Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you are retired and have a good life, can I ask how much pension you draw?

343 replies

User5512 · 07/02/2024 21:08

I tried some calculators and they all gave me vastly different numbers.

I’d like to know (roughly) how much money does a couple need to have a good life in retirement.

If you are retired, would you be kind enough to give me a rough idea of your lifestyle and how much pension you get?

thanks :)

OP posts:
ruby1957 · 08/02/2024 14:11

I hope all you current tax-payers are aware of this - I find the figures banded around by those in the 'good retirement' position rather distasteful.

ALL taxpayers are responsible for covering the unaffordable life-style of some retirees.

Taxpayers are on the hook for a colossal £2.6 trillion to pay for existing inflation-proofed pensions for public sector workers now and over decades to come.28 Aug 2022

L0bstersLass · 08/02/2024 13:32

ZebraPensAreLife · 08/02/2024 09:05

Or they simply can’t afford to put 40% of their salaries into their pension.

I don’t know anyone who can afford to make that sort of contribution - we’ve all got too high rent / mortgage / essential bills.

MN really is like another world sometimes

@ZebraPensAreLife Before paying off the mortgate. I was putting in the minimum required to get my employer to put in the maxiumum they would.
I was putting in 5% and they were putting in 7%.

We were over-paying the mortgage and now that's done I'm putting 50% of my salary into my pension. It's made very little difference to my take home salary but is having a dramatic impact on my pension.

I've been doing that for 4 years and am hoping to retire in another 4 if we can keep this level of investment up. The increase in the threshold of maximum annual contribution into a pension has also been very helpful.

pinkspeakers · 08/02/2024 13:23

Surely everyone has to do their own calculations? Based on what they currently spend and what they would no longer need to spend, or be willing to give up, once they are retired. These "what do you need for a comfortable retirement" figures as a general statement are just nonsense.

I would say that I was pleasantly surprised when I worked out how much less I would need given that I would no longer be paying into a pension and NI. Plus obviously average tax goes down with income. That plus not paying for mortgage, kids (hopefully!), cost of commuting, means you need nowhere near the same net income as when you are younger.

SummerFeverVenice · 08/02/2024 13:13

Many are asking about the calculators and how they come up with estimated amounts for retirement. These amounts are usually adjusted for future estimated inflation.

If the cost of food, goods & services keeps going up an average of 5% a year, then in 20 years what you can buy now for £1 you will need £4.32 to buy it in 2054. In other words, your £1 today is only worth 20p in 2054. There are many future inflation calculators out there where you can tweak the figures.

So if you are 20 years from retirement, and you think 🤔 hey I can live off £2k a month if I were to retire today mortgage free, you would need to plan to have £8k a month to match that same living standard.

Keep in mind, the state pension does go up every year with a cost of living increase. This is why the triple lock is MORE important for the younger generations than it is for current OAPs. If the triple lock on state pension is broken, then the fate of Millenials and Gen Z will be abject poverty because the buying power of the state pension will erode year on year. The state pension is already not generous it has to keep pace with inflation or today’s young workers and students will be left with pennies on the £ to survive.

Lovesplasticstraws · 08/02/2024 13:02

Upthread PP said they or their DHs couldn't access Civil Service Pension until SPA. This isn't strictly the case. Can claim it earlier but will be reduced. Something like 4 to 5 percent per year below SPA. It is worth doing the sums because sometimes a smaller amount of money paid for longer is more beneficial than waiting. I am not a financial advisor etc

EdgarsTale · 08/02/2024 12:58

We’ll have 60k a year which should be plenty. I want to have enough for holidays, trips & meals out. I don’t just want to ‘survive.’

SummerFeverVenice · 08/02/2024 12:53

@saltinesandcoffeecups

  • ”Working for awhile until US SS kicks in for me (DH may get a small sum but he’s not eligible to contribute because of his pension rules)
  • ~$3K/mo /£2.3K per mo SS (your equivalent of NI, I think)

Your spouse can claim SS on their record or on your record without it affecting your SS claim. Depending on your age upon claiming, spousal benefits can range from 32.5 percent to 50 percent of your husband’s or wife’s primary insurance amount — the retirement benefit to which he or she is entitled at full retirement age, or FRA. Your spouse below refers to you, as it is written to your DH:

You are eligible for SS spousal benefits if:

  • Your spouse is already collecting retirement benefits.
  • You have been married for at least a year.
  • You are at least 62 years old (unless you are caring for a child who is under 16 or disabled, in which case the age rule does not apply).

You can collect benefits on a spouse’s work record regardless of whether you also worked. If you are eligible for both your own retirement benefit and a spousal benefit, Social Security will pay you the higher of the two amounts.

If your DH becomes a widower (sorry), he can still claim.
The chief criteria to qualify for survivor benefits are:

  • You were married to the deceased for at least nine months (unless the death is accidental or occurs in the line of military duty, in which case there is no minimum time period).
  • You are at least age 60, unless you are disabled (then it’s 50) or caring for a child of the deceased who is under 16 or disabled (in which case there's no age minimum).

https://www.aarp.org/retirement/social-security/questions-answers/spouse-social-security.html

Mypensionisthis · 08/02/2024 12:39

user1491396110 · 08/02/2024 12:12

Well this is a scary thread for me 🙈
We take home 2000 a month. We have £25 a week left after all out goings....

Once the kids are at school (another 4 years) we will have an extra £1000 a month but we need that to live a bit after having nothing for years, house repairs need doing and our car is on its last legs...

We are 38 so I don't see how we can possibly save enough to live on.

Scary.

But it's relative.
If you're on a smaller income, you will manage on less than that in retirement. Everyone needs to work out their own figures.
But, even if it's a tiny amount, start paying into a workplace pension as early as you can . It's tax-effective, the employer contributes and the effects of compound interest make a massive difference if you have had many years paying in.
And don't rely on a man! That's general life advice, not just about pensions.

user1491396110 · 08/02/2024 12:12

Well this is a scary thread for me 🙈
We take home 2000 a month. We have £25 a week left after all out goings....

Once the kids are at school (another 4 years) we will have an extra £1000 a month but we need that to live a bit after having nothing for years, house repairs need doing and our car is on its last legs...

We are 38 so I don't see how we can possibly save enough to live on.

Scary.

ClareBlue · 08/02/2024 12:01

You definitely don't need 2/3 rds your current income if you are above 30k.
You can make surprisingly good savings not being in work that you should factor in.
No commute costs and often can bin a car if you are 2 car household or even both as you have time for public transport
All leisure at off peak prices including flights etc for holidays
Time to shop around for all your services To get all the discounts and incentives
Flexibility to shop when there are deals to be had and respond quickly to take advantage Of vouchers etc
Research and find all sorts of events at discounts or subsidised prices
Time to cook and avoid impulse purchases, lunches at work, coffees, work collections, work clothes, etc
More relaxed and more time so less likely to impulse spend for quick gratification and repair and fix things yourself instead of paying for it
No peak travel. Find travel bargains on trains to cities etc because you can go when it's off peak

There's more, but that's the idea. We reckon you can easily halve what you live on by not being in work and have the same standard of living.

The big one is housing. If you are mortgage free then you have great options. But if your rent or mortgage is going to be part of your pension it is different.

Ponoka7 · 08/02/2024 11:38

We'll have around £24k between us and around £10k in savings, possibly for a nearly new car when needed. Mortgage free and don't have to give a lot towards GC, probably around £700 a year if that's all I can afford, we'll have enough as long as I stay mobile. It's when you need taxis to get around and really feel the cold etc. Along with pensions, health should be a priority. At the moment there is loads of free stuff to do were we live. I'd be happy to make my retirement about volunteering, the odd class and visiting were I can get to on my bus pass, if skint. On £24k we can do a holiday every year still and we'll probably do a tinsel and turkey weekend, but others would shudder at that.

vivainsomnia · 08/02/2024 11:36

Not so many holidays as were in 70's and 80's by then
My mum is mid 70s and my dad is 80. They are both still very active. They can easily walk 10km a day. They travel a lot, go away 6 weeks in the winter.

I guess it all comes down to your health and what you enjoy in life. I would expect £2,000 a month to enjoy mine, my OH about the same. Anything over would be great.

Bowbobobo · 08/02/2024 11:33

I’m five years off retiring, busy topping up my SIPP, buying ISAs and PBs, partly from income and partly from money left by my DF. Mortgage is paid off, which changed my situation and mindset completely. In today’s money I will need £36k to live comfortably, based on what I currently spend less the costs of working. I ignore ‘advice’ from the pension industry, which just wants you to stash cash to boost their profits, so a massive conflict of interest.

SpraggleWaggle · 08/02/2024 11:30

We are aiming for a real terms income of about £90k between the two of us, made up of a combination of DC pensions, a small amount of DB pension, ISAs and other savings. The plan is to retire before state pension age- if all goes to plan and if we're still eligible for state pension by the time they become payable, we'll then give some money to our kids and keep our income the same.

All of this is based on pretty standard assumptions about returns and inflation which could of course be completely wrong.

myphoneisbroken · 08/02/2024 11:26

(None of my friends and family have much money, and none will have MN-style pensions. I do think that matters as I am not comparing myself to those who have more.)

myphoneisbroken · 08/02/2024 11:24

These threads really make me laugh. I take home £3k now, I have to pay my mortgage (£500) and support my DC, I am also spending c. £700 a month on retraining. I have a comfortable lifestyle and am still able to save a bit. I expect to have £1700 or so a month in retirement and feel that that will be more than ample.

CandyLips · 08/02/2024 11:23

I am retired and have a good standard of living. I have no mortgage and have approx 55,000 pre tax. I don't have a mortgage. I holiday twice a year long haul and in the UK and Europe at least twice a year. I worked in many countries where others might not due to financial incentives.

Tontostitis · 08/02/2024 11:22

We gave up when they raided pensions back in the 90s and started buying derelict properties and renovating them as rentals. Now both retired in our early 60s we've sold a couple and we have around £30k a year from investments and live quite frugally. We've never been big spenders, we don't take foreign holidays etc although we do like to eat out and we just spend less. With no mortgage and just two of us at home it's amazingly cheaper than having kids, teenagers or young adults.

sensationalsally · 08/02/2024 11:22

A lot depends on where you live. Housing is cheap in my area, so we downsized to a very nice bungalow. All of our energy bills have halved as a result. We gave up one of our cars. We have an income of around 40k + state pension. We live a very comfortable lifestyle, restaurants, theatre visits, gym memberships, several holidays a year including long trips abroad. I was, like you, very worried before retirement about how we were going to manage. Turns out everything is more than fine. We do not have 2 thirds of our previous joint income, it's probably half.

BusyMummy001 · 08/02/2024 11:18

Very dependent on whether you plan to have the mortgage paid off, acquire a new car before you retire, have made sure the house is future proofed (boiler been replaced, roof maintained with a 25yr guarantee etc) and so on.

I’d do a schedule calculating things like annual cost of fuel bills, TV licence, council tax, car maintenance, dental check ups, vet fees, how much you’ve actually spent in the supermarkets in the last year; then add 10% to cover unexpected inflation (another war/oil crisis etc) to get your basic/essential living costs; then I’d add in an amount for holidays, activities (rambling assoc, rock choir, golf club fees etc), annual clothing/shoe spend, hair cuts, make up.

Think you can use templates on line as an aid.

All of these costs will be particular to you - only you know how much it costs to heat your house, which brands/how much you like to spend on clothing, how often you like to get your hair done (once every couple of years for me as I just can’t be bothered until it gets too long).

But once you have this figure you can start planning.

Flumpywoo · 08/02/2024 10:19

That's assuming you don't want a drop in living standards. If you have a very high income then I'm sure you could survive on less and still be comfortable.

Maybe work out what your outgoings are now (minus the mortgage and travel costs), including the cost of your annual holiday(s), money for Christmas, birthdays, car insurance etc. Basically anything you know you'll need to pay out for as standard every year.

99victoria · 08/02/2024 10:16

Never understood those calculators. My OH and I have about £20k between us in pensions. We both work part-time and bring in another £10k between us and we find it plenty to live on. Our mortgage is paid off - council tax ridiculously high which is annoying but we're careful with our spending. We can afford to go to the theatre, take the grandchildren out etc. We go abroad 2 or 3 times a year (I arrange and book them myself - I reckon I save about 1/3 of the cost doing that). We don't eat put or have takeaway etc but we've never really done that

I guess if you have expensive hobbies (my husband goes to football and has an allotment, I'm part of a local band and go walking and to lunch with friends and I'm a governor of a local school) or love fancy cars or want to fly business class, you might need more but we consider we have a great life on our £28/£30k.

We will have more of course, when we turn 67 in 4 years time and get our state pensions. We'll probably give up our jobs then 😊

Flumpywoo · 08/02/2024 10:13

In an ideal world I would say that you should have whatever your income is now (if comfortable) minus your mortgage payment and travel to work costs, assuming you'll be mortgage free when you retire. And hopefully have some savings built up as a back up, in case you need to do work on the house etc.

But depending on how long until you retire, you'll need what your income will be the equivalent of at retirement, as what you earn now will be worth less by then, due to inflation etc.

budgiegirl · 08/02/2024 10:05

I have three relatives who are pensioners, all now are widows. Two get an income of around £2000 per month, one has an income of around £3500. Mix of state pensions, private pensions, income from investments etc. Two of them are old enough that they still get a state pension from their deceased DHs, which is included in the figures, otherwise they'd be on quite a bit less.

All manage just fine on these incomes, although it helps that all are now mortgage free. They live comfortably, all though not extravagantly, and can afford holidays, days out, meals out, to run a car etc.

To say that you need £50k for a couple just isn't true, in my opinion. We bring home less than that now, and we have 3 teenagers and a mortgage. Again, we manage, and we have far more outgoings than my pensioner relatives.

Jmaho · 08/02/2024 09:54

My parents had about £1200 a month from my dad's private pension (he worked for 50 years and always paid in) and state pensions although my mum got less than full
They lived well. Modest house paid off at age 60, ate out a lot. Not so many holidays as were in 70's and 80's by then. But more than comfortable
Small amount in savings
Dad died last year and mum gets about £750 a month from his private pension plus state (she gets more now Dad has died) and she's doing fine financially
Not extravagant but can spend money without worrying
I think we will be OK but only in our 40's and I am still hoping to get a state pension. Without state pension life will be much less comfortable

Swipe left for the next trending thread