Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Ex BIL messaging me

267 replies

thisisuttermadness · 07/02/2024 14:49

NC for this.

Long story short, my sister and my ex BIL divorced around 6 years ago. All water under the bridge now, they don't have contact anymore, no kids together so a relatively straightforward separation. It was hard at the time as BIL had been a part of the family for a lot of years and I regarded him as more of a brother to be honest, so the separation was hard for the rest of the family but it was the right decision for my sister and we obviously stood by her as her family. I'm still friends with BIL on social media but no longer close, and in all honesty we have very little contact. I messaged him after his child was born to a new woman a couple years ago to congratulate him, and he replied thank you etc, but otherwise we don't generally speak.

Today I received a message from him out of the blue asking how I was. I replied that I was fine and asked about him etc, we had a pleasant exchange about our respective kids etc. All fine and pleasant. He then asked me if I knew why my sister was still using "his name", and that he'd discovered this recently and it bothered him. I said I didn't know why she had made this decision, and that it's not really anything to do with me, but I assumed it was because it was less hassle to keep her married name for practical reasons (my sister is a very pragmatic person). I explained this was likely the reason and he continued to state that this was "weird" and "wrong" and could I "suggest" to her that she should revert back to her maiden name. I said this wasn't my place and legally it's her name, and asked why it was a concern to him so many years down the line? He said that I wouldn't understand because I "hadn't been through it", but that this surname was "a part of him" and he didn't need the "constant reminder". Again, I asked how on earth he's being constantly reminded when he literally has no contact with my sister anymore? He couldn't answer this, just said "it's not her identity anymore, it's MY surname". I was going round in circles explaining to him that it was also in fact her legal surname to use as she wished and there was little he could do about that. He then stated that "there is only going to be one Mrs X soon and it's not her". I pointed out that there are many, many Mrs X's in the world and he didn't own the rights to that particular surname. I suggested he just focused on his new relationship/ wife to be and family and move on from what my sister chooses to do / not do. He then became defensive stating that "I don't care about her or what she does but I don't think this is right". I had to end the discussion as we were just going round in unhelpful circles and I was fed up of repeating myself.

I then spoke to my sister and she said he'd also been in touch with her recently out of the blue saying similar things, demanding to know why she wasn't changing her name. She said she told him she'd made a decision to keep the name she was known by in professional circles and just for ease. He was apparently unpleasant towards her so she ended up blocking him, hence he's now badgering her family members.

AIBU that this is just a ridiculous thing to for him to get wound up about? Why now, 6 years down the line is my sister's name suddenly an issue just because he's remarrying?! He surely cannot expect my sister to change her name just because he finds it "weird" and thinks its "not her identity"?! And also why is he bothering me with this?! I assume this has only become an issue because he's getting married again, but why should it matter? For context the surname is a very common one - think Smith / Jones - and so there'll be literally thousands of women with this name across the world and yet his new wife needs to be "the only one"?!

Aside from all of this, what has any of it got to to with me?! I wasn't even married to the guy!

The whole thing has just annoyed and baffled me and just wanted some outside perspectives! Thank you.

OP posts:
Mudflaps · 07/02/2024 15:20

I'd message him back saying now that he's brought it to your mind you've always secretly loved that name and you're going to change yours to it so you'll match your sister. Then block him.

PossumintheHouse · 07/02/2024 15:19

beatrix1234 · 07/02/2024 15:16

I would not like it because my surname belongs to my family, my ex husband is no longer family and I don’t keep in touch with him, so feels weird to me if he still used my name, specially if I’m about to get married, but that’s just my personal opinion and everyone is different I guess.

You can’t own a name, first or second or otherwise. And I’d be amazed if you’re the only family in the world with your surname.

thisisuttermadness · 07/02/2024 15:19

The name is also as common as the likes of Smith or Jones. It's not even particularly unique. That's what makes it funnier that his wife to be needs to be "the only one" 😆

OP posts:
sunlovingcriminal · 07/02/2024 15:18

@girlfriend44 you do realise that there is no legal obligation to change your name back to your maiden name once you divorce?

Why should I lose the name I've had for over a decade? And is the same as my kids? And which I am known as in my industry?!

The husband doesn't have a legal title over the name, like a possession!

You've made me laugh... maybe I should wrap the name up and give it back to my ex husband like a returned gift!

beatrix1234 · 07/02/2024 15:16

thisisuttermadness · 07/02/2024 15:10

Can you explain why?

I would not like it because my surname belongs to my family, my ex husband is no longer family and I don’t keep in touch with him, so feels weird to me if he still used my name, specially if I’m about to get married, but that’s just my personal opinion and everyone is different I guess.

thisisuttermadness · 07/02/2024 15:16

toomuchfaff · 07/02/2024 15:04

hahahahaha I've heard this before, bloke getting wound up because the ex didn't revert HIS name.. usually accompanied by a mad new girlfriend about to become wife wanting to be the ONLY Mrs X...

Tell him it's none of your business, uts actually none of HIS business what name your sister goes by, in reality ANYONE, even you, your husband, your mother and your neighbours could change your name by deed pole to "his" name, he doesn't own a name. Then tell him you'll entertain no further discussions on this matter and block him if necessary.

Yep, I could change MY name to Mrs X tomorrow if I wanted to and there'd be nowt he could do about it!

OP posts:
sunlovingcriminal · 07/02/2024 15:15

Left · 07/02/2024 15:12

If he’s that bothered he can take on his new wife’s surname 🤷‍♀️

Or even make up a completely new surname for him and his new wife to enjoy?! Something very unique.

I suggested this to my new dp, but for some reason he didn't take to being Mr and Mrs Fandango-Flamingoes....

(Which your BIL can't have btw, there is time for me to yet convince my dp 🥳)

DoILookThrilled · 07/02/2024 15:15

Well, it is his name but she’s stolen it and he owns it! Cheek of the woman. Back in the real world he’s mental. She can call herself what she wants. Block, ignore and move on

thisisuttermadness · 07/02/2024 15:15

another thing that irked me was the way he messaged on the pretext of asking how I was and how the family and kids are etc... he didn't actually give a shit about that. He was only messaging to interrogate me about my sister's life decisions 🙄

OP posts:
girlfriend44 · 07/02/2024 15:14

LoveSandbanks · 07/02/2024 15:10

My parents divorced over 40 years ago. My mother is still known by her married surname. Hes ridiculous to even suggest it.

why though she isnt married anymore. You only take the name by marriage!

Left · 07/02/2024 15:12

If he’s that bothered he can take on his new wife’s surname 🤷‍♀️

thisisuttermadness · 07/02/2024 15:12

KreedKafer · 07/02/2024 15:11

Are you sure it wasn't his current fiancee messaging from his account?

Well obviously not 100% sure but now you've made me question it 🤔 I don't know her at all, never met her, but the messaging style seemed very BIL.

OP posts:
KreedKafer · 07/02/2024 15:11

Are you sure it wasn't his current fiancee messaging from his account?

LoveSandbanks · 07/02/2024 15:10

My parents divorced over 40 years ago. My mother is still known by her married surname. Hes ridiculous to even suggest it.

Bellaboo01 · 07/02/2024 15:10

thisisuttermadness · 07/02/2024 14:49

NC for this.

Long story short, my sister and my ex BIL divorced around 6 years ago. All water under the bridge now, they don't have contact anymore, no kids together so a relatively straightforward separation. It was hard at the time as BIL had been a part of the family for a lot of years and I regarded him as more of a brother to be honest, so the separation was hard for the rest of the family but it was the right decision for my sister and we obviously stood by her as her family. I'm still friends with BIL on social media but no longer close, and in all honesty we have very little contact. I messaged him after his child was born to a new woman a couple years ago to congratulate him, and he replied thank you etc, but otherwise we don't generally speak.

Today I received a message from him out of the blue asking how I was. I replied that I was fine and asked about him etc, we had a pleasant exchange about our respective kids etc. All fine and pleasant. He then asked me if I knew why my sister was still using "his name", and that he'd discovered this recently and it bothered him. I said I didn't know why she had made this decision, and that it's not really anything to do with me, but I assumed it was because it was less hassle to keep her married name for practical reasons (my sister is a very pragmatic person). I explained this was likely the reason and he continued to state that this was "weird" and "wrong" and could I "suggest" to her that she should revert back to her maiden name. I said this wasn't my place and legally it's her name, and asked why it was a concern to him so many years down the line? He said that I wouldn't understand because I "hadn't been through it", but that this surname was "a part of him" and he didn't need the "constant reminder". Again, I asked how on earth he's being constantly reminded when he literally has no contact with my sister anymore? He couldn't answer this, just said "it's not her identity anymore, it's MY surname". I was going round in circles explaining to him that it was also in fact her legal surname to use as she wished and there was little he could do about that. He then stated that "there is only going to be one Mrs X soon and it's not her". I pointed out that there are many, many Mrs X's in the world and he didn't own the rights to that particular surname. I suggested he just focused on his new relationship/ wife to be and family and move on from what my sister chooses to do / not do. He then became defensive stating that "I don't care about her or what she does but I don't think this is right". I had to end the discussion as we were just going round in unhelpful circles and I was fed up of repeating myself.

I then spoke to my sister and she said he'd also been in touch with her recently out of the blue saying similar things, demanding to know why she wasn't changing her name. She said she told him she'd made a decision to keep the name she was known by in professional circles and just for ease. He was apparently unpleasant towards her so she ended up blocking him, hence he's now badgering her family members.

AIBU that this is just a ridiculous thing to for him to get wound up about? Why now, 6 years down the line is my sister's name suddenly an issue just because he's remarrying?! He surely cannot expect my sister to change her name just because he finds it "weird" and thinks its "not her identity"?! And also why is he bothering me with this?! I assume this has only become an issue because he's getting married again, but why should it matter? For context the surname is a very common one - think Smith / Jones - and so there'll be literally thousands of women with this name across the world and yet his new wife needs to be "the only one"?!

Aside from all of this, what has any of it got to to with me?! I wasn't even married to the guy!

The whole thing has just annoyed and baffled me and just wanted some outside perspectives! Thank you.

Block him.

Simple.

thisisuttermadness · 07/02/2024 15:10

beatrix1234 · 07/02/2024 15:09

If my ex husband went around using my surname as his I would be angry too and would NOT like it so I totally see where he’s coming from.

Can you explain why?

OP posts:
Tempnamechng · 07/02/2024 15:09

He needs blocking - I can see why he is your exbil.

Bladwdoda · 07/02/2024 15:09

I’d suggest all the family block him and his partner and ignore any future messages. I’d also be clear if he doesn’t stop you’ll report for harassment.

sounds like a knob. I’d also suspect the new partner doesn’t like it.

beatrix1234 · 07/02/2024 15:09

If my ex husband went around using my surname as his I would be angry too and would NOT like it so I totally see where he’s coming from.

thisisuttermadness · 07/02/2024 15:09

The other thing he said was, "it affects my credit rating".... Eh?! Does it? I thought the fact that they were once married was the part that linked them financially, rather than the specific name?

Told my sister he'd said that, and she laughed her head off saying, "well tell him my credit score is fantastic so in that respect I'm only improving his image"😂

OP posts:
GrumpyPanda · 07/02/2024 15:08

Tell him karma is a bitch. If he'd been less hidebound and had taken on her name on marriage he wouldn't be having this particular problem.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 07/02/2024 15:07

Your sister should tell him very firmly that her name is none of his business and she won’t hesitate to go down the harassment route if he continues.

I worked with a HT once who’d kept her name as it was the same as her children, then when they were adults she was known to the school community by it so kept it. Her ex husband used to message her once or twice a year still trying to persuade her even though she’d kept it for over twenty years by that point. He and his second wife were both furious.

thisisuttermadness · 07/02/2024 15:07

IncompleteSenten · 07/02/2024 15:06

Suggest to her that she tells him she'll do it for £10,000. Compensation for the hassle. 😁

😂

OP posts:
BigFatCat2024 · 07/02/2024 15:07

Well I'd guess that his wife to be has an issue with it, and that's why he's now getting arsey. I'd just block him

thisisuttermadness · 07/02/2024 15:07

I can't get my head around it, he honestly looks so happy on social media with his new partner and child, it just makes no sense why they'd waste headspace on this non issue!

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread