Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think this isn't right? mother convicted if manslaughter

279 replies

greenacrylicpaint · 07/02/2024 06:43

https://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-68223118

A jury has found a Michigan mother guilty of involuntary manslaughter for failing to stop her son from carrying out a deadly school shooting.

by all means, she didn't come across as mother of the year, but come on.
what sentence will the father get?
an absent father in a similar case?

oh america

OP posts:
LemonTT · 07/02/2024 11:56

greenacrylicpaint · 07/02/2024 11:41

with the gun laws, gun acceptance in some us states giving your child a gun (for shooting on a range) is not really unusual.

Are you even thinking about what you are saying.

The mother was an adult. She didn’t have to buy a gun. It wasn’t an impossible position nor was a perceived social norm a reason to buy a gun. Parents in the US don’t routinely arm children and society at large doesn’t condone it. Laws prohibit it.

And there may be many reasons why she broke the law. But that shouldn’t stop a jury finding that she did break the law. Just like her son broke the law. Questions of diminished responsibility would be explored at trial as a defence. That would not stop other processes taking over to deal with somebody who was dangerous to society.

When people so something wrong which breaks the law, that is a simple factual statement. How responsible they are for their actions is considered firstly as to whether they can stand trial and secondly in how they are sentenced.

travelallthetime · 07/02/2024 11:51

greenacrylicpaint · 07/02/2024 11:41

with the gun laws, gun acceptance in some us states giving your child a gun (for shooting on a range) is not really unusual.

You seem to be missing the point that she gave her mentally unstable 15 year old a gun and then went on to ignore the drawing he did of a school shooting. She clearly knew she was in the wrong by running away too. I think you need to give this one up. The conviction is 100% the right one

MrsSkylerWhite · 07/02/2024 11:48

Seems reasonable to me, given the circumstances. What an appalling parent.

Hooplahooping · 07/02/2024 11:46

She literally bought a murder weapon + gifted it to her mentally unwell teenager.

she then didn’t keep it in a gun safe or locked away, or keep tabs on it at all.

she refused to engage with the school about her son’s violent drawing.

I am not familiar with the legal precedent in the state that she is in - but this would seem to pretty comprehensively meet the criteria for Gross Negligence Manslaughter in the UK

LemonTT · 07/02/2024 11:46

MrsPinkCock · 07/02/2024 08:18

I think it’s a fair conviction too. Even if you look at gross negligence manslaughter in the UK, a prosecution could theoretically be possible here too.

CPS guidelines on GNM:

a) The defendant owed a duty of care to the deceased, assessed by

  • Whether the damage was foreseeable;
  • Whether the deceased was in an appropriate position of proximity to the defendant;
  • Whether it was fair and just to impose liability on the defendant.
b) By a negligent act or omission the defendant was in breach of the duty which he owed to the deceased; c) The negligent act or omission was a cause of the death; and d) The negligence, which was a cause of the death, amounts to gross negligence and is therefore a crime.

I suppose where it might fail in the UK is whether a school mum had an automatic duty of care to school children she had probably never met (lack of proximity). But looking at the legal tests at least, I think it ticks all the other boxes, so not surprising really.

They could probably make a case for Joint Enterprise as well. Which would be much more serious.

CustardySergeant · 07/02/2024 11:45

She gave her mentally unstable 15 year old son a gun for Christmas! Of course she should be charged.

KarlieKM · 07/02/2024 11:43

Accountability.

She made poor choices in supporting her child. It seems she didn't follow up on any support offered. Denial perhaps.

More difficult here, when parents are desperate for help for their children and support is not available.

greenacrylicpaint · 07/02/2024 11:41

with the gun laws, gun acceptance in some us states giving your child a gun (for shooting on a range) is not really unusual.

OP posts:
KrisAkabusi · 07/02/2024 11:36

Lassiata · 07/02/2024 11:01

All these posts listing reasons she should be convicted, they're all reasons she's a bad parent. So charge her with negligence or something then. But don;'t you see the fundamental difference between that and convicting her of manslaughter for someone else's crime? Seems like a very worrying precedent to me.

No. She bought him a gun. That goes beyond negligence.

Sususudio · 07/02/2024 11:32

This is the NYT piece referred to by a PP.
https://www.nytimes.com/2024/02/01/opinion/mother-homicide-court-crumbley.html Very detailed.

The parents of victims are planning to sue the school, as well.

Rosscameasdoody · 07/02/2024 11:29

Lassiata · 07/02/2024 11:01

All these posts listing reasons she should be convicted, they're all reasons she's a bad parent. So charge her with negligence or something then. But don;'t you see the fundamental difference between that and convicting her of manslaughter for someone else's crime? Seems like a very worrying precedent to me.

Involuntary manslaughter was entirely appropriate. It’s not someone elses’ crime - she contributed to it by buying her son the gun used to kill people when she had known of, and refused to engage in getting him treatment for, mental health problems. She was also aware that there were red flags all over the place regarding his behaviour. Her son was also fifteen - a minor - and as a parent she is responsible for him. If it sets a precedent, then good - hopefully it will make people sit up and think.

Lifesd · 07/02/2024 11:28

I hope the father gets convicted too but this should be a wake up call to parents of kids like these who facilitate this behaviour and I have to say it but it is more prevalent with sons than daughters and I can’t help but think that is because of a prevalent “boys will be boys” attitude. I’m not saying this is a right but I’m willing to consider it as a step in the right direction if it makes parents think twice.

MissRheingold · 07/02/2024 11:27

I am very much pro guns but in this case it was clear the shooter was underage and troubled and the parents must take responsibility for buying him a gun that he could use unsupervised.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 07/02/2024 11:25

Lassiata · 07/02/2024 11:01

All these posts listing reasons she should be convicted, they're all reasons she's a bad parent. So charge her with negligence or something then. But don;'t you see the fundamental difference between that and convicting her of manslaughter for someone else's crime? Seems like a very worrying precedent to me.

She provided him with the gun.

Anyone who actively provides a person with mental health issues - adult or child - with a firearm is absolutely complicit in crimes they commit with that firearm.

If he’d managed to take a gun of hers then she’d have been neglectful. Actively arming him goes way beyond that.

doilooklikeicare · 07/02/2024 11:24

Rosscameasdoody · 07/02/2024 11:18

Just a thought. But in any eventuality, who in their right mind buys their fifteen year old son a gun ?

People that want to be charged with manslaughter!

Rosscameasdoody · 07/02/2024 11:18

Just a thought. But in any eventuality, who in their right mind buys their fifteen year old son a gun ?

doilooklikeicare · 07/02/2024 11:08

Lassiata · 07/02/2024 11:01

All these posts listing reasons she should be convicted, they're all reasons she's a bad parent. So charge her with negligence or something then. But don;'t you see the fundamental difference between that and convicting her of manslaughter for someone else's crime? Seems like a very worrying precedent to me.

She's a bad parent and she broke the law by providing a child with a gun.

Two separate issues, but he couldn't get the gun without her assistance.

She facilitated the murders.

Actions all have consequences.

BodyKeepingScore · 07/02/2024 11:06

I think she deserved the conviction. She bought him the gun. She knew of his plans, even going so far as to beg him not to do it. In what way is she not responsible @OP?

Lassiata · 07/02/2024 11:01

All these posts listing reasons she should be convicted, they're all reasons she's a bad parent. So charge her with negligence or something then. But don;'t you see the fundamental difference between that and convicting her of manslaughter for someone else's crime? Seems like a very worrying precedent to me.

SataraSahara · 07/02/2024 10:56

"Involuntary manslaughter is defined as an individual who has committed an unlawful killing without an intention to cause grievous bodily harm or kill the victim, causing the death by recklessness or gross negligence instead."

The parents of this 15 year old child reportedly:

  • neglected him from the age of 9, leaving him alone for hours while they went out drinking, tended to horses and engaged in extramarital affairs
  • were aware he was complaining of hallucinations
  • were recieving texts from him complaining of demons and ghosts
  • were aware that he was engaging in animal abuse and kept the head of a baby bird in a jar
  • refused to get their son mental health support that he was directly requesting
  • bought him a semi-automatic handgun
  • did not secure the gun or prevent him from taking him into school (minors cannot legally possess guns in Michigan outwith specific circumstances not relevent here)
  • cut short a meeting called by the school to discuss a picture their sun had drawn which has been described as follows: "A drawing of a semiautomatic handgun, pointing at the words, "The thoughts won't stop. Help me." In another section of the note was a drawing of a bullet, with the following words above that bullet: "Blood everywhere." Between the drawing of the gun and the bullet is a drawing of a person who appears to have been shot twice and bleeding. Below that figure is a drawing of a laughing emoji. Further down the drawing are the words, "My life is useless." And to the right of it are the words, "The world is dead.""
  • declined to take thier child home as suggested by the school

I don't believe parents should be held responsible for their children's actions in general but by ignoring obvious warning signs, refusing to provide their son with mental health support and providing him with free access to a deadly weapon it does seem that they have met the legal threshold required for an involuntary manslaughter conviction.

This isn't a clear case of blame the mother and let the father off the hook, either - the parents are being tried seperately by their own request.

The actions of both parents have been deeply irresponsible and selfish, with tragic consequences - 4 teenagers are dead and a 5th is now a murderer, serving a life sentence with no possibility of parole.

luckylavender · 07/02/2024 10:51

greenacrylicpaint · 07/02/2024 06:48

the snippets I have seen of her hearing in court were brutal.

no, I'm not surprised.

I hope she is able to appeal.

Have you read the whole case? She definitely could have done more.

ThreeLocusts · 07/02/2024 10:48

OP not sure if this has been mentioned but the New York Times published a damning piece on the trial recently. It's called What is this mother really guilty of?

Being a Luddite I can't attach it, but its main message is that yes the accusation (at the time, now conviction) stretches the definition of manslaughter to snapping point, and that this is the US grasping at straws, punishing the people they can get hold of while failing to solve the policy, social and cultural issue of fetishization of and too easy access to guns.

You are right it will be very interesting to see what sentence the father gets. If it's any more lenient, we'll have a new outcome of sexism on our hands.

Sususudio · 07/02/2024 10:48

Yep. She didnt read it, and just panicked at the thought of mums being held responsible.

OP, just don't buy your DS/DD a knife or a gun, take him/her to a shooting range for Mother's Day, and pay attention to what he/she and what school says.

BMW6 · 07/02/2024 10:46

It certainly looks like the OP didn't even read the news link she posted!
🙄

Sweetdreams98 · 07/02/2024 10:41

And they were running away. They bought burner phones, took cash out, thousands and thousands of dollars. They were caught less than 10 miles from Canadian border.
And all those saying , but the father? Again, nobody reads newspapers, his trial start next month.