Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Ex BIL messaging me

267 replies

thisisuttermadness · 07/02/2024 14:49

NC for this.

Long story short, my sister and my ex BIL divorced around 6 years ago. All water under the bridge now, they don't have contact anymore, no kids together so a relatively straightforward separation. It was hard at the time as BIL had been a part of the family for a lot of years and I regarded him as more of a brother to be honest, so the separation was hard for the rest of the family but it was the right decision for my sister and we obviously stood by her as her family. I'm still friends with BIL on social media but no longer close, and in all honesty we have very little contact. I messaged him after his child was born to a new woman a couple years ago to congratulate him, and he replied thank you etc, but otherwise we don't generally speak.

Today I received a message from him out of the blue asking how I was. I replied that I was fine and asked about him etc, we had a pleasant exchange about our respective kids etc. All fine and pleasant. He then asked me if I knew why my sister was still using "his name", and that he'd discovered this recently and it bothered him. I said I didn't know why she had made this decision, and that it's not really anything to do with me, but I assumed it was because it was less hassle to keep her married name for practical reasons (my sister is a very pragmatic person). I explained this was likely the reason and he continued to state that this was "weird" and "wrong" and could I "suggest" to her that she should revert back to her maiden name. I said this wasn't my place and legally it's her name, and asked why it was a concern to him so many years down the line? He said that I wouldn't understand because I "hadn't been through it", but that this surname was "a part of him" and he didn't need the "constant reminder". Again, I asked how on earth he's being constantly reminded when he literally has no contact with my sister anymore? He couldn't answer this, just said "it's not her identity anymore, it's MY surname". I was going round in circles explaining to him that it was also in fact her legal surname to use as she wished and there was little he could do about that. He then stated that "there is only going to be one Mrs X soon and it's not her". I pointed out that there are many, many Mrs X's in the world and he didn't own the rights to that particular surname. I suggested he just focused on his new relationship/ wife to be and family and move on from what my sister chooses to do / not do. He then became defensive stating that "I don't care about her or what she does but I don't think this is right". I had to end the discussion as we were just going round in unhelpful circles and I was fed up of repeating myself.

I then spoke to my sister and she said he'd also been in touch with her recently out of the blue saying similar things, demanding to know why she wasn't changing her name. She said she told him she'd made a decision to keep the name she was known by in professional circles and just for ease. He was apparently unpleasant towards her so she ended up blocking him, hence he's now badgering her family members.

AIBU that this is just a ridiculous thing to for him to get wound up about? Why now, 6 years down the line is my sister's name suddenly an issue just because he's remarrying?! He surely cannot expect my sister to change her name just because he finds it "weird" and thinks its "not her identity"?! And also why is he bothering me with this?! I assume this has only become an issue because he's getting married again, but why should it matter? For context the surname is a very common one - think Smith / Jones - and so there'll be literally thousands of women with this name across the world and yet his new wife needs to be "the only one"?!

Aside from all of this, what has any of it got to to with me?! I wasn't even married to the guy!

The whole thing has just annoyed and baffled me and just wanted some outside perspectives! Thank you.

OP posts:
thisisuttermadness · 07/02/2024 19:28

find it really odd that I would potentially divorce DH, have another man's child before marrying him, and give that child exDHs surname, when it's neither my family name, nor my new partners, but that of an unrelated man I was once in a relationship with because I "can't be arsed" with the paperwork of changing it back.

This isn't relevant to my sister's situation though? She hasn't had another man's child. She has no kids at all. She's just a single woman with a surname she's had for a lot of years that she wanted to keep. 🤷‍♀️

OP posts:
Minglingpringle · 07/02/2024 19:26

PumpkinSpiceSeason · 07/02/2024 18:42

Had to go fully "let me speak to your manager" when staff wanted to see a divorce certificate.

(Sorry, DS bumped me midway through post)

When I filled in the online form for a DBS check, the computer was unable to accept that the following three things are true at the same time:

  1. I am married
  2. My title is Ms
  3. I have never changed my name

It would not let me proceed without giving my previous name.

In the end I was told to say I was a Miss. So I had to lie on a DBS form….not a good look.

I complained but heard nothing back.

Minglingpringle · 07/02/2024 19:23

WillYouPutYourCoatOn · 07/02/2024 19:11

That's kind of the point though. It's her married name, as you literally say. That's how people see it, the married name, that she's never changed back.

No, she doesn't have too. But it's his name that she acquired via marriage specifically to him.

I see it like continuing to wear wedding rings after divorce. They are a sign of marriage to one specific person. No, you don't legally have to remove them, but it's very faux innocence to claim it no longer represents a connection to that marriage, when that is exactly what they symbolise.

I don't think it's sexist. It's irrelevant if it's a man or woman. If you take someone else's name on marriage, it's exactly that, your married name.

I find it really odd that I would potentially divorce DH, have another man's child before marrying him, and give that child exDHs surname, when it's neither my family name, nor my new partners, but that of an unrelated man I was once in a relationship with because I "can't be arsed" with the paperwork of changing it back.

That’s why it’s so rubbish to change your name when you get married.

Your name does not just represent you. It represents you-as-a-subset-of-this-marriage.

Whereas for the partner who didn’t change their name, it’s still just their name representing them. Theirs forever, whatever happens in their life.

The name changer is B-list.

ThePenguinIsDrunk · 07/02/2024 19:20

Y(or your DSis)ANBU, it's her name. I've always said if DH and I split unamicably I'd keep his name just to piss hom off but on a serious note my degree is in my married name, my kids all share our surname and I've had this name as many years now as I haven't which is a pretty big deal.
I'm curious how he would have reacted had she not taken 'his' name on marriage? I suspect that he would have been as obnoxious as he is now. Can have it both ways.

WillYouPutYourCoatOn · 07/02/2024 19:11

thisisuttermadness · 07/02/2024 18:34

Good for you!

Sick of men thinking they "own the rights" to a woman's name after they're divorced. Ridiculous and sexist attitude! A woman's married name is her legal name to keep if she so wishes and anyone who thinks they can tell her what to do with it can get to fuck in my opinion.

That's kind of the point though. It's her married name, as you literally say. That's how people see it, the married name, that she's never changed back.

No, she doesn't have too. But it's his name that she acquired via marriage specifically to him.

I see it like continuing to wear wedding rings after divorce. They are a sign of marriage to one specific person. No, you don't legally have to remove them, but it's very faux innocence to claim it no longer represents a connection to that marriage, when that is exactly what they symbolise.

I don't think it's sexist. It's irrelevant if it's a man or woman. If you take someone else's name on marriage, it's exactly that, your married name.

I find it really odd that I would potentially divorce DH, have another man's child before marrying him, and give that child exDHs surname, when it's neither my family name, nor my new partners, but that of an unrelated man I was once in a relationship with because I "can't be arsed" with the paperwork of changing it back.

Kwam31 · 07/02/2024 19:09

Personally do not see why you'd keep the name of a man you divorced when there's no kids.
The old MN myth of how hard it is to change your name, is that; a myth, it's not difficult.

TTCSoManyQuestions88 · 07/02/2024 19:08

New wife is clearly giving him shit about it. Block him and your sister should really lock down her social media so that the new wife can't spy on her.

Notsoadmirablecrichton · 07/02/2024 19:06

My MIL is still Mrs XH despite divorcing over 40 years ago. Entirely her call. Not sure what I’d do in that situation. I’ve actually had my married name longer than my maiden name so it’s definitely part of my identity too.

MrsToriCostner · 07/02/2024 19:04

Get your sister to message him and say
" up until you actually messaged my sister, I was seriously contemplating going back to my maiden name but seeing as though you've been such a cunt about the whole thing and not asked me nicely, although we both know your cock doesn't touch your arse, you can fuck yourself " 🤗

KreedKafer · 07/02/2024 19:03

My mum’s friend (who must be 80ish now) still has the surname of her first husband, even though they divorced in the mid-1980s and she then married someone else. When her children were under 18 she didn’t want a different name to theirs, and after that she couldn’t be arsed with the fuss of changing it. I genuinely hope your sister is still using her married name in about 50 years’ time and that her ex is still raging about it.

Jl2014 · 07/02/2024 18:49

6 years later, getting remarried and he still hasn’t moved on. Sad.

PumpkinSpiceSeason · 07/02/2024 18:42

Had to go fully "let me speak to your manager" when staff wanted to see a divorce certificate.

(Sorry, DS bumped me midway through post)

PumpkinSpiceSeason · 07/02/2024 18:41

I also only ever went by Ms when married because I didn't think it was anyone's business if I was married just by reading my name.

Natwest accidently made me Mrs and it was the only place that ever did. I went to change it to Ms and had to g

thisisuttermadness · 07/02/2024 18:35

Thementalloadisreal · 07/02/2024 18:31

Sounds like your sister needs to change her middle name too - Mrs hername Fuckyousteve XXXX

😂😂

OP posts:
thisisuttermadness · 07/02/2024 18:34

PumpkinSpiceSeason · 07/02/2024 18:27

I made it very clear to my ex if I took his name it would be mine forever no matter what happened.

I have mortgages, degrees, passports, and professional identities in two countries. No way in hell I'm going to change back!

DS (not his) was born a few years ago and as DP is half Spanish, so we gave DS both our surnames in that style. Thus ex's name is also part of my kid's legal identity.

But it's not his anymore. It's mine.

Good for you!

Sick of men thinking they "own the rights" to a woman's name after they're divorced. Ridiculous and sexist attitude! A woman's married name is her legal name to keep if she so wishes and anyone who thinks they can tell her what to do with it can get to fuck in my opinion.

OP posts:
Thementalloadisreal · 07/02/2024 18:31

Sounds like your sister needs to change her middle name too - Mrs hername Fuckyousteve XXXX

Atethehalloweenchocs · 07/02/2024 18:30

To be fair, I do think a lot of people struggle with the keeping the name thing - I have several female friends who have waited until their kids are out of school before changing their name back from their married names. And I guess it may be uncomfortable to have someone known as Mrs X after the relationship ends. HOWEVER - he is being ridiculous, and needs to get over himself immediately.

PumpkinSpiceSeason · 07/02/2024 18:27

I made it very clear to my ex if I took his name it would be mine forever no matter what happened.

I have mortgages, degrees, passports, and professional identities in two countries. No way in hell I'm going to change back!

DS (not his) was born a few years ago and as DP is half Spanish, so we gave DS both our surnames in that style. Thus ex's name is also part of my kid's legal identity.

But it's not his anymore. It's mine.

thisisuttermadness · 07/02/2024 18:26

NotQuiteNorma · 07/02/2024 18:05

You said he only found out about this recently, in which case it wouldn't have bothered him the last 6 years because he didn't know about it. To be honest I kind of agree with him. I think it is a bit weird that your sister doesn't want to let go of his name and move on herself years after divorcing him. His name is no longer a part of her. That stopped when they divorced. If the marriage was that bad it ended in divorce why would she want to keep his surname anyway?

I've already (clearly, I thought) explained why she chose not to change it - she couldn't be bothered with the hassle, it's the name she's been known by in a professional context for many years now, and, added to which, as Ive updated - my ex BIL actually indicated in a text following their split that he "wasn't bothered, it's only a name" when she enquired as to his views about her keeping it or not.

Lots of good reasons for my sister to just think, OK I won't bother then and I'll just get on with my life. As did my BIL, for 4 years, until he pops up out of the blue coincidentally around the time he is due to remarry, suddenly having an issue with my sister's name (after presumably having stalked her on LinkedIn - and he has the audacity to call her weird?), and demanding to know why she won't change it.

It's very, very clear where this has come from and why it's an issue. His new fiancée presumably doesn't want to marry a man who's ex wife still has the same name. I don't think that's entirely reasonable, personally.

OP posts:
Threecrows · 07/02/2024 18:24

thisisuttermadness · 07/02/2024 15:01

Tbh my sister and I both suspect the same! It's not been an issue for 6 years and now all of a sudden it is? And also the comment about "there's about to be a new Mrs X and she's the only one" or whatever he said. Ridiculous!

I was going to say he was being a groomzilla, but actually it’s bridezilla!

izzygirlis4 · 07/02/2024 18:21

I've been divorced 12 years and still have my husbands name. It does annoy him tho but I don't really care.

My mother has been divorced 47 years and she still has my dad's name.

NotMyDayJob · 07/02/2024 18:20

My dad tried this with DM, despite the fact that on divorce my parents had been married 18 years, so nearly half my mother's life, her entire professional career and they had three children together. She just laughed at him. And it wasn't a common name so she was resigned to a life associated with him which she actually didn't want. But she valued having the same name as her children.

The fact is if I wanted to I could change my name to Mrs exBIL just because I felt like it and there'd be nothing he could do.

WillYouPutYourCoatOn · 07/02/2024 18:17

SomeCatFromJapan · 07/02/2024 18:11

@WillYouPutYourCoatOn the etiquette is that the divorced woman keeps her married name on divorce, but the form changes. So where she was previously "Mrs Thomas Todger", after divorce she is "Mrs Jane Todger" and a new wife will be "Mrs Thomas Todger" should Mr Todger remarry.

Yes.

But no one actually does this anymore. Much like eating soup by pushing the spoon away from you. Correct etiquette. Not real world normal practice.

SomeCatFromJapan · 07/02/2024 18:11

@WillYouPutYourCoatOn the etiquette is that the divorced woman keeps her married name on divorce, but the form changes. So where she was previously "Mrs Thomas Todger", after divorce she is "Mrs Jane Todger" and a new wife will be "Mrs Thomas Todger" should Mr Todger remarry.

PrestonHood121 · 07/02/2024 18:09

A simple "I can't do anything about this situation and my sister has given you her reasons for keeping her name as is. I won't be discussing it further."