Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to not do Safeguarding training?

481 replies

Sausagenbacon · 06/02/2024 13:21

I belong to a church, and occasionally serve coffee at the end of the service. I am being asked to take Safeguarding training, which I think is utterly pointless.
I have expressed this and been told that it's policy, and I have to do it.
AIBU to just stop doing coffee?

OP posts:
scoobysnaxx · 08/02/2024 00:52

Hobnobswantshernameback · 06/02/2024 13:24

You think safeguarding training is pointless?
jolly good
probably best you stop volunteering if you can't understand why it's needed and helpful and how important it can be
how pathetically selfish

This.

Please stop volunteering.

The elderly are a vulnerable group who do need safeguarding and if you can't be bothered to do the training or worse, think it's POINTLESS, you have no business working with any kind of vulnerable client group.

NewName24 · 07/02/2024 23:36

There are changes afoot in Safeguarding and reporting which I don't think anyone has mentioned (apologies if I've missed it).

The onus will be on whoever witnesses any abuse or whoever is the person first disclosed to report it directly once the change comes in, rather than telling the Safeguarding Officer and hoping they will do something about it.

Here
At the moment, talking about child abuse - which, if the OP is helping after the service might well be something she needs to be aware of.

TempestTost · 07/02/2024 23:34

herewegoagainy · 07/02/2024 22:55

@TempestTost thank you for that post. It clearly outlines the issue.
I think at a minimum we should not be asking volunteers to do training when people being paid for the same task in a commercial organisation do not have to do the training. It is illogical and a barrier to expect more from volunteers than is expected from paid workers.

Yes, and I think it raises some questions about what insurance companies are doing too. How is it that Walmart - a store where many "vulnerable" people shop - doesn't need to ensure all of their employees have this kind of training in order for Walmart to have liability insurance? But small, often financially struggling, organizations do?

There is also a failure to understand that even in churches or charitable organizations, not all roles are the same.

NewName24 · 07/02/2024 23:30

herewegoagainy · 07/02/2024 20:53

@ThistleTits the minister will be around.

Not always.
The vicar is taking the service at my Church only about once every 6 weeks.

Many presbyters have 4 or more Churches

ftp · 07/02/2024 23:03

I am guessing that your safeguarding or local diocese are just tightening up, possibly given recent issues on this. It really does not take that long, and is certainly not pointless. As a Christian, I am sure you would want to help someone in need, and this will make you more aware and able to do so.

As a former church safeguarding officer, I would ask you the following:

  • are you alone with any vulnerable elderly (and that, sadly in legal terms, just means anyone over state pension age) or any other young (under 18) or vulnerable people
  • would anyone regard you as a person they could rely on or trust e.g ask you about finances, accept a lift home from you?
  • would any of them regard you as a friend, even if you do not really know them?
  • are they likely to invite you into their home as a result of meeting you in church?
Please be aware, that if you do chat to them, and have heightened awareness due to your training, you might well be in a position to notice something and help them.
Ilovecleaning · 07/02/2024 22:56

The fact that you think it is pointless suggests you shouldn’t be doing the job. Most of us have to do Safeguarding now - annual training and you have to pas every training course. You must do it or stop serving coffee.

herewegoagainy · 07/02/2024 22:55

@TempestTost thank you for that post. It clearly outlines the issue.
I think at a minimum we should not be asking volunteers to do training when people being paid for the same task in a commercial organisation do not have to do the training. It is illogical and a barrier to expect more from volunteers than is expected from paid workers.

Wouldprefertobereading · 07/02/2024 22:46

Except you have to understand and recognise potential issues to do so..…. for which you need the training.

TempestTost · 07/02/2024 22:29

ludocris · 07/02/2024 13:39

Again I find this such a strange attitude from the likes of @herewegoagainy and @TempestTost. So far the arguments against doing it are either the OP isn't going to see or hear anything she needs to refer on (weird assumption to make), it's a 'tick box' exercise (this suggests you think the training is too basic and something more is needed?) or, most oddly of all, 'if it's everyone's responsibility then everyone should do the training'.

In an ideal world, no one would need safeguarding training because abuse and neglect wouldn't exist.

Second best would be that no one needs training because everyone instinctively knows all the signs to look for and how to respond appropriately.

Neither of the above is possible so what we have is organisations trying to ensure that as many people as possible who might be in close contact with someone vulnerable get a bit of training on what to look out for.

Why on earth this is being touted as a waste of time/box ticking exercise/'stupid rule' is beyond me.

The argument is that there needs to be some real thought about who we demand gets training. You, and many others here, seem to be saying that anyone who might possibly come into contact with anyone vulnerable needs to have this training. Well - that is everyone. That's not a reasonable approach.

Maybe in an ideal world, we ALL have ALL the training. Every person who is not a hermit gets first aid, food handling (just in case), mental health first aid, DEI, whatever they are calling the do-not-sexually-harass people training these days, administering naloxone training, and more.

Except that's not really reasonable. You need to actually fit what you ask of people to their role. It might make sense to ask people doing the tea and food to get a food handling course. Or maybe even first aid - though in workplaces often the requirement is a certain number of people per shift should have some of these kinds of courses, not everyone, unless it really is directly their job.

Someone said volunteerism is being killed, and that is true. It is harder and harder to get people in these roles. And part of the reason is that there are more and more demands on volunteers to tick these boxes. It takes more time, it means people have to make themselves available at other times, etc.

There 10 minute online courses people are talking about are not doing much, if anything, other than ticking a box for the insurance company. It does however put barriers in the way of someone stepping up to do a simple job.

AnnieSnap · 07/02/2024 22:03

threatmatrix · 07/02/2024 19:40

I’ve owned restaurants etc and we have to do health and safety training but Jesus Christ getting the little old tea lady who’s doing a favour in the church to do training is ludicrous.
I wonder how many injury’s or deaths there’s been been throughout the years from the tea lady. Also most people working in places like Costa would have only been shown what to do by other staff.

You clearly misunderstand ‘safeguarding training’ 🙄 it’s not about the “little old tea lady” causing injury or death 🙄

pollymere · 07/02/2024 21:55

If you did the training perhaps you'd understand why it isn't pointless. You're actually in an excellent position for people to tell you things and you may find that people make disclosures which are a safeguarding issue. You could easily find out someone is being abused by their carer or children, or being taken advantage of by a neighbour. It really could make a huge difference.

Pandadunks · 07/02/2024 21:44

Why wouldn’t you do something that might help you spot the signs of when someone may need support or help I some way? Not everyone suffering or lonely makes it obvious. It’ll also allow you to understand what safeguarding is and isn’t - so you are confident reporting any concerns you might have about the behaviour of other volunteers should it be inappropriate.
it about protecting the vulnerable- whether they are very young or old or just people in need of support.
But if you aren’t interested then I guess you just stop helping out.

I volunteer and all our regular helpers have DBS checks too. Anyone who doesn’t want to do a safeguarding course wouldn’t be welcome anyway.

CandyflossKing · 07/02/2024 21:34

It's an online course. You don't even have to watch the whole thing - just skip through to the questions. Wouldn't take long at all! But if you'd rather not volunteer that's your prerogative.

Atethehalloweenchocs · 07/02/2024 21:33

*SudokuMania · Yesterday 16:58

"I think that volunteer work should not involve an unreasonable burden of training. So if the training is up to an hour, I would do it. But if it is longer than that, I would not do it."
My DH volunteered to help at an event. It involved children but he'd not be left alone with them and would be surrounded by other adults with the appropriate training.
The safeguarding course was 3 hours - longer than he'd be at the event itself.
He doesn't have time for that! So he had to pull out.'*

That is ridiculous @SudokuMania - it is not surprising there is a shortage of volunteers with these kind of rules.

Limenlemon · 07/02/2024 21:30

You should absolutely do it - it'll be quick, informative and worth while. I'm sure the Church would be sad to see you go, especially if you're cemented into the team.

Maybe you're doing yourself a disservice by thinking you 'just' do the tea/coffee!

Safeguarding training is something we should all do. Many positions whether paid or unpaid often require it as mandatory. And not only that, it often needs to be kept up to date - repeating it every 12 months indefinitely whilst you're in the role. You might feel at times you're repeating yourself, but it's always good to have a refresher.

Paid or unpaid, you are a part of a community based team, you should all be trained to the required levels necessary regardless of post.

I doubt the training would be too harsh, and you'd be supported to ensure you understand and pass the material required.

And as we Christians often do when we need guidance, pray on it.

Good Luck OP with what you decided.

ILoveNigelTufnel · 07/02/2024 21:28

Safeguarding is everybody’s business. Working with potentially vulnerable people, you need to know what signs to look out for and even if you do, safe guarding training needs to be updated every few years.

LolaSmiles · 07/02/2024 21:28

I know what safeguarding is. If someone discloses something when you hand them a coffee you say 'sugar is over there' and then refer the disclosure to a safeguarding officer. You don't get involved in a discussion, or start an investigation, or do anything else other than refer it
Safeguarding is more than what someone should do in the event a person makes a disclosure though.

Safeguarding includes noticing concerns, including any changes in the people you're interacting with, and knowing how to respond to disclosure, which includes how to navigate the discussion when a disclosure is made so that the person feels heard but you're not investigating or asking leading questions.

Safeguarding is also about good practice within roles throughout an organisation to safeguard volunteers and service user/organisation members as well as being vigilant for potential signs of harm. This is why organisations do, or should do, safeguarding refreshers so that the organisational culture is one that safeguards.people Vs a culture where it's viewed as a pointless tick box exercise because it's unlikely someone's going to disclose to me anyway, and if they did I'd just tell the safeguarding person so why should I have to do the training again?

DreamingofManderley · 07/02/2024 21:26

Safeguarding isn’t about passing. You hand coffee out to elderly people, what if you noticed something that would need to be reported? Safeguarding training is not pointless. It could potentially help you to help others if they need it.

zombie0037 · 07/02/2024 21:06

Thar not a very christian attitude is it?

herewegoagainy · 07/02/2024 21:03

@ThistleTits if it is C of E it is an online course, not face to face

ohfook · 07/02/2024 21:01

I have to do safeguarding annually as part of my job and I was asked to give up my Saturday to do safeguarding training for a voluntary role I do at a church. I have to admit my attitude was similar to yours and I really thought it was pointless but I did it anyway because I enjoy doing the voluntary role.

In the end I found it more interesting than I thought as the church safeguarding comes from a slightly different perspective to my work. I'm not catholic so I'm not referring to anything specific, but a huge part of it was ensuring mistakes of the past aren't repeated whilst also acknowledging that the church shouldn't turn its back on anyone so may end of having a duty of care to both a custom and a perpetrator. I expected it to be wishy washy but a lot of it was ensuring outdated attitudes were challenged and giving practical advice for where there was a conflict of interest - for example a woman escaping dv joins your congregation and weeks later so does her abuser, or you have children attend your church and you discover a member of the congregation has previously abused children. It also had a large focus on elder abuse as with aging congregations that is probably what you're most likely to come across so they want to know you know how to spot the signs.

Tldr:// I know it's really annoying but they do come at it from a different perspective to usual safeguarding and I think it's part of the church's drive to push out the turning a blind eye that so often happened in the past and reconcile their duty of care to all people with the need to keep the vulnerable safe.

ThistleTits · 07/02/2024 21:00

herewegoagainy · 07/02/2024 20:53

@ThistleTits the minister will be around.

It was more of a "what if." Unless it's time constraints or perhaps you think you have been away from learning for too long. It will be a very informal learning environment.

herewegoagainy · 07/02/2024 20:53

@ThistleTits the minister will be around.

ThistleTits · 07/02/2024 20:51

Really? No, you do not get "involved" as you say. What do you do if the safeguarding officer is not around. Do you say "awfully sorry, I haven't done the training and the relevant person is not around on a Tuesday?" As I said, there is a bit more to safeguarding than you are implying.

herewegoagainy · 07/02/2024 20:49

@justasking111 Lots of people have criminal records but would still pass a DBS. In most cases affront may be a cover up for being afraid of a DBS.