Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Smart phone ban for children

37 replies

Signalbox · 07/02/2024 16:47

Following the tragic death of teenager Brianna Ghey, Brianna's mum is calling for a ban on children having unrestricted use of smart phones.

AIBU to think that this is a really great idea.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/p0h9h4nt

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/av/uk-68197138

BBC Radio 4 - Best of Today, The parents calling for a 'smartphone-free childhood'

The mother of murdered teenager Brianna Ghey is calling for an under-16 social media ban

https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/p0h9h4nt

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
RatatouillePie · 08/02/2024 12:43

It's called parenting.

I teach in a secondary school and lots of parents can't be bothered with the arguments of saying NO to a child, so let them do as they please.

I have no issue with my teenager having a smart phone, BUT I get to choose which apps he can and can't have, and I use family link to make sure I can monitor his phone usage, and limit how much time he can spend on certain apps. I have very clear rules/boundaries and he knows the consequence if he breaks them. (e.g. no phone at all).

Absolutely no phone in his room at night. I am so bored of teenagers that are not getting enough sleep due to being on their phones at night!

At my school phones are banned. Any phone spotted is confiscated and the parent collects it. This is to limit bullying during school hours.

The messages I've seen (Snapchat etc...) and screenshots that my tutor group have shown me are often quite vile and it's no wonder some kids feel like shit when they receive messages like that from cowards who hide behind an app.

Pandadunks · 08/02/2024 12:38

I would love this, if sudden ‘dumb’ phones became all the rage with kids!
The genie is out of the bottle though.
Our kids have no Social Media at all age 14 and 11 and I would highly recommend that.

Acatdance · 08/02/2024 12:37

I don't see how you'd realistically enforce it.

Propertylover · 08/02/2024 12:36

I think the initial idea makes sense if developed properly.

We used to have mobile phones that only made and receive phone calls and text. We have simple mobile phones for older users.

It is therefore not impossible to develop phones that allow phone calls, texts and apps for health monitoring but with no (very limited) access to social media or the internet.

No child needs a phone that has the ability to access porn or social media. I would like to see a study on the impact of children (sadly primarily boys) being able to access porn etc. on their phones on the increase of VAWG. Also a study of the impact of social media on children’s mental health.

This is much wider that the sad murder of Brianna and about the mental health of current and future children.

Bananamoonshine · 07/02/2024 19:21

My dd has had a smartphone since she was 6 due to medical conditions requiring her to carry one at all times. She’s a teenager now, she has never looked up anything inappropriate or sent any nasty messages etc etc

LlynTegid · 07/02/2024 19:17

Social media sites would take responsibility if all the countries where their advertising revenue comes from would charge much higher taxes if they did not.

JanefromLondon1 · 07/02/2024 19:14

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn due to privacy concerns.

Beezknees · 07/02/2024 19:14

No, I don't agree that they should be banned. Parents should monitor them more.

SOME social media sites need to take responsibility. Twitter/X is full of porn. All other social media sites seem to be able to block this but not that one.

TheSnowyOwl · 07/02/2024 19:10

Banning phones or the internet isn’t the answer. Most children have access to computers at home and for a lot of those children the restrictions are non existent or not sufficient but the parents are ignorant of this or fooled into thinking that they have suitable controls and observation. It’s rarely foolproof and often children are better with technology that their parents.

Signalbox · 07/02/2024 19:06

It needs to be described better. Dont let your kid into the equivalent of a drugs and sex den where there are threats of harm and exposure to frightening or dangerous behaviour, thats what people are saying

This. For those arguing for education you can educate children about something bad without giving them unrestricted access to that thing.

OP posts:
Signalbox · 07/02/2024 19:03

soupfiend · 07/02/2024 18:43

Banning phones - is short hand though and I think its better to be more precise about what is being said here

Its unrestricted access to violence, porn, unsafe people, risky forums/threads, unmonitered or unsafe social media sites - this is the problem

Phones can supply all that if they are smart phones and are unmonitored and on the child 24/7 so thats why this is being said like this.

It needs to be described better. Dont let your kid into the equivalent of a drugs and sex den where there are threats of harm and exposure to frightening or dangerous behaviour, thats what people are saying

However how you do this, I dont know.

Yes well put. This is what I should have said in my OP.

OP posts:
soupfiend · 07/02/2024 18:43

Banning phones - is short hand though and I think its better to be more precise about what is being said here

Its unrestricted access to violence, porn, unsafe people, risky forums/threads, unmonitered or unsafe social media sites - this is the problem

Phones can supply all that if they are smart phones and are unmonitored and on the child 24/7 so thats why this is being said like this.

It needs to be described better. Dont let your kid into the equivalent of a drugs and sex den where there are threats of harm and exposure to frightening or dangerous behaviour, thats what people are saying

However how you do this, I dont know.

Janiie · 07/02/2024 18:30

Newbutoldfather · 07/02/2024 17:53

I think parents need to control their children’s access to the internet, not the state.

It would be impossible to control, anyway.

This. Parents need to snoop and snoop until they are 100% sure their kids can use sm safely and appropriately. So, random checks. Know their passwords. They have to earn trust it isnt just given when a smart phone is handed over. How can the murderers parents have had no idea what their 15yr olds were looking at?!

StopTheBusINeedAWeeWeeAWeeWeeBagOChips · 07/02/2024 17:57

Signalbox · 07/02/2024 17:50

All that will happen is we will have a bunch of people hitting 16/18 and having no real clue how to use these things appropriately and not being supervised properly while they find out the hard way

This is the situation we have now only it is children age 10 / 11 / 12 who are not being supervised properly while they find out the hard way.

And I think the argument is that phones for children would limit what they can access on the internet rather than an all out ban.

Which is why education is important for parents and kids.

Responsible parents will have various measures in place to restrict things already.

The kids without supervision need educating, not banning.

Allfur · 07/02/2024 17:55

Syndulla - 'people who have experienced trauma often search out simple solutions' - what like the Dutch guy whose kid was killed by a car, whilst cycling to school and subsequently campaigned for bike lanes? Look at Holland now. Real change can indeed come from trauma.

iamveryearlytoday · 07/02/2024 17:53

I would love to see them banned for children under a certain age. My kids are still very young, but I really hope there is an enormous social shift before they get to secondary school.

Newbutoldfather · 07/02/2024 17:53

I think parents need to control their children’s access to the internet, not the state.

It would be impossible to control, anyway.

Signalbox · 07/02/2024 17:50

All that will happen is we will have a bunch of people hitting 16/18 and having no real clue how to use these things appropriately and not being supervised properly while they find out the hard way

This is the situation we have now only it is children age 10 / 11 / 12 who are not being supervised properly while they find out the hard way.

And I think the argument is that phones for children would limit what they can access on the internet rather than an all out ban.

OP posts:
CurlsnSunshinetime4tea · 07/02/2024 17:48

teaching children and young people how online content can be "faked" would be the way to go.
teaching and modeling responsible usage is the way forward.
it's one thing for a child to watch muana at a restaurant vs a teen watching a gang development and a live altercation.

Janiie · 07/02/2024 17:48

I mean surely banning the dark web and torture clips is the way to go.

Signalbox · 07/02/2024 17:45

CurlsnSunshinetime4tea · 07/02/2024 17:29

It’s not really the “phone” but access to influencers/social media content.
phones can be safely used to coordinate pick up and drop offs in this busy world.

Yes I think it's a call to limit what children have access to on their phones rather than banning phones completely. I think often parents are completely unaware of the content that children have access to or otherwise monitoring what they are looking at can become such a battlefield they just give up.

OP posts:
DancefloorAcrobatics · 07/02/2024 17:34

I won't deny that phones and more so social media can be evil.
But how would you enforce a ban?
Education and exposure is the better way forward.

We invented this online world, now we need to teach our children how to negotiate it.

Briannas death is tragic. I won't deny that the hatred has been fuelled by social media, but its the killers who are fully responsible for her death.

CurlsnSunshinetime4tea · 07/02/2024 17:29

It’s not really the “phone” but access to influencers/social media content.
phones can be safely used to coordinate pick up and drop offs in this busy world.

Signalbox · 07/02/2024 17:24

SleepingBeautySnores · 07/02/2024 17:17

She doesn't want phones for kids to be banned, she just doesn't want them having access to the internet on their phones, and bearing in mind how much teen suicide due to cyber bullying has increased so much, I don't blame her, just for that fact alone.

Think about it, why do we give our kids a phone?

Is it so that they can contact us in emergency?

Or do you want them to have access to things that you wouldn't in a million years dream of giving them if they were in the shops. You wouldn't buy them porn magazines would you?

Surely you haven't bought your child a phone in order that their so called friends can bully them, did you?

If you answered yes to the first question, but no to the other two, then why not agree that she actually has a point?

Or is it that most of us are simply scared of having to deal with our kids having a tantrum if we take their access to the internet via their phones, away from them that makes us automatically say no, won't happen? If that's the reason, then let's face it, we're shit parents!

I think the point made in the BBC Sounds piece, that it is too late for children who already have smart phones, is about right. The idea would need to be aimed at delaying younger children from having access to them. That way you are not depriving an older child of something they already have but you are recognising the harms and acting to reduce them for the next generation.

OP posts:
StopTheBusINeedAWeeWeeAWeeWeeBagOChips · 07/02/2024 17:24

No, banning is rarely the way.

Better education for children, and parents coming to the time when their kids will want phones would be far more effective.

All that will happen is we will have a bunch of people hitting 16/18 and having no real clue how to use these things appropriately and not being supervised properly while they find out the hard way.

I totally understand why her Mum is calling for this, but I don't think it should happen.