Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To hate it being called pancake tuesday

639 replies

scrambledeggsandbeans · 07/02/2024 15:55

Just that really, it's shrove Tuesday it is the traditional feast day before the start of Lent on Ash Wednesday. Lent – the 40 days leading up to Easter – was traditionally a time of fasting

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
Fink · 09/02/2024 20:16

HowdidImanagetohavetwoaccountaandthenloseboth · 09/02/2024 19:46

The programme that I do allows us to relax one discipline on Sundays (e.g. we could have pudding, or alcohol, or television, or not exercise, or not get enough sleep ... but we're not allowed to go back onto social media, and we're not allowed to relax the prayer

Blimy! sounds like prison or even worse an English state secondary school!

The major difference is that it's voluntary! We choose to sign up to the programme as individuals, and then meet up regularly with other women doing it. Only a minority of people in the parish do it, and there's no judgement on those who do or don't, or what anyone else chooses to give up/do. I like having a structure and a challenge. Otherwise, I know myself, I would try to cheat - I'd keep to the letter of the rules and not the spirit. I find it helpful to have some accountability.

Plus, it makes the chocolate blow out on Easter Sunday a) really special and b) not a guilty pleasure. You can tell a good Catholic, because any weight they lose from fasting in Lent will be straight back on by the end of Easter week!

Fink · 09/02/2024 20:08

OchonAgusOchonOh · 09/02/2024 19:47

Reporting back on the eastern/orthodox rules.

Nothing is eaten until sundown and then the food is not exactly feast like. No meat, fish, eggs, dairy products, wine or oil.

However, there are exceptions. Wine and oil are permitted on Saturdays, Sundays, and a few feast days, and fish is permitted on palm Sunday as well as the annunciation when it falls before Palm Sunday, and, best of all, caviar is permitted on Lazarus Saturday. Meat and dairy are prohibited entirely until the fast is broken on Easter.

No sex either during lent.

My Orthodox friend always has a Lenten birthday. You can imagine how delicious the cake is made without dairy products, oil, or eggs!

It's much easier if you live in a majority-Orthodox country. In Greece, for example, you can buy a whole range of compliant foods in average supermarkets, they're in the 'fasting' aisle! It's brilliant for people with lactose intolerance and so on. And they've developped a load of tasty vegetable dishes made without dairy or oil. Because they don't only fast during Lent, there are three other fasts in the year and then twice weekly for the rest of the year.

The no food until sunset thing is not widely observed, that's just for the real hardcore enthusiasts. A couple of levels below that is no main meal before midday, which is much easier. The general expectation, even if you only do the basic level, is to eat less than usual at every meal.

No sex during Lent was traditional in western Catholicism too. We leave it up to the couple to decide for themselves now, but I know some still observe it.

Abhannmor · 09/02/2024 20:03

OchonAgusOchonOh · 09/02/2024 18:52

Big is a relative term. I possibly made it sound bigger than it actually is. It's still only about 2% of the population but I guess it is quite visible because there are a lot of CoI churches in towns and villages from the days of british rule. Obviously a lot of the churches are no longer in use.

Edited

True. Because all old Catholic churches or their sites became C of I post Reformation. Catholic churches tend to date from the mid 1800s onwards. Often big and not very pretty. We are a mostly Catholic country yet there is no official Catholic cathedral in Dublin or Cork.

SummerDays2020 · 09/02/2024 19:54

I've never heard it called Pancake Tuesday (but I'm in England) Always Pancake day/Shrove Tuesday. It can be both at the same time. My DD goes to a RC school and they do pancake tossing in the Nun's garden!

Fink · 09/02/2024 19:50

OchonAgusOchonOh · 09/02/2024 19:41

Yeah, we'd often give up something we didn't like. I regularly gave up sugar in my tea, despite not actually drinking tea.

I remember my daughter one year giving up chocolate biscuits. She still ate chocolate and biscuits, just not biscuits that came pre-packaged with chocolate on/in them. She sometimes ate actual pieces of chocolate as a topping on plain biscuits, which she would never do outside of Lent. I felt that was slightly taking the metaphorical biscuit. 😅

The nuns didn't tell us about Sundays either when we were young. Since it's personal devotion and not official theology, it's hard to find historical information for how/when the Church's official stance on it changed. I still don't know if the teaching developped between my childhood and now, or if it was always Sundays off but no one ever spoke about it, or if it had long been the practice in some other places in the world, and more travel and globalisation meant it eventually reached us.

OchonAgusOchonOh · 09/02/2024 19:47

Reporting back on the eastern/orthodox rules.

Nothing is eaten until sundown and then the food is not exactly feast like. No meat, fish, eggs, dairy products, wine or oil.

However, there are exceptions. Wine and oil are permitted on Saturdays, Sundays, and a few feast days, and fish is permitted on palm Sunday as well as the annunciation when it falls before Palm Sunday, and, best of all, caviar is permitted on Lazarus Saturday. Meat and dairy are prohibited entirely until the fast is broken on Easter.

No sex either during lent.

knitnerd90 · 09/02/2024 19:47

Have skipped a bunch of pages but I like the version in a bunch of Midwest/Rust Belt cities -- pazcki day! (Polish style doughnuts, with fillings)

HowdidImanagetohavetwoaccountaandthenloseboth · 09/02/2024 19:46

The programme that I do allows us to relax one discipline on Sundays (e.g. we could have pudding, or alcohol, or television, or not exercise, or not get enough sleep ... but we're not allowed to go back onto social media, and we're not allowed to relax the prayer

Blimy! sounds like prison or even worse an English state secondary school!

OchonAgusOchonOh · 09/02/2024 19:41

ColleenDonaghy · 09/02/2024 19:40

My mum didn't even let me have Paddy's Day OR my birthday off.

We did keep it simple though - many's a year we just gave up salt on our dinner. Grin

Yeah, we'd often give up something we didn't like. I regularly gave up sugar in my tea, despite not actually drinking tea.

ColleenDonaghy · 09/02/2024 19:40

My mum didn't even let me have Paddy's Day OR my birthday off.

We did keep it simple though - many's a year we just gave up salt on our dinner. Grin

OchonAgusOchonOh · 09/02/2024 19:36

Fink · 09/02/2024 19:25

The line now is that whatever you give up is your own personal devotion, so it's up to you whether you carry on with it on Sundays or have a day off. Both can be justified theologically - on the one hand, Sunday is always the day of the Resurrection so should always have an element of celebration, even in a penitential season; on the other hand, even the Sundays in Lent have a liturgically penitential slant, and they're called First Sunday of Lent, not First Sunday around Lent. 😁 The programme that I do allows us to relax one discipline on Sundays (e.g. we could have pudding, or alcohol, or television, or not exercise, or not get enough sleep ... but we're not allowed to go back onto social media, and we're not allowed to relax the prayer requirements).

Solemnities (major feast days) are the same as Sundays. More often than not the Annunciation and St. Joseph's Day will be during Lent. St. Patrick's Day is a solemnity in Ireland but not in most other countries. Birthdays I guess it's up to the individual. I have a birthday which is sometimes in Lent and sometimes not; I'm glad it's not this year!

Eastern Catholics and Orthodox are different. There what you give up on which days is fixed, all that varies is how strictly you observe it.

The nuns never told us any of that. It was just give up for lent.

It sounds like you do a lot over lent. Good for you. I do think occasional self discipline like that is generally good for us regardless of any religious beliefs.

The eastern/orthodox sounds fascinating. I'm off to Google what you give up on what day. I guess they need to be careful not to get their data mixed up😁

Wellhellooooodear · 09/02/2024 19:33

Hate it if you like but nobody cares. Pancake day here.

Fink · 09/02/2024 19:25

OchonAgusOchonOh · 09/02/2024 18:49

That's a total swiz. We were never told you were allowed to break the giving up on sundays. Paddy's day and your birthday if it was during lent were the only accepted concessions.

The line now is that whatever you give up is your own personal devotion, so it's up to you whether you carry on with it on Sundays or have a day off. Both can be justified theologically - on the one hand, Sunday is always the day of the Resurrection so should always have an element of celebration, even in a penitential season; on the other hand, even the Sundays in Lent have a liturgically penitential slant, and they're called First Sunday of Lent, not First Sunday around Lent. 😁 The programme that I do allows us to relax one discipline on Sundays (e.g. we could have pudding, or alcohol, or television, or not exercise, or not get enough sleep ... but we're not allowed to go back onto social media, and we're not allowed to relax the prayer requirements).

Solemnities (major feast days) are the same as Sundays. More often than not the Annunciation and St. Joseph's Day will be during Lent. St. Patrick's Day is a solemnity in Ireland but not in most other countries. Birthdays I guess it's up to the individual. I have a birthday which is sometimes in Lent and sometimes not; I'm glad it's not this year!

Eastern Catholics and Orthodox are different. There what you give up on which days is fixed, all that varies is how strictly you observe it.

OchonAgusOchonOh · 09/02/2024 18:52

Sceptic1234 · 09/02/2024 18:49

I'm possibly a bit like you...brought up in a C of E tradition but an atheist. Find churches / denomination intersting. Church of England priests are definitely ordained and I think the process is quite long.

Intersting that Church of Ireland is so big. The Scottish anglican church is very small.

Big is a relative term. I possibly made it sound bigger than it actually is. It's still only about 2% of the population but I guess it is quite visible because there are a lot of CoI churches in towns and villages from the days of british rule. Obviously a lot of the churches are no longer in use.

OchonAgusOchonOh · 09/02/2024 18:49

HowdidImanagetohavetwoaccountaandthenloseboth · 09/02/2024 18:35

I was told once the Sundays aren’t part of lent , just the other days making it 40. So on Sunday you can take the host , drink the wine or have anything you have given up for Lent.
Now I know that Shrove comes from absolution at confession ( thanks pp on this thread) shall call it pancake day in future ! Being the atheist I am , these days.
Thanks also to the pp who remarked that being an atheist was great what with all that food, chocolate, booze and presents. Made me smile .

ps can you have pancakes tomorrow ( Saturday) you know , just to perfect them for Tuesday? Asking for a friend

That's a total swiz. We were never told you were allowed to break the giving up on sundays. Paddy's day and your birthday if it was during lent were the only accepted concessions.

Sceptic1234 · 09/02/2024 18:49

OchonAgusOchonOh · 09/02/2024 18:44

The church of Ireland isn't all that small. Certainly in comparison to catholicism it is but there are still plenty of churches around. There are three within spitting distance (well, 40 minute drive) of me and I live rurally. I know they have bishops and priests but our local one goes by Rev and is a woman.

Do church of England ones not get ordained as priests? What do they call the equivalent of being ordained?

Sorry for the 20 questions but I find it all really interesting, despite being an atheist.

I'm possibly a bit like you...brought up in a C of E tradition but an atheist. Find churches / denomination intersting. Church of England priests are definitely ordained and I think the process is quite long.

Intersting that Church of Ireland is so big. The Scottish anglican church is very small.

OchonAgusOchonOh · 09/02/2024 18:47

OchonAgusOchonOh · 09/02/2024 18:45

I wonder is it a breakaway group? I will google.

Wikipedia says:

The Church in Wales (Welsh: Yr Eglwys yng Nghymru) adopted its name by accident. The Welsh Church Act 1914 referred throughout to "the Church in Wales", the phrase being used to indicate the part of the Church of England within Wales. At a convention (of the Welsh Church) held in Cardiff in October 1917, Mr Justice Sankey said that, while the name "the Church of Wales" appealed to him, he advised that there were good legal reasons why the name "the Church in Wales" should be adopted, at least at first, in order to follow the wording in the act. The matter was therefore left at that convention for the second Governing Body to decide at its first session.[7]

BeautyGoesToBenidorm · 09/02/2024 18:46

I'm Jewish with three Jewish DC and an atheist partner. We like pancakes, that's it 😁😁

OchonAgusOchonOh · 09/02/2024 18:45

Sceptic1234 · 09/02/2024 18:32

Wonders of Google.... there is a small Anglican Church in Wales, but for some reason it is called "The Church in Wales" rather than the Church of wales.

I wonder is it a breakaway group? I will google.

OchonAgusOchonOh · 09/02/2024 18:44

Sceptic1234 · 09/02/2024 18:26

It gets complicated....the Church of England is Anglican, but the Church of Scotland is Presbyterian. The Anglican church in Scotland is very small called the Scottish Episcopalian Church.

I think there is a small Anglican "Church of Ireland" in Ireland itself and that the few protestants in the south tend to belong to it. They have bishops, priests etc like catholics. Some Anglican ministers choose to be called "Father" (even in England) but it's not that common.

Almost all protestants in the North are Presbeterians and have much more in common with Scottish protestants than with English Anglicans ... they have no bishops or priests, church elders and ministers run things.

All the protestant churches reject the idea that there is anyone on earth who can speak with authority about what God wants. The Catholic and Orthodox churches have popes / patriarchs who have traditionally been regarded as being able to speak with Devine authority.

The church of Ireland isn't all that small. Certainly in comparison to catholicism it is but there are still plenty of churches around. There are three within spitting distance (well, 40 minute drive) of me and I live rurally. I know they have bishops and priests but our local one goes by Rev and is a woman.

Do church of England ones not get ordained as priests? What do they call the equivalent of being ordained?

Sorry for the 20 questions but I find it all really interesting, despite being an atheist.

HowdidImanagetohavetwoaccountaandthenloseboth · 09/02/2024 18:35

DataBatman · 07/02/2024 16:21

There's 47 days between Shrove Tuesday and Easter Sunday, 40 days only takes you to Palm Sunday.

I was told once the Sundays aren’t part of lent , just the other days making it 40. So on Sunday you can take the host , drink the wine or have anything you have given up for Lent.
Now I know that Shrove comes from absolution at confession ( thanks pp on this thread) shall call it pancake day in future ! Being the atheist I am , these days.
Thanks also to the pp who remarked that being an atheist was great what with all that food, chocolate, booze and presents. Made me smile .

ps can you have pancakes tomorrow ( Saturday) you know , just to perfect them for Tuesday? Asking for a friend

Sceptic1234 · 09/02/2024 18:32

Wonders of Google.... there is a small Anglican Church in Wales, but for some reason it is called "The Church in Wales" rather than the Church of wales.

Abhannmor · 09/02/2024 18:30

OchonAgusOchonOh · 09/02/2024 18:17

I thought that might be the case. Presumably because Wales was colonised before the church of england was established. When was Wales colonised?

Wales was Incorporated into England in 1536 by Henry VIII. One year after the break with Rome I think. Hence the statistics are always England and Wales. Fair play to them for keeping the Cymraeg language. Miserable fuckers at Holyhead but sin scéal eile.

Sceptic1234 · 09/02/2024 18:26

OchonAgusOchonOh · 09/02/2024 17:29

Really interesting about the NI protestant thing. I wonder is that to create a feeling of unity with other predominantly unionist churches? Obviously I know you can be a catholic unionist and a protestant nationalist but it would be more unusual than the converse.

What is a "lower church"? I've heard the term but I have no idea what the difference is between high church and low church.

Is anglican church of Ireland/England/Scotland/Wales? Is there a church of wales? I've never heard it referred to.

It gets complicated....the Church of England is Anglican, but the Church of Scotland is Presbyterian. The Anglican church in Scotland is very small called the Scottish Episcopalian Church.

I think there is a small Anglican "Church of Ireland" in Ireland itself and that the few protestants in the south tend to belong to it. They have bishops, priests etc like catholics. Some Anglican ministers choose to be called "Father" (even in England) but it's not that common.

Almost all protestants in the North are Presbeterians and have much more in common with Scottish protestants than with English Anglicans ... they have no bishops or priests, church elders and ministers run things.

All the protestant churches reject the idea that there is anyone on earth who can speak with authority about what God wants. The Catholic and Orthodox churches have popes / patriarchs who have traditionally been regarded as being able to speak with Devine authority.

kkloo · 09/02/2024 18:25

EmeraldA129 · 09/02/2024 10:01

Personally I don’t like pancakes, so maybe that’s it 😂

I guess from my work I see people torn apart about buying presents for their kids at Xmas & many adults that only receive a present because we give them one… and far too many people who are depressed and feel so alone as they don’t have anyone to share a meal or tradition with. I love Christmas in my wee family, but think that it is a time of pain & upset for many. Anyway, this was a relatively light hearted thread that I’ve taken down a rabbit hole 🙈

Oh I understand that it's a painful day for many, I'm just saying that most people associate it with more than just Santa, whether they enjoy or celebrate Christmas or not.

I've heard a few people call it 'turkey day' in recent years, which I think is something people call thanksgiving, but saying that it seems like more of a jokey thing rather than a name that will 'stick' for Christmas 😅