Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the photos aren’t appropriate/too revealing for college work

314 replies

ThatsMyPenguin · 07/02/2024 04:02

DS is 18, he’s in his second year at college doing an Art and Design course, one of the units is all photography based. He’s loving it.
As part of the unit they need to create a mini portfolio of some portraits, landscapes and still life images. There seems to be a fair amount of creative control. He wants to be a photographer so this unit is important to him.

Last night he was working on the computer downstairs and I was looking at his images (he was editing them).
He has taken some pictures of an old school friend (currently 17) in lingerie. They are quite tastefully done (I won’t post them here as like I said they seem inappropriate to me).
Some have been done to look like she is laying on a bed I think and the placement of her hands make it seem quite sexual, another is from behind and the lingerie doesn’t provide much coverage of her behind so that seems quite inappropriate. He’s taken pictures of her which aren’t revealing too, focused more on her face etc. They are much better but he is insisting he will be fine to use a combination and it’s “art”. They are well done I just don’t think it’s appropriate to take pictures like that of a 17 year old!! His college tend to display some of the work too so I’d be surprised if they allow it, DS says they are fine with it but admits they don’t know she is 17.

AIBU to say pictures of this nature aren’t appropriate considering they are for uni and she’s not 18?

OP posts:
determinedtomakethiswork · 07/02/2024 06:56

It's actually making me really uneasy that your son is taking photos of a girl like that and can't see your point of view regarding exhibiting them.

KennedyFeets · 07/02/2024 06:55

I think it's inappropriate and completely lacks imagination as an assignment project. Can't he take a nice photo of leaves or squirrels, why is it always naked attractive yoing girls and women 🙄 it's using sex and female body to get marks and recognition.

ThatsMyPenguin · 07/02/2024 06:52

Divebar2021 · 07/02/2024 06:46

Well you’ve seen the photos OP are they simple, minimalist and natural? Is the lingerie sporty and covering or is it lacy and revealing? Are any of the poses sexual to you? ( you said something about hands) because there seems to be a disconnect between his apparent aims and the resulting photos. By all means be guided by the tutor but the tutor needs to know she’s 17.

I can see why he thinks that it's minimalistic. The bra is a plain black bra that comes a bit lower onto the ribs like a corset almost, but obviously it's intended to be a push up bra I imagine as cleavage is quite obviously. The bottoms are the hipster style, so her bum is quite on show in one of the images.
In the one made to look like she is laid on a bed her hand is on her lower stomach which I thought could be construed as sexual.

OP posts:
viridiano · 07/02/2024 06:50

OP, I doubt that there is any negative intention on the part of your DS, so don't be harsh on him. He has fully explained his intention with the photos, and part of art is exploring the human form. Artists have done this since time immemorial, it's not sexual.

However, in the context of being in school, and the girl being under 18, of course, it's right to question it and ensure she is protected from any unwanted consequences of this.

You are both right. He has produced a thoughtful piece of work and had they been a year or two older, it would have been fine.

But I do think it is right to let the tutor know that this girl is under 18.

But also, please don't invalidate the work your son has done or act like he has done something wrong - he's put a lot of work into his project - he just hasn't really thought about this, because he's 18 - it's just a mistake and a lack of understanding on his part.

urbanbuddha · 07/02/2024 06:47

The model release form is necessary for any image of a child btw. Child models need their parents’ permission to take part in any kind of modelling.

Divebar2021 · 07/02/2024 06:46

Well you’ve seen the photos OP are they simple, minimalist and natural? Is the lingerie sporty and covering or is it lacy and revealing? Are any of the poses sexual to you? ( you said something about hands) because there seems to be a disconnect between his apparent aims and the resulting photos. By all means be guided by the tutor but the tutor needs to know she’s 17.

ThatsMyPenguin · 07/02/2024 06:45

LolaSmiles · 07/02/2024 06:43

His tutor is unlikely to know which students are over 18 or under 18.
As a member of staff I'd not want to see any nude or semi-nude image of a child. He needs to be very clear that he's planning on submitting semi-nude photos of a child for his project.

The rest of his rant sounds like a teenager who thinks they're offering a new an progressive way of thinking that's more forward-thinking outlook but really it's just the same old male human taking photos of half naked female.

You're right I highly doubt the tutor knows her age, she doesn't go to that college (she's at the same sixth form as my DD, DS goes to college) so the tutor won't even know who she is!

OP posts:
LolaSmiles · 07/02/2024 06:43

His tutor is unlikely to know which students are over 18 or under 18.
As a member of staff I'd not want to see any nude or semi-nude image of a child. He needs to be very clear that he's planning on submitting semi-nude photos of a child for his project.

The rest of his rant sounds like a teenager who thinks they're offering a new an progressive way of thinking that's more forward-thinking outlook but really it's just the same old male human taking photos of half naked female.

Cloudysky81 · 07/02/2024 06:42

I can imagine the safeguarding lead at their school will be receiving a few emails this morning.
This all seems like an awful idea, that will end badly for everyone concerned.

urbanbuddha · 07/02/2024 06:42

Does the tutor realise she is under18? Your DS will have to make that clear, as atm there is no valid model release form.

ThatsMyPenguin · 07/02/2024 06:40

eggbot · 07/02/2024 06:36

There you go OP. He's broken the law. Now what are you going to do about it.

I’ve read that and I’m not actually sure he has. It doesn’t state that every image of someone under age in underwear is illegal and makes it clear than positioning etc. Is relevant. The positions aren’t explicitly sexual so could be debated what he has done is fine.
I’m not saying I agree with the images or that they are appropriate just that based on what the previous poster has posted it doesn’t appear to me that they are illegal.

OP posts:
ThatsMyPenguin · 07/02/2024 06:37

Just been having a chat about it with DS before he leaves this morning. He has agreed to check with his tutor but thinks that although she is in underwear the images aren't intended to be sexual at all. He says his goal was "simplistic, minimalistic and natural" and to show beauty without makeup/fashion wear. He claims his tutor was in and out of the studio while he was taking them so would have said something if it was an issue.
He then went on a whole rant about how it's not exactly progressive that a female can't be photographed in her underwear without it being classed as sexual, and the fact that I can only see the images that was is more reflective of me being close-minded than the nature of the images themself which aren't intended to be or in the style of a sexual lingerie shoot at all.
I've told him that while that may be his intention when taking the images, many will view a young, attractive girl in her underwear as being sexual. Whether that is right or not is irrelevant.
I've suggested he use the ones of her face which aren't revealing and then rethinks the others.
He has said he will go on what his tutor says.

OP posts:
eggbot · 07/02/2024 06:36

Ponoka7 · 07/02/2024 06:30

@ThatsMyPenguin he is breaking the law and under safeguarding the collage will have to report it. It needs to ask as though he hasn't done it yet so they can tell him no. He needs to understand the law on this. Taken from a safeguarding website.

" In the UK the age of consent for sexual intercourse is 16. However, it is an offence to make, distribute, possess or show any indecent images of anyone aged under 18, even if the content was created with the consent of that young person. The law is contained in Section 1 Protection of Children Act 1978. ‘Indecent’ is not defined in legislation. When cases are prosecuted, the question of whether any photograph of a child is indecent is for a jury, magistrate or district judge to decide.
Indecent imagery does not always mean nudity; however, images are likely to be defined as such if they meet one or more of the following criteria:

  • nude or semi-nude sexual posing (e.g. displaying genitals and/or breasts or overtly sexual images of young people in their underwear)
  • someone nude or semi-nude touching themselves in a sexual way
  • any sexual activity involving a child
  • someone hurting someone else sexually
  • sexual activity that includes animals
The non-consensual sharing of private sexual images or videos with the intent to cause distress is also illegal. The relevant legislation is contained in section 33 of the Criminal Justice and Courts Act 2015. Terms such as ‘revenge porn’ and ‘upskirting’ are also used to refer to specific incidents of nudes and semi-nudes being shared. However, these terms are more often used in the context of adult-to-adult non-consensual image sharing offences outlined in s.33-35 of the Criminal Justice and Courts Act 2015, Voyeurism (Offences) Act 2019 and s.67A of the Sexual Offences Act 2003."

There you go OP. He's broken the law. Now what are you going to do about it.

Amba1998 · 07/02/2024 06:34

It’s a no from me

and if my 17 year old daughter consented but I hadn’t as her parent, you better believe I’d be coming banging your door down. Think of her family.

urbanbuddha · 07/02/2024 06:32

If she’s under 18 the model release form must be signed by her parents or legal guardian. So he’ll have to ask her dad.
How does he feel about that? Will it help him to understand it’s not “art”, just exploitation.

Ponoka7 · 07/02/2024 06:31

It's also disappointing that both you and your DD think that her "being smart" means that she can consent.

Ponoka7 · 07/02/2024 06:30

@ThatsMyPenguin he is breaking the law and under safeguarding the collage will have to report it. It needs to ask as though he hasn't done it yet so they can tell him no. He needs to understand the law on this. Taken from a safeguarding website.

" In the UK the age of consent for sexual intercourse is 16. However, it is an offence to make, distribute, possess or show any indecent images of anyone aged under 18, even if the content was created with the consent of that young person. The law is contained in Section 1 Protection of Children Act 1978. ‘Indecent’ is not defined in legislation. When cases are prosecuted, the question of whether any photograph of a child is indecent is for a jury, magistrate or district judge to decide.
Indecent imagery does not always mean nudity; however, images are likely to be defined as such if they meet one or more of the following criteria:

  • nude or semi-nude sexual posing (e.g. displaying genitals and/or breasts or overtly sexual images of young people in their underwear)
  • someone nude or semi-nude touching themselves in a sexual way
  • any sexual activity involving a child
  • someone hurting someone else sexually
  • sexual activity that includes animals
The non-consensual sharing of private sexual images or videos with the intent to cause distress is also illegal. The relevant legislation is contained in section 33 of the Criminal Justice and Courts Act 2015. Terms such as ‘revenge porn’ and ‘upskirting’ are also used to refer to specific incidents of nudes and semi-nudes being shared. However, these terms are more often used in the context of adult-to-adult non-consensual image sharing offences outlined in s.33-35 of the Criminal Justice and Courts Act 2015, Voyeurism (Offences) Act 2019 and s.67A of the Sexual Offences Act 2003."

Protection of Children Act 1978

An Act to prevent the exploitation of children by making indecent photographs of them; and to penalise the distribution, showing and advertisement of such indecent photographs.

http://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1978/37

LolaSmiles · 07/02/2024 06:29

Definitely nothing different about men taking photos of women in lingerie.
If the assignment goes toward his grade he could ask a tutor if it is acceptable to submit semi-nudes of someone under 18.
Agree with this and I'd find it hard to believe that anyone in education would say that it's a good idea to have semi-nude photographs of a minor.

Keeping Children Safe in Education talks about:
"consensual and non-consensual sharing of nude and semi-nude images and/or videos (also known as sexting or youth produced sexual imagery)" as a safeguarding concern.

There is a note about consensual nude and semi nude images sharing between older children is still illegal, even if it is not abusive.

peacockeleven · 07/02/2024 06:23

This seems like a bad idea. Just googling 'can an adult take a photo of a 17 year old in underwear' shows these two pieces of info among many, many websites saying don't do it, including photographers forums.

However, it is an offence to make, distribute, possess or show any indecent images of anyone aged under 18, even if the content was created with the consent of that young person. The law is contained in Section 1 Protection of Children Act 1978.

WHAT COUNTS AS AN INDECENT IMAGE OF A CHILD?
An indecent image of a child is a photograph, pseudo-photograph, drawing or other depiction of a child under the age of 18 that displays content of a sexual nature. The definition of what counts as ‘sexual’ is not set out in the law, however the courts have taken it to mean:
• Sexual pictures including ones where the subject is wearing underwear

PBandJ111 · 07/02/2024 06:22

She’s under 18 so that’s a firm no. What was you ds thinking.

eggbot · 07/02/2024 06:20

helpnohelpno · 07/02/2024 04:25

I would tell him given her age he needs to a, check with college they are appropriate and b, if he does intend to use them have return permission from her and ideally her parents. Particularly if they are going to be on display at all.

This. Personally I'd be asking her to sign a form like they do with models.

Motnight · 07/02/2024 06:18

ThatsMyPenguin · 07/02/2024 04:38

In the images where her body can be seen, you can’t really see her face, or just an obscured side profile, but there are others which are more focused on her face.
She definitely could model if that’s what she wanted, has the looks for it! But I don’t know if she actually wants to or if for her it was just a bit of fun. My DD is the year below her at the same school and the girl has a reputation for being smart and sensible so I’d guess she’s thought it through but at 17 I’m not sure she’d have the foresight to appreciate the risks.

DS likes to be different with his art which is why I’d imagine he’s done this!

Nah. Your ds taking photos of undressed/ scantily dressed young women is the opposite of being different with his art.

CaramelCarmen · 07/02/2024 06:18

This is definitely something that he should not be allowed to do. Whether she has "consented" or not, she's 17 and has her family and professional life ahead of her. At that age she doesn't have the capacity to assess the future implications of some 18 year old taking near naked shots and sharing them.
Tell him to delete them and inform the college, they need to implement appropriate boundaries.
Also, as PP mentioned, there's nothing "different " about a male exploiting a female.

Achillo · 07/02/2024 05:36

'DS likes to be different with his art which is why I’d imagine he’s done this!'

Definitely nothing different about men taking photos of women in lingerie.
If the assignment goes toward his grade he could ask a tutor if it is acceptable to submit semi-nudes of someone under 18.

Swipe left for the next trending thread