Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To give DD less money for lunch

39 replies

Justrolledmyeyesoutloud · 06/02/2024 19:37

She is in year 7, takes a very basic packed lunch (filled roll, apple and a chocolate bar or cake), also has £10 on Parentpay to buy a drink and extras.
Found her roll in her bag uneaten so will have to throw it out. She bought herself a bacon roll and some waffles today.
Just had a chat with her about making good choices but don't want to food shame her.
Any advice? As l am writing this, am thinking £2 a day is too much on top of a packed lunch. Should l reduce it to £5?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
BCBird · 27/03/2024 18:58

A drink can be 1pound plus. Other day boy had a burger, cookie and drink £3.50- shocking prices. FSM is 2.50. You can get a meal , a dessert and small drink for this but realistically most pupils do not choose this

The6thQueen · 07/02/2024 08:12

My kids are 10 and 13. Used to just let them eat what they wanted for lunch from the school canteen and topped up when they ran out. It was ridiculous the amount they went through, it’s the drinks I think, the canteen charges more because of the sugar content. Sometimes they were spending £7 a day 😱
Now, they get £12 a week to spend how they like, but when it’s gone, it’s gone. They make their own packed lunches and have worked out ways to have what they want from school and a couple of packed lunches in between. Good budgeting lesson 😊

Youcannotbeseriousreally · 07/02/2024 08:07

Starzinsky · 06/02/2024 19:45

I think I would rather my kids ate. I have boys who ate at break and lunch school so topped up to what they needed even if they took a sandwich. If your child isn't overweight and healthy and you can afford £10 a week, not sure why you would need to ration what they eat.

Yes this, mine tend to take a packed lunch as the line can be so long sometimes. But they are free to get extras if they want too. I always ensure they have credit on their account. I don’t see the issue.

Multipleexclamationmarks · 07/02/2024 08:06

You don't have to make talking to her about it food shaming, I'd be more focused on food wastage. Tell her it costs a lot of monet to keep wasting perfectly good food.
My 2 take a packed lunch and I put £10 a month on parent pay so if they want a treat they can get one, apparently a chocolate brownie is 70p. If they want a meal from school they tell me in advance so I don't waste food making lunch to be thrown away.

MamPadi · 07/02/2024 07:58

My DD is yr 8, started yr 7 taking a packed lunch twice a week but she started not eating it and hardly anyone else takes a packed lunch at her school. I would give her a set amount a week, if she spends it all then packed lunch the rest of the week. Some days she'll make very unhealthy choices but if the rest of her meals are balanced it's not the end of the world and she should get it out of her system when she's a bit older. My DD had pasta with tomato sauce yesterday for example, and a lot of days buys a chicken salad bap

Summerdew · 07/02/2024 07:19

dancinginthewind · 07/02/2024 01:08

If it's any comfort, DC1 was like this for the first few months of Yr7. I think it was a novelty thing and also tied in with the uncertainty of being in a new, big school so, if all of the people you were with went to the canteen, you did too as otherwise you worried you might not find them again plus exploring new friendship groups. She's now in Yr9 and, other than when she forgot lunch one day and when a friend forgot her entire school bag (so lunch and payment card), I don't think she's bought anything all year.
At about this stage, we had a chat about the money side of it. Not just what Shs was spending but what were people she was with doing. It was interesting as a couple of people had apparently had their parents tell them they were spending too much, one never bought anything as they didn't have any money, a couple rarely bought things. As well as saying that I thought it was a waste of money & unhealthy, I focussed on the friendship dynamics. How did the person who didn't have any money feel? What about those whose parents were asking them not to spend as much? By the summer term, it had evolved so that on a Friday they all bought lunch in the canteen but for the rest of the week they took packed lunch.

Thank you, you’ve put a fresh perspective in this for me and I will be a bit more relaxed because all of this makes sense.

dancinginthewind · 07/02/2024 01:08

If it's any comfort, DC1 was like this for the first few months of Yr7. I think it was a novelty thing and also tied in with the uncertainty of being in a new, big school so, if all of the people you were with went to the canteen, you did too as otherwise you worried you might not find them again plus exploring new friendship groups. She's now in Yr9 and, other than when she forgot lunch one day and when a friend forgot her entire school bag (so lunch and payment card), I don't think she's bought anything all year.
At about this stage, we had a chat about the money side of it. Not just what Shs was spending but what were people she was with doing. It was interesting as a couple of people had apparently had their parents tell them they were spending too much, one never bought anything as they didn't have any money, a couple rarely bought things. As well as saying that I thought it was a waste of money & unhealthy, I focussed on the friendship dynamics. How did the person who didn't have any money feel? What about those whose parents were asking them not to spend as much? By the summer term, it had evolved so that on a Friday they all bought lunch in the canteen but for the rest of the week they took packed lunch.

caringcarer · 07/02/2024 01:00

My Foster son has a cooked breakfast every morning so 2 x scrambled eggs, toast, plum tomatoes and either sausages, bacon or hash browns with it and fresh orange juice. He doesn't eat a lot for college lunch. He doesn't like queueing for the hot food. He often just buys a chicken and salad wrap as only a small queue for this and an oat bar. He takes an apple or a banana with him from home and a full water container. He eats a healthy snack like hummus and carrot sticks when he gets home then his cooked meal later in the evening. He does a lot of sports so needs to eat plenty of protein and vitamins. He only has £15 on his card each week. He's in over 4 lunch times.

caringcarer · 07/02/2024 00:51

Would she agree just a packed lunch 2 days a week and just a school lunch 3 days? It would still be about £10 a week.

canonlydoblue · 06/02/2024 23:46

My son takes a packed lunch every day but also has money on parent pay. He's recently stopped eating breakfast before school and prefers to buy something at break time and then eat his lunch later. At the moment that's two hash browns and a blinking Radnor Fizz!

RedSoloCup · 06/02/2024 23:25

My DD takes a sausage roll, crisps, caramel wafer and buys one thing a day, fruit and vegetables happen at home 🤣 she spends about £1.50 a day

melj1213 · 06/02/2024 23:09

DD gets £40 put into her lunch account every month, so £10 a week. School lunch is £3.50 a day for a main, drink and pudding and break time snacks are 70p-£1.50.

The school publishes the lunch menu online for the upcoming month so DD can decide how she wants to budget her money over the month eg if one week there is no school lunches that she wants but the following week she wants school lunch every day then she can spend nothing by taking packed lunches for the first week then spend £17.50 in week two.

Generally it works out that she has school lunch a couple of times a week and packed lunches the other days. On days she takes a packed lunch she will buy a snack/drink at break using her lunch money and on days she buys lunch she will take a snack/drink from home to maximise her budget.

We have built this up through secondary school - she's in Yr 9 now so she just gets the £40 put in every month but we started in Yr 7 by putting £10 a week into her account on the understanding that packed lunches were the default but if she had forgotten her lunch/didn't have time to make it then she would have money in her account to get a school lunch as well as being able to get a snack/drink at break but if I found out she was wasting food by taking a packed lunch and then buying food anyway then the lunch account would have been reduced and packed lunch would have been her only option.

RosesAndHellebores · 06/02/2024 22:39

I expect she wanted to do what her friends were doing for lunch. Talk to her.

PaperDoIIs · 06/02/2024 22:37

saltinesandcoffeecups · 06/02/2024 22:31

I think on the food waste thing just tell her to be smart about it. If she sees something on the menu during the week to not take the packed lunch.

This could work. There are a few days here and there when DD loves the school dinners so that's what she has (2/3 days a week) , on the other days she has packed lunch.

saltinesandcoffeecups · 06/02/2024 22:31

I think on the food waste thing just tell her to be smart about it. If she sees something on the menu during the week to not take the packed lunch.

idontlikealdi · 06/02/2024 22:28

Dts get £20 a week. If they decide to spend it all on Radnor splash by Wednesday they can take what they forage from home.

BananaPyjamaLlama · 06/02/2024 22:14

If shes got a packed lunch she doesnt need money for extras as well.

justthecat · 06/02/2024 22:10

She probably wants to do what her friends are doing, the novelty at this age. Mine stopped when had to deal with the queue every day

Flora56 · 06/02/2024 22:04

We do the same. Packed lunch and she supplements with extras from the canteen. She gets a full school meal on average once a week.

We upload an agreed amount of money each half term and when it’s gone, it’s gone. If she blows it in a week on biscuits then she has to have packed lunch until the next half term.

I did give her extra the last week before Christmas because she was shattered and it meant she didn’t need to make her lunches but other than that we’ve stuck to it.

unlikelychump · 06/02/2024 22:00

My y7 makes herself a packed lunch most days and has input into the shopping list.

She was also spending about 12-15 a week on snacks/drinks. We've come up with an agreement that if she spends less than £7.50 we put £2.50 into her money pot, if she spends nothing we put £5 in. She's never got the £5 but has got the £2.50 every week this term. It is a win for us because that has halved the budget. I don't mind her having some snacks with her peers.

The numbers were randomly chosen as about half of what she was spending. She doesnt otherwise get regular pocket money, so she is pleased with this (though not yet spending it)

OldTinHat · 06/02/2024 22:00

This post has made me chuckle as its reminded me about DS (now 25). He always took a packed lunch but had hollow legs. Lunch was gone at first break so I'd top up his canteen card in case he was going to 'die of hunger'.

One lunchtime, he apparently queued for half an hour (lunch was 45 mins) to order a panini. Got said panini and took it outside to sit with his mates. Just as he lifted the sandwich up to take a bite, a seagull swooped down and snatched the whole thing out of his hand.

It still makes me laugh thinking about it. He was so very furious when he got home!

So, no practical advice, OP, other than setting a monthly top up on the card (which I did). If they blow it all in the first couple of days, well, tough, basically. I always sent my DC off with a packed lunch so I knew they wouldn't starve.

Hmmmm2018 · 06/02/2024 21:53

I reckon it would be better to say only packed lunches Monday to Wednesday then use the £10 to only have school lunch on Thursday and Friday. She then gets to enjoy the school stuff 2 days a week but you don't get the wastage on other days

HmmWhatNameToHave · 06/02/2024 21:48

Why not make the £10 part of her pocket money. Basic pack lunch from home, extras from school or extras from the supermarket, or school lunch a couple of days and bring packed lunch other days. It will be her choice and no doubt she will learn to be be more economical.

TwylaSands · 06/02/2024 21:34

Have her shop for and make her own packed lunch

Justrolledmyeyesoutloud · 06/02/2024 21:33

Starzinsky · 06/02/2024 19:45

I think I would rather my kids ate. I have boys who ate at break and lunch school so topped up to what they needed even if they took a sandwich. If your child isn't overweight and healthy and you can afford £10 a week, not sure why you would need to ration what they eat.

I'm not rationing it - l ended up throwing food away today because she didn't want that and her canteen food

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread