Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not pick my 14 year old daughter up from school?

310 replies

Str3bor · 07/02/2024 13:31

DD is 14 and in year 10. We moved in with my partner a year ago and as such we now live 20 mins away from her school (40 minute round trip) there is no direct public transport route. If she makes her own way home she has to get the school bus to to the train station and then get the train home, all in all it take her just over an hour but is doable.

Me and partner work it between us to take her, he sometimes drops her off in the morning on his way into work. Doing this she gets into school 10 minutes earlier than she would like to but my partner needs to get her in for this time so he is on time for work. I will take her when he is not and will usually try and pick her up and will work my day so that I can.

This morning she was refusing to leave because she still had ‘1 minute’ before the time they usually leave. This is after being shouted down and told that it’s time to go and getting bad attitude back from her. I lost my rag with her and told her she goes when she is told or she or she can get the train in the morning to school. She point blank refuses to do this.

when you take her or pick her up there is not a please or thank you from her, she doesn’t say a word in the car and trying to talk to her is hard work. The same goes when she wants to see her friend of a weekend she expects me to drop everything and pick her up and drop her off again not a please or thanks in sight or any sign of appreciation (they are also a 40 minute round trip away).

her brother goes to the local school so makes his own way whilst I pick her up, she refuses to move schools which is her choice and I appreciate at this stage in her school life it would be hard for her and disruptive. She also says it’s my own fault for moving house so I have to take her.

now whilst I don’t mind continuing with taking her in morning I am thinking would I be unreasonable to start making her get the bus/train home from school?

I am just starting to resent her attitude, she doesn’t appreciate anything we do for her and constantly moans about something, she has no manners and and just back chats constantly and I’m getting fed up of bending over backwards for her when she can’t even say please or thanks mum.

OP posts:
C8H10N4O2 · 07/02/2024 15:11

C00k · 07/02/2024 14:30

@C8H10N4O2 he's the OP being 'punished'? She needs to prioritise her kid and parent in a compassionate manner and understand how unsettling it is to a child to have to move house and live with some man, and have your mother fuming over nothing.
The only reason to make kids live in a house with a new boyfriend is if it is in their best interests. Clearly not the case here.

Edited

Again - so mothers should not enter new relationships whilst they have children?

She has allowed the child to make the choices about schools, is ensuring she has a chauffeur service to and from school every day. Both the DM and her DP are providing a taxi service.
She is asking for help in how to deal with a teenager's moods - my kids neither moved home nor dealt with changes in relationship status at this age and we had exactly the same bouts of taxi service ingratitude and moodiness. Its normal teen behaviour.

The definition of "compassion" here is that the mother avoids relationships not because the DP may be harmful to the DC but simply because one teen of the two is having moods about moving. What about the other child who is happy and doing well at the better school - do his views not matter?

These are all variations on "mothers can't move on until the kids leave home". Its just not realistic. Change happens, sometimes by choice for the overall good and sometimes because we have to deal with it. What the OP is asking for is help dealing with very familiar teen moods and hormones and change. The answer "nothing must ever change" helps nobody but just flings blame at her. Teens don't need anything to change to have these bouts of moods.

Coyoacan · 07/02/2024 15:09

I'm a great believer in gratitude but I take my dgd to school nearly every day and it's never occurred to me that she should thank me for it

Spinet · 07/02/2024 15:06

I would work on your relationship with her quite apart from the lifts thing. Make time to do nice things together. That way she's less likely to be rude but if she is (being, after all, a teenager) it's not the only dynamic between you.

lanthanum · 07/02/2024 15:01

How about taking the line of "sorry I lost my rag, and I promise I will continue taking you to school - I know it's not been easy moving over here and I do want to do what I can to help. I think what's making me get cross is just that I'd like you to understand that the lifts do take up quite a lot of time. I'd feel giving you the lifts is much more worthwhile if it did mean a smile and a thank you."

Try and have the conversation when she's in a good mood, even if that means waiting a few days. (I have all the difficult conversations with my DD on the way home from one particular activity, because that's when she's in the best mood!)

Bythefireside · 07/02/2024 15:01

That’s where you are so wrong and create rude entitled adults. She absolutely owes her mum a thank you as you would anyone who does something for you.

Bythefireside · 07/02/2024 14:59

Doesn’t mean she has to be rude.

sunr111se · 07/02/2024 14:57

Your poor daughter

You made these decisions, not her. She sounds like she's struggling. She's a teenager - they are difficult at the best of times without a massive life upheaval! My dd gets narky in the mornings if I try to make her leave before the usual time ; it's just a teen thing! You've changed her life so it's your responsibility to sort it out. And yes if you and her dad were still together and decided to move so far away; it would still be the case.

SoYoung · 07/02/2024 14:55

It's very telling that you want to "correct her behaviour and attitude". She's obviously very unhappy. Doesn't that matter? As long as she's polite you don't care about what's going on with her and what could be causing her behaviour or attitude as you put it?

It's not about driving to school/trains etc. She's your child, something is wrong, try starting there. Also, so many people on this thread are trying to get through to you and you're just batting it away. Why start the thread if you're not going to take any other insights on board? Was it just a "let's find ways to stick it to my ungrateful daughter" thread? Because that's awful. If you really wanted advice on how to make things better then you should take it.

Ponderingwindow · 07/02/2024 14:51

14yos have attitudes. They are testing the redefinition of the relationship with their parents . You shouldn’t take it too seriously. Correct the behavior if it is bad, but don’t overreact.

she doesn’t owe you a thank you for driving her to or from school. That is your job, especially having moved her away from her school.

Willyoujustbequiet · 07/02/2024 14:50

ohdamnitjanet · 07/02/2024 13:39

No wonder she’s pissed off with you, deliberately giving her potentially 2 hours travelling every day. That’s a long journey home. Quite honestly I wouldn’t have moved so far from her school.

This.

I find your attitude shocking tbh.

DoILookThrilled · 07/02/2024 14:44

When did the obsession with taking children to / from secondary school start? She doesn’t NEED driving there. She had the choice to move schools but doesn’t want to and here are the consequences. Lots of children have a 1 hour journey to school and it’s not a biggy. If she’s being rude then don’t take her to school r

Str3bor · 07/02/2024 14:43

C00k · 07/02/2024 14:35

@catwithflowers As PPs have also said, no, of course people who chose to have a kid for not getting thanked for bare minimum tasks. Does your boss thank you for each tiny task you perform?
The kid has no choice but to go to school, the mother chose to uproot her, so nope, no thanking necessary.

So I deserve to be treated with disrespect and bad attitude and everyone else around her does to?

Let me also be clear, she now gets taken too and from school rather than before when she had to get the bus, the school journey time is even less for her now she gets driven. She still sees her friends just as often as I still take her to them as I used to, I pick her friends up so they can stay over.

OP posts:
Rosesanddaisies1 · 07/02/2024 14:42

So you’ve uprooted her life and made her live with a new stepdad? I would have HATED having to get a lift to school as a teen. Walking home from school was the best time of day. You need to cut her some slack

171513mum · 07/02/2024 14:39

An hour trip to or from school is not that bad, my kids have always done that for secondary along with loads of others. It's 15/20 mins drive but that's never been on the cards unless there's a train strike or some other problem. The difficulty is the change from one to the other. It depends how inconvenient it is for you.

I'd agree that no 14 year old says thank you for a lift to school. And it almost certainly hasn't crossed her mind that a 20 min trip for her is a 40 min trip for you. Maybe a compromise whereby you take her twice or three times a week, or when it's raining. Taking public transport sometimes might make her realise how much she appreciates the lifts.

C00k · 07/02/2024 14:35

@catwithflowers As PPs have also said, no, of course people who chose to have a kid for not getting thanked for bare minimum tasks. Does your boss thank you for each tiny task you perform?
The kid has no choice but to go to school, the mother chose to uproot her, so nope, no thanking necessary.

Mischance · 07/02/2024 14:35

what I’m trying to do is correct her behaviour and attitude - in order to do that you need to reflect on the cause of these, and they probably are not just her age. Some of the problem will be about an enforced move for your benefit that has been to her detriment. You cannot change her behaviour without trying to understand it. And letting her know that you understand.

Str3bor · 07/02/2024 14:34

TimetoPour · 07/02/2024 14:17

If you had phrased this differently, you would not have had such a hard time………

Teenage daughter’s attitude stinks. She is rude, ignores you and is deliberately defiant over small things. You know that moving was difficult for her and have done your best to help the transition by ensuring she stays in her previous school and you and new partner ensure she gets there and back each day. What can I do to make her recognise that we are not doormats and deserve ti be treated with the same level of respect we try to treat her with?

Instead, your post reads that you moved her across town and expect her to be grateful that you put yourself out to avoid her having to take public transport.

You need to address her attitude overall if she is rude and being generally unpleasant. Why does she feel this way? By sending her out on her own, you will push her further away and create an even more hostile situation.

Worded it well better than me, you should write my future posts!

exactly this.

OP posts:
catwithflowers · 07/02/2024 14:33

C00k · 07/02/2024 13:58

She does not need to say please and thank you to you for taking her to and from school. That’s your job as a parent.
You uprooted her to facilitate your love life. Stop trying to paint the child as the villain, ffs.

😳 seriously? Of course she should say thank you for the lift to school!! In the same way that kids should say thank you for dinner when a parent has made it for them.

I'm amazed that anyone would think this level of rudeness in a teenager is okay. Yes teens are tricky, it's a hard time for them but as a parent you aren't making their lives any easier by encouraging such a basic lack of manners!

C00k · 07/02/2024 14:30

@C8H10N4O2 he's the OP being 'punished'? She needs to prioritise her kid and parent in a compassionate manner and understand how unsettling it is to a child to have to move house and live with some man, and have your mother fuming over nothing.
The only reason to make kids live in a house with a new boyfriend is if it is in their best interests. Clearly not the case here.

UnbeatenMum · 07/02/2024 14:30

She sounds quite anxious to me. Needing to arrive at a set time and refusing to say goodbye to your Dad could both be social anxiety rather than a bad attitude. Especially if her friends aren't always in school as she would potentially be sitting on her own.

Jellycatspyjamas · 07/02/2024 14:29

Its exactly the consequence of the "You must never change anything if you have children" blaming of mothers here. The mother must be blamed and punished for moving on after divorce and building a new relationship.

I don’t think mothers should be punished for moving on but they do need to consider the impact of moving away from their child’s school and social circle. They need to consider the impact a moving a new adult into their home. Nothing is consequence free - surely we’re well
past the point of expecting children to suck it up.

DeedlessIndeed · 07/02/2024 14:29

Her choice was either a really long commute or disruption to her education, friends etc.

You've not left her with many good options. That, plus normal teenage attitude no doubt is a recipe for disaster...

TinkerTiger · 07/02/2024 14:28

Str3bor · 07/02/2024 14:06

Just to make it clear I have never once tried to move her schools, she was given the option, she said no which is fine understandable and I have and will continue to be happy to do the school run.

what I’m trying to do is correct her behaviour and attitude

Given an option, but was it really? She wasn’t given the option to move though I bet. You moved her further away from her school, gave her the ‘option’ to move schools too, she said no and you’re 🤷🏽‍♀️

C8H10N4O2 · 07/02/2024 14:25

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines - previously banned poster.

Its exactly the consequence of the "You must never change anything if you have children" blaming of mothers here. The mother must be blamed and punished for moving on after divorce and building a new relationship.

The father has also moved house. Many teens whose parents are together move house. The child is being ferried to and from school and was given the choice of staying or changing schools. She is 20 minutes away - they haven't moved to Australia. Its a normal everyday family experience where the teen in question has been given choices in how the change is managed.

hobbitonthehill · 07/02/2024 14:24

Of course she's angry and unsettled you've put your fanny before your children lol