Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you’ve regretted having a third child or sticking at two?

137 replies

Busby88 · 07/02/2024 21:29

I know third child posts come up all the time on Mumsnet (I think I’ve read them all 😅) but just wondering if anyone has any insight on whether they’ve regretted the decision they made when deciding whether or not to go for a third child?

I know logically it is better to stick at two. Holidays, finances, car space, emotional time to invest in current DC, risk to me and any future child etc etc. But oh my heart absolutely longs for a third. I always saw myself with three kids but never really thought about it until I had two and I started to consider what a shift it would be.

So I’m not asking for all the arguments for sticking at two, I know these off by heart. I’m just after first hand experiences of people who were either desperate for a third but decided to stick at two, or people who went for a third and regret it ( I know you’d never regret the actual child but you know what I mean hopefully).

Name changed because some people IRL know my normal MN username and I don’t want them to know how seriously we are considering a third…

OP posts:
QueryA · 09/02/2024 21:52

I have 3, but its a bit different as no 2&3 are twins, so it wasn't a planned choice to have 3. I love them all, and wouldn't change now they are here, but it would have been so much easier with 2. They do fight a lot, perhaps because there is only 2 years between all 3 of them.

Busby88 · 09/02/2024 21:41

@Bathtimebarbara Twins, a child with a severe disability, or something happening to impact on my health are all big fears of mine and a huge factor for me.

@sunflowerpinks Not at all, if anything I would rather hear that people haven’t regretted sticking at two, even if they really really wanted a third. I am usually a heart over head person but with regards to this I feel like that would potentially be putting my own desires over what’s best for my children.

OP posts:
Busby88 · 09/02/2024 21:37

@Ifyouknowyouknowyouknow That sounds really tough, hopefully some time and space will help you come to a decision that is right for you and your family. I can completely understand the worry about the impact on your two children.

OP posts:
Tohaveandtohold · 09/02/2024 21:36

We have 3 and have no regrets. DC3 is such a delight. I always wanted 2 but after DD2, we just knew we weren’t done. There’s 10 and 4 years age difference between him and his older sisters so they both adore him and it’s a different dynamic but it’s lovely. Having to pay childcare fees again is annoying but it’s one we already planned will happen anyway so no regrets .

Busby88 · 09/02/2024 21:35

@prescribingmum Yeah I feel like once my youngest hits the toddler years I might change my mind, I do love the baby year. If we were to go for a third I need to be sure it’s because we want a third child not just because I miss having a baby!

OP posts:
Beetlebumz · 09/02/2024 21:35

I was one of three. It’s not all Rosy. One is always left out

prescribingmum · 09/02/2024 21:30

We stopped at 2. I am not sure I have the physical and mental capacity to devote to another. First two are close in age and I feel a lot of regret about how much I missed of DC1 toddler years due to sheer exhaustion of having 2 under 2. Although both are independent, I feel I wouldn't be able to do as much with them if also caring for a baby/toddler. I love newborn and upto 1 year old but am not a fan of the toddler years and feel relieved at the prospect of not going through them again.

Financial pressure also a consideration - we could comfortably manage the primary years with 3 but I can see it becoming a stretch when paying for holidays for 5 adults/uni contributions etc.

I get pangs of wanting a third but the reality stops me from going there.

DinosaurOfFire · 09/02/2024 21:26

I personally love having three kids. We have a fun, mostly happy, home with lots of noise and for the most part my 3 get on together. They do bicker but they don't fight or properly fall out. They happily spend time together with each other and with us. I always imagined having a larger family, 3 kids was always my minimum and I would probably have had more if my DH was on board!

TheaBrandt · 09/02/2024 21:22

So glad we stopped at 2. Teens are fab but full on emotionally and financially then you hit peri menopause and can’t be arsed with parenting any more than two. Well that’s how I feel at 50. And literally all my friends.

DGPP · 09/02/2024 21:20

I love having three, wouldn’t change a thing! They are brilliant, their relationships are great. We adore it

Ifyouknowyouknowyouknow · 09/02/2024 21:20

I’m in absolute turmoil atm and this thread has been helpful. I really really wanted a third to the point we tried for 3 months, then decided to take a break (as wanted to avoid a summer baby and DH wasn’t 100% on the decision). Then somehow conceived during that break so the positive test came as a complete shock to me. Despite desperately wanting DC3 since I’ve actually been pregnant all I can see are downsides to the point where I’m considering a termination. Yes we can afford it but if we didn’t have DC3 we would have more time and money for DCs 1 and 2, and I’ve also worried that the baby will hold them back from doing fun things - started a thread about exactly that.

They will be 6.5 and nearly 4 when this one is due.

Yummymummy2020 · 09/02/2024 21:18

Love having three and although it may change as they grow, my two toddlers adore the new baby!

Bathtimebarbara · 09/02/2024 21:17

My cousin absolutely regrets it

wanted three
got twins, one of whom is severely disabled

their entire future has been turned on its head and truthfully life is very hard for them and for their other children.

Lantyslee · 09/02/2024 21:17

I'm one of three, my DH is one of three. We always wanted three and so we did - two didn't feel like enough. There's only 3.5 years between all of the so it was hectic when they were little but have absolutely no regrets.

abeeabeeisafterme · 09/02/2024 21:15

It's not quite what you asked, but I always wanted four children. I had four, am thrilled with them and the mix, and feel zero desire to have more.

Dottina · 09/02/2024 21:13

I would have loved a bigger family, but dh isn't keen. Tbf we don't have a big enough house anyway. In my dreams we'd move away from the SE and live somewhere cheap enough for more space etc, but as it is we are where we are and 2 dcs is probably where we'll stop

sunflowerpinks · 09/02/2024 21:10

*I also don't understand the logic of this post.

a) No one who's got three kids will openly admit to regretting it and
b) Why will hearing from someone who regrets it help you?

It feels like you're just looking for confirmation that you are right in wanting a third.*

Yes, that is my impression too.

sunflowerpinks · 09/02/2024 21:08

But a lot of the reasons that people state for sticking at two (I.E juggling the overwhelm of teenage emotions) are written by people with two kids who aren’t even at that stage, so I’m guessing I’m looking for lived experiences.

Well, we have two now aged 20 and 22 and ist been absolutely great. We love being a family of 4!

Busby88 · 09/02/2024 20:24

@allfurcoatnoknickers dont worry my youngest isn’t one yet either and yet I think about it so often! Be interesting to see if that changed as he gets older

OP posts:
Busby88 · 09/02/2024 20:23

Thepeopleversuswork · 09/02/2024 18:09

I also don't understand the logic of this post.

a) No one who's got three kids will openly admit to regretting it and
b) Why will hearing from someone who regrets it help you?

It feels like you're just looking for confirmation that you are right in wanting a third.

You either want a third kid or you don't. The opinions of randoms on the internet with wildly different circumstances are totally irrelevant to your considerations.

I know it probably doesn’t sound really logical. Basically on all the threads I’ve read, the overwhelming consensus is that two children is best. It’s made me feel that having a third child would basically be the selfish decision. But a lot of the reasons that people state for sticking at two (I.E juggling the overwhelm of teenage emotions) are written by people with two kids who aren’t even at that stage, so I’m guessing I’m looking for lived experiences.

Likewise lots of people seem to ask this question so I’m wondering if any of them have stuck at two then regretted it.

Basically I’m full of indecision because I’m scared that I’ll regret whatever decision I do make.

OP posts:
12tog · 09/02/2024 20:01

My DC3 is the joy of my life. A real ray of sunshine. Obviously I love all my DC but the unplanned one is the absolute bonus! We made lots of sacrifices in order to have a bigger family and I don’t regret it for a second.

Doris9 · 09/02/2024 19:20

I think baby 3 is sometimes the result of compromise: where one parent wants 2 and the other wants 4.

allfurcoatnoknickers · 09/02/2024 18:41

Reading this thread with interest because I am SO broody for a third and DH wants another one even more than I do. I'm an only child and he's one of three, so two isn't what either of us are used to.

DD isn't even one yet though so it's far too soon to really be seriously considering it, but it's on my mind.

Chilliandbanana · 09/02/2024 18:26

I have 3. No regrets at all. She completed our family!

Ionlylikedityesterday · 09/02/2024 18:16

Three is tough and I think now, in retrospect, two or four would have been better. Regret is the wrong word completely. With three one is often left out and particularly as they grow older. It’s now painful to see two siblings close and one not but as young adults you can’t force relationships or time together. I would focus on asking or observing people with three who are grown up or at least late teens. It was all fine when they were young but changed completely around 16 years old. With three young adults I am daily in pieces or at my wits end. Two would have been so much easier at this age. I can’t imagine what the future holds either.