Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why are men like this? Working or not to work

183 replies

Teenangels · 07/02/2024 19:42

I am very lucky as I know the COL is effecting everyone at the moment.

I work fulltime, 4 day working week, and have 4 kids although they are now nearly adults/adults. My husband runs his own successful business.

Now here is the issue he can not understand why I would work, in a stressful job that I love. I stayed at home when the children were younger but once they went to school. I went back to work, the kids to private school, so had clubs and wraparound care, so it was easy for me to be at work. He does not do anything around the house and never has

My husband is wants me to be at home, go out for lunch, the gym, and meet out with friends.

Why are men so bloody old fashioned and dare I say proud that they can "keep" a woman.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Teenangels · 10/02/2024 13:13

Nancydrawn · 10/02/2024 01:01

For the record, I certainly don't think everyone without a job does this! I took it from this sentence from the OP: "My husband wants me to be at home, go out for lunch, the gym, and meet out with friends." Honestly, if anyone's saying that, it's the OP's husband.

I don't think paid work outside the house is the only way to be happy. If the OP was someone who wanted to stay home to garden, to volunteer, to get a degree, to sit and enjoy the work because that's what she likes: have at it!

I'm merely saying that for me, if my husband looked at my career and how important it was to me, and then said that I should quite to "go out for lunch, the gym, and meet out with friends," I'd wonder if he knew me at all, or if he respected who I wanted to be.

My husband has supported me working and as I previously said it really helped when we struggled.

He know thinks as we are stable that I don’t need to work, and have an easier life.

OP posts:
Nancydrawn · 10/02/2024 01:01

indigoskies · 09/02/2024 08:35

So work or don't work OP? Up to you. I'm not sure what you want from this? It will just incite the usual jealous posters with snipes about 'ladies who lunch' - as if that's all there is to do for women who don't work. The usual stupid comments that all women who don't work are obsessed with their nails or whatever. Must be, right?

For the record, I certainly don't think everyone without a job does this! I took it from this sentence from the OP: "My husband wants me to be at home, go out for lunch, the gym, and meet out with friends." Honestly, if anyone's saying that, it's the OP's husband.

I don't think paid work outside the house is the only way to be happy. If the OP was someone who wanted to stay home to garden, to volunteer, to get a degree, to sit and enjoy the work because that's what she likes: have at it!

I'm merely saying that for me, if my husband looked at my career and how important it was to me, and then said that I should quite to "go out for lunch, the gym, and meet out with friends," I'd wonder if he knew me at all, or if he respected who I wanted to be.

flatmop · 09/02/2024 11:12

If I had the choice between a stressful job or not working, I'd stop working. If I was bored, I'd find an easier job part-time job that gave me a routine without the stress. I can understand his confusion.

EC22 · 09/02/2024 10:42

can we swap husbands haha
as long as he’s not forcing you to give up work I see no issue

EvangelicalAboutButteredToast · 09/02/2024 10:41

My guess is he is sick of hearing about your job. Do you vent to him about it?

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 09/02/2024 10:39

professionalmum01 · 09/02/2024 10:09

Also, quitting work is not just about pottering about at home. If you have kids you can be way more involved as a parent thats much harder to do well when working. Also, you can do volunteering work and give back to the community. You can go back to uni to learn a new skill. There's a lot that can be done if not working.

The thing is, lots of people in work volunteer in the community and go back to uni etc as well. I did a part time MBA a few years ago and have volunteered in the community for years... the skills that I've gained through my work enable me to contribute in ways that I wouldn't be able to otherwise.

As for being an involved parent, I don't feel that I would have done a better job if I hadn't worked. I was able to work flexibly to be there for dd whenever needed and dh was a hands-on, involved parent too. I couldn't be any prouder of the adult that she has become, nor could I be any happier with the quality of our relationship. I don't think it makes a difference tbh... though in any case, this question is irrelevant to the OP as her kids are already grown up.

My mum did the whole study/volunteering/SAHP thing and it simply wasn't enough for her... she wishes that she had kept her career. I think both dh and I would feel the same.

professionalmum01 · 09/02/2024 10:29

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 09/02/2024 10:19

No I don't, but that wouldn't make any difference. It isn't about the money.

I guess I come at this from a different perspective than many, because my own mother bitterly regrets having given up her career to be at home, despite having had a very comfortable life financially on my dad's income. It is her single biggest regret in life and the source of so much sadness - not because of the lost earnings or financial independence etc, but because of the perception that she wasted her talents, failed to fulfil her potential and didn't make the contribution to society that she could have made. She is in her eighties now, and it still impacts negatively on her mental health.

My DH is an intelligent, driven and ambitious man who takes pride in his achievements and wants to make his mark on the world. I wouldn't dream of suggesting that his work was unimportant simply because of how much I might earn. Yes, we are married, but he is an individual with dreams and aspirations of his own.

I get that as we are come from different backgrounds. My mum never worked and absolutely loved being a SAHM. She had zero interests in working and if she had married a wealthy man which she didn't would of been her dream come true. Her sister did marry a wealthy man and she has never worked a day in her life and yes i do get the co dependency as both in retirement age and she does have to cater for his every needs but she wasn't savvy enough to secure her own financial secure without depending on him but she has lived a very luxurious life travelling the world. That's the thing we are all so different :)

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 09/02/2024 10:19

professionalmum01 · 09/02/2024 10:06

But do you earn 750k a year and are closer to retirement? The context matters

No I don't, but that wouldn't make any difference. It isn't about the money.

I guess I come at this from a different perspective than many, because my own mother bitterly regrets having given up her career to be at home, despite having had a very comfortable life financially on my dad's income. It is her single biggest regret in life and the source of so much sadness - not because of the lost earnings or financial independence etc, but because of the perception that she wasted her talents, failed to fulfil her potential and didn't make the contribution to society that she could have made. She is in her eighties now, and it still impacts negatively on her mental health.

My DH is an intelligent, driven and ambitious man who takes pride in his achievements and wants to make his mark on the world. I wouldn't dream of suggesting that his work was unimportant simply because of how much I might earn. Yes, we are married, but he is an individual with dreams and aspirations of his own.

Saymyname28 · 09/02/2024 10:15

I don't think it's about the pride of "keeping" you but of owning you. For you to have nothing better to do than cater to them, to have no power or independence.

professionalmum01 · 09/02/2024 10:14

ItsAllGoingWrongNow · 09/02/2024 10:09

Yes I have 3 young kids. I earn £80k FTE as a lawyer. I'm currently working 2/3rds time.

DH earns many multiples of that and has for the last 15 years or so...

I spent 7 years qualifying as a lawyer, and get immense satisfaction and stimulation from my job. I feel it contributes to society and it's a massive part of my identity. The idea that I wouldn't do it purely because I'm married to someone (with a penis) who earns more than me is absolutely awful.

I don't think its because you are married to man that earns more is the reason for women deciding to stop working. Some women genuinely don't enjoy their jobs. Some of them get tired of it and want to stop and have a break, Its great that you love your work.
Plus i'd imagine that as your husband is earning 800k a year then you can pay for nannies/cleaners/gardeners etc... so you can focus on work and i do get why women want to work as I'm one of them and the husband could support us but then if he was on 800k I'm not sure i would be doing what I'm doing. I'm on a six figure salary too.

indigoskies · 09/02/2024 10:12

It's personal preference isn't it? I know quite a few self-made men who have come from nothing, but made hundreds of millions through .com or finance, but their wives still prefer to keep in working in some capacity, even though the money is effectively meaningless to the family. They just need that structure and self-esteem. Other wives don't work because they value time and flexibility over the benefits of their particular work. They may do a lot if other things - you're only limited by energy and imagination really. Nobody judges anyone and nobody ever talks about work anyway.

professionalmum01 · 09/02/2024 10:09

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 09/02/2024 10:04

Indeed. I earn a lot more than my DH and can easily cover our household costs. It wouldn't occur to me to suggest that DH should just quit his job to potter around at home...I think he would find that very patronising and disrespectful.

Work is about so much more than money for many people.

Also, quitting work is not just about pottering about at home. If you have kids you can be way more involved as a parent thats much harder to do well when working. Also, you can do volunteering work and give back to the community. You can go back to uni to learn a new skill. There's a lot that can be done if not working.

ItsAllGoingWrongNow · 09/02/2024 10:09

professionalmum01 · 09/02/2024 10:03

What do you constitute as a high income though as this means different things to different people?
Have you got kids as that changes everything! Before kids the thought of not working would be inconceivable. But now with two kids and a stressful job i do ask myself why i bother at times even if i know i couldn't be a SAHM.

Edited

Yes I have 3 young kids. I earn £80k FTE as a lawyer. I'm currently working 2/3rds time.

DH earns many multiples of that and has for the last 15 years or so...

I spent 7 years qualifying as a lawyer, and get immense satisfaction and stimulation from my job. I feel it contributes to society and it's a massive part of my identity. The idea that I wouldn't do it purely because I'm married to someone (with a penis) who earns more than me is absolutely awful.

professionalmum01 · 09/02/2024 10:06

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 09/02/2024 10:04

Indeed. I earn a lot more than my DH and can easily cover our household costs. It wouldn't occur to me to suggest that DH should just quit his job to potter around at home...I think he would find that very patronising and disrespectful.

Work is about so much more than money for many people.

But do you earn 750k a year and are closer to retirement? The context matters

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 09/02/2024 10:04

ItsAllGoingWrongNow · 09/02/2024 09:59

But this places all the benefits of working on financial earnings. For me (and for many people) working is so, so, much more than that.

My DH earns 10x what I do (and I'm a fairly high earner) but I wouldn't ever stop working because it's so much more than just income.

Indeed. I earn a lot more than my DH and can easily cover our household costs. It wouldn't occur to me to suggest that DH should just quit his job to potter around at home...I think he would find that very patronising and disrespectful.

Work is about so much more than money for many people.

professionalmum01 · 09/02/2024 10:03

ItsAllGoingWrongNow · 09/02/2024 09:59

But this places all the benefits of working on financial earnings. For me (and for many people) working is so, so, much more than that.

My DH earns 10x what I do (and I'm a fairly high earner) but I wouldn't ever stop working because it's so much more than just income.

What do you constitute as a high income though as this means different things to different people?
Have you got kids as that changes everything! Before kids the thought of not working would be inconceivable. But now with two kids and a stressful job i do ask myself why i bother at times even if i know i couldn't be a SAHM.

ItsAllGoingWrongNow · 09/02/2024 09:59

professionalmum01 · 09/02/2024 09:54

Its pretty simple. If he's making 750k a year and you are working 4 days a week and getting stressed then anyone would ask why bother working. If my husband was earning 750k a year i would not be doing what I'm doing now and just be doing part time contract work for "pin" money. We are married and have kids and i've got savings so those who are saying you need to secure your financial future well yes i am as if we get divorced he'll have to share that money as well as pay for maintainance for the kids. Also, as I'll be doing part time contract work I can still do more full time work if the relationship breaks down but unlikely given that we have been together for over 20 years.
On Mumsnet there is a big cross section of individuals from all walks of life and asking the general population what they think when they are not in your situation isn't really going to give you any useful insights into his behaviour. Perhaps you need to ask other women in the same situation as you what they think and most of the time you'lll find its that he's earning so much that the money you earn doesn't even touch the sides and instead he'd rather see you taking it easy and relaxing than working when you don't need to. You mentioned having grown up kids too. I can think of a lot of things i could do with my time if i was an empty nester rather than working. Going to the gym, getting my nails done, eating out, travelling and then doing some part time work to keep myself in the "game" so to speak. My husband oftens says you know you can quit work when you want to. He's a high income earner but i am as well but not quite earning 750k a year. If he was then i might change my mind.

Edited

But this places all the benefits of working on financial earnings. For me (and for many people) working is so, so, much more than that.

My DH earns 10x what I do (and I'm a fairly high earner) but I wouldn't ever stop working because it's so much more than just income.

professionalmum01 · 09/02/2024 09:54

Its pretty simple. If he's making 750k a year and you are working 4 days a week and getting stressed then anyone would ask why bother working. If my husband was earning 750k a year i would not be doing what I'm doing now and just be doing part time contract work for "pin" money. We are married and have kids and i've got savings so those who are saying you need to secure your financial future well yes i am as if we get divorced he'll have to share that money as well as pay for maintainance for the kids. Also, as I'll be doing part time contract work I can still do more full time work if the relationship breaks down but unlikely given that we have been together for over 20 years.
On Mumsnet there is a big cross section of individuals from all walks of life and asking the general population what they think when they are not in your situation isn't really going to give you any useful insights into his behaviour. Perhaps you need to ask other women in the same situation as you what they think and most of the time you'lll find its that he's earning so much that the money you earn doesn't even touch the sides and instead he'd rather see you taking it easy and relaxing than working when you don't need to. You mentioned having grown up kids too. I can think of a lot of things i could do with my time if i was an empty nester rather than working. Going to the gym, getting my nails done, eating out, travelling and then doing some part time work to keep myself in the "game" so to speak. My husband oftens says you know you can quit work when you want to. He's a high income earner but i am as well but not quite earning 750k a year. If he was then i might change my mind.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 09/02/2024 09:42

Out of interest, OP, in what way do you think his views are "old fashioned", given that you don't consider him to be sexist?

And why did you say that he was proud to "keep" a woman if you actually meant that he was proud of having come from very little to where he is now? That seems an odd phrase to use if his pride isn't specifically linked to the idea of being able to support a non-working wife?

The tone of your posts seems to have changed dramatically from the start of the thread, when you seemed quite irritated by his "old fashioned" views and his ego-driven stance, but now you seem to be keen to assure us that he is the model husband who has only ever been concerned about making your life easier.

Is it easier for you to come to terms with the idea that he is just a bit old fashioned than to confront the very likely prospect that he is actually very sexist? Because that's certainly how it comes across on this thread.

Teenangels · 09/02/2024 08:56

indigoskies · 09/02/2024 08:35

So work or don't work OP? Up to you. I'm not sure what you want from this? It will just incite the usual jealous posters with snipes about 'ladies who lunch' - as if that's all there is to do for women who don't work. The usual stupid comments that all women who don't work are obsessed with their nails or whatever. Must be, right?

I wanted to ask how women would feel, I think it’s his pride, that he has come from very little to where we are now.

I did not see it as sexist, he just does not get it that I will be bored. I know that with the COL crisis it seems like first world problems.

OP posts:
indigoskies · 09/02/2024 08:35

So work or don't work OP? Up to you. I'm not sure what you want from this? It will just incite the usual jealous posters with snipes about 'ladies who lunch' - as if that's all there is to do for women who don't work. The usual stupid comments that all women who don't work are obsessed with their nails or whatever. Must be, right?

Teenangels · 09/02/2024 08:19

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 09/02/2024 01:15

I'm not trying to "pin this on being sexist", I'm simply reflecting back what I've read.

I'm not sure why you even started this thread tbh, or what you expected posters to say.

As for your question as to whether it was sexist for you to support him at the beginning of your relationship when you earned more? No. But I do think it's interesting that you started off as the higher earner in your relationship and yet your career was still somehow the one that ended up taking a back seat.

We did start of the relationship with me earning more over 20 years ago, my career never took a back seat, I worked and stayed at home looking after the children, while working part time as that is what I wanted to, he started working hard at the business.

We knew that I would never make profits over 3/4 of million a year like he does with me working in the public sector.

OP posts:
ilovebreadsauce · 09/02/2024 01:17

He probably thinks if you as a family can afford it, one if you should be bringing up the kids.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 09/02/2024 01:15

Teenangels · 08/02/2024 20:44

I THINK he is proud that he has achieved so much and we enjoy a life that I do not have to work but chose to work, my earnings are for me alone.

I have not backtracked, I did do and do more around the house, because when he was starting the business he was working 80-90 hours, and I was working 16-25 hours a week.

If I was earning equally or we both had to work to make ends meet then of course it would be sexist. I can never dream to earn what he makes from the business in 10 years and yes that makes of very privileged.

I know I am lucky not to have to work but I want to as I would become very bored.

Was it sexist that I earned more then him at the beginning of our relationship but I supported him?

Honestly I think that you are trying to pin this on being sexist.

I'm not trying to "pin this on being sexist", I'm simply reflecting back what I've read.

I'm not sure why you even started this thread tbh, or what you expected posters to say.

As for your question as to whether it was sexist for you to support him at the beginning of your relationship when you earned more? No. But I do think it's interesting that you started off as the higher earner in your relationship and yet your career was still somehow the one that ended up taking a back seat.

Nancydrawn · 08/02/2024 22:45

PS: I'm not saying you feel the same way that I do about work, OP. But I do hope your husband can take the way you feel, whatever way that is, seriously.