Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you’ve regretted having a third child or sticking at two?

137 replies

Busby88 · 07/02/2024 21:29

I know third child posts come up all the time on Mumsnet (I think I’ve read them all 😅) but just wondering if anyone has any insight on whether they’ve regretted the decision they made when deciding whether or not to go for a third child?

I know logically it is better to stick at two. Holidays, finances, car space, emotional time to invest in current DC, risk to me and any future child etc etc. But oh my heart absolutely longs for a third. I always saw myself with three kids but never really thought about it until I had two and I started to consider what a shift it would be.

So I’m not asking for all the arguments for sticking at two, I know these off by heart. I’m just after first hand experiences of people who were either desperate for a third but decided to stick at two, or people who went for a third and regret it ( I know you’d never regret the actual child but you know what I mean hopefully).

Name changed because some people IRL know my normal MN username and I don’t want them to know how seriously we are considering a third…

OP posts:
LauritaEvita · 08/02/2024 20:54

Rocknrollstar · 08/02/2024 18:33

Stuck at two. we both wanted four but realised we couldn’t afford them. we are both the middle one of three and agreed we would never have three and put another child in that position.

I’m intrigued by this as one of 3 myself. What position do you mean? As in, you and your husband would have preferred just 1 sibling each?

DrearyLane · 08/02/2024 20:51

Three completed my family, but it has made it significantly poorer, crazier and at times harder. I think my experience would have been better with family support, but that’s not something we have.

SongbirdGarden · 08/02/2024 20:49

I am in my 50s and so glad l stuck at two. Mine are both young adults now but l am absolutely exhausted. I have never regretted not trying for a third. People under estimate how much work is still involved mentally, physically and emotionally at this stage, as well as issues with aging parents, and the menopause. I am a lone widowed parent, which probably makes a difference.

Busby88 · 08/02/2024 20:49

Depends what type of family you want to give your kids.

@Gulag This is a really insightful way of looking at it which I’d never considered before (too busy thinking about the practicalities)

@CuttingMeOpenthenHealingMeFine I’m so sorry for your loss, that must have been (and still be) mentally tough for you. Sending love.

OP posts:
Busby88 · 08/02/2024 20:42

Mairzydotes · 08/02/2024 19:26

I have 3. If number 3 had been more like one of the first two , like I imagined, life would be easier.

Also , what if number 3 is twins?

This is a big fear, I couldn’t handle twins so I do think that’s quite a good reason for sticking with two. Likewise I would struggle if we had a child with a severe disability, or if the pregnancy negatively impacted my own health in some way.

OP posts:
Bunnyhopskip · 08/02/2024 20:41

I was adamant I only wanted two, then had a few wobbles since dd2 turned three, really considered it, but then COVID and lockdown, and the last thing on my mind was another baby, with both kids home full time, trying to homeschool eldest, and keep youngest occupied. By the time we were out of the other side, dd2 was preparing for school, and I felt like I'd missed the boat a bit with having a third. I've had moments when I've thought, oh fuck it, let's just try and see what happens, but I know deep down it would stretch me too far physically and mentally (and as a family, financially!) I don't think I'll ever not feel slightly broody, but as mine two have got older, I can certainly see how having another now, would really restrict us, and make life alot more difficult. Even little things like, the fact they can jump in the car themselves and do their own belts up, makes life much easier, and I imagine us trying to get out the house and to school on time with a baby/toddler in tow... We barely make it now, with nothing slowing us down! I think I'll always long for a third, and in hindsight, wish we'd just bit the bullet and had another during covid when we were serious about it, but maybe it just wasn't meant to be.

CuttingMeOpenthenHealingMeFine · 08/02/2024 20:41

We really wanted three but decided to stick at two, we would always talk about having a third and then talk ourselves straight back out of it. We nearly went for it a number of times, then last year just before I turned 40 we decided fuck it let’s go for it and got pregnant straight away but sadly it ended in miscarriage and it was so awful that I just won’t try again especially with miscarriage risk being higher in the forties. I think we will always regret talking ourselves out of it so much in the previous years as we would have felt like we had more time.

Busby88 · 08/02/2024 20:40

DorotheaHomeAlone · 08/02/2024 18:41

I’m confused by your post - do you only want to hear from people with three if they regret it? We have three and love it. Happy to share more if that’s of interest.

Oh no sorry didn’t mean it to sound like that! By all means share away. I have just read so many mumsnet posts around the negatives of having three children, but these seem to be from people who have two children or less. So was wondering if those people who do have three actually regret it… but would love to hear all the positives!

OP posts:
Houseplantmad · 08/02/2024 20:34

We tried for 3 but I had several miscarriages. 20 years later I am glad we had just the two - especially during the teen/early adult years when they require/d so much support. I don’t think I could have coped.

Hesleepswiththefishes · 08/02/2024 20:32

Three is hard but the dynamic is brilliant

think if you meet up with 2 friends or 3

with 3 it’s just a bit more fizzy, if you want a quiet chat you meet with 2

its hard to ask parents with 3 as they can’t imagine life without one of those 3

LorlieS · 08/02/2024 20:26

@JinglePringle I felt exactly the same as you - had two kids in my 20s and done. Separated in my 30s and then met second husband who had no kids. Had my third at 39 and my kids are 16, 13 and 3...so it really was like starting again!!
I'm totally knackered but no regrets.

JinglePringle · 08/02/2024 20:18

I have 2. I want to want a 3rd but I'm 37, both kids are out of nappies, walking, talking and almost in school. I couldn't bare to start again from newborn.

I might look into fostering but definitely 2 biological and done.

Zanatdy · 08/02/2024 20:16

I have 3 but 1 is much older. I wouldn’t have had 3 little ones close in age. I think you do need to consider cost, and not just nursery fee’s but helping with Uni costs as student loans are means tested etc, they are really important factors over whether other people regretted it. Each child costs an awful lot of money, and in a COL crisis you do need to consider what’s driving the desire for one more and affordability. I wanted a 3rd as I wanted a daughter, that’s what drove my desire for 3, but also because I had 11yrs between son 1 and son 2, so I wanted ds2 to have a sibling close in age as ds1 was never able to have that. A lot to consider

Travelsweat · 08/02/2024 20:10

We had a third and are so happy we did. Our family just didn’t feel complete with two. They are close in age and are best friends. I like that they will all have that sister bond for life. It’s also great during school holidays and weekends because they entertain each other. MIL tried to ‘warn’ us that a third would be too much work (she has just two herself), and we are so glad we didn’t listen to her. If you both really want a third and have the means to make it work, I say go for it.

phoenixrosehere · 08/02/2024 19:55

Giv0iw · 08/02/2024 19:32

I know this is a boring opinion but I think other people's experiences are largely irrelevant. You DO need to base it on things like time, finances and if your house is big enough.

In my mind it's clear cut ultimately what sort of life do you want to give your children?

This is true.

DH and I both agreed before we became engaged that three was our limit and that’s what we planned for and if it hadn’t of happened we would be fine regardless.

LorlieS · 08/02/2024 19:53

I've got three but feel a bit sad for the much younger one as she's more "on her own" than her two big big brothers are (16, 13 and 3) ❤️

RandomQuestionOfTheDay · 08/02/2024 19:53

Very glad we stuck at two.

Around the time DC2 was 3 and I was heading for 40, I would have been happy to have a third if DH had wanted to as well. Or maybe not as I remember thinking I couldn’t afford £1k a month for another child’s childcare.

As time has gone on the happier I’ve been to only have two. Parenting is hard work even now they’re early teens. I’m glad I’m not also juggling the needs of a younger child. Also getting a little freedom back is awesome.

Dilysthemilk · 08/02/2024 19:49

I have 3 - I have a gap of 6.5 & 8.5 years between my 3rd and my 1st and 2nd. I wish I had gone for a 4th all the time. It is hard to go back but it’s also lovely because you appreciate all the gorgeous baby years a lot more. Also I think I would have been really sad at my older 2’s sibling relationship as they are very different from each other so they are not very close but the 3rd brings them and us altogether. I’m much too old for a 4th now but I do wish I had.

phoenixrosehere · 08/02/2024 19:48

DC3 is 3 month and we cannot imagine life without her. There’s a six year difference between her and her brother which is the same difference between my nephew and niece. Seeing DS1 and DS2 interact with her is so sweet. She smiles, coos back at them, and reaches out to touch them. We are definitely done. Would have gone for a tubal but the hospital I was at didn’t do them so DH is getting the snip as agreed.

We had been on the fence about a third and agreed if there was no pregnancy last year, we were done at two and lo and behold, three was due. Finances so far haven’t changed much other than buying nappies. Had the bulkier expensive items still and bought a few baby girl bundles from Vinted before she was born. My parents went overboard so she’s set until she’s one. 😂

Yesnosorryplease · 08/02/2024 19:45

3 has been lovely, and my 3rd was by far the easiest and the one I enjoyed the most as a baby. I'm so so glad dh changed his mind (he was firmly 2 and done at one point). All of us are very happy to have dc3.

BUT, the expense is pretty significant. I don't think I'd really thought through how 3x school shoes or 3x swimming lessons is 33% more than I would have been paying. When they were younger it was less noticeable but now they're teens and the school lunches and trips are serious £££, they need phones, allowances and will need driving lessons and uni support, I actually wonder what the hell we were thinking when we entered into dc 3 so casually.

We have good incomes, supportive families and non demanding kids, so we will be fine, but I look at everyone else with 2 and know we would have felt much more comfortable if we'd stopped there!

lochmaree · 08/02/2024 19:40

following as we are considering a 3rd.

Strictlymad · 08/02/2024 19:40

I think your personal situation is different and important to consider. I would love a third but have high risk pregnancies, difficult deliveries and premature babies. If you have straightforward pregnancies and deliveries that’s a big plus. We have decided for us it’s wiser to stick at 2

Gulag · 08/02/2024 19:38

Giv0iw · 08/02/2024 19:32

I know this is a boring opinion but I think other people's experiences are largely irrelevant. You DO need to base it on things like time, finances and if your house is big enough.

In my mind it's clear cut ultimately what sort of life do you want to give your children?

I agree with this. I had the time, space and money (although I would be richer with just two). I also wanted to give my kids the experience of a lively, chaotic household. Some people prioritise having a bit more order and being able to give their kids more individual attention and resource. Depends what type of family you want to give your kids.

Gulag · 08/02/2024 19:35

I have three (and really struggled to decide). In the end I knew that I wouldn’t regret it so I went for it and I find it fantastic. My third is wonderful and I really like the dynamic compared to the intensity of two. I have occasionally twinges of regret when booking a hotel and paying for three lots of swimming lessons but that’s it :)

Veggie1961 · 08/02/2024 19:35

NewName24 · 08/02/2024 00:20

I have three and it made our family complete.
100% right for us.

Same here .Absolutely no regrets .

Swipe left for the next trending thread