Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not pick my 14 year old daughter up from school?

310 replies

Str3bor · 07/02/2024 13:31

DD is 14 and in year 10. We moved in with my partner a year ago and as such we now live 20 mins away from her school (40 minute round trip) there is no direct public transport route. If she makes her own way home she has to get the school bus to to the train station and then get the train home, all in all it take her just over an hour but is doable.

Me and partner work it between us to take her, he sometimes drops her off in the morning on his way into work. Doing this she gets into school 10 minutes earlier than she would like to but my partner needs to get her in for this time so he is on time for work. I will take her when he is not and will usually try and pick her up and will work my day so that I can.

This morning she was refusing to leave because she still had ‘1 minute’ before the time they usually leave. This is after being shouted down and told that it’s time to go and getting bad attitude back from her. I lost my rag with her and told her she goes when she is told or she or she can get the train in the morning to school. She point blank refuses to do this.

when you take her or pick her up there is not a please or thank you from her, she doesn’t say a word in the car and trying to talk to her is hard work. The same goes when she wants to see her friend of a weekend she expects me to drop everything and pick her up and drop her off again not a please or thanks in sight or any sign of appreciation (they are also a 40 minute round trip away).

her brother goes to the local school so makes his own way whilst I pick her up, she refuses to move schools which is her choice and I appreciate at this stage in her school life it would be hard for her and disruptive. She also says it’s my own fault for moving house so I have to take her.

now whilst I don’t mind continuing with taking her in morning I am thinking would I be unreasonable to start making her get the bus/train home from school?

I am just starting to resent her attitude, she doesn’t appreciate anything we do for her and constantly moans about something, she has no manners and and just back chats constantly and I’m getting fed up of bending over backwards for her when she can’t even say please or thanks mum.

OP posts:
ThreePointOneFourOneFiveNine · 07/02/2024 17:57

Moving a child her age away from her school, to move in with your boyfriend, in her GCSE years, is massive deal. I'm not saying you shouldn't have done it, but I am saying you need to recognise just how big an impact this has on her. As adults we have a lot of experience that can give us perspective on these situations. At her age she has very little life experience and will be living in a very small world of school and a few friends. What you've done is a really big deal. Sit her down for a chat and tell her you recognise what a massive thing this is in her life and ask her to tell you how she's feeling about it all. Don't even mention the problem with her attitude over other things, that would turn it into a conversation about what you want. Just listen to her. Have a conversation about her attitude at a later date, but first make sure she knows that you know what she's going through.

Ohnoooooooo · 07/02/2024 17:56

I would not move a child in their GCSE years - it is highly unlikely the local school would match her existing subject choices. Even if they offered all her subjects - it won't mean she could do them due to timetabling or they are likely different exams boards, teachers have chosen to follow different timings paths.
And that doesn't cover her making new friends etc.
I think she needs to be more polite to you but quite frankly you moved to be with your partner and now I think you need to consider her education needs for the next 18 months and she can move locally for 6th form.
Making her travel 2hrs a day because you wanted to live with your boyfriend is not great and she might resent you and him.
She may not talk after school because she is exhausted from her day and would be a mess of hormones and needs some time to decompress.

historyrepeatz · 07/02/2024 17:55

I think you are being harshly treated. There's more than just the lifts. I wouldn't tolerate DC talking to me like that or barking orders/ shopping lists at me. When she wants a lift to a friend's the answer would be no and not just no lift but she's not going if she's been a brat and no funds either. If you are back posting in a few years about DD people on here will say it's your fault for not sorting her out earlier!

lifeispainauchocolat · 07/02/2024 17:54

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Yep - it makes for some really uncomfortable reading.

lifeispainauchocolat · 07/02/2024 17:54

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Bookworm1111 · 07/02/2024 17:52

Jarstastic · 07/02/2024 17:50

Typical mumsnet pile on. And blended families are red rags to a bull.

It doesn't sound far, 20 minutes drive. We moved further away from DC's old school, an hour door to door walking and train. The teens had the choice of travel or move school. One did a couple of weeks of travel at the end of Y10, didn't like it and wanted to move school. We wouldn't have considered driving them and no doubt we wouldn't have got any thanks (sorry OP, this is typical! Holidays are a particular bug bear. Even the one that was so positive and enthusiastic at 12 was a nightmare at 15). This DC started a new school in Y11 (I know!), did have a lot of support and private tutoring but ended up with much better GCSEs than they would have done at the old school. By their own admission.

The pile-on's been aimed at the teen, not OP. It's been horrible to read.

NameChange9490 · 07/02/2024 17:51

She sounds like a 14 year old…

It sounds like she’s been through a lot in the last few years. You seem to have a very authoritarian attitude towards her as well, “I’m the adult, she’s the child”. Well she won’t be a child for much longer and she’ll remember how you treated her during these difficult adolescent years. Meet her hostility with hostility and you’ll push her further away, meet it with compassion and she’ll come back to you in a couple of years (and probably apologise profusely for how rude she was to you as a teenager!)

As others have said, you chose to move an hour by public transport away from her school, you should probably help her get there and back and not necessarily expect thanks. And if you say that leaving time is a certain time then expect her to be ready to leave by that time but no earlier - one of my biggest bug bears is people who say they want to leave at one time then start hassling you to get in the car earlier than they said.

Jarstastic · 07/02/2024 17:50

Typical mumsnet pile on. And blended families are red rags to a bull.

It doesn't sound far, 20 minutes drive. We moved further away from DC's old school, an hour door to door walking and train. The teens had the choice of travel or move school. One did a couple of weeks of travel at the end of Y10, didn't like it and wanted to move school. We wouldn't have considered driving them and no doubt we wouldn't have got any thanks (sorry OP, this is typical! Holidays are a particular bug bear. Even the one that was so positive and enthusiastic at 12 was a nightmare at 15). This DC started a new school in Y11 (I know!), did have a lot of support and private tutoring but ended up with much better GCSEs than they would have done at the old school. By their own admission.

Bululu · 07/02/2024 17:49

@bluedelphiniums · Today 17:11 I expected more from a teacher. You should know better about the horrible period teenagers and their families go through. Hopefully you are more patient and understanding in real life.

SpidersAreShitheads · 07/02/2024 17:48

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Bululu · 07/02/2024 17:47

Teenager girls can be like this. It is so soul destroying but it is common. I hated and was difficult to ignore. Hopefully it gets better.

EvangelicalAboutButteredToast · 07/02/2024 17:42

What’s the consequence when she refuses to leave the house at the time she wants to leave?

lazyarse123 · 07/02/2024 17:39

bluedelphiniums · 07/02/2024 17:11

Very enlightening as a teacher to see how many parents let their kids dictate their every decision, and how they defend their rudeness because OP has (shock, horror) decided to move in with a man that isn't her father, without knowing any of her back story. Yes the child might be unsettled temporarily, but doesn't excuse their rude, bolshy attitude. This sense of entitlement that MN affords children is what makes so many of them bloody hard to manage in school. 'You are at the centre of everyone's world DC and we won't do anything that you don't give us permission to do.' Great life lesson, not.

Perfectly put. Easy to see where some kids get their entitlement from. It's time to grow up and consider other people.

rainbowsparkle28 · 07/02/2024 17:39

Youcannotbeseriousreally · 07/02/2024 13:44

So, for you to satisfy yourself and live with your partner you moved miles from your daughter’s school and you’re cross at HER because she finds the whole thing too much?

Cool.

This. And then expect her to be grateful...🙄🤨

SpidersAreShitheads · 07/02/2024 17:35

I mean this kindly OP but have you ever actually stopped to really think about how she might be feeling? I mean honestly and genuinely thought about things from her perspective?

Or are you too caught up in your annoyance at her "bad attitude" to have taken a step back to consider it more objectively?

In your posts, there's a lot of "us/we" type language about you and your partner - and a lot of hostile/confrontational language about your daughter. For example "we shout up and she barks back" - when actually you've shouted up the stairs so she's just shouted back.....so matching your style of communication? Your insistence on using the description of her "refusing" to move schools reeks of disapproval when lots of PP have told you why it would be a terrible idea to make her move schools now. It just comes across very much as you/your DP vs your DD - and if your DD is sensing the same, she's going to be feeling pretty shit.

Yes, undoubtedly part of it is a typical teen attitude which stinks sometimes. Good parenting is loving your child even when they don't make it easy, and de-escalating situations while maintaining appropriate boundaries. You seem to be very reactive to your DD and quite outraged at her "attitude" and responses, which suggests that maybe you're not making ideal choices either.

The other thing is that you might have moved to a "better" area but your DD won't care too much about that. You've uprooted her during important school years and she's now further from her friends/network. You moved solely to accommodate your relationship with your DP, and in doing so you've created a more challenging school/social situation for your DD. Did you discuss this with her first? Did you acknowledge any of this to her? Your irritated "I'm the adult, she's just a child, I make the decisions" comment suggests that maybe your attitude is just as bad as hers....and at least partially why you're in this situation now.

No one is suggesting you shouldn't have a relationship, but you seem to have put your own needs first without actually considering the fact that these things will have an impact on her. Or considered the fact that she might not see things the same way as you.

There's nothing wrong with pulling her up on unacceptable rudeness but as part of that you need to consider the root cause, and also how you communicate to her too. Being the adult doesn't mean that you get a free pass - she is equally as deserving of consideration and respectful communication, particularly when major life decisions have been made which have significantly affected her.

HaudYerWheeshtYaWeeBellend · 07/02/2024 17:33

Personally OP when she behaves in this manner I’d drop her off at school as normal and then advise her she has to make her own way home due to her behaviour and attitude this morning and follow through with it.

I understand she’s frustrated however she can’t have it all ways and she needs to realise her behaviour has consequences.

MushMonster · 07/02/2024 17:33

Children of parent who parent are greatful, or will become grateful.

lifeispainauchocolat · 07/02/2024 17:33

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

MushMonster · 07/02/2024 17:32

She needs to grow up.
Natural consequences is the best way of teaching. I would let her get the bus/ train if you arepositive she is not getting herself into any trouble.
Or go for letting her make her way to and from other activitiesif you have any inkling she may stop going to school, getting there late....
And I will make clear that if you do not see a clear improvement in her attitude, appreciation, gratefullness and general demeanour, then change her school.

tachetastic · 07/02/2024 17:32

@Str3bor when you take her or pick her up there is not a please or thank you from her,

I always remember a quote from the TV show Supernatural.

"Kids aren't supposed to be grateful. They're supposed to eat your food and break your heart."

Stupid programme but I always thought the quote hit it on the head.

pootlin · 07/02/2024 17:27

I think letting her get the train and bus back in the afternoons is a good idea.

Also stop giving her treats if she’s rude.

Do positive reinforcement when she isn’t rude.

gingergiraffe · 07/02/2024 17:27

Sorry but I cannot find where it says the partner and op have six children between them. Please can someone point it out to me?

ConsistentlyElectrifiedElves · 07/02/2024 17:26

Moveoverdarlin · 07/02/2024 17:23

Could you not have waited until she finished school to move in with your boyfriend? I don’t think many kids say ‘thanks’ to their parents for dropping them at school, it’s kind of what you signed up for.

I refer back to my previous post where I said my parents got off lightly. I used to have to get public transport to school and on the days where one of my parents was able to pick me up I always said thank you!

That said, I agree with a PP that I wouldn't expect OP's DD to always be grateful when the situation of requiring a lift isn't of her own making.

Moveoverdarlin · 07/02/2024 17:23

Could you not have waited until she finished school to move in with your boyfriend? I don’t think many kids say ‘thanks’ to their parents for dropping them at school, it’s kind of what you signed up for.

Flottie · 07/02/2024 17:22

1987qwerty · 07/02/2024 13:39

You're the ones that changed things. Should have considered the impact fully.

This I feel a bit sorry for your daughter as this has had a big impact on her day to day life