Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Cancer inequality - Charles

281 replies

notknowledgeable · 06/02/2024 14:24

Obviously I know life is unfair, but even so I am stunned. Treatment starts the same week he is diagnosed? Most of us have to wait 2-4 months. And I don't expect he will be directed to food banks when the DWP repeatedly stuffs up his ESA claim either

OP posts:
JenniferBooth · 07/02/2024 14:32

The Yorkshire Post getting their arse handed to them on a plate on Twitter for criticising those bringing up cancer inequality.

https://x.com/yorkshirepost/status/1754579005867434232?s=20

https://x.com/yorkshirepost/status/1754579005867434232?s=20

Chanxex · 07/02/2024 14:17

Thesquaddogs · 07/02/2024 13:59

@MistressoftheDarkSide
Using anecdotal evidence from the 90s is harking back 30 years. The evidence today is that more people in the UK are surviving cancer than ever before. Again and again the message is to take advantage of screening programmes. If your FIL died of bowel cancer make sure your husband has regular screening. If you are concerned about yourself or elderly relatives for specific reason, request full bloods.
I think I am right in saying that clinical trials for new drugs are more likely to be offered through the NHS as part of a research programme than through private health insurance.

Yes the clinical trials are NHS but there are ways of registering you as an NHS patient for the purpose of trials whilst still being a private patient. Certainly this is what happened with us. You’d prob need your consultant to be doing NHS work too and they’d put you into their NHS clinic alongside the private one. This was all at the Marsden so may be different elsewhere

Thesquaddogs · 07/02/2024 13:59

@MistressoftheDarkSide
Using anecdotal evidence from the 90s is harking back 30 years. The evidence today is that more people in the UK are surviving cancer than ever before. Again and again the message is to take advantage of screening programmes. If your FIL died of bowel cancer make sure your husband has regular screening. If you are concerned about yourself or elderly relatives for specific reason, request full bloods.
I think I am right in saying that clinical trials for new drugs are more likely to be offered through the NHS as part of a research programme than through private health insurance.

JenniferBooth · 07/02/2024 13:54

Thesquaddogs · 07/02/2024 08:17

@MistressoftheDarkSide
Did your stepfather take part in the FiT screenings for bowel cancer? The age requirement for the regular FIT screenings is down to 55 in parts of the country. If you look at Bowel Cancer UK forum, many of the new cases of bowel cancer are picked up through this. Early diagnosis is the key to curing bowel cancer.
So many people who complain about their treatment don't bother with the screening programme.

I tried phoning emailing my GP practice and even tweeting them. First e mailed them last May about a change in bowel habits. Still waiting although i think ive solved the problem It seems to be lactose intolerance. The point is though they still havent got back to me. People keep saying it but the patient blamers dont want to hear it THE PROBLEM IS GETTING PAST THE GP OR EVEN GETTING TO THE GP/ A BLOODY APPOINTMENT

CustardySergeant · 07/02/2024 13:36

Would you prefer he opt for treatment by the NHS? When he can afford to pay for private treatment? I'm sure he would be criticised for using the NHS when he can afford to pay and many people have commented that they know of cancer being diagnosed and NHS treatment starting immediately anyway.

Basically, he'll be criticised whatever he does.

Angrymum22 · 07/02/2024 13:35

I recently came across the NHS screening system for Hepatitis C.
its actually a disease that is difficult to catch apart from blood to blood contact but as a healthcare professional, where sharps injuries occasionally happen it is a real risk.
I ended up with a sharps injury while treating a patient with terminal cancer last year. I did the risk assessment and patient had a history of hep c. The advice is to wait 3 months before testing and accessing the test via occupational health is complicated. I was looking at private testing when I discovered the NHS site. I ordered the test, it arrived within 48hrs. I sent it back the same day and received the result in 24hrs. Fortunately it was negative.
There are a lot of tests available via NHS a) if you know where to look and b) if you are eligible.
I think that this form of screening will be the way forward since it cuts out the GP but the results are available for them to act on. So much time is wasted on the “worried well“. Simple screening would help the NHS free up time for the real sick and any abnormality is flagged up to the GP to act on. Even if a test isn’t available without referral a private system that allows patients to reassure themselves would help reduce the overload we are seeing today.

Chanxex · 07/02/2024 13:30

SalviaDivinorum · 07/02/2024 13:11

There are always restrictions of some sort - here is the BUPA "Cancer Promise" Plenty of limitations here.

  • With Bupa full cancer cover, there are no limits on how long your treatment lasts or how much it costs, for as long as you have Bupa health cover.
  • Some policies do have limits that you or your employer may have opted for. If you’ve opted to put a limit on your policy, we’ll cover costs up to that limit.
  • You’ll need to use a hospital from the Bupa network.
  • You’ll also need to see a fee-assured consultant. This is a consultant that we recognise and who charges within Bupa rates.
  • Everyone’s policy is individual. You may not be covered for some conditions or treatments. Check your cover documents or speak to us if you’re not sure.

You don't have the right to see any consultant of your choice and the best may not be a "fee assured" one and the experimental and trial treatments may not be approved

And for the most part you can navigate the system, travel and get what works best. Doesn’t always work but it’s a hell of a lot better than NHS. What my husband got privately was like a different world to what others with his rare condition were getting on the NHS from the support groups I was on

Chanxex · 07/02/2024 13:29

SalviaDivinorum · 07/02/2024 13:11

There are always restrictions of some sort - here is the BUPA "Cancer Promise" Plenty of limitations here.

  • With Bupa full cancer cover, there are no limits on how long your treatment lasts or how much it costs, for as long as you have Bupa health cover.
  • Some policies do have limits that you or your employer may have opted for. If you’ve opted to put a limit on your policy, we’ll cover costs up to that limit.
  • You’ll need to use a hospital from the Bupa network.
  • You’ll also need to see a fee-assured consultant. This is a consultant that we recognise and who charges within Bupa rates.
  • Everyone’s policy is individual. You may not be covered for some conditions or treatments. Check your cover documents or speak to us if you’re not sure.

You don't have the right to see any consultant of your choice and the best may not be a "fee assured" one and the experimental and trial treatments may not be approved

Except we did, and we did have full cover. Aviva, including all central London hospitals, we saw exactly who we wanted, when and where we wanted. I now have vitality and it’s EXACTLY the same.

SalviaDivinorum · 07/02/2024 13:11

Chanxex · 07/02/2024 09:52

That’s not strictly speaking true. Most private cover will cover all cancer treatments and follow up it’s only the most basic policies which might not. The treatment isn’t always the same. Privately the oncologists can offer a significant number of effective treatments which are standard of care across the world but not covered by NHS for cost reasons. They’ll often treat more aggressively too. They can often also use drugs off label if there’s sufficient evidence of effectiveness and they can provide evidence to the insurance company.

There are always restrictions of some sort - here is the BUPA "Cancer Promise" Plenty of limitations here.

  • With Bupa full cancer cover, there are no limits on how long your treatment lasts or how much it costs, for as long as you have Bupa health cover.
  • Some policies do have limits that you or your employer may have opted for. If you’ve opted to put a limit on your policy, we’ll cover costs up to that limit.
  • You’ll need to use a hospital from the Bupa network.
  • You’ll also need to see a fee-assured consultant. This is a consultant that we recognise and who charges within Bupa rates.
  • Everyone’s policy is individual. You may not be covered for some conditions or treatments. Check your cover documents or speak to us if you’re not sure.

You don't have the right to see any consultant of your choice and the best may not be a "fee assured" one and the experimental and trial treatments may not be approved

WhichIsItWendy · 07/02/2024 12:23

If you had millions £££ in the bank, would you deny treatment the same week as others don't get that?

Or are you suggesting everyone with cancer should get same week diagnosis and treatment? What if it means your taxes double? Or should they take money from other ailments to enable cancer to be well treated?

It's VERY easy to simplify an issue but cancer rates and healthcare demands have increased massively. If you want better treatment the money needs to come from somewhere.

The best thing we can ALL do to improve healthcare for everyone is take steps to stay healthy. Stop accepting obesity as a society standard. Cook better. Move more. Drink less. Smoke less. Reduce the demand.

TheFormidableMrsC · 07/02/2024 12:22

My surgery was carried out within 3 days of my diagnosis and my active treatment was seamless after that.

Rosscameasdoody · 07/02/2024 12:19

nappyvalley2024 · 06/02/2024 14:43

I thought there was a 2 week rule for cancer?

GP’s make a referral on the two week pathway if they suspect cancer. Not sure what the guidance is on the timeline of any subsequent appointment because my mum was referred on this pathway and actually waited six weeks for an appointment. It was then a further few weeks awaiting test results and another wait for treatment to start - overall it was around the three month mark from diagnosis to start of treatment.

Rosscameasdoody · 07/02/2024 12:13

Abracadabra12345 · 06/02/2024 20:11

I agree!

Why ? Why is it in poor taste when the fact that Charles has been diagnosed and started treatment within a couple of weeks perfectly illustrates that ordinary people are waiting longer and longer for cancer treatments, and in many cases that wait impacts their chances of survival. That’s what’s shameful.

Chanxex · 07/02/2024 12:07

fiftiesmum · 07/02/2024 10:22

Colleagues of mine have found it quite scary moving across to the private sector at how aggressively some treatments are used.
And it is the current government and not the NHS which restricts treatment by underfunding overall so budgets get limited and therefore only cost effective treatments can be used

And that’s unfair but the fact is that unless you have a common non stage 4 cancer you’ll get different and probably better treatment privately. An early stage breast / bowel / prostate cancer, yes treatment is likely the same but as soon as you add in anything advanced or less common you’re going to have a better chance of a longer life in fair health privately. Why do you think that Deborah James, bowel babe, had her stage 4 cancer managed for so long? She was a private patient at the Royal Marsden presumably with a stellar health insurance. No way would she have had half the procedures she had on the NHS

Crazycrazylady · 07/02/2024 11:17

Thesquaddogs · 06/02/2024 15:55

@Dinoswearunderpants
A statistic ofen quoted is that 98% of men with prostate cancer die of something else. It is generally not a killer. They are bound to treat bowel cancer first. One of the first things I did was go on the Cancer Forums for help and support and advice. They are brilliant.

Yip
My dads urologist told me that he he biopsied 100 80 year olds prostrate . 85 of them would show cancer cells but that it is such a slow growing cancer that something else would normally kill them long before the prostrate cancer did. He wouldn't biopsy as he said a) it's a horrible procedure with potential awful side effects and b) for lots of me there is significant impact of hearing the word 'cancer' at all regardless of prognosis.

So in your dads case an enlarged prostrate would not be unusual depending on his age and if there is something on his lung, it's more likely to have been as a result of his first cancer than his prostate

Crazycrazylady · 07/02/2024 11:02

It's not just Kc, treatment at any private clinic is faster than than public system. Unfair of course but hardly news.

Having said that recently I was seen within two weeks for a suspicious lump recently and had is aspirated and biopsied on the same day. I was incredibly impressed with my public treatment

fiftiesmum · 07/02/2024 10:22

Colleagues of mine have found it quite scary moving across to the private sector at how aggressively some treatments are used.
And it is the current government and not the NHS which restricts treatment by underfunding overall so budgets get limited and therefore only cost effective treatments can be used

Chanxex · 07/02/2024 09:54

SalviaDivinorum · 07/02/2024 09:28

Private health insurance comes with policy limits and the insurers have to agree to the treatment and the bills.

Even if you go privately, you won't get "the money no object" treatment that is available to the RF unless you are seriously rich and can top up thousands or hundreds of thousands from your own pocket. Cutting edge experimental drugs are usually not covered. There's a go fund me for some TV personality who wants a certain procedure that is £50K a go. He needs at least 3.

No many policies are not limited for cancer and will cover drugs you mention, I saw so many people find raising for treatments my husband was being offered as first line treatments.

Chanxex · 07/02/2024 09:52

fiftiesmum · 07/02/2024 09:48

Private health insurance will only cover for a limited amount of treatments then the cover runs out and people transfer across to NHS treatment (often under the same oncologist).
Their treatment will be exactly the same - but the sheer numbers of other patients means they will have to wait to be called and will not be happy

That’s not strictly speaking true. Most private cover will cover all cancer treatments and follow up it’s only the most basic policies which might not. The treatment isn’t always the same. Privately the oncologists can offer a significant number of effective treatments which are standard of care across the world but not covered by NHS for cost reasons. They’ll often treat more aggressively too. They can often also use drugs off label if there’s sufficient evidence of effectiveness and they can provide evidence to the insurance company.

fiftiesmum · 07/02/2024 09:48

Private health insurance will only cover for a limited amount of treatments then the cover runs out and people transfer across to NHS treatment (often under the same oncologist).
Their treatment will be exactly the same - but the sheer numbers of other patients means they will have to wait to be called and will not be happy

MinnieCauldwell · 07/02/2024 09:32

My cancer treatment started within 2 weeks of diagnosis, no complaints from me. Private health care would not have been much quicker and I would have had the same surgeon anyway.

SalviaDivinorum · 07/02/2024 09:28

Zanatdy · 07/02/2024 06:46

Same as people who have private medication insurance, Charles isn’t getting any special treatment over those others who choose to pay for private medical insurance. Life is full of inequalities, but maybe some people choose to pay for private medical insurance other other luxuries, maybe they forfeit holidays and TV packages, weekend wine and takeaways so they can pay that. Sure some people have no choice and can’t afford it but others choose not to pay for it and spend their money on other things. So they therefore they accept that if they are diagnosed with cancer they are at the mercy of the NHS. My mum waited 4 months before her surgery for bowel cancer, she could have paid to get seen earlier but chose not to (thankfully cancer was contained in the bowel and 10yrs on now no recurrence).

Private health insurance comes with policy limits and the insurers have to agree to the treatment and the bills.

Even if you go privately, you won't get "the money no object" treatment that is available to the RF unless you are seriously rich and can top up thousands or hundreds of thousands from your own pocket. Cutting edge experimental drugs are usually not covered. There's a go fund me for some TV personality who wants a certain procedure that is £50K a go. He needs at least 3.

Buckarood · 07/02/2024 09:13

MistressoftheDarkSide · 07/02/2024 08:47

Also - screening programmes are great if you know about them, can access them etc.

Way to go with victim blaming of the elderly. "Many GPs" isn't "All GPs".

What's the solution though? There has to be a level of self responsibility rather than expecting people to knock on the door to do the screening and then to Swan off. For those unable to manage their health and appointments etc you'd hope they have support; for those that don't which is sadly a lot then there are much bigger issues at play. The bowel screen is sent through the post and can be posted back, I wonder if uptake of that is better than those conducted at the GPs?

MistressoftheDarkSide · 07/02/2024 08:47

Also - screening programmes are great if you know about them, can access them etc.

Way to go with victim blaming of the elderly. "Many GPs" isn't "All GPs".

MistressoftheDarkSide · 07/02/2024 08:43

@Thesquaddogs

Was it available or widely publicised in the late 90s?

Swipe left for the next trending thread