you’ve not seen those exact words ok the NHS general info site.
You’re ignoring all the guidelines that are starting to appear about thirdhand smoke (I can find you more if you want) as well as all the research.

BobbyBiscuits · 09/02/2024 11:42

@Whoopaday I guess I'm not gonna be holding any babies any time soon then. I honestly didn't know that just the smell was actively harmful, but I get it that it's unpleasant. I don't try and mask the smoke smell with perfume, I just wear it like most people do. A lot of my family smoked around babies and kids as recently as 15 years ago. That's pretty bad isn't it. (Not me mind you). No-one ever smokes indoors in the family now. Or has a baby.

Thedogscollar · 09/02/2024 11:14

TomeTome · 09/02/2024 08:42

I think if there was genuine risk then it would be firmly in the guidelines. Again that last link doesn’t work and certainly none of them have backed up the advice some of you are suggesting. It’s really important to be able to quantify risk and understand evidence based guidance as apposed to feelings or opinion. That’s doubly important when it surrounds our children.

You need to research passive smoking and the effects on others especially babies. There is a genuine risk.

If you personally would be happy to have your baby cuddled by someone who has just smoked a cigarette without changing their top and washing their hands then that is your decision to make.

Just because you cannot find this advice written somewhere in NHS guidelines doesn't make it any less valid.

ChiefEverythingOfficer · 09/02/2024 10:23

TomeTome · 08/02/2024 21:09

I not sure it’s “weird” to discuss what drives behaviour or ideas. You seem very het up about the smell of smoke, do you feel the same doubts/worries about the smell of cooking or even strong scent? What about the smell of woodsmoke or engine oil? Feelings come from somewhere and I’m not suggesting you do anything you’re not personally comfortable with but I also think if you present that as accepted medical opinion then you should be able to back that up with facts.

Smoking is gross. Babies should not be exposed to smelly smoky clothes. If for no other reason than it freaking stinks.

Fwiw - I think you are het up about this and trying to drive a point home.

i will listen to the midwife in this instance.

MrsSkylerWhite · 09/02/2024 10:11

VeniVidiWeeWee · Yesterday 00:24
**
Do you take you baby out along roads with cars passing? I suspect particulate pollution is much worse for health”

Oh please. So throw in a smoker for good measure?

Wouldn’t let smokers near our babies, OP, and told them why.

W0tnow · 09/02/2024 10:08

I agree with whoever said that smokers just don’t get how unpleasant they smell. Maybe there’s a risk, maybe there isn’t, but I wouldn’t like to be held for an extended period of time (or any time, really) by someone who had been smoking, or who was wearing clothes with residual odour.

TomeTome · 09/02/2024 08:42

I think if there was genuine risk then it would be firmly in the guidelines. Again that last link doesn’t work and certainly none of them have backed up the advice some of you are suggesting. It’s really important to be able to quantify risk and understand evidence based guidance as apposed to feelings or opinion. That’s doubly important when it surrounds our children.

Treehugger22 · 09/02/2024 02:50

I mean the smell

Treehugger22 · 09/02/2024 02:50

Shouldn't harm her but I wouldn't let that smoke get onto my baby just yuk

Themuffintop · 09/02/2024 02:37

Some of you need to get a grip.
OP your baby is fine.

Thedogscollar · 09/02/2024 02:14

TomeTome · 09/02/2024 01:50

Yes but that’s individual opinion and seems to be based on a sort of Chinese whispers rather than fact. People keep posting links but on reading the advice is not what they are suggesting.

It is not Chinese whispers it is fact. If a cigarette is smoked downstairs in a house the smoke will still travel upstairs into other rooms clinging to fabrics along the way.
The toxins cling to the clothes, skin and hair of the smoker the particulates are exhaled out in their breath. The baby who is being held close by the smoker will be breathing in these toxins much more rapidly than you or I would into their tiny lungs.
Over time this could lead to SIDS, bronchitis, pneumonia and asthma. The advice is correct change your top was your hands.

Peaceandquietandacuppa · 09/02/2024 01:59

TomeTome · 09/02/2024 01:50

Yes but that’s individual opinion and seems to be based on a sort of Chinese whispers rather than fact. People keep posting links but on reading the advice is not what they are suggesting.

maybe they don’t want to say it’s ok to smoke and hold a baby, so they just say ‘don’t smoke’ on the official guidance. Whereas if you know people are going to smoke anyway, common sense is to change clothes and wash hands.

Peaceandquietandacuppa · 09/02/2024 01:56

TomeTome · 09/02/2024 00:27

@EmilyTjP I can’t see where that advice is in the link you provided. Who told you that this was what should be done and why isn’t it listed on the nhs website or on the lullaby trust you linked to? I’m really intrigued as to why it’s being presented as known advice but isn’t easily findable.

Why are you so hung up on this? https://healthforunder5s.co.uk/sections/baby/secondhand-smoke-just-the-facts/#:~:text=Make%20it%20a%20house%20rule,to%20three%20hours%20after%20smoking.

Most people wouldn’t like any strong smells around baby, it’s just common sense. I used to get annoyed with people wearing strong perfume and would make an excuse to take baby back. Smoke is even worse because of all the toxins.

Secondhand smoke- Just the facts | Baby | Health for Under 5s

This article offers lots of information about the risks associated with secondhand smoke and how you can protect your baby from the harm that smoke can cause.

https://healthforunder5s.co.uk/sections/baby/secondhand-smoke-just-the-facts/#:~:text=Make%20it%20a%20house%20rule,to%20three%20hours%20after%20smoking.

TomeTome · 09/02/2024 01:50

Thedogscollar · 09/02/2024 01:38

I have no idea. It is however common sense given the toxins that cling to the smoker after having a cigarette.
Other NHS staff have been on this thread stating exactly the same advice.

Yes but that’s individual opinion and seems to be based on a sort of Chinese whispers rather than fact. People keep posting links but on reading the advice is not what they are suggesting.

Themuffintop · 09/02/2024 01:42

YABU. Could not get worked up about this.

Cigarettes stink, sure. But your baby will be fine. Nothing a bath won’t fix.