Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the photos aren’t appropriate/too revealing for college work

314 replies

ThatsMyPenguin · 07/02/2024 04:02

DS is 18, he’s in his second year at college doing an Art and Design course, one of the units is all photography based. He’s loving it.
As part of the unit they need to create a mini portfolio of some portraits, landscapes and still life images. There seems to be a fair amount of creative control. He wants to be a photographer so this unit is important to him.

Last night he was working on the computer downstairs and I was looking at his images (he was editing them).
He has taken some pictures of an old school friend (currently 17) in lingerie. They are quite tastefully done (I won’t post them here as like I said they seem inappropriate to me).
Some have been done to look like she is laying on a bed I think and the placement of her hands make it seem quite sexual, another is from behind and the lingerie doesn’t provide much coverage of her behind so that seems quite inappropriate. He’s taken pictures of her which aren’t revealing too, focused more on her face etc. They are much better but he is insisting he will be fine to use a combination and it’s “art”. They are well done I just don’t think it’s appropriate to take pictures like that of a 17 year old!! His college tend to display some of the work too so I’d be surprised if they allow it, DS says they are fine with it but admits they don’t know she is 17.

AIBU to say pictures of this nature aren’t appropriate considering they are for uni and she’s not 18?

OP posts:
Yummymummy2020 · 07/02/2024 09:22

Oh op, this sounds so dodge and honestly if it was my daughter I would go nuts. I think even if the images are not intended to be sexual this could really blow up on your son. He might be trying to be arty but she is still 17 and nothing changes that. I wish you luck if her parents find out. And the thing is even if it is ok by the college that does not mean there will not be fall out!

Ruralrules · 07/02/2024 09:20

As a photographer myself, I'd recommend that your son gives the processed images to the girl and deletes all raw and edited images of her in underwear.
Email her stating he's done this and carry on with his work having learnt a lesson.
Best of luck to him although I'd be very careful of planning a full career in photography. He should Google photographers in his local area and he'll find they're coming out of the woodwork.

Laiste · 07/02/2024 09:19

I don't know how any 18 year old can be so oblivious about the laws about taking, making and sharing images.

It's been all over the bloody news for ages. Just last week i think BBC were were on about the problems of kids taking and sending pics of each other ect. and how it's ILLEGAL.

Where the hell was the college on this?

Even my NINE year old's year - yr 5 !!! - is being coached this week at school to understand.

And as for being ''different with his art'' .... blimey. Really? Pictures of half naked attractive women is ''different''? You didn't shoot that idea down?

I'm eyerolling so hard my eyeballs are in danger of falling out the back of my head OP.

5128gap · 07/02/2024 09:19

In addition to all the other comments, he's not being very creative is he? The content sounds very clichéd. There are many ways of the human form, in all its variations. Yet he's gone for the least original way of doing so.

Yep1234 · 07/02/2024 09:17

This is illegal. So no. Absolutely not.

SoupDragon · 07/02/2024 09:14

chantelion · 07/02/2024 09:11

And his own mother came on here trying to justify this, yet it didn't cross her own mind or scream out to her that this isn't appropriate??

did you even read the thread title or the first post?

she's not trying to justify it, she's explained what her son was thinking. She thinks it was inappropriate!

SoupDragon · 07/02/2024 09:12

LookItsMeAgain · 07/02/2024 09:05

I agree, he could have done a mix of photos with the girl and then similar posed photos with a bloke. Then there would be no sexual connotations being made. The male and female form.

Photos of a male the same age as the girl would still have been illegal if they hadn't turned 18. The sex of the model uses is irrelevant, it's their age and the style of the photos.

diddl · 07/02/2024 09:12

So does minimalist have to mean underwear or very little clothing?

chantelion · 07/02/2024 09:11

Nofilteritwonthelp · 07/02/2024 07:02

Ugh another creep who says something is "art". I would not be very impressed. Is it even legal? Why did he choose this as a subject matter?

And his own mother came on here trying to justify this, yet it didn't cross her own mind or scream out to her that this isn't appropriate??

ToRecordOnlyWater · 07/02/2024 09:11

I think it’s good your son has reevaluated this, I studied photography at college and one of my friends did a lovely series of self portraits of himself in underwear/states of undress with editing to make him into an almost fantasy-type character and our teacher had to rein him in a little as they were being exhibited publicly and even though they were of himself he hadn’t really factored in his age. All the photos we shot in the portrait modules tended to just be of each other, but we weren’t allowed to be excessively revealing. I kind of realised why when my friend and I were on duty looking after our exhibition (it was in an empty shop in a town centre) and a local well-known creep stopped by and asked where ‘the nudes of us’ were. So grim.

Ohnoooooooo · 07/02/2024 09:08

His tutor was in and out of the studio while he was taking photos of a 17 year old in her underwear?? I bet he was.
Seriously this gets worse - if your son wants to be a photographer understanding the law around this is pretty important. His personal opinion is not.

LolaSmiles · 07/02/2024 09:07

At least he's backtracking now OP and might be learning something from the experience.

If he's serious about pursuing photography, he'll probably gain more from his course by refining his photography technique and taking high quality photos than trying to take semi-nudes of peers and tangle himself up in word vomit about why his semi-nudes are different to the other semi-nudes of women.
It's a right of passage for teens to get into various isms and how they're misunderstood/doing something groundbreaking/not like the boring old farts who came before them, but part of growing up is going to involve realising that some of that is the foolishness of youth.

LookItsMeAgain · 07/02/2024 09:05

eggbot · 07/02/2024 06:59

Why didn't he ask his male friends his own age?

I agree, he could have done a mix of photos with the girl and then similar posed photos with a bloke. Then there would be no sexual connotations being made. The male and female form.

Coolblur · 07/02/2024 08:59

As he's clearly decided you know nothing and are 'close minded, when in fact you are wise to the world men and telling it like it is. He thinks he is cool, progressive and edgy, so could you present your argument against the idea as it's boring and predictable for a young man to present what he pretends are 'arty and tasteful' photos of a young woman? The college will have seen it all before, as we all have. Plus, does he really want to be considered a sleaze just as he's starting out? That might limit his career (and relationship) options somewhat.
Another angle is that he should care more about his friend, the girl in the shots (how did he convince her to do this?) Imagine she's interviewing for a job in the future, her prospective employer googles her and finds these images online. I highly doubt their first thought would be, 'these are beautifully shot, such good composition'.

BestBadger · 07/02/2024 08:59

If he's insistent on submitting these photographs, because "it's art" I'd caution him.

He'll have a hard time as a male photographer/artist justifying his use of her images.

I'd get him to do some reading around it or watch Berger's "Ways of Seeing" or even Mary Beard's "Shock of the Nude" Then see if he still thinks his work will stand up when it's assessed/critiqued. (It sounds to me like it won't)

I'm surprised this hasn't been addressed by his tutor already to be honest.

deydododatdodontdeydo · 07/02/2024 08:59

Nonplusultra · 07/02/2024 08:32

If he’s so confident about the pure nature of his art, he won’t have a problem showing them to her parents and getting their consent, right?

Sounds like her dad has seen them and said no.

Joleyne · 07/02/2024 08:56

I'm sure Op's son had no idea of breaking the law, or making sexualised images of this girl. He's young and he made a mistake.

However, the photos could so easily be used against him. Consent can be changed and the police would regard it as making and possessing concerning images of a minor. He really, really does not want to risk it.

JustGotToKeepOnKeepingOn · 07/02/2024 08:56

"DS likes to be different with his art which is why I’d imagine he’s done this!"

Sadly your DS doesn't sound very different to many males. I'd be really disappointed if any son of mine did this kind of photography. It's cheap and tacky and exploits young women. He shouldn't have taken the pictures and he definitely shouldn't be using them in his GCSE work or displaying them in school.

Has he not considered that his photography will possibly be frowned on by the examiners? Why have his tutors allowed those images to be taken? Surely he risks getting low marks for such unimaginative images?

borntobequiet · 07/02/2024 08:52

DS likes to be different with his art which is why I’d imagine he’s done this!

Nothing much “different” about photos of women in their underwear.

SmashedPrawnsInAMilkyBasket · 07/02/2024 08:47

ThatsMyPenguin · 07/02/2024 06:40

I’ve read that and I’m not actually sure he has. It doesn’t state that every image of someone under age in underwear is illegal and makes it clear than positioning etc. Is relevant. The positions aren’t explicitly sexual so could be debated what he has done is fine.
I’m not saying I agree with the images or that they are appropriate just that based on what the previous poster has posted it doesn’t appear to me that they are illegal.

I’m sure he will do well when debating that with the police.

User3353235 · 07/02/2024 08:43

EDIT: Didn't see the drip feed about him being gay. Changes the context of course but still not a good idea

This is an absolutely terrible idea. Coming from someone who comes from the fashion/design industry and has experience with those courses.

Lingerie photos have absolutely no educational value. The purpose of college is to teach students to broaden their horizons and learn creative, conceptual thinking. Copying what you see in fashion mags is the same as an illustration student copying comic art. It's derivative, reductive and serves no learning purpose.

I would also be very wary of this whole thing as red flag. Your son probably enjoys the thrill of being able to use his role as a fashion student to get female friends to pose for him. It's a slippery slope which starts off as edgy fun fuelled by hormones and could easily lead to dark places.

I have a friend from college who did exactly this. Taught himself photography and used his degree to wriggle into the fashion scene. He got loads of girls to partake in shoots, some of them genuine commissions from underwear companies. He'd carry a portfolio of these near-naked photos with him and proudly show them to everyone who'd listen, even on nights out. There was nothing officially illegal that ever happened, but this guy was a creepy, "red pill", MRA type of crypto bro. He was not actually very successful with girls but loved the power of making them pose in underwear as part of his job. It's obviously nothing comparable to you son but bear in mind the fashion industry is FULL of these sort of men. You need to very cautious which direction he goes into and give him clear boundaries.

Janetime · 07/02/2024 08:39

Hang on op; the fact your son is gay was a drip feed. You posted saying he had taken sexualised shots of a girl in her underwear, now attacking posters for thinking that’s creepy and saying we are all man haters.

your son is going to fail if he thinks minimalist in photography means hardly any clothes. He is clearly unable to see past this. Try to help him and stop attacking posters. Minimalist can be in a pair of simple black cigarette pants and black polo neck. It is about the shot. Not her body.

GanninHyem · 07/02/2024 08:37

ThatsMyPenguin · 07/02/2024 06:37

Just been having a chat about it with DS before he leaves this morning. He has agreed to check with his tutor but thinks that although she is in underwear the images aren't intended to be sexual at all. He says his goal was "simplistic, minimalistic and natural" and to show beauty without makeup/fashion wear. He claims his tutor was in and out of the studio while he was taking them so would have said something if it was an issue.
He then went on a whole rant about how it's not exactly progressive that a female can't be photographed in her underwear without it being classed as sexual, and the fact that I can only see the images that was is more reflective of me being close-minded than the nature of the images themself which aren't intended to be or in the style of a sexual lingerie shoot at all.
I've told him that while that may be his intention when taking the images, many will view a young, attractive girl in her underwear as being sexual. Whether that is right or not is irrelevant.
I've suggested he use the ones of her face which aren't revealing and then rethinks the others.
He has said he will go on what his tutor says.

Lol, he's a cocky little cunt isn't he?
Ask him how he would feel if he saw the exact same photographs, same poses, same lingerie but YOU were the subject. Or his granny. Would they be a scathing indictment of the fashion and make up industry or ergh mum I don't want to see these raunchy pics.

If his tutor really was in and out of the studio I would be raising this issue with the college myself, it contravenes all sorts of safeguarding.

CharlotteBog · 07/02/2024 08:36

I've only read OP's posts.

Law and all that aside, I'm mostly concerned that it just didn't occur to him that he needed to think very carefully about taking these photos.

Marblessolveeverything · 07/02/2024 08:35

The college won't be happy with the attention of exposing photos of a minor.

I am sure in the brief about consent they referenced age i.e. over 18 as well as capacity. Your son could be thrown off the course.