Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the photos aren’t appropriate/too revealing for college work

314 replies

ThatsMyPenguin · 07/02/2024 04:02

DS is 18, he’s in his second year at college doing an Art and Design course, one of the units is all photography based. He’s loving it.
As part of the unit they need to create a mini portfolio of some portraits, landscapes and still life images. There seems to be a fair amount of creative control. He wants to be a photographer so this unit is important to him.

Last night he was working on the computer downstairs and I was looking at his images (he was editing them).
He has taken some pictures of an old school friend (currently 17) in lingerie. They are quite tastefully done (I won’t post them here as like I said they seem inappropriate to me).
Some have been done to look like she is laying on a bed I think and the placement of her hands make it seem quite sexual, another is from behind and the lingerie doesn’t provide much coverage of her behind so that seems quite inappropriate. He’s taken pictures of her which aren’t revealing too, focused more on her face etc. They are much better but he is insisting he will be fine to use a combination and it’s “art”. They are well done I just don’t think it’s appropriate to take pictures like that of a 17 year old!! His college tend to display some of the work too so I’d be surprised if they allow it, DS says they are fine with it but admits they don’t know she is 17.

AIBU to say pictures of this nature aren’t appropriate considering they are for uni and she’s not 18?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
SoupDragon · 08/02/2024 08:50

I wonder about the reading ability of some posters when they are unable to grasp that the photos have already been deleted because of the illegality.

Plus the OP said all along that they were not appropriate - at no point did she say they were OK.

GreyWednesday · 08/02/2024 08:40

Newchapterbeckons · 08/02/2024 05:11

The age of consent needs to change.
It’s grossly out of date.

I see people make this mistake all of time, mixing up ages and assuming its okay because the minor is over sixteen.

A child is a child - legally, physically and metaphorically. The age of consent was agreed in a different era. We are far more educated about its impacts now.

People will say teens will be teens that they should be allowed to explore, but this is a poor response because it doesn’t take into account the cognitive ability of the child, or lack of, to understand the (very far reaching) consequences. We should be better protecting our children. It should be eighteen.

Edited

Surely it can’t be grossly out of date if you only want to raise it by 2 years?

A large majority of my peer group (at sixth form and then again when I started uni at 18) were no longer virgins by 18. I assume that’s not unusual, so I’m not sure how criminalising consenting 16 and 17 year olds who are choosing to have sex will help. Improved sex education regarding informed consent and healthy relationships would be better.

What might make more sense would be to change the law so that someone over the age of 21 cannot legally have sex with someone between the ages of 16 and 18, to help to prevent relationships with a large age gap and a potential power dynamic.

WhyIOughtTo · 08/02/2024 07:05

Pieceofpurplesky · 07/02/2024 19:37

I can't actually believe the OP actually asked the question and supported her son. Surely everybody knows it's wrong?

Not if the girl is sensible and pretty enough to be a model and not if she says it's Ok and wants some nice photos for herself apparently. And not if it's for art and not if it's innovative. Oh, and not if you are gay.

Then it's all fine.

LatteFlatte · 08/02/2024 06:55

He's committed a crime by taking, making, possessing and distributing indecent pictures of a child under 18. It's insane that neither of you can understand this and worse that you're trying to defend it.

LolaSmiles · 08/02/2024 06:48

You'd think there'd be guidelines given out at the start
I agree, though my gut is that post 16 a little common sense is expected from students. When I ran EPQ we used to go through what made a good project and what wasn't and we could guide them. I have to say it never crossed my mind to tell students not to submit work where the focus is sexualised content of minors.

On the other hand the tutor apparently being around and in the room when a lingerie shoots was going on and a teen is semi naked sounds strange to me. The situation would ring alarm bells.

Newchapterbeckons · 08/02/2024 05:11

The age of consent needs to change.
It’s grossly out of date.

I see people make this mistake all of time, mixing up ages and assuming its okay because the minor is over sixteen.

A child is a child - legally, physically and metaphorically. The age of consent was agreed in a different era. We are far more educated about its impacts now.

People will say teens will be teens that they should be allowed to explore, but this is a poor response because it doesn’t take into account the cognitive ability of the child, or lack of, to understand the (very far reaching) consequences. We should be better protecting our children. It should be eighteen.

sashh · 08/02/2024 02:42

Notamum12345577 · 07/02/2024 15:14

I don’t think I will be doing an image search for topless photos of a 17 year old thanks! 😮

Sorry I didn't express this very well, I meant google teh name(s).

Ijustneedaanswer · 07/02/2024 23:22

Well said. I'm shocked by some of the responses.

Ijustneedaanswer · 07/02/2024 22:56

Wow

jbuggy86 · 07/02/2024 22:49

As someone that was an art major this might be a liability issue for the college and your son. With his friend not being 18 he should talk to his professor and see if there are age restrictions on models and form of nudity. If there are consent forms/waivers that his friend and their parents could sign. You may have to have a sit down with him and his friend. My college had us sign some consent forms if the model wasn't hired by the school itself and we're under age.

Allthatwegotisthispalebluedot · 07/02/2024 22:03

It is very concerning that you keep going on about consent and how sensible she is, OP. You keep reiterating that she WANTS the photos, therefore it must be ok if your poor hapless son just sends them to her, because how could he possibly take responsibility for himself and refuse? After all, he’s only an 18 year old man - he can’t be expected to take responsibility can he? Sensible 17 year old girls on the other hand MUST be able to take responsibility though!

Society won’t change until men do. Your son is plenty old enough to learn that he’s fucked up and he can make it right by taking responsibility and deleting the photos, and not sending them to her.

He’s also plenty old enough to learn there’s nothing groundbreaking or ‘different’ about photographing beautiful young women in their underwear.

Nanny0gg · 07/02/2024 22:00

fliptopbin · 07/02/2024 10:46

Fair enough, the teen was a bit naive, realised he jad made a mistake and changed what he was doing. But what the fuck was the tutor thinking?
Also, surely any art tutor dealing with classes containing teens should pre-empt this issue!

Yes
You'd think there'd be guidelines given out at the start

Ijustneedaanswer · 07/02/2024 21:54

This is some support forum. It's just lambasting people who are usually just looking for advice without putting their foot in it and escalating a problem. The way some of these "helpful comments" have been put, you would think the lad grabbed the girl off the street, stripped her to her knickers while his mother took photos! He made a stupid mistake, with a girl he'd grown up with and is a few months younger than him but who knew him well enough to ALLOW him to photograph her in a vulnerable position. They're BOTH moron's and both KIDS - don't even bother, an 18 year old "man" is still a bloody kid without the sense they were born with. Does anyone think that his poor mother is not going out of her mind right now AFTER doing everything she could to show her child this was inappropriate. As a last resort she turned to this "support forum" because her son was obviously not listening, only to find herself being cyber bullied? I bet if you'd have asked her last month the question she posed, she too would have said no way would her son be so bloody stupid because he's been raised right, but guess what, it's not always how they're raised: kids are stupid and do stupid things that's when you step in and be a parent, which she clearly did. Leave her alone, she has enough to worry about. @ThatsMyPenguin I hope for his sake he listens to you and deletes them, but it's not your fault. You didn't mess up. You obviously have a good relationship with him and it's clear it was innocent, if not misguided and stupid of him to take those photos, but if anything sinister was going on why show your mum, unless he's a psychopath (🙃)! Kids really suck, but we do our best and hopefully he'll learn from this. To the moral high ground, shame on you, let's hope the view doesn't fade from the glass tower!

Atethehalloweenchocs · 07/02/2024 21:30

It sounds like he has learned a difficult lesson - that whatever his intention in making his art, there are other things that he has to consider. I hope it does not deter him too much, poor lad. And that his friend can get her nice pictures from him in more suitable clothing when she turns 18.

Ijustneedaanswer · 07/02/2024 21:28

I imagine you know yourself and you have said of the bar you think it's inappropriate even if it is art, so people asking what are you thinking are misguided, but the question is how do you convince your DS. Perhaps this thread is a way to show DS it's not just you being their "muuuuum"! and without pushing too hard, which at their age means they'll dig in harder, you can put your point across better. If it was me, I'd suggest they speak with their tutor in the hypothetical (v.important!) and explain DS vision and what he wants the photos to say/provoke/emote. He can mention he has someone in mind, but definitely disclose their age and see where the college stands. I'm pretty sure they'll point him in a different direction or perhaps suggest he "use" an older model, that way you can be concerned without being the one to "censor" him and potentially stop him showing future projects. I wonder have you spoken with the girl's parents - like you I'm sure they'd not be overly keen for their d to be portrayed like that for school. The law is not ambiguous when it comes to what it considers child porn, so he needs to be very careful how he proceeds as he could land himself in a lot of trouble. Maybe ask how he would feel if he or if strangers had to pass photos of his sister displayed as Art along the corridors of her school. They could also put the girl herself at risk, it only takes one pervert have they considered that (no point telling 17 year olds the big life "your future employer could see them" consequences; kids don't think like that!)m They both may be parents themselves one day, only then will he really understand. Hope it works out. Good luck x

tempnameforadvice · 07/02/2024 21:27

@Missingmyusername OP said her son said the tutor was in and out of the studio when her son was taking the photos......

Apolloneuro · 07/02/2024 21:12

Sounds like it’s been a useful learning opportunity for your son. I’m glad he’s deleting them, but do continue to challenge his perception of what constitutes sexualisation/exploitation.

I believe you when you say he thought he was being avant grade, but he really, really wasn’t, was he.

Newname000 · 07/02/2024 21:11

GenevièveSapha · 07/02/2024 19:43

According to UK law.... it is child pornography until the age of 18... your son could easily be charged... and convicted... he'd carry that with him for the rest of his life. Probably seems harmless to them now... but could possibly affect the rest of their/his lives/life...

My advice... take the photos... enjoy the photos... (amongst themselves) but publicly displaying them while she is still a minor would be a huge mistake...

No! It's an offence to even take or possess such images.

Divebar2021 · 07/02/2024 20:26

Thanks @Whoopaday if people are going to quote the law they shouldn’t be making fundamental mistakes like that. It’s day one safeguarding stuff.

Whoopaday · 07/02/2024 19:54

GenevièveSapha · 07/02/2024 19:43

According to UK law.... it is child pornography until the age of 18... your son could easily be charged... and convicted... he'd carry that with him for the rest of his life. Probably seems harmless to them now... but could possibly affect the rest of their/his lives/life...

My advice... take the photos... enjoy the photos... (amongst themselves) but publicly displaying them while she is still a minor would be a huge mistake...

I just wanted to change the language in your post, there is not such thing as “child pornography” it’s “child sexual assault material”. Pornography only applies to adults

GenevièveSapha · 07/02/2024 19:43

According to UK law.... it is child pornography until the age of 18... your son could easily be charged... and convicted... he'd carry that with him for the rest of his life. Probably seems harmless to them now... but could possibly affect the rest of their/his lives/life...

My advice... take the photos... enjoy the photos... (amongst themselves) but publicly displaying them while she is still a minor would be a huge mistake...

Creatureofhabit87 · 07/02/2024 19:39

For college why do anything with someone in lingerie? Just seems totally unnecessary!

Pieceofpurplesky · 07/02/2024 19:37

I can't actually believe the OP actually asked the question and supported her son. Surely everybody knows it's wrong?

EmeraldA129 · 07/02/2024 19:15

I came on to say YABU & that you shouldn’t stifle his creativity. Nude or sensual images are all over the place.

but then I saw the girl is 17 & changed to YANBU. I’m sure there’s no bad meaning in what has happened & she is old enough to have sex if she wants, but in terms of her image I think this could still be classed as taking & sharing indecent images of children until she is 18. I might be wrong on that & please speak up if I am mumsnetters!

Oblomov23 · 07/02/2024 18:20

Any father who found out his dd had had her photo taken in her underwear by a peer would be beyond furious. It's beyond my comprehension how your dd could have imagined for one second that this was ok. Literally staggering. How could you not either? I'm shocked.