Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the photos aren’t appropriate/too revealing for college work

314 replies

ThatsMyPenguin · 07/02/2024 04:02

DS is 18, he’s in his second year at college doing an Art and Design course, one of the units is all photography based. He’s loving it.
As part of the unit they need to create a mini portfolio of some portraits, landscapes and still life images. There seems to be a fair amount of creative control. He wants to be a photographer so this unit is important to him.

Last night he was working on the computer downstairs and I was looking at his images (he was editing them).
He has taken some pictures of an old school friend (currently 17) in lingerie. They are quite tastefully done (I won’t post them here as like I said they seem inappropriate to me).
Some have been done to look like she is laying on a bed I think and the placement of her hands make it seem quite sexual, another is from behind and the lingerie doesn’t provide much coverage of her behind so that seems quite inappropriate. He’s taken pictures of her which aren’t revealing too, focused more on her face etc. They are much better but he is insisting he will be fine to use a combination and it’s “art”. They are well done I just don’t think it’s appropriate to take pictures like that of a 17 year old!! His college tend to display some of the work too so I’d be surprised if they allow it, DS says they are fine with it but admits they don’t know she is 17.

AIBU to say pictures of this nature aren’t appropriate considering they are for uni and she’s not 18?

OP posts:
MorningSunshineSparkles · 07/02/2024 07:14

From what you’ve described it sounds like soft porn not art. Your DS better be careful he doesn’t get in an awful lot of trouble due to her age. And tell him to aim higher than a page 3 photographer

WhyIOughtTo · 07/02/2024 07:14

As a member of staff I'd not want to see any nude or semi-nude image of a child.

Me neither. What a position to put the teacher in.

My dd posed for some photographs for her friends A level photography coursework and three years later when the next dd and I were looking round the college some of the photos of DD1 were on the tables. A3 size.

lambballs · 07/02/2024 07:14

I work for an exam board. The college may very well decide it's ok - we will not. It will be flagged to our safeguarding team who will report back to the school, potentially to the police, and will not award his grade.

We have all sorts come through that teacher sign off on, especially in EPQ. Knives are made, experiments done on small children and babies. Photos of a barely dressed teenager is definitely in the same category.

I can't see the images, but it sounds like he has other options to submit. I'd encourage him to do so.

urbanbuddha · 07/02/2024 07:13

We can’t put aside the legality of it. If he wants be a professional photographer he has to attend to all the troublesome boring bits. Like consent forms. He should also try and understand the reasons behind them.

OhBeAFineGuyKissMe · 07/02/2024 07:12

urbanbuddha · 07/02/2024 06:32

If she’s under 18 the model release form must be signed by her parents or legal guardian. So he’ll have to ask her dad.
How does he feel about that? Will it help him to understand it’s not “art”, just exploitation.

Edited

Ask her dad!!! Of course only a male relatives opinion counts.

seafronty · 07/02/2024 07:12

Go phone the girls Mum and Dad and see how happy they are about it. They'll be over the moon I guess.

NashvilleQueen · 07/02/2024 07:11

I think it's inappropriate and completely lacks imagination as an assignment project. Can't he take a nice photo of leaves or squirrels, why is it always naked attractive yoing girls and women 🙄 it's using sex and female body to get marks and recognition.

It's this for me. His tutor will probably roll his eyes at the fact that an 18 yr old given a camera defaults to taking pictures of a woman in her underwear and calling it art. it's a bit cringe and he may get the piss taken out of him for it. And that's aside from the valid safeguarding points others have made.

Mumof2teens79 · 07/02/2024 07:09

Putting the legality of her age aside for a moment.
There is a big difference between him Putting them in a college portfolio for marking by a select group of examiners, and him displaying or publishing them publicly.
Just because the college displaying some artwork doesn't mean they have to either display this OR not allow it at all. It can just go in his portfolio.

ThatsMyPenguin · 07/02/2024 07:05

Ok I think we are all being a bit harsh calling him creepy. I genuinely believe he didn't intend for them to be sexual, he is gay so not naturally viewing her in a sexual way. I think he was actually trying to do what he has said and perhaps not thought it through fully.

OP posts:
Janetime · 07/02/2024 07:05

Sorry op, this is far from good, and he’s not different with his art, he’s just a common or garden lad whose got excited about a girl in her undies, and used his art course as a way to let him photograph her and see her in her undies. Prob going to flunk it.

onwardsup4 · 07/02/2024 07:04

Achillo · 07/02/2024 05:36

'DS likes to be different with his art which is why I’d imagine he’s done this!'

Definitely nothing different about men taking photos of women in lingerie.
If the assignment goes toward his grade he could ask a tutor if it is acceptable to submit semi-nudes of someone under 18.

This ! How is it different or artistic ?

SquishyGloopyBum · 07/02/2024 07:02

Minimalistic and natural beauty. Ha! Did he take any of males then?

It's what all male photographers say in the name of 'art' - progressive indeed....... Hmm

viridiano · 07/02/2024 07:02

eggbot · 07/02/2024 07:00

Other than the "greasy" description I think you're right. It's not groundbreaking in anyway.

It's not groundbreaking, but exploring the human form is a huge part of art generally. I expect that's all he felt he was doing, and he has given a good explanation of his intention.

I don't think there was any sleazy or sexual intention, and he thinks he is being tasteful, he's simply naive. He's 18 so his ideas aren't likely to be groundbreaking and unique, are they?

urbanbuddha · 07/02/2024 07:02

I think your DS is in for a life lesson here.
Come the group tutorial - the “crit” when all students view and discuss one another’s work - female students are likely to hand him his arse on a plate.
The more immediate concern is that her parents have not signed the release form and until they do these photos should not be displayed, not even to the student group.

Nofilteritwonthelp · 07/02/2024 07:02

Ugh another creep who says something is "art". I would not be very impressed. Is it even legal? Why did he choose this as a subject matter?

Nofilteritwonthelp · 07/02/2024 07:02

Ugh another creep who says something is "art". I would not be very impressed. Is it even legal? Why did he choose this as a subject matter?

GreyWednesday · 07/02/2024 07:00

ThatsMyPenguin · 07/02/2024 06:52

I can see why he thinks that it's minimalistic. The bra is a plain black bra that comes a bit lower onto the ribs like a corset almost, but obviously it's intended to be a push up bra I imagine as cleavage is quite obviously. The bottoms are the hipster style, so her bum is quite on show in one of the images.
In the one made to look like she is laid on a bed her hand is on her lower stomach which I thought could be construed as sexual.

To be honest, she could easily have a smaller/more revealing bikini and have worn it on a family holiday with pictures all over social media. I don’t think it’s how much of her is visible that’s the issue.

The college need to know she’s under 18. If that’s acceptable to them then it’s up to the girl whether the pictures are used, so long as she fully understands what that means.

eggbot · 07/02/2024 07:00

KennedyFeets · 07/02/2024 06:58

Very cliche of greasy male photographer snapping pics of young women and girls ibn skimpy clothings as 'art'. Nothing interesting or new, just sleazy, exploitative and salacious. Gross.

Other than the "greasy" description I think you're right. It's not groundbreaking in anyway.

NotMyDayJob · 07/02/2024 06:59

ThatsMyPenguin · 07/02/2024 06:52

I can see why he thinks that it's minimalistic. The bra is a plain black bra that comes a bit lower onto the ribs like a corset almost, but obviously it's intended to be a push up bra I imagine as cleavage is quite obviously. The bottoms are the hipster style, so her bum is quite on show in one of the images.
In the one made to look like she is laid on a bed her hand is on her lower stomach which I thought could be construed as sexual.

If he honestly can't see that is sexual and would be perceived as sexual and you think only 'could be' that is extremely concerning. Maybe you should get his dad to chat to him about respect for women.

eggbot · 07/02/2024 06:59

Why didn't he ask his male friends his own age?

viridiano · 07/02/2024 06:58

I wonder if it would be worth pointing your son to some instances where young girls/ teens have had their photos put online and then regretted it later.

I do think it's really important that you also validate and appreciate his work, and tell him that they are good photos etc. but that they are images of a minor in her underwear, so that needs some thought before exhibiting.

Ask him how many photos and artworks he has seen which depict people under 18 in their underwear in the way that he has. He won't be able to think of many.

There are some very valid concerns for the girl as she isn't 18 yet - he should talk to his tutor about it and be honest about that, and also find out if her parents are aware.

KennedyFeets · 07/02/2024 06:58

Very cliche of greasy male photographer snapping pics of young women and girls ibn skimpy clothings as 'art'. Nothing interesting or new, just sleazy, exploitative and salacious. Gross.

NotMyDayJob · 07/02/2024 06:57

He's taking pictures of an underage girl. He may not intend them to be sexual but he is at best naive and at worst a liar.

Even if this girl consented for the photos I doubt she consented for them to be put up in college (and it's not clear she can't consent as others have said).

And the idea that a male taking pictures of a female in her underwear is some how arty, alternative, unusual? All the lols.

KennedyFeets · 07/02/2024 06:56

I wonder what the 17 year olds parents think about it.

Soontobe60 · 07/02/2024 06:56

ThatsMyPenguin · 07/02/2024 04:38

In the images where her body can be seen, you can’t really see her face, or just an obscured side profile, but there are others which are more focused on her face.
She definitely could model if that’s what she wanted, has the looks for it! But I don’t know if she actually wants to or if for her it was just a bit of fun. My DD is the year below her at the same school and the girl has a reputation for being smart and sensible so I’d guess she’s thought it through but at 17 I’m not sure she’d have the foresight to appreciate the risks.

DS likes to be different with his art which is why I’d imagine he’s done this!

Photos of young women in their underwear isn’t being ‘different’. It’s very Page 3 circa 1980 tbh. Somewhat sleazy and exploitative. Now if he’d taken photos of his male mates in their underwear, hairy bums and all, THAT would be different!