Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the photos aren’t appropriate/too revealing for college work

314 replies

ThatsMyPenguin · 07/02/2024 04:02

DS is 18, he’s in his second year at college doing an Art and Design course, one of the units is all photography based. He’s loving it.
As part of the unit they need to create a mini portfolio of some portraits, landscapes and still life images. There seems to be a fair amount of creative control. He wants to be a photographer so this unit is important to him.

Last night he was working on the computer downstairs and I was looking at his images (he was editing them).
He has taken some pictures of an old school friend (currently 17) in lingerie. They are quite tastefully done (I won’t post them here as like I said they seem inappropriate to me).
Some have been done to look like she is laying on a bed I think and the placement of her hands make it seem quite sexual, another is from behind and the lingerie doesn’t provide much coverage of her behind so that seems quite inappropriate. He’s taken pictures of her which aren’t revealing too, focused more on her face etc. They are much better but he is insisting he will be fine to use a combination and it’s “art”. They are well done I just don’t think it’s appropriate to take pictures like that of a 17 year old!! His college tend to display some of the work too so I’d be surprised if they allow it, DS says they are fine with it but admits they don’t know she is 17.

AIBU to say pictures of this nature aren’t appropriate considering they are for uni and she’s not 18?

OP posts:
Newchapterbeckons · 07/02/2024 10:05

CrabbiesGingerBeer · 07/02/2024 10:00

You can’t consent to sexual photos being taken of a child even if you are a parent or guardian (thank god - can you imagine if child porn was legal so long as the parents agreed!)

Edited

We prefer to call it child abuse images not ‘child porn’ which minimises.

CrabbiesGingerBeer · 07/02/2024 10:00

puncheur · 07/02/2024 09:56

Under 18s can't sign model release forms. It would have to be done by her parents or legal guardian.

You can’t consent to sexual photos being taken of a child even if you are a parent or guardian (thank god - can you imagine if child porn was legal so long as the parents agreed!)

tellmewhenthespaceshiplandscoz · 07/02/2024 09:59

Thing is OP he could have achieved those aims with his subject fully clothed, if he's as good as he says he is

tellmewhenthespaceshiplandscoz · 07/02/2024 09:57

Ponoka7 · 07/02/2024 06:31

It's also disappointing that both you and your DD think that her "being smart" means that she can consent.

Agree. When I look back at what I "consented " to I cringe. And in a few cases thank the stars things didn't turn out another way.

We think we know everything but actually even at 18 many of us know fuck all really especially of long term consequences of actions

puncheur · 07/02/2024 09:56

Under 18s can't sign model release forms. It would have to be done by her parents or legal guardian.

peacockeleven · 07/02/2024 09:56

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

.

ThatsMyPenguin · 07/02/2024 09:56

They are still friends, as he is with most people he went to school with. Yes they are still peers!

OP posts:
Nanny0gg · 07/02/2024 09:56

CarrotsAndCheese · 07/02/2024 09:47

I hope you're not suggesting that it would be ok for him to send her those images once she's turned 18, because they would still be images of a child. He needs to destroy them now and he can take new photos of an adult.

That's a valid point

Thank you

CrabbiesGingerBeer · 07/02/2024 09:56

Rosscameasdoody · 07/02/2024 09:52

The age of consent is 16 - this girl is 17, so I would imagine it’s OK if she has given consent. I wouldn’t have thought the more revealing ones would be displayed though - I would hope not.

And you’d be wrong. It’s not possible to consent to indecent photos until 18.

ThatsMyPenguin · 07/02/2024 09:55

Newchapterbeckons · 07/02/2024 09:53

It seems to me like he hasn’t been educated enough. How doesn’t he know this is illegal? My kids have had it drummed into them. I would be going over everything with him in your situation. Indecent photos can put you on the sex offenders register and charged accordingly. Consent is a massive one. A total evaluation.

Mostly he needs to understand to really respect and not objectify women regardless and especially because of his sexuality.

He does and always has known it’s illegal. It didn’t occur to him that his peer was underage in this context. He’s realised it now, they are getting deleted.

OP posts:
Newchapterbeckons · 07/02/2024 09:55

’for art’ is not an excuse either

sashh · 07/02/2024 09:55

ThatsMyPenguin · 07/02/2024 09:39

Can we remember that he and this girl are in the same school year, they are peers. Only this year has he had to try and remember that some of them are over 18 and others under. He’s not chosen her because she is under 17, it hasn’t even occurred to him that she was under 18 as they are peers!! Of course he doesn’t view her as a child when they have grown up together.

But she is not his peer, not any more. She is not in college with him.

tellmewhenthespaceshiplandscoz · 07/02/2024 09:55

Achillo · 07/02/2024 05:36

'DS likes to be different with his art which is why I’d imagine he’s done this!'

Definitely nothing different about men taking photos of women in lingerie.
If the assignment goes toward his grade he could ask a tutor if it is acceptable to submit semi-nudes of someone under 18.

This

How comfortable would you feel if this was a young man taking photos of your 17 year old daughter for his portfolio? I'm sure he doesn't mean it to be but there is something very grubby about this. And it's also highly unoriginal/creative

Newchapterbeckons · 07/02/2024 09:53

ThatsMyPenguin · 07/02/2024 09:46

Of course I have and I have messaged him not 10 minutes ago saying if he sends them to her I will have to tell the police.

He has said he will delete them on his lunch break, can’t right now as he’s in a different class.

Other than taking his word for that there is nothing else I can do.

It seems to me like he hasn’t been educated enough. How doesn’t he know this is illegal? My kids have had it drummed into them. I would be going over everything with him in your situation. Indecent photos can put you on the sex offenders register and charged accordingly. Consent is a massive one. A total evaluation.

Mostly he needs to understand to really respect and not objectify women regardless and especially because of his sexuality.

ThatsMyPenguin · 07/02/2024 09:53

Ponoka7 · 07/02/2024 09:49

@ThatsMyPenguin you spoke about him picking something else to wear, who supplied the original underwear? There was a man charged by the police who had sent underwear to and was giving compliments to a 15 year old, his reasoning was that it was increasing her confidence. You've just said that your son sending indecent images is OK because it might make her feel good about herself. You need to get your head around why these laws need to exsis and make sure your son isn't in danger of dating a minor. Doesn't he have any male friends that could do a shoot?

She did, he understands all the relevant laws, like I said it hasn't occurred to him that she was under 18, they were in the same school year.
If they wanted to date and have sex they could so I'm not sure how dating is relevant here?

He has told me he is going to delete them, not send them and not use them.

OP posts:
Yep1234 · 07/02/2024 09:53

She is a child until she is 18. It’s illegal.

Enuffs · 07/02/2024 09:53

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Enuffs · 07/02/2024 09:52

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Rosscameasdoody · 07/02/2024 09:52

MrsGarethSouthgate · 07/02/2024 04:20

She still counts as a juvenile so no, it’s definitely not okay.

The age of consent is 16 - this girl is 17, so I would imagine it’s OK if she has given consent. I wouldn’t have thought the more revealing ones would be displayed though - I would hope not.

urbanbuddha · 07/02/2024 09:51

Before he re-shoots next week ask him to really consider why it is so complicated to take “simple, minimalist” pictures of a 17 year old girl. If he could reflect that in his photographs that could be art.

If he hasn’t read it already he should have a look at ‘Photography: A Critical Introduction’ by Liz Wells.

Ponoka7 · 07/02/2024 09:49

@ThatsMyPenguin you spoke about him picking something else to wear, who supplied the original underwear? There was a man charged by the police who had sent underwear to and was giving compliments to a 15 year old, his reasoning was that it was increasing her confidence. You've just said that your son sending indecent images is OK because it might make her feel good about herself. You need to get your head around why these laws need to exsis and make sure your son isn't in danger of dating a minor. Doesn't he have any male friends that could do a shoot?

Enuffs · 07/02/2024 09:49

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

CarrotsAndCheese · 07/02/2024 09:47

Nanny0gg · 07/02/2024 09:43

Sending them is an absolute NO!!

Wait till she's 18 fgs

I hope you're not suggesting that it would be ok for him to send her those images once she's turned 18, because they would still be images of a child. He needs to destroy them now and he can take new photos of an adult.

ThatsMyPenguin · 07/02/2024 09:46

CarrotsAndCheese · 07/02/2024 09:44

Yes, but now he knows he's broken the law by making those images of a child, and he knows that he will commit another offence by distributing the images to her instead of deleting all copies of them. You have told him this, haven't you?

Of course I have and I have messaged him not 10 minutes ago saying if he sends them to her I will have to tell the police.

He has said he will delete them on his lunch break, can’t right now as he’s in a different class.

Other than taking his word for that there is nothing else I can do.

OP posts:
brogueish · 07/02/2024 09:46

ThatsMyPenguin · 07/02/2024 09:39

Can we remember that he and this girl are in the same school year, they are peers. Only this year has he had to try and remember that some of them are over 18 and others under. He’s not chosen her because she is under 17, it hasn’t even occurred to him that she was under 18 as they are peers!! Of course he doesn’t view her as a child when they have grown up together.

The thing is, that doesn't matter. If he were 15 and she were 17 it would be the same. She is under 18 and if he sends the pictures to her then he is distributing images of a child. Even if it is just to her, and even if she asked him to take the pictures and then to send them to her. The law's really clear on this. The college should be raising this as a safeguarding concern really.

Swipe left for the next trending thread