Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Cancer inequality - Charles

281 replies

notknowledgeable · 06/02/2024 14:24

Obviously I know life is unfair, but even so I am stunned. Treatment starts the same week he is diagnosed? Most of us have to wait 2-4 months. And I don't expect he will be directed to food banks when the DWP repeatedly stuffs up his ESA claim either

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Shivermetimbers13 · 11/02/2024 11:10

The nhs should be funded enough that everyone is able to receive top quality treatment in a timely fashion

Agree 100%.

HelpIcantfindaname · 11/02/2024 11:06

When I was first diagnosed with Stage 4 bowel cancer I waited 2 months to start chemo. After I'd had a long treatment break because my liver mets were stable, a scan showed they'd trebled in size & I was back on chemo within 2 weeks.

Charles is the king. I'd be shocked if he didn't get better, quicker treatment than the rest of us.

FillFall · 11/02/2024 11:00

@SmashedPrawnsInAMilkyBasket

I definitely wasn't implying that people were lying about their experiences of cancer care. It was more that they are just highlighting the good bits of their care and not acknowledging any of the issues with the NHS.

SmashedPrawnsInAMilkyBasket · 10/02/2024 18:40

FillFall · 10/02/2024 17:45

Mumsnet is such a funny place. This thread has so many posters who have had positive experiences with the NHS and yet there are many other threads where the opposite is true. Here is a recent thread about how on earth can you get an appointment with a GP. As mentioned by PP's it's good that cancer patients are been seen quickly after referral but that's no good if you can't get to see a GP in the first place.

But those threads both reflect the reality of healthcare today. Nobody here is saying it’s not difficult to get a GP appointment; but they are giving examples of receiving fast and exemplary treatment for diagnosed cancer. The two aren’t mutually exclusive. The NHS is generally (and I say generally because nothing is true in all cases) still very good at providing fast and effective treatment for serious illnesses like cancer. The lack of GP provision is a separate matter and has a number of causes, only one of which is funding (another is taxation, which means GPs who work full time take home less than those who work three days a week). Both things can be true at the same time without it making Mumsnet “a funny place” (your implication being, I think, that people aren’t telling to truth about one thing or the other).

FillFall · 10/02/2024 17:45

Mumsnet is such a funny place. This thread has so many posters who have had positive experiences with the NHS and yet there are many other threads where the opposite is true. Here is a recent thread about how on earth can you get an appointment with a GP. As mentioned by PP's it's good that cancer patients are been seen quickly after referral but that's no good if you can't get to see a GP in the first place.

montelbano · 10/02/2024 14:36

To sum up:
First hurdle is getting a GP appt. That depends on individual surgeries.

Second: most cancers can present very differently. For some, it is immediately obvious that there is something serious going on. For others, the cancer can be hidden or the symptoms seem to suggest a different/minor problem. A process of elimination may be needed. ( in my case, I had a series of minor and varied symptoms, most of which I dismissed as too minor to trouble my GP. But, eventually something became troubling and the wonderful GP went into overdrive. She was magnificent. Two weeks of blood tests , ultrasound at surgery, put on emergency pathway and saw an oncologist and cardiologist within 10 days, armed with MRI and CT scans. Surgery within two weeks then chemo.
similarly , a friend had stage 4 breast cancer. The cancer did not show up on a mammogram which she had had 3 months earlier ( even the consultant could not feel it as it was so deep in her breast) but because of a seemingly unrelated blood test. The day after the blood test she had a call from a very stern oncologist Secretary that she had to see the oncologist that day and would not no for an answer...they almost had a shouting match til I chucked my friend in the car. She started treatment later that day.
.
Third: it does seem to depend on where in the UK you live and the individual health trusts.

Fourth: I have private health care but chose not to use is as , for me, the NHS was so quick and efficient ( am saving the private care for a knee op!)

Five: obviously the King would have private health care and access to the best treatment, surgeons and oncologists. He will be paying for it.
More importantly how could he be treated in an NHS hospital? There would be a real need for security in and around the hospital,and it wouldn't be just a case of hang onto his wheelchair. The Press outside would be a nightmare to control, block up access to A&E, other entrances, car parks, etc, making it a nightmare for patients, staff, and police.
A private hospital, used to treating VIP patients, would have procedures in place to coordinate with security and policing protocols. And, most private hospitals are quite small; much easier to deal with than a sprawling NHS hospital with multiple car parks, multiple entrances with little or no security, and thousands of staff and patients. Does anyone really want the Press roaming the corridors and wards, waylaying patients and staff, trying to get that 'oh, so important' picture that would sell for hundreds of thousands?

Six : I feel so lucky that I live in an area that ,for cancer, at least, I can get swift treatment. Am so sorry for those that are struggling, as, nowadays, many cancers can be successfully treated and others managed.

sorry this is so long.

Trinity65 · 10/02/2024 11:45

Rosscameasdoody · 07/02/2024 12:19

GP’s make a referral on the two week pathway if they suspect cancer. Not sure what the guidance is on the timeline of any subsequent appointment because my mum was referred on this pathway and actually waited six weeks for an appointment. It was then a further few weeks awaiting test results and another wait for treatment to start - overall it was around the three month mark from diagnosis to start of treatment.

I have been put on this regards a Endescopy.
Had an appointment due last Thursday so went there but they had to postpone it and I would get a call re a re book.
They did call yesterday and I am being seen on the 14th now (a day before it will have been 2 weeks since my Doctor appointment).
I did ask for a morning appointment but the Man said there wasn't any until the following week and I have to be seen Tuesday or they can be sued for being in Breach (of the two week pathway I presume).

I just want it done now as I am worried to be fair . I previously had a skin cancer.

Wonderfulstuff · 08/02/2024 19:47

I'm really glad that so many people have been seen and treated so quickly for Cancer. This is how it should be for everyone regardless of wealth. But please don't disbelieve those of us, like OP, who haven't been so lucky. It's more common than you might think at the moment.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-68240096

Nurse with patient making mammogram

Cancer waiting times in 2023 worst on record in England

Proportion starting treatment within 62 days in England drops to new low after 11 years of decline.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-68240096

Elphame · 08/02/2024 12:06

If you want someone to blame for the long waits in the NHS look at the tories who have underfunded it for years and consequently fucked it right up

Take a look at the Welsh NHS. It's in a far worse state than in England so don't believe for one minute that Labour will do any better. Things are only going to get worse.

Absolutely45 · 08/02/2024 08:00

Newchapterbeckons · 08/02/2024 07:47

What are you talking about! The tests are within a two week window. For everyone. The cancer pathway has been used very sadly by several members of my family and friends recently and all were within this time frame.

You said tests and diagnosis. That is my reply.

Stop with the endless pursuit of misery and chasing bad news. The King has cancer and this whole thread is fucking horrible and shameful.

My first reply said its right and proper KC got prompt treatment.

Anecdotal is great but its not everyones experience, the 2 week target is a referral target from GP to a specialist who will, if required put one on a waiting list for tests and treatment, that target is 62 days, often missed.

Seeing a GP is a bit of a mission too.

Report the thread if you think its Horrible and shameful.

cottontail24 · 08/02/2024 07:57

Haven't read the full thread but I've seen comments of a similar theme all over Facebook since the news broke. It's grim. And stupid. Of course he will get special treatment, he's the king! Anyone with money can choose to go private and get treatment much sooner. It's not fair, but it's life.

I find it so distasteful that rather than sympathising with someone whose just been diagnosed with this horrible disease people are jumping on him and attacking him for how quickly he's getting treated. Treatment which may or may not work btw, because cancer doesn't discriminate and no amount of money or status means he'll automatically be ok.

If you want someone to blame for the long waits in the NHS look at the tories who have underfunded it for years and consequently fucked it right up. Don't blame those who are able for whatever reason to get quicker treatment. If you were able to you would too. We aren't all equal and life isn't fair.

Newchapterbeckons · 08/02/2024 07:50

I am out of this thread because it says everything about a persons character to be so explicitly cruel. Cancer is a monster regardless of who you are - you will not be spared if it is aggressive regardless of how much money you have.

The coffin chasers on here fuelled by other peoples misery, fear and pain repulse me. It’s not okay.

Newchapterbeckons · 08/02/2024 07:47

Absolutely45 · 08/02/2024 07:44

@Newchapterbeckons thats the target to see a specialist in an urgent case, the target for treatment to begin is 62 days, which is in many cases exceeded.

The number waiting more than the 62-day target time for therapy in the past year has topped 69,000 across England

what is "Droid"? ah i see you removed that gem.

Edited

What are you talking about! The tests are within a two week window. For everyone. The cancer pathway has been used very sadly by several members of my family and friends recently and all were within this time frame.

You said tests and diagnosis. That is my reply.

Stop with the endless pursuit of misery and chasing bad news. The King has cancer and this whole thread is fucking horrible and shameful.

Absolutely45 · 08/02/2024 07:44

@Newchapterbeckons thats the target to see a specialist in an urgent case, the target for treatment to begin is 62 days, which is in many cases exceeded.

The number waiting more than the 62-day target time for therapy in the past year has topped 69,000 across England

what is "Droid"? ah i see you removed that gem.

Newchapterbeckons · 08/02/2024 07:38

Absolutely45 · 08/02/2024 07:35

Apart from the OP wasn't suggesting that at all.

Its right and proper he gets treated promptly but we should too.

Its a scandal we have to wait (on average) months for diags/tests and treatment, long term sickness is one reason we have so many people not working, who could be adding to the GDP of the country.

NB Averages mean some get treated sooner, others later before someone says "oh i got treated before i was even diagnosed..."

Edited

It’s 2 weeks for cancer my friend, not months.

Newchapterbeckons · 08/02/2024 07:37

pp sound positively disappointed patients aren’t being left to rot with cancer - and this might be one area of the nhs that is working well. Some are always looking for that bad news story. I like to think they are journos and not messed up posters looking for an endless doom loop.

Absolutely45 · 08/02/2024 07:35

CustardySergeant · 07/02/2024 13:36

Would you prefer he opt for treatment by the NHS? When he can afford to pay for private treatment? I'm sure he would be criticised for using the NHS when he can afford to pay and many people have commented that they know of cancer being diagnosed and NHS treatment starting immediately anyway.

Basically, he'll be criticised whatever he does.

Apart from the OP wasn't suggesting that at all.

Its right and proper he gets treated promptly but we should too.

Its a scandal we have to wait (on average) months for diags/tests and treatment, long term sickness is one reason we have so many people not working, who could be adding to the GDP of the country.

NB Averages mean some get treated sooner, others later before someone says "oh i got treated before i was even diagnosed..."

Newchapterbeckons · 08/02/2024 07:32

tothelefttotheleft · 07/02/2024 23:07

If you feel u to it the Guardian online is looking for peoples experiences who have been diagnosed with cancer the same week as the king.

How tasteful of the guardian

FillFall · 08/02/2024 07:29

It's good to hear everything is fine and dandy with the NHS and there was I thinking that it was on its uppers. 😶

tothelefttotheleft · 07/02/2024 23:07

Yoloohno · 07/02/2024 00:20

There is definitely, my dad was diagnosed the same day as the King had his procedure. Not his diagnosis.

He’s only a few months older, we’ve not even being given a treatment plan never mind starting it.

Sorry but why is one man worth more than another just because of a birth right.

If you feel u to it the Guardian online is looking for peoples experiences who have been diagnosed with cancer the same week as the king.

Niixky · 07/02/2024 21:26

I had a growth scan at 30ish weeks pregnant, they saw a shadow on my bladder with a blood flow on a Tuesday, referred me to urology that night, I got a call from urology the next day they booked me in for a cystosopy for that Saturday, saw a tumour believed to be low grade cancer, decided they couldn’t remove it until after I had my baby and it wasn’t urgent enough to risk my baby by getting him out then, I was induced so I didn’t go over, i had him on a Sunday was given 6weeks to heal from my emergency C-section and 6 weeks 1day after I had my boy I was in getting the cancer removed. Grade 2 bladder cancer at 28 extremely rare I didn’t have symptoms and it was all dealt with extremely quickly the only delay was my pregnancy. I’ll now have to get regular check ups to make sure it’s fully gone and stays away but my experience has been positive. I’m sure people do wait ages but I didn’t and that was fully through the nhs no private treatment. Private patients will always get seen sooner as the waiting lists are much shorter and they’re paying for the treatment. Obviously the fact he’s the King means he will get the best healthcare available the same with the other royals and celebrities/ the ultra wealthy who pay for that care.
The nhs should be funded enough that everyone is able to receive top quality treatment in a timely fashion

notknowledgeable · 07/02/2024 21:03

Thesquaddogs · 07/02/2024 08:17

@MistressoftheDarkSide
Did your stepfather take part in the FiT screenings for bowel cancer? The age requirement for the regular FIT screenings is down to 55 in parts of the country. If you look at Bowel Cancer UK forum, many of the new cases of bowel cancer are picked up through this. Early diagnosis is the key to curing bowel cancer.
So many people who complain about their treatment don't bother with the screening programme.

well, I have always taken full advantage of every screening offered, and it didn't help me

OP posts:
TheFormidableMrsC · 07/02/2024 17:42

I can add experience of private cancer care. My Mum was treated privately for oesophageal cancer. She had a nice room with an en-suite in a big London hospital. The insurance company wouldn't agree to a PET scan. Had she had it, she wouldn't have had to go through pointless and traumatic surgery because the scan would have revealed that the cancer was beyond anything but palliative care. They argued the cost of everything. I don't think it was worth it at all. She would have had the same treatment AND the scan on the NHS. As I said in a previous post, I could not have wished for better care during my own cancer journey and that was during the first year of the pandemic.

BashfulClam · 07/02/2024 15:37

2-4 months. My brother was operated on within 2 weeks and into chemo 2 weeks later as they realised he still had markers (they thought they’d got it all). Obviously it takes a few weeks to analyse the tests/scans and decide best treatments.

NewYearNewNameOldMe · 07/02/2024 14:38

His treatment may well be in a luxurious private hospital. He may well pay through the nose for it, where he will sit in a comfy chair in a beautifully decorated room while staff attend to his every need; cups of tea or coffee, biscuits from Fortnum & Mason, the latest copy of House and Hound by his side. That's what his wealth is paying for.

But if he's having chemo, the drugs dropped into his veins will be just the same as I had on the NHS and while I hope they are effective, I also hope he doesn't suffer the worst of the side effects because they are awful and can be life changing.

Not everything is better because you pay to go private.

Swipe left for the next trending thread