Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Ex BIL messaging me

267 replies

thisisuttermadness · 07/02/2024 14:49

NC for this.

Long story short, my sister and my ex BIL divorced around 6 years ago. All water under the bridge now, they don't have contact anymore, no kids together so a relatively straightforward separation. It was hard at the time as BIL had been a part of the family for a lot of years and I regarded him as more of a brother to be honest, so the separation was hard for the rest of the family but it was the right decision for my sister and we obviously stood by her as her family. I'm still friends with BIL on social media but no longer close, and in all honesty we have very little contact. I messaged him after his child was born to a new woman a couple years ago to congratulate him, and he replied thank you etc, but otherwise we don't generally speak.

Today I received a message from him out of the blue asking how I was. I replied that I was fine and asked about him etc, we had a pleasant exchange about our respective kids etc. All fine and pleasant. He then asked me if I knew why my sister was still using "his name", and that he'd discovered this recently and it bothered him. I said I didn't know why she had made this decision, and that it's not really anything to do with me, but I assumed it was because it was less hassle to keep her married name for practical reasons (my sister is a very pragmatic person). I explained this was likely the reason and he continued to state that this was "weird" and "wrong" and could I "suggest" to her that she should revert back to her maiden name. I said this wasn't my place and legally it's her name, and asked why it was a concern to him so many years down the line? He said that I wouldn't understand because I "hadn't been through it", but that this surname was "a part of him" and he didn't need the "constant reminder". Again, I asked how on earth he's being constantly reminded when he literally has no contact with my sister anymore? He couldn't answer this, just said "it's not her identity anymore, it's MY surname". I was going round in circles explaining to him that it was also in fact her legal surname to use as she wished and there was little he could do about that. He then stated that "there is only going to be one Mrs X soon and it's not her". I pointed out that there are many, many Mrs X's in the world and he didn't own the rights to that particular surname. I suggested he just focused on his new relationship/ wife to be and family and move on from what my sister chooses to do / not do. He then became defensive stating that "I don't care about her or what she does but I don't think this is right". I had to end the discussion as we were just going round in unhelpful circles and I was fed up of repeating myself.

I then spoke to my sister and she said he'd also been in touch with her recently out of the blue saying similar things, demanding to know why she wasn't changing her name. She said she told him she'd made a decision to keep the name she was known by in professional circles and just for ease. He was apparently unpleasant towards her so she ended up blocking him, hence he's now badgering her family members.

AIBU that this is just a ridiculous thing to for him to get wound up about? Why now, 6 years down the line is my sister's name suddenly an issue just because he's remarrying?! He surely cannot expect my sister to change her name just because he finds it "weird" and thinks its "not her identity"?! And also why is he bothering me with this?! I assume this has only become an issue because he's getting married again, but why should it matter? For context the surname is a very common one - think Smith / Jones - and so there'll be literally thousands of women with this name across the world and yet his new wife needs to be "the only one"?!

Aside from all of this, what has any of it got to to with me?! I wasn't even married to the guy!

The whole thing has just annoyed and baffled me and just wanted some outside perspectives! Thank you.

OP posts:
WillYouPutYourCoatOn · 07/02/2024 20:41

Svalberg · 07/02/2024 19:36

So your husband's mother should have changed her name from Mrs CoatOn when you married him so that there weren't two Mrs CoatOns? How odd...

Bit misogynistic to expect women to keep changing their names. I would also imagine that those insisting that women don't have a valid reason for sticking to one name for professional purposes have never worked in a professional field. I once refused to give a reference for Jane Smith because I didn't know her. Turns out I did know her, but as Jane Brown - but it was too late and she didn't get the job, oops, oh well.

Well, no... because she's still part of that family.

LivingDeadGirlUK · 07/02/2024 20:39

I have the same first name as DP's ex wife, should I ask her to change it?

WillYouPutYourCoatOn · 07/02/2024 20:39

thisisuttermadness · 07/02/2024 19:28

find it really odd that I would potentially divorce DH, have another man's child before marrying him, and give that child exDHs surname, when it's neither my family name, nor my new partners, but that of an unrelated man I was once in a relationship with because I "can't be arsed" with the paperwork of changing it back.

This isn't relevant to my sister's situation though? She hasn't had another man's child. She has no kids at all. She's just a single woman with a surname she's had for a lot of years that she wanted to keep. 🤷‍♀️

Well, if you're going to quote the only part of what I wrote that doesn't apply to your sister...

Neodymium · 07/02/2024 20:38

💯 would be the new wife.

if men don’t want their partners to keep their surname then they shouldn’t insist on them changing it in the first place.

I was somewhat reluctant to change my surname. But once I did I made it clear that I would never be changing it back if we broke up. I’m only doing it once.

Shuggie1234 · 07/02/2024 20:37

I agree with him. I think it’s a bit strange to divorce someone and then keep their name.

thisisuttermadness · 07/02/2024 20:36

PonyPatter44 · 07/02/2024 20:26

He doesn't actually sound very well, does he? I think blocking him is the right thing to do. Can you block people on LinkedIn?

I think you can but it won't stop you from appearing in a google search. I tried it earlier as an experiment, I typed my sisters full (married) name into Google plus "LinkedIn" and the top search returned is her. You can then click on her profile and see her picture. I don't think you even have to have a LinkedIn profile to see this.

OP posts:
AGoingConcern · 07/02/2024 20:35

People are so bizarre about names.

That's now her last name just as much as it is his. I know plenty of women who don't change back after divorce for one reason or another - the most common is because changing names in certain professions can be a true ordeal and can have actual financial/career impacts.

He has absolutely no right to ask her to change her name anymore than he would if some new person moved to town with the same name. Set a crystal clear boundry and refuse to engage or even listen to any more talk of this. "I am not willing to discuss [sister] or this topic. Please do not contact me about it again." Unfriend him on social media and block him if he tries again. Give your family a heads up that you've done so and the language so they can do the same if they choose. If he continues this, your sister should honestly consider sending a very blunt email & hard copy letter saying that if he persists down this path she will file a harrassment complaint.

Zanatdy · 07/02/2024 20:30

It’s no doubt as his new wife has an issue with it, given he’s not bothered about it until now. Just block him too and next family member will have to do the same. He doesn’t own the name so it’s tough luck

AuContraire · 07/02/2024 20:28

I'd suggest to him that he takes his new wife's surname.

Then block him.

What a loser.

PonyPatter44 · 07/02/2024 20:26

He doesn't actually sound very well, does he? I think blocking him is the right thing to do. Can you block people on LinkedIn?

TheFormidableMrsC · 07/02/2024 20:23

This is nuts! I've had similar though. My married surname is fairly unusual but I've had it for 23 years, my son has the same name. It's my name. I'm not changing it for anybody. Why the hell should I? My ex started using his mother's maiden name. I mean grow the fuck up. My ex's gene pool is so weird that people who shouldn't have the revered surname have got it. So as far as I am concerned, it's mine too. If my son changes his surname (which he would like to do when he can legally), I will change mine then.

OP, I'd block him, this is new wife driven without a doubt. How terribly insecure she is. What's she going to do? Write to a million Mrs Smiths and tell them how she they use "her" name. So petty.

iamwhatiam23 · 07/02/2024 20:15

Definitely his fiancé that has the problem and he's doing the dirty work! My ex and his new wife were exactly the same! I kept my surname because it was easier with the kids having the same name and also easier than changing all my documentation! They were practically apoplectic with rage!

BirthdayRainbow · 07/02/2024 20:07

Just read OP. Even before I got the bit about just one Mrs X it was obvious he's getting married again and that why he wants your sister to change.

Beautiful3 · 07/02/2024 20:00

Omg please send him the screen shot!!!

thisisuttermadness · 07/02/2024 19:59

Creatureofhabit87 · 07/02/2024 19:46

Whilst I don’t agree he should contact you, I do agree it’s weird when people keep their married name if they have no kids and are divorced, I mean why would you want it?!

Why would you want it? I don't think she actively "wants" it, as such. She just doesn't care either way so she's gone with the easiest option, ie do nothing with it.

If your name didn't mean anything to you emotionally, if you regarded it as just a name and nothing more, and if you were professionally well known by that name, why would you go to the hassle of changing it? What's the point?

OP posts:
GabriellaMontez · 07/02/2024 19:52

Creatureofhabit87 · 07/02/2024 19:46

Whilst I don’t agree he should contact you, I do agree it’s weird when people keep their married name if they have no kids and are divorced, I mean why would you want it?!

Its mine and I like it.

Its been mine for many years.

Notanotheruser111 · 07/02/2024 19:52

I’ve had my married name for more than half my life, if I divorced I would not change it and if I remarried I don’t think I would change it either. If I had to live life over I wouldn’t have changed it in the first place. But now it’s mine it’s part of my identity.

Rewis · 07/02/2024 19:51

Honestly, I can kinda understand where he is coming from. That doesn't mean that your sister needs to do anything. She can keep the name, you can all block him and he and his soon to be wife has to delay with it. But he's entitled to have feelings about it, maybe even approach and ask. But he needs to let it go after asking and being told no.

Creatureofhabit87 · 07/02/2024 19:46

Whilst I don’t agree he should contact you, I do agree it’s weird when people keep their married name if they have no kids and are divorced, I mean why would you want it?!

StaunchMomma · 07/02/2024 19:46

I bet it's the new Mrs who is pissed about it.

Tough.

Why should your Dsis let go of the name she's well known as professionally? Even without that, it's a pain to change names on documents/passports etc. She's entitled to keep the name and it doesn't affect him one jot whether she does or not.

I agree that blocking and forgetting about him is the way forward.

thisisuttermadness · 07/02/2024 19:43

@Svalberg
Very good points. My sister is a high flying company director and was actually head hunted for her current role. So her professional identity is hugely important.

OP posts:
Svalberg · 07/02/2024 19:36

WillYouPutYourCoatOn · 07/02/2024 16:38

I get what you're saying. I think it's not so much about another woman pretending she belongs to my DH, because no-one belongs to anyone. It's more, that specific name, Mrs Surname, is for the wife of Mr Surname. Not before, not after, it's your "wedded name" your "name by marriage" so it makes sense in my head that you shouldn't be using it if you are no longer wed. Unless you're keeping for DC, as mentioned previously.

I appreciate others don't think the same. But my marriage is important to me. It's special. No, I wouldn't want another woman using my "wedded name".

I think you don't have to entertain BIL requests, but I do think you should handle this respectfully and not all this "tell the weird spying fiancée and idiot BIL to get stuffed" from other posters. It comes across like your sister is enjoying the idea that this upsets them. This obviously means a lot to them. And I think rightly so.

So your husband's mother should have changed her name from Mrs CoatOn when you married him so that there weren't two Mrs CoatOns? How odd...

Bit misogynistic to expect women to keep changing their names. I would also imagine that those insisting that women don't have a valid reason for sticking to one name for professional purposes have never worked in a professional field. I once refused to give a reference for Jane Smith because I didn't know her. Turns out I did know her, but as Jane Brown - but it was too late and she didn't get the job, oops, oh well.

thisisuttermadness · 07/02/2024 19:36

Incidentally, I did ask ex BIL twice within the exchange with him how he'd "discovered" this information. He dodged my question both times. So he's clearly been stalking her on her LinkedIn profile which is just plain weird.

OP posts:
thisisuttermadness · 07/02/2024 19:34

TTCSoManyQuestions88 · 07/02/2024 19:08

New wife is clearly giving him shit about it. Block him and your sister should really lock down her social media so that the new wife can't spy on her.

My sister has no social media accounts at all, she's only on LinkedIn. That's where they've found out she still uses her married name I'd imagine. There's no other possible way they could have known.

OP posts:
thisisuttermadness · 07/02/2024 19:32

ThePenguinIsDrunk · 07/02/2024 19:20

Y(or your DSis)ANBU, it's her name. I've always said if DH and I split unamicably I'd keep his name just to piss hom off but on a serious note my degree is in my married name, my kids all share our surname and I've had this name as many years now as I haven't which is a pretty big deal.
I'm curious how he would have reacted had she not taken 'his' name on marriage? I suspect that he would have been as obnoxious as he is now. Can have it both ways.

I suspect the same as you!

In contrast, I've told my partner that if we do ever marry I want to keep my own surname and double barrel his on the end, so that my name matches that of our daughter. He's happy with this. He hasn't once suggested I "must" take his name. Equally I couldn't see him giving a shit if I did take his name upon marriage, and we later split and I wanted to keep it. Well, he didn't care that his ex wife did the same, so 🤷‍♀️

I just don't understand the possessiveness over a name. That's all it is, a name.

I don't agree with the analogy of keeping wedding rings on post divorce, at all. Removing them is an easy process that takes seconds. Changing one's name is not and there can be good practical reasons for choosing not to do so, relating to one's professional identity for a start.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread