Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the photos aren’t appropriate/too revealing for college work

314 replies

ThatsMyPenguin · 07/02/2024 04:02

DS is 18, he’s in his second year at college doing an Art and Design course, one of the units is all photography based. He’s loving it.
As part of the unit they need to create a mini portfolio of some portraits, landscapes and still life images. There seems to be a fair amount of creative control. He wants to be a photographer so this unit is important to him.

Last night he was working on the computer downstairs and I was looking at his images (he was editing them).
He has taken some pictures of an old school friend (currently 17) in lingerie. They are quite tastefully done (I won’t post them here as like I said they seem inappropriate to me).
Some have been done to look like she is laying on a bed I think and the placement of her hands make it seem quite sexual, another is from behind and the lingerie doesn’t provide much coverage of her behind so that seems quite inappropriate. He’s taken pictures of her which aren’t revealing too, focused more on her face etc. They are much better but he is insisting he will be fine to use a combination and it’s “art”. They are well done I just don’t think it’s appropriate to take pictures like that of a 17 year old!! His college tend to display some of the work too so I’d be surprised if they allow it, DS says they are fine with it but admits they don’t know she is 17.

AIBU to say pictures of this nature aren’t appropriate considering they are for uni and she’s not 18?

OP posts:
LolaSmiles · 07/02/2024 16:42

It's grown women mocking a teenager trying to do well in his college course.
Obviously he hasn't got ground breaking ideas and is coming out with cliches. He's an 18 year old on an art course. He sounds like a reflective teen from what the op has said. Mocking him is uncalled for.
Nobody is mocking him for wanting to do well on his course.

There's a bit of eye rolling and mockery because when his mother has understandably challenged why he's got semi naked photos of a teenage child, instead of considering his mother might have a point he launched into word vomit about why actually what he's doing is unique, art and so much deeper than lingerie shoots of a teenager.

Thankfully he seems to be finally taking on board what's been raised, which is more than can be said for a lot of posters on this thread.

wubwubwub · 07/02/2024 16:13

Universalsnail · 07/02/2024 13:27

It's grown women mocking a teenager trying to do well in his college course. Obviously he hasn't got ground breaking ideas and is coming out with cliches. He's an 18 year old on an art course. He sounds like a reflective teen from what the op has said. Mocking him is uncalled for.

He's an adult on a creative art/photography course.

We're allowed to say he isn't being original in his ideas.

Delphiniumandlupins · 07/02/2024 16:10

Would probably be a good idea for your son to mention to his tutors at college that they all need to think carefully about (and check) the age of models, whether they can consent to being used as models, what images can be made and how used/distributed. It sounds as though he has simply not thought about her age but the college should reinforce the legislation with students.

Hope he enjoys his course, I'm sure his work will progress as he matures.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 07/02/2024 16:03

ThatsMyPenguin · 07/02/2024 14:07

The tutor was in and out helping with lighting/equipment etc. It was his job to be there and support DS (they had others in the other studios which is why it was in and out according to DS)
I'd be more annoyed if his tutor wasn't helping him! The tutor had no idea she was 17!

You need to report it including the tutor's involvement to the college.

It's notable that he's only said DELETE THEM NOW once he's realised there's a Mum sniffing around the legalities.

I wouldn't be surprised if he denies ever knowing what the content of the shoot was or claiming your son said she was 18 to try and get out of the massive safeguarding hole he's created with his students.

DoggUncertainty · 07/02/2024 15:54

Universalsnail · 07/02/2024 12:56

I agree with you.

The idea that a 17 year old can consent to penetrative sex with a 40 year old but is the victim of child on child child abuse if she lets an 18 year old long term friend take photos of her in underwear is pretty rediculous.

I appreciate the the law about images is to protect young people from exploitation, but there is clearly considerable nuance here and the law needs revising to consider that nuance.

Yes exactly, some revision needed and nuance to be looked at with each case.

I'm even more extreme in some of my views about this, for example I don’t think 18 year olds should be able to consent to partake in hardcore porn, I feel it should be as old as possible, to give the person’s brain time to fully develop, possibly 25.

I guess though then you’d have to look at all the other things 16+ year olds can do such as getting married (with permission), driving, and other things that can have consequences, and ask if they’re old enough for them too?

It’s an interesting moral topic really, how old should young people be to make certain choices, and have the current laws got it right?

Notamum12345577 · 07/02/2024 15:14

sashh · 07/02/2024 08:35

It wasn't that long ago you could talk on your phone while driving, smoke in pubs, not wear a seatbelt.

Laws change.

Do an image search, you will not find those pictures anywhere now.

I don’t think I will be doing an image search for topless photos of a 17 year old thanks! 😮

MeridianB · 07/02/2024 15:08

Motnight · 07/02/2024 06:18

Nah. Your ds taking photos of undressed/ scantily dressed young women is the opposite of being different with his art.

This. Sorry but as subject matter it doesn't sound at all original (or appropriate). And as others have said, consent issues are crucial. Safer all round for him to use some other pictures.

Notamum12345577 · 07/02/2024 15:03

CrabbiesGingerBeer · 07/02/2024 09:29

Well, if you don’t mind him risking ending up on the sex offenders register and the consequences that will have on his life….

Just to note, child sex offences on his record means he can never do most careers involving children and many careers that don’t. They will always come up on a enhanced background check.

Edited to say: she doesn’t have to make the complaint. Anyone who knows about the pictures can do it and her consent is irrelevant. In this case, I can see her parents going straight to the police. I would, particularly with the tutor involvement - two adults, one in a position of authority using college resources to take lingerie shots of my underage daughter (which is how it comes across with the tutor actually coming in during the session)? I’d be at the police station asap.

Edited

An 18 year old taking photos of a 17 year old in her underwear with her consent is not going to end up on the sex offenders register

BobbyBiscuits · 07/02/2024 15:01

To study art you need to be able to draw/capture images of the body. Fine art students would always have extensive life drawing in the curriculum I'd imagine. I used to be a life art model when I was 18 (fully nude) and the students were often of a similar age. The human body is depicted in art and he is making art. She isn't even nude (but many pictures could/ might be) so it's fine, honestly. As long as it looks good as a piece of art and the model is consenting.

Notamum12345577 · 07/02/2024 14:58

CrabbiesGingerBeer · 07/02/2024 09:26

I’d be reporting them all to the police. Let them all try and talk themselves out of child porn (filmed on college grounds!) charges.

Photos in her underwear, yes not appropriate for college but not exactly child porn!
Police won’t be interested.

toomuchfaff · 07/02/2024 14:57

wasn't there a big controversy recently about famouns pictures of a woman back in the 60s and she fought for ownership of them in a famous portfolio as she was 17 and it was argued that as she was underage, she couldn't give consent.

NaughtybutNice77 · 07/02/2024 14:54

BusyMummy001 · 07/02/2024 13:47

Not if exhibiting them puts him at risk of being arrested?

And sadly, if you get a tutor or a parent who wants to take issue (after all, if they are displayed her parents may become aware of them) and the police officer on duty who takes the law on this issue very seriously, then he could be arrested. For what? Some photos they simply took for an art project which can be reshot with clothes on…

I’d like to think CPS would be sensible, but I personally know of one 16yo boy who got a record after receiving unsolicited nude selfies from his 15yo girlfriend - and spoke to his parents about it as he was worried… who spoke to hers and the girls’ parents called the police.

He needs to delete them. It’s not worth the risk.

You've missed my point. I'm saying it's his decision not his mum's. It's not like she has information or knowledge he doesn't. She's told her son to be careful and advised against it. That's it. Her input is done ....unless of course she comes up with further information which she can share with him.
I seriously doubt the college will allow him to break any laws with his exhibit.

Tinseltiss · 07/02/2024 14:45

I want to add I don’t think your son has done anything illegal but to shre with the collage and them display it would be. I hope you can get him to understand this

Tinseltiss · 07/02/2024 14:44

The age of consent is 16 the age of porn is 18 this is illegal even if art it won’t be allowdd

Iusedtoliveinsanfrancisco · 07/02/2024 14:30

I’ve posted above and yes the tutor definitely has responsibility to check ages etc.

Southdweller · 07/02/2024 14:25

ThatsMyPenguin · 07/02/2024 14:07

The tutor was in and out helping with lighting/equipment etc. It was his job to be there and support DS (they had others in the other studios which is why it was in and out according to DS)
I'd be more annoyed if his tutor wasn't helping him! The tutor had no idea she was 17!

So to quote you "It was his job to be there and support DS" "I'd be more annoyed if his tutor wasn't helping him! The tutor had no idea she was 17!"

Your DS tutor is assisting his students taking potentially illegal photos of underage girls, as he is not checking their ages. News flash its his studio so he has responsibility to ensure this does not happen, he sounds like he should not hold this position. How many more times has this happened?

If you think you have no moral obligation to raise these concerns with the collage then I despair. Just tell us which college and we will do it for you, unless you want to cover it up to protect your DS obviously.

ThatsMyPenguin · 07/02/2024 14:07

Paradiddlediddle · 07/02/2024 13:57

Tutor sounds grim as well “in and out of of the studio whilst he was taking them”. Oooh a very very young woman/girl is having nearly nude lingerie pics taken, think I’ll pop and in and out for a good old shufty.
This whole thing just makes for horrible reading. I’m sure your son hasn’t been malicious or creepy deliberately @ThatsMyPenguin but it’s (exploitation/sexualisation/fetishisation/degradation of women) just absolutely soaked into everything in society isn’t it?
Thank goodness you and her dad noticed what was going on and put a stop to it.

The tutor was in and out helping with lighting/equipment etc. It was his job to be there and support DS (they had others in the other studios which is why it was in and out according to DS)
I'd be more annoyed if his tutor wasn't helping him! The tutor had no idea she was 17!

OP posts:
Paradiddlediddle · 07/02/2024 13:57

Tutor sounds grim as well “in and out of of the studio whilst he was taking them”. Oooh a very very young woman/girl is having nearly nude lingerie pics taken, think I’ll pop and in and out for a good old shufty.
This whole thing just makes for horrible reading. I’m sure your son hasn’t been malicious or creepy deliberately @ThatsMyPenguin but it’s (exploitation/sexualisation/fetishisation/degradation of women) just absolutely soaked into everything in society isn’t it?
Thank goodness you and her dad noticed what was going on and put a stop to it.

BusyMummy001 · 07/02/2024 13:47

NaughtybutNice77 · 07/02/2024 13:39

In the nicest possible way I don't really think it's your concern unless of course you think there might be some major Safeguarding issues.
It's his course. Surely what he exhibits is between him and the institution. He's already said he disagrees with you. Now what?

If it's any consolation I would think it's likely he's studied modules around law, consent, internal property, decency etc.

Not if exhibiting them puts him at risk of being arrested?

And sadly, if you get a tutor or a parent who wants to take issue (after all, if they are displayed her parents may become aware of them) and the police officer on duty who takes the law on this issue very seriously, then he could be arrested. For what? Some photos they simply took for an art project which can be reshot with clothes on…

I’d like to think CPS would be sensible, but I personally know of one 16yo boy who got a record after receiving unsolicited nude selfies from his 15yo girlfriend - and spoke to his parents about it as he was worried… who spoke to hers and the girls’ parents called the police.

He needs to delete them. It’s not worth the risk.

PinkMendinilla · 07/02/2024 13:46

Quite honestly, I did a level arts and a goodly number including myself included some form of sexual expression such as lingerie photography of one another thinking we were original and subversive. We then justified and explained it with long frilly prose and references. It's just that age. A lot of art pertains to sex and the human body anyway. It isn't inappropriate in my experience, just quite predictable!

Ask does he have good reasoning behind this theme or is it just going to look gratuitous?

I'm not sure if it would be viewed the same these days, sex politics have changed a lot and obviously we can't see the content (youre right not to share it). I don't know about model release forms being needed for coursework, we didn't do this but could be way out of date here.

I'd ask his friend to think through making these images public very carefully if you're in touch with her directly. People will be able to take photos at the end of year exhibition etc.

ThatsMyPenguin · 07/02/2024 13:45

BusyMummy001 · 07/02/2024 13:38

@diddl just said this to my 18yo who is doing A Level art and a foundation diploma, both requiring portfolios. I said that, surely, they would give out basic guidance on what is legally not considered ethical as part of the course? If he were doing a food tech or paramedic BTEC, the legal responsibilities around it would be highlighted, wouldn’t they?

However her reply was: but doing revealing pictures of a girl you rather fancy is just a bit weird mum - why would anyone do that and think it was suitable for the portfolio? That’s just going to make the tutors feel super uncomfortable. Ick. 🤷🏻‍♀️

One. Who said he fancied her?
Two. He is on a course with adults, it isn't sixth form, there is definitely a more mature feel to the work submitted by his cohort over all

OP posts:
NaughtybutNice77 · 07/02/2024 13:39

In the nicest possible way I don't really think it's your concern unless of course you think there might be some major Safeguarding issues.
It's his course. Surely what he exhibits is between him and the institution. He's already said he disagrees with you. Now what?

If it's any consolation I would think it's likely he's studied modules around law, consent, internal property, decency etc.

BusyMummy001 · 07/02/2024 13:38

@diddl just said this to my 18yo who is doing A Level art and a foundation diploma, both requiring portfolios. I said that, surely, they would give out basic guidance on what is legally not considered ethical as part of the course? If he were doing a food tech or paramedic BTEC, the legal responsibilities around it would be highlighted, wouldn’t they?

However her reply was: but doing revealing pictures of a girl you rather fancy is just a bit weird mum - why would anyone do that and think it was suitable for the portfolio? That’s just going to make the tutors feel super uncomfortable. Ick. 🤷🏻‍♀️

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 07/02/2024 13:33

No, not appropriate - for the girl’s age and in that further education context.

TBH I’m surprised you need to ask.

diddl · 07/02/2024 13:31

You'd think that all this would be some of the first things covered.

Especially if he still thinks it would be ok to send them to her even after the tutor said to delete.