Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not pick my 14 year old daughter up from school?

310 replies

Str3bor · 07/02/2024 13:31

DD is 14 and in year 10. We moved in with my partner a year ago and as such we now live 20 mins away from her school (40 minute round trip) there is no direct public transport route. If she makes her own way home she has to get the school bus to to the train station and then get the train home, all in all it take her just over an hour but is doable.

Me and partner work it between us to take her, he sometimes drops her off in the morning on his way into work. Doing this she gets into school 10 minutes earlier than she would like to but my partner needs to get her in for this time so he is on time for work. I will take her when he is not and will usually try and pick her up and will work my day so that I can.

This morning she was refusing to leave because she still had ‘1 minute’ before the time they usually leave. This is after being shouted down and told that it’s time to go and getting bad attitude back from her. I lost my rag with her and told her she goes when she is told or she or she can get the train in the morning to school. She point blank refuses to do this.

when you take her or pick her up there is not a please or thank you from her, she doesn’t say a word in the car and trying to talk to her is hard work. The same goes when she wants to see her friend of a weekend she expects me to drop everything and pick her up and drop her off again not a please or thanks in sight or any sign of appreciation (they are also a 40 minute round trip away).

her brother goes to the local school so makes his own way whilst I pick her up, she refuses to move schools which is her choice and I appreciate at this stage in her school life it would be hard for her and disruptive. She also says it’s my own fault for moving house so I have to take her.

now whilst I don’t mind continuing with taking her in morning I am thinking would I be unreasonable to start making her get the bus/train home from school?

I am just starting to resent her attitude, she doesn’t appreciate anything we do for her and constantly moans about something, she has no manners and and just back chats constantly and I’m getting fed up of bending over backwards for her when she can’t even say please or thanks mum.

OP posts:
Jellycatspyjamas · 07/02/2024 14:00

You are the adult, and you decided to move her away from her school and her friends. The consequence of that decision is that she needs help getting to and from school and maintaining her social life. I think an hour each way is a lot on top of a school day, so I’d be dropping her off/picking her up.

I don’t expect my kids to thank me for getting them to and from school, it’s my job as their parent to facilitate that. Given you made a move that makes it difficult for her to travel independently, I wouldn’t expect to be thanked.

Wasbedeudetetdas · 07/02/2024 14:00

Str3bor · 07/02/2024 13:58

She was like this before we moved. She doesn’t want to go to school, most of her friends now just don’t go at all and the ones that are left are always off sick and she hates that I make her go. I suppose that’s why she is never going to say please or thanks.

maybe about once every 2 weeks she has to make her own way home if I can’t get her due to work reasons and she kicks off.

I don’t mind doing the school run or taking her to her friends but i suppose it’s her attitude I’m trying to address and her behaviour towards myself and others

Before you moved and also before the new relationship, or only before you moved?

MarnieMarnie · 07/02/2024 13:59

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines - previously banned poster.

TinkerTiger · 07/02/2024 13:58

You sound like the kind of mother we heard about on MN whose child decides to go NC. You've moved your children FOR A MAN and want her to be grateful.

I never thanked my parents for ferrying me around, does your boss thank you every day for doing your job?

I swear the attitude to children sometimes is shocking. Seems like once they're out of nappies they should be fully independent looking after themselves and kissing the ground for you keeping them alive.

BananaPyjamaLlama · 07/02/2024 13:58

I get that it wasnt her choice to live further away from the school and of course she doesnt want to switch schools and leave her friends.
But her attitude is appalling. I would insist she behave appropriately (polite, thankful, not make a fuss about being 10 minutes early etc) or she goes on public transport.

Str3bor · 07/02/2024 13:58

She was like this before we moved. She doesn’t want to go to school, most of her friends now just don’t go at all and the ones that are left are always off sick and she hates that I make her go. I suppose that’s why she is never going to say please or thanks.

maybe about once every 2 weeks she has to make her own way home if I can’t get her due to work reasons and she kicks off.

I don’t mind doing the school run or taking her to her friends but i suppose it’s her attitude I’m trying to address and her behaviour towards myself and others

OP posts:
C00k · 07/02/2024 13:58

She does not need to say please and thank you to you for taking her to and from school. That’s your job as a parent.
You uprooted her to facilitate your love life. Stop trying to paint the child as the villain, ffs.

GingerIsBest · 07/02/2024 13:57

I think moving so that you're 20 minutes drive away but an hour by public transport was a bit ridiculous. Surely there was some compromise that would allow her to stay in the school she was in - necessary for her year group - and that would allow her more flexibility to get around and see her friends etc?

Being rude is not okay, but it sounds to me like she's pretty resentful. Prior to moving, did she have a lot of independence? Heading to to see friends/meet up without too much difficulty? DH and I have talked about this exact issue as we'd quite like to move, but a big consideration is that DS needs to stay at his current school and while we're happy to do a certain amount of lifting - we already do - we wouldn't want to make it so that he couldn't be as independent and as flexible as he is currently as it's something he really enjoys. So, for example, one area which would be good for us as it's quite nice and w could get a bit more for our money is off our consideration list because it's just too difficult for DS to go anywhere without being driven.

audweb · 07/02/2024 13:57

Shes your kid, and your responsibility. You chose to move away, and I assumed agreed that it was fine for her to remain at the same school because you could facilitate that. Why does she need to thank you for every lift? Honestly, I think it would be incrediably harsh to stop those just because she's grumpy. And yes, if there is a set time to leave, why pressure to leave earlier? Just give her the minute or two that she normally has.

EliflurtleAndTheInfiniteMadness · 07/02/2024 13:56

I don't think she has to be thankful you drive her to school or to see friends when you've made the choice to move her away from those things. Getting your school age child to and from school and taking them to see friends are very basic parts of parenting. You're seeing it as you and your partner deserving thanks for that, whereas rightly she's just seeing it as something you need to so because you chose to move.

TeenLifeMum · 07/02/2024 13:56

What teen says “thank you” for taking them to school 😂😂😂

You’ve turned her world on its head and now she has to live with mum’s guy and get a bus/train home after school. I couldn’t be bothered with that either - I would drive her both ways. Speak to her about how you expect to be spoken to but threats to get the train in the morning seem out of proportion when you’ve put this on her.

saoirse31 · 07/02/2024 13:55

Try and see what youve done to her life from her point of view. Its not all about you, really.

Floopani · 07/02/2024 13:55

Str3bor · 07/02/2024 13:46

She will still get dropped off in the morning and I actually don’t mind picking her up but she has zero manners and is just rude, she is like this with everyone and I feel ashamed sometimes. My poor dad loves her and if we go to see that I end up arguing with her over making her go and say bye to him because she won’t.

we actually only live 20 mins drive away in a better area, if me and her dad were still together and decided we wanted to move to a better area would you still make these comments? She is the child and I am the adult making decisions. Her brother goes to a better school because of it and whilst she won’t move schools herself she gets dropped off and picked up every day and I accept that as the decision I made to move. However what I don’t accept is her rudeness and lack of manners and generally just treating us like Uber drivers that don’t get paid

Yes, I think these comments would still be fair if you and her dad were still together and you suddenly decided to move in her GCSE year and give her the choice of either a long public transport journey or having to travel on your partner's schedule. You could have waited until she was past GSCEs.

I say that as someone who moved an hour's drive away from my partner to facilitate my child going to a college they wanted to go to (absolutely right for their career plans). My DP and I picked up the travelling to see each other, knowing it was for the short term only.

Also, she is being a fourteen year old. You've got a few years yet until they realise they were arseholes for a while there. All part of parenting.

Midnlghtrain · 07/02/2024 13:55

You shout up at her, she shouts down at you - sounds fair.

You've moved her away from her home and school, in with a new man (because you wanted to) and you're moaning about the school run and taking her to see friends? Teenagers often act out to display feelings they can't communicate, take note.

helpnohelpno · 07/02/2024 13:53

Yeah I'm with everyone else, you created a shit situation . You have made her life significantly harder for zero benefits to her. She's now reliant on you guys for lifts which are only on your terms. And she's a teen with hormones all over the place.

I'd apologise for the threats this morning and maybe show some acknowledgment of how tough this must be for her.

BogRollBOGOF · 07/02/2024 13:52

Being uprooted doesn't bring out the best in teenagers, and this move is a lot of upheaval and inconvenience to her. It's not surprising that she doesn't want to move schools at this stage of education/ social development.

Try and keep the confrontations down and show some understanding. Talking about attitude and behaviour is better afterwards when everyone has calmed down.
Be realistic, you're not going to get bountiful gratitude for giving her a lift to save a lot of inconvenience that your choices have caused compared to the previous situation.

Itslegitimatesalvage · 07/02/2024 13:52

She’s 14 so pushing boundaries and attitude is just what they do. It’s par for the course and you need to be the one who de-escalates situations, let the grumpiness roll off you and stay calm.

But this driving thing… you moved your kids in with a guy for you, not for them. You moved them away from their home and local area for you, not for them. They do not need to be thankful. They don’t need to like it at all. And giving her an hour commute there and back? No. You are entirely wrong. I hope you have apologised to doing this to her. The lift things is annoying and her attitude is annoying, but you have to take some of it because you did this to her and give it some times to see if she settles down. If she has been given a time to be ready for, then don’t make her leave before that time. It’s just causing a fight for nothing. Unless she has a habit of coming down late, stop calling her down early.

Octavia64 · 07/02/2024 13:52

Even if you and her dad were together it's not a good idea to move a child in year 10 or 11.

Most teens go through a stage of being rude. You can address that separately to the school issue.

I found the book

Get out of my life but first take me and Alex into town

helpful.

MustBeNapTime · 07/02/2024 13:51

I think it's a bit tricky to be honest. How long were you with your partner before you moved in with him? Did she get any say in the matter or was it a fait accompli? She's probably feeling (understandably) disgruntled at being made to leave at a certain time or facing a long journey on public transport. How long was her journey previously?

She's in year10, which is a difficult year and then she's also at a hormonal age so there's all the normal stroppiness going on. I think you need to cut her some slack really. Plus I'm not sure she needs to be thanking you for taking her to school and as a rule I'm really strict about please and thank you's.

Thementalloadisreal · 07/02/2024 13:47

If this is new behaviour / attitude - you don’t mention what she was like before you moved - it sounds like she’s not settled in the new home and pushing back against things being decided for her, out of her control.

mightydolphin · 07/02/2024 13:46

You sound very self absorbed. It was selfish to move so far from your DD's school. I imagine her resentment is being expressed through her attitude. Respect is earnt.

Str3bor · 07/02/2024 13:46

She will still get dropped off in the morning and I actually don’t mind picking her up but she has zero manners and is just rude, she is like this with everyone and I feel ashamed sometimes. My poor dad loves her and if we go to see that I end up arguing with her over making her go and say bye to him because she won’t.

we actually only live 20 mins drive away in a better area, if me and her dad were still together and decided we wanted to move to a better area would you still make these comments? She is the child and I am the adult making decisions. Her brother goes to a better school because of it and whilst she won’t move schools herself she gets dropped off and picked up every day and I accept that as the decision I made to move. However what I don’t accept is her rudeness and lack of manners and generally just treating us like Uber drivers that don’t get paid

OP posts:
beAsensible1 · 07/02/2024 13:45

It sucks simply sit her down and say what you’ve said here.

you understand the upheaval and are happy to accommodate but the attitude has to end.

let her know after half term if the behaviour doesn’t pick up she’ll be coming home on public transport.

would it be quicker for her on a electric bike?

Wasbedeudetetdas · 07/02/2024 13:45

1987qwerty · 07/02/2024 13:39

You're the ones that changed things. Should have considered the impact fully.

Exactly this.
You've made her life harder but you expect her to thank you for it?

Itsnotallaboutyoulikeyouthink · 07/02/2024 13:45

No teen is going to say thanks for giving them a lift to sxhool. they don’t want to be there most of them. Personally I go above and beyond to make sure that their journey from school is as short as possible so although they get the school
bus I pick them up from the bus stop otherwise they have a 20min walk and quite often have to be out the house 30 mins later for sports.