Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not agree that anyone can do lower paid jobs and top jobs have to pay well as few people can do them?

206 replies

CheekboneMagazine · 07/02/2024 00:45

Following on from the 6 figure thread and a comment about justifying these wages.
I get annoyed by hearing this over and over.
I'm a social worker on 28K. I don't think everyone could do my job. Or do it well. Today my day has consisted of getting a small child to trust me enough in a half hour visit in order to talk to me about their feelings, speaking to an unaccompanied asylum seeker about benefits with no translator available, writing a report for court, being sworn at repeatedly by a teenager who was under the influence and chairing a multidisciplinary meeting with police, school, local authorities, NHS etc. I have to be able to talk to parents about their drug screening results without them feeling judged and disengaging, yet be able to turn around and hold my own with solicitors and judges.
I have to be relatable to people who are in the midst of a mental health crisis or addiction, but also professional and articulate. I have to be flexible and adapt to the many urgent referrals which come in but I cannot let any of my regular contact or statutory visits breach timeframes.

I'm certain that not people many could be teachers or nurses or air hostesses either. I'm certain I would make a terrible barista or bank clerk! Many doctors I know say that they wouldn't have the skills to be their own secretaries or P.A's.

These jobs are not poorly paid because they are unskilled or because anyone could do them. They are poorly paid because they are traditionally done by women and/or because they don't make anyone else substantially richer. In fact I really struggle to think of a female dominated profession which pays well. Maybe accountancy?

OP posts:
hettie · 07/02/2024 06:47

CheekboneMagazine · 07/02/2024 01:17

@Jellycatspyjamas but I'll never get anywhere near six figures. Neither will any nurses, teachers (maybe some??) or OTs.

Actually you could. The deputy COO of our trust is a social worker. Many very senior leadership posts in councils or social care.

Sunnytomorrow · 07/02/2024 06:46

You are not unreasonable. Caring jobs are chronically undervalued and underpaid by society. Part of the reason is that, in capitalism, market forces mean that jobs that generate money are valued higher (and therefore remunerated better) than jobs that provide care.

In a fair market, the total net benefits of a job would be valued - both private benefits (i.e how much money the job generates for the employer) plus social benefits (i.e the total value of that work to society as a whole including indirect benefits such as cutting crime etc). We’d also factor in any social costs of various jobs (eg, pollution generated by some work). That requires a bit of government intervention, but would be worth it as society would be better, safer and happier overall.

For example, a government ‘top up’ pay for social care (of, say, £2 an hour) could better reflect the true benefit that we get from the work carers do. It would also have knock-on benefits: by attracting more people to caring jobs as a career, lowering crime rates by improving interventions, reducing the gender-based pay gap, etc.

This could apply to all care roles: teachers, mothers, care home workers, nursing roles.

This isn’t an anti-capitalist bash by the way; it’s just being realistic that no system is perfect and one of the downsides of capitalism is that unrestricted market forces don’t always give the best overall result for society, so we need someone
like the government to intervene.

Smerpsmorp · 07/02/2024 06:43

CheekboneMagazine · 07/02/2024 00:49

@MiaGee but who's going to shell out to pay local authority staff more?

Social work is paid so little for what you do - I’m a teacher and can’t believe that teachers and social workers pay is not equal.

I considered retraining but took one look at the salary and thought no, absolutely not. Not for all that extra work! it sounds like I’d enjoy the role but I couldn’t afford a pay cut!!

I’ve been a teacher for 12 years and am on UPS3. I have responsibility for overseeing the ECT programme (the first year teachers). It is such a difficult job and even more difficult since covid. I work 4 days a week, and I earn approximately £40k due to having a little bit of extra responsibility. My full time salary would be about £50k. It can’t go any higher - unless I become leadership, which frankly means you give up any hope of a normal life (my husband is SLT).

and then you read on here posts from people who are currently at work, writing they earn £100k but are underpaid when really they just go on mumsnet half the time! But apparently it’s so easy to get a job like this!

NeverAloneNeverAgain · 07/02/2024 06:38

I'm going slightly against the grain. It's not a badly paid profession. As an ASYE you're starting out but will get increments and move up the bands as you gain experience. At this stage you should (not guaranteed) have a protected caseload and your TM should be allocating based on experience so the higher end CP you should either support with or not be solely allocated - I appreciate this is not always the case. I had a PPO in my first month of ASYE.

We do have a good pension if you're not in the private sector.

I also love what I do. I've been in frontline safeguarding for 10yrs+. I'm on £44000 and will stay on this as I'm at the top of my bracket, but this is out of choice. I have no desire to progress into management as it takes me away from the aspects of the job I love. Moving up the ladder equals more pay.

Do I think we should be paid more - yes. If you work out my hourly rate when in proceedings and all the unpaid hours on weekends and evenings I'm probably on less than minimum wage. Can 'anybody' do it - no. Its not an easy profession and no one likes us, however that won't change regardless of the wage.

When I think of lower paid jobs I don't count SW in that. I think of our admin staff who do an amazing job at organising meetings, doing the tasks that take up my time to free me to do other things and generally sort my working life out for about £19000. Shop workers are woefully underpaid yet we would be buggered without them. Realistically whilst maybe your pay doesn't always reflect what you do it's not a low paid profession.

Having said all that, I'm really pleased you enjoy your role and hope you continue to do so!

Morningcaffeine · 07/02/2024 06:25

I’m a nurse on £32k (would be £35k if full time). I understand that in the grand scheme of things that is not the worst salary in the world. However, I did a three year degree and a post graduate course to specialise and I sometimes get in the car after a shift and weep, thinking that what I’ve done is worth so little.
I think the problem is that society as a whole doesn’t value my profession enough. Of course I could have picked a different career and earnt more but that is beside the point. We need people to do jobs like mine and the OP’s and it’s so demoralising that our pay doesn’t reflect our impact on society.

Meadowfinch · 07/02/2024 06:01

There's no doubt most social workers are underpaid. Partly it is because some jobs require fewer qualifications to get started. Having half a million in student debt means salaries need to be higher in some jobs to ever justify someone taking such a huge risk.

Architecture - 7 years study
Brain surgery - 10 years study
Social worker or my job (digital marketing) - 3 years study
Healthcare assistant - straight from school.

And the capitalism point is correct. I have to show that every campaign I run makes my company money. I have to track how much money and prove it. The last one found them £260k of business. If that ever stops, I'll be replaced without a backward glance. That's the deal.

Being in the NHS saves the country money, but it's harder to prove, which gives them the excuse to pay less.

If you moved to Aus I bet you would be paid more. Maybe something to consider?

Moonmelodies · 07/02/2024 05:47

You say 'not many people could be teachers, nurses, or air hostesses' ... and yet, many people are.

fungibletoken · 07/02/2024 05:41

@CheekboneMagazine

"but I don't want to. I love what I do. I just don't understand why we can't be paid a living wage for doing what we're naturally good at

[...]

but I'll never get anywhere near six figures. Neither will any nurses, teachers (maybe some??) or OTs."

I definitely sympathise, but there are a few different issues here, and this smacks a little bit of a race to the bottom. Six figures is way beyond a living wage. £28k is even arguably still a living wage.

So what are you really saying? That you don't understand why some jobs pay so much more than others? Again, though - what other jobs pay is a bit of a red herring. If you work in a sector with customers that pay a lot of money for the product or service then you're more likely to see some of that money. But that's not to the detriment of people in other lines of work. It's not like taking slices out of a pie.

HarlanPepper · 07/02/2024 05:38

I earn less than you OP, as a healthcare support worker in the NHS. People are always telling me they couldn't or wouldn't do my job, and whilst I do take that with a pinch of salt, I do agree that a lot of people couldn't do it well.

malificent7 · 07/02/2024 04:41

Yanbu. On £28,000.
Ahp...3 year degree in a highly specialised scientific and techical subject. Got a 1st.
Work all across the hospital in a and e, theatre, community.
See very sick, dying patients every day and lots of gore.
Have to be responsible for health and safety and small errors on my part have big implications.
I love my job but i am not paid well.

SilverBranchGoldenPears · 07/02/2024 03:22

Ok so I get those 6 figures (but only just). I get paid for my years of experience and knowledge (yes law), but I am no more ‚clever‘ than your average professional and much of my work is people focussed so not on paper as such.
My assistant is only ok at her job and anyone could do it with organisational skills and she is paid 50k.
The low paid job you are doing is highly skilled and no doubt with your skill set you could command a much higher salary if you wanted to. You chose, luckily for society, social work. But you could in theory do anything. Lots of low paid work is unskilled and literally anyone could do it. And yes it’s mainly women, but that’s a whole other kettle of fish.

Absolutenonstop · 07/02/2024 03:19

You’re not being unreasonable. Most people couldn’t do your job, but you also went into it knowing the parameters of pay (even though it’s unfair for what you take on). You also say you love your job, which is a gift in itself.

I despise my job, and I knew I would when I went into it. I also knew there was a high chance of my earning 6 figures. (Commercial law). That’s the choice I made.

PupInAPram · 07/02/2024 03:10

CurlsnSunshinetime4tea · 07/02/2024 01:21

the thing is, if you are bright enough to make it through the sw uni program you are equally bright enough to have undertaken studies in a field that pays more.
yes you are very underpaid for what you do BUT with a different focus you could easily have become an hr lawyer and have been paid more.

You have completely missed the point.

BruFord · 07/02/2024 02:12

I do actually agree with you that I think some jobs command huge salaries because they are related to making money. Because these jobs make money, that means there is a lot of money available for the people in these jobs.

Sadly, @Acapulco12, I think you’re right. One of my relatives makes six figures (not sure how much). He makes his employers several million every year through sales so his contribution to the company is easily quantifiable and he gets paid from that revenue.

Nurses, teachers, social workers make incredibly valuable contributions to society that can’t be quantified in the same way.
They should be better paid, which means changes to government policy and probably general taxation.

BobbyBiscuits · 07/02/2024 02:12

@CheekboneMagazine I feel you. I had aspirations in the arts, my fella is a musician, my mates are teachers and work in retail, one is media management for a finance company so she's doing alright.
I thought if you did want to pursue accountancy that was a good piece of advice but obviously not if you don't want to.

CheekboneMagazine · 07/02/2024 02:06

@FredaFox you could always get a job in the public sector, as we have it so good.

OP posts:
FredaFox · 07/02/2024 02:03

@Acapulco12 as are people in the private sector without the benefits of public
Jobs at the lower end of the scale especially are not paid more in public which is often why people say

CheekboneMagazine · 07/02/2024 01:59

@Jellycatspyjamas I completely agree but I can see it going that way!

OP posts:
Jellycatspyjamas · 07/02/2024 01:57

Which brings up an interesting point about performance related pay.

Performance related pay would be disastrous in social work. Who would decide what “good” performance looked like?

Good social work takes time, outcomes aren’t always great regardless of how good the worker is, how do you value comforting a neglected child while also finding them somewhere safe to stay while also caring for the parent.

Acapulco12 · 07/02/2024 01:56

FredaFox · 07/02/2024 01:49

Local authority staff get more than enough with their juicy pensions and flexi time

It may be that they get good pensions and flexi time, but the most junior staff are very lowly paid, which is a problem.

Acapulco12 · 07/02/2024 01:55

CheekboneMagazine · 07/02/2024 01:45

@Acapulco12 sorry I didn't mean it to come across like that! I just wanted to see if there are any views from the six figure brigade as to why they're worth more than nurses or teachers. I think it's probably as people said, there's no money in these services!
Which brings up an interesting point about performance related pay. I used to disagree with it because I felt it was another stick to bash overworked, overstretched women with. Like 'pull your socks up Barbara, I know you've got an elderly mum and three children and you're on your own but 26 year old Brian planned and delivered an excellent lesson on climate change by connecting up to a school in Ecuador and why don't you have hours to spend and infinite energy to do similar?' But I guess it would increase wages.

Not at all! Sorry, I got on my high horse there, because I’m just so frustrated at the news headlines we’re seeing every day about the awful state that public services are in. I do actually agree with you that I think some jobs command huge salaries because they are related to making money. Because these jobs make money, that means there is a lot of money available for the people in these jobs.

On the other hand, frontline workers (especially in the public sector) don’t tend to have particularly high salaries unless they are management because their jobs - unfortunately - don’t make anyone money. I think I understand the ‘logic’ of this system - that money makes money - but I don’t support it or agree with it n

Jellycatspyjamas · 07/02/2024 01:53

@Jellycatspyjamas but I'll never get anywhere near six figures. Neither will any nurses, teachers (maybe some??) or OTs.

The vast majority of people don’t get anywhere near 6 figures, it represents 4% of the population (all of whom post on mumsnet it would seem).

Earning £50k, well within the realms of social work, puts you in the top 15% of earners. I think all the “I earn 6 figures” posts around here really skew people’s idea of what a good salary looks like.

FredaFox · 07/02/2024 01:50

By local authorities I mean admin staff
Drs police nurses social workers deserve more

FredaFox · 07/02/2024 01:49

CheekboneMagazine · 07/02/2024 00:49

@MiaGee but who's going to shell out to pay local authority staff more?

Local authority staff get more than enough with their juicy pensions and flexi time

CurlsnSunshinetime4tea · 07/02/2024 01:48

@CheekboneMagazine yes, especially women in law. But just commenting on the concept.
people sometimes limit themselves, but life is about compromise. A job that fulfills vs drudgery.
Nursing is a job that many could do, but to do it well you need the right personality. Even with zero personality you could still work in some sectors of nursing and manage fine.