Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not agree that anyone can do lower paid jobs and top jobs have to pay well as few people can do them?

206 replies

CheekboneMagazine · 07/02/2024 00:45

Following on from the 6 figure thread and a comment about justifying these wages.
I get annoyed by hearing this over and over.
I'm a social worker on 28K. I don't think everyone could do my job. Or do it well. Today my day has consisted of getting a small child to trust me enough in a half hour visit in order to talk to me about their feelings, speaking to an unaccompanied asylum seeker about benefits with no translator available, writing a report for court, being sworn at repeatedly by a teenager who was under the influence and chairing a multidisciplinary meeting with police, school, local authorities, NHS etc. I have to be able to talk to parents about their drug screening results without them feeling judged and disengaging, yet be able to turn around and hold my own with solicitors and judges.
I have to be relatable to people who are in the midst of a mental health crisis or addiction, but also professional and articulate. I have to be flexible and adapt to the many urgent referrals which come in but I cannot let any of my regular contact or statutory visits breach timeframes.

I'm certain that not people many could be teachers or nurses or air hostesses either. I'm certain I would make a terrible barista or bank clerk! Many doctors I know say that they wouldn't have the skills to be their own secretaries or P.A's.

These jobs are not poorly paid because they are unskilled or because anyone could do them. They are poorly paid because they are traditionally done by women and/or because they don't make anyone else substantially richer. In fact I really struggle to think of a female dominated profession which pays well. Maybe accountancy?

OP posts:
chopinwaltz26 · 07/02/2024 19:34

Very many years ago at work a similar topic was raised. The union rep came around to drum up support for pay negotiations. He had a very interesting exchange with one of my (older, male) colleagues.
The upshot was (according to older, male colleague): no problem with people being paid the same money (wildly stupid as the work was incredibly different) as long as those, who enter the workforce after school, do not earn anything for the first 7 years to equalise the difference in earning with those, who spent time after school at university.
Union rep scuttled off very quickly. I was left wide-eyed (but not legless)!

Emma8888 · 07/02/2024 19:31

If it’s market forces, how come we have a shortage of teachers? If market forces were at work, pay for teachers would rise, until all the teaching posts were filled. But this has not happened.

Because it's not short enough, simply put. There aren't children going to empty classrooms and teaching themselves. Yes there are schools where class sizes are too large, as they cover for shortages. Or some subjects being taught by those really not qualified. But teachers care about kids and make-do with what's in front of them. If they didn't, short term it would be horrific and children would suffer, but long term you'd see money go up. I remember when PGCEs were heavily marketed at universities, got grants, bursaries etc. a quick google tells me that you can get up to £15,000 to train in an in-demand subject in Wales right now for example. So there is money being put towards the problem, just not across the board.

CroftonWillow · 07/02/2024 19:25

I don't agree few people can do higher paid jobs, as if they need to be particularly intelligent or talented. It's that empoyers pay for experience.

Mumof2NDers · 07/02/2024 19:20

CheekboneMagazine · 07/02/2024 00:45

Following on from the 6 figure thread and a comment about justifying these wages.
I get annoyed by hearing this over and over.
I'm a social worker on 28K. I don't think everyone could do my job. Or do it well. Today my day has consisted of getting a small child to trust me enough in a half hour visit in order to talk to me about their feelings, speaking to an unaccompanied asylum seeker about benefits with no translator available, writing a report for court, being sworn at repeatedly by a teenager who was under the influence and chairing a multidisciplinary meeting with police, school, local authorities, NHS etc. I have to be able to talk to parents about their drug screening results without them feeling judged and disengaging, yet be able to turn around and hold my own with solicitors and judges.
I have to be relatable to people who are in the midst of a mental health crisis or addiction, but also professional and articulate. I have to be flexible and adapt to the many urgent referrals which come in but I cannot let any of my regular contact or statutory visits breach timeframes.

I'm certain that not people many could be teachers or nurses or air hostesses either. I'm certain I would make a terrible barista or bank clerk! Many doctors I know say that they wouldn't have the skills to be their own secretaries or P.A's.

These jobs are not poorly paid because they are unskilled or because anyone could do them. They are poorly paid because they are traditionally done by women and/or because they don't make anyone else substantially richer. In fact I really struggle to think of a female dominated profession which pays well. Maybe accountancy?

Can add dental nurse to the traditionally female job and poorly paid! It’s shocking really.

Emma8888 · 07/02/2024 19:18

"This is as far from the truth as it’s possible to be.
There is rarely a lack of people wanting or qualified to take highly paid positions. They can be filled with lower salaries than advertised.
Whereas there are tens of thousands of vacant nursing posts and yet the pay remains inadequate. Governments prefer to leave posts unfilled or pursue unethical recruitment from poor countries.
This is based in sexism and the undervalue of women’s work."

In my industry (specialized but not requiring specific qualifications like a doctor) we frequently have jobs that pay mid six figures open for months while they try and recruit. There are always applicants but they are rarely qualified (in terms of skills and experience, not paper). In most cases the only way to fill these roles is to employ a recruiter who poaches from competitors, and the only way to successfully poach those who otherwise wouldn't be looking is to offer more money, and so the cycle goes. I absolutely think that the money paid for these roles is crazy, yes, it's a job with a lot of pressure, long hours, etc. but even so, we aren't responsible for nuclear codes either. Incidentally the gender balance in this industry for the senior roles is about 50-50.

If every nurse currently employed by the NHS walked out tomorrow they would have no choice but to throw money at the problem. Even now I know of situations where they can't recruit in some specific circumstances so pay agency nurses more than double the NHS rate. That's it happening on a smaller scale. But I'd wager 90+% of nurses don't do it for the money, they do it because they enjoy helping others, job security, civic duty or other non cash reasons. So they won't quit en masse, so the government won't do much. Don't get me wrong, I'm massively grateful to nurses and other healthcare workers (and have family and friends employed by the NHS) and it would cause untold suffering if they quit. But the government also know that because they are not purely money motivated, they won't.

DreadPirateRobots · 07/02/2024 17:48

Nellodee · 07/02/2024 17:42

A well educated workforce generates more income. A healthy workforce costs less in disability benefits and generates more income. A minimal prison population costs less and earns more. An fast, effective immigration system means lower costs in housing asylum seekers.

Spending as little as possible on public services does not necessarily reduce the tax burden and could quite easily increase it. In many cases, it’s false economy.

True. The problem is the long gap (often at least ten years, quite possibly up to 50) between an investment in public services being made and the resultant benefits and cost savings being achieved. A government's horizon is about five years because of the election cycle, and in any case the money you'll save in ten years is not available to you now to make that investment in the first place. If these problems were easy to solve, we would live in a different (and much better) world. As the best-meaning person in the world with good support, the money you are going to have to make systems better is always going to be not nearly as much as you'd like, and if you lose the next election in five years then your lovely twenty-year plan is fucked.

As they say: democracy is the worst political system except for every other political system.

Echobelly · 07/02/2024 17:46

There is no fucking way a nurse should be paid less (and it's a lot less) than me, for example. I just edit stuff, copy and paste things into templates and do a bit of admin and comms for a big business and I can work 9-5 and not think about it when I'm not working. Nurses work ludicrous hours, people's lives literally depend on them, it's emotionally and physically exhausting.

But of course nursing is seen as a 'woman's job' and thus a 'calling' and nurses are 'angels', so they don't need money. 🙄

Nellodee · 07/02/2024 17:42

A well educated workforce generates more income. A healthy workforce costs less in disability benefits and generates more income. A minimal prison population costs less and earns more. An fast, effective immigration system means lower costs in housing asylum seekers.

Spending as little as possible on public services does not necessarily reduce the tax burden and could quite easily increase it. In many cases, it’s false economy.

Jellycatspyjamas · 07/02/2024 15:42

(and I daresay would get up at 3am if a client called in a desperate state)

I would sincerely hope not, caring doesn’t mean being ever available. Managing professional boundaries is especially important in a job where you could literally work 24/7 and still not be done.

toomuchfaff · 07/02/2024 15:18

They are poorly paid because they don't generate revenue... nothing to do with being female or anything; they don't make any money.

Even in private corporations, jobs that generate revenue earn more than those that don't, those that are "operational expenditure" vs Sales for instance have wildy different renumeration packages.

Merrymouse · 07/02/2024 15:15

Shelf stackers - not at all, they only execute according to instructions given and will be replaced by robots at some not so distant future. Nearly everyone could do this job.

Not to undermine the importance of the sales and marketing manager, but during Covid shelf stackers in my village made a huge difference to my life, because they literally made sure I had food, and they I’m sure that for many they were the closest form of human contact.

The human presence of people working in shops makes a big difference to the community.

nearlylovemyusername · 07/02/2024 15:01

KreedKafer · 07/02/2024 12:30

None of the six-figure salary people where I work would last five minutes working in a care home, teaching at a primary school, working on the door at nightclub, being a hospital porter, working in an abattoir, etc. They would all happily admit this.

There are some highly paid jobs that very few people can do. There are also some very badly paid jobs that very few people can do, and often they are the very jobs that are the most necessary for society to function. For example, I'm pretty sure that the Director of Sales & Marketing at your favourite supermarket chain does not make as much difference to your daily life as the people who stack the shelves.

This post shows how little understanding people have about high paying jobs - Director of Sales & Marketing at my favourite supermarket chain makes a huge difference to me - they define pricing/promo and product strategies so direct impact on my wallet and on my diet. And there are very few people able to do great job there. Shelf stackers - not at all, they only execute according to instructions given and will be replaced by robots at some not so distant future. Nearly everyone could do this job.

Caring jobs though (and nursing, teaching etc) are totally different, I fully agree with previous posters, this level of pay is shambolic

BillionaireTea · 07/02/2024 14:59

In a fair market, the total net benefits of a job would be valued - both private benefits (i.e how much money the job generates for the employer) plus social benefits (i.e the total value of that work to society as a whole including indirect benefits such as cutting crime etc). We’d also factor in any social costs of various jobs (eg, pollution generated by some work).

absolutely love this idea. It's a lot like assessing wellbeing not GDP as measure of national growth.

OP is definitely underpaid.

Can I throw in another dimension of reward? Responsibility and management of culture. The tasks OP mentions that make up her busy day are skilled. However they are all discrete tasks and while she probably takes huge care over individuals (and I daresay would get up at 3am if a client called in a desperate state), she is not responsible for the outcomes of hundreds or thousands of people.

If you are a CEO or a very public facing role, especially in a global or huge business, or leading even a part of an institution like central government or the NHS, you have to be fronting it all the time. You don't just have to be doing tasks, you have to be choosing and prioritising and managing the culture and mood of many, many other people.

In my "biggest" job I had to weigh my words amd my facial expression carefully every second, juggle so so many competing priorities, always bear in mind what was happening and what the political or corporate climate might do to our brand and organisation - you never turn off the news or switch off. It's sort of like having a baby, you can't forget it even if someone else is technically in charge for a day while you have a nap.

Your own health is secondary, if you have to appear at something you have to be there.

I know that's the case with e.g. junior doctors too- there is always a counterfactual. Basically I agree our way of valuing things is fucked. But I just wanted to point out that there is a particular kind of stress in bring responsible for thousands- that most of us don't note or know about.

Bringbackspring · 07/02/2024 13:32

@Ginmonkeyagain I wasn't suggesting that high earners should be able to book their own tickets. It was just a basic example of how they are not necessarily smart. Of course they don't need to book their own tickets. My point was that I work with some very senior, well paid people who can't find the nose on their face most of the time. And some low paid admins who I swear could run the organisation if they had to.

I also disagree that it's always about them having knowledge/decision making ability. Many do of course, I don't dispute that. But I often find it's a case of he/she who shouts loudest wins. There are lots of very loud people in organisations who say everything with such an air of confidence that people assume they must know what they're talking about and promote them up the ranks, when half the time they're spouting utter bollocks.

Alicewinn · 07/02/2024 13:13

Yes I think there's truth in female roles being underpaid as well. Rightly or wrongly I always found the quickest way to get a pay rise is to leave the job and find a better paying/more respectful company/boss

Ginmonkeyagain · 07/02/2024 13:07

@Bringbackspring high earners don't get paid to book train tickets etc.. that is why people are paid to do it for them.

It is a false economy to pay someone £150k plus a year and make them do their own admin.

The highest earners are not so much paid for their capacity for hard work but their ability to make decisons and their knowledge.

Naptrappedmummy · 07/02/2024 12:49

But how would the funds be redistributed, realistically? Does anyone have any ideas?

RebelMoon · 07/02/2024 12:48

I'm often mildly ashamed that I sit on my ample arse in my home office and earn twice the amount people like OP are paid. My job is technically difficult but ultimately I'm sat at a desk pressing keys. My work doesn't change people's lives. It sucks that society doesn't value the jobs that really matter.

Bringbackspring · 07/02/2024 12:44

Why are there so many responses basically saying you should change jobs/fields if you want to earn more? This post isn't about the OP wanting to earn more (although I'm sure they do). It's to make the point that low pay does not equal low skill. Many very challenging jobs are low paid. And on the flip side, we regularly see threads on here from well paid people (or mid-well paid) saying they don't have much to do at work and they are a bit bored. Also many high earners are propped up in their jobs/lives by other people doing a lot of the work for them on a significantly lower wage. These high earners are not always particularly bright. Many of the most senior people I work with lack the basic knowledge required to book a train ticket or find an agenda that was emailed to them 3 times.

And as has been said many, many times on MN, if everyone leaves the low paying jobs to become a lawyer or an accountant, who the hell is going to provide care for anyone, serve you in a shop, make your precious fancy coffees? And who on earth needs that many accountants!

KreedKafer · 07/02/2024 12:30

None of the six-figure salary people where I work would last five minutes working in a care home, teaching at a primary school, working on the door at nightclub, being a hospital porter, working in an abattoir, etc. They would all happily admit this.

There are some highly paid jobs that very few people can do. There are also some very badly paid jobs that very few people can do, and often they are the very jobs that are the most necessary for society to function. For example, I'm pretty sure that the Director of Sales & Marketing at your favourite supermarket chain does not make as much difference to your daily life as the people who stack the shelves.

MamaAlwaysknowsbest · 07/02/2024 11:43

Look at Prince Andrew and the amount of money he has and it will tell you , all you need to know about the rich, well paid and anyone who takes time to boast their betterness based on money.

MamaAlwaysknowsbest · 07/02/2024 11:42

Life is not fair. You should be paid much more for what you do. Someone sitting on a desk ( ok, doing what for humanity ), tell me, what really is getting over 100 000. Of course it is not fair and it is bollocks to say some random chap and gal are worth more in money because have bigger brain. Look at their expenditures, morals and how they treat others and you see they are morally broken like everyone else, if not worse, having in mind what one can pay these days with more money.

XelaM · 07/02/2024 11:41

@minipie

Yes BUT numbers of women in law firms drop off hugely at around age 30 and above - which also tends to be when the 6 figures kicks in. At senior levels in law firms it is still mostly men. Women leave law or go in house or to smaller firms which pay less.

Not my experience at all and I work in the City for one of the largest law firms in the world - in an almost all-female team. The larger the firm the better the maternity package usually. I have never felt disadvantaged as a woman in the legal profession.

Usernamen · 07/02/2024 11:32

minipie · 07/02/2024 09:43

Yes BUT numbers of women in law firms drop off hugely at around age 30 and above - which also tends to be when the 6 figures kicks in. At senior levels in law firms it is still mostly men. Women leave law or go in house or to smaller firms which pay less.

Wouldn’t be surprised if the same applies in medicine - women 30+ often go part time or choose more flexible (but also less well paid) specialisms.

And?

They are still well-paid professions which are female dominated.

If the OP’s claim that jobs are low paid because women choose to do them, then pay in medicine and law would have dropped off a cliff decades ago. But it hasn’t.

You might want to look up the trend in female % of equity partners in law firms and female % of consultants - growing year on year with no sign of slowing down (the junior cohorts coming through are mostly women, those retiring mostly men).

EmmaStone · 07/02/2024 11:25

It's all economics - supply and demand. No employer is going to pay more than necessary to get the right body in the chair. Also, one's gross salary is only part of a package - I may get an above average gross salary, but I don't get loads of holiday (31 days inc BHs), my employer only contributes 3% to my pension, I frequently work unpaid overtime, during holidays and my days off (and from my Covid sickbed). When I was at University, I wanted a job that would pay me to have a lifestyle I wanted to attain, so that's what I did. I'm lucky that I enjoy my job, but I wouldn't have pursued a job that didn't pay well.