Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Could autism be caused by lack of sleep?

192 replies

sharptoothlemonshark · 06/02/2024 11:57

I don't mean the disrupted sleep all babies and toddlers put their parents through, I mean serious sleep deprivation at an early age. Or deprivation of one type of sleep.

With everything we now know of the need for adequate sleep for brain development, it makes sense that babies who do not get enough are not going to develop normally neurologically.

And many parents with children who have serious ASD report MASSIVE lack of sleep, well beyond normal

Anybody have any insights into this link? Which way round is the cause and effect? or could it be a vicious circle?

YABU - no, asd cannot be caused by lack of sleep/ my autistic child always slept well etc

YANBU - my autistic child was sleep deprived/ there might be a causal link between lack of sleep and going on to develop ASD

OP posts:
TigerRag · 06/02/2024 13:33

sharptoothlemonshark · 06/02/2024 13:27

I've worked in care or education of autistic children, and am aware of how many families seek respite care because of sleep issue, etc, and have often offered respite care myself. ( I am a foster carer as well as a teacher) I had an adopted daughter with ASD who is no longer part of the household - still in touch, but she lives in residential care now

I'm still waiting for a source?

MorningSunshineSparkles · 06/02/2024 13:32

I don’t have the capability to politely tell you how fucking offensive this is.

BusMumsHoliday · 06/02/2024 13:29

sharptoothlemonshark · 06/02/2024 13:15

we know sleep is needed for brain development, and that there is several types of sleep and they are all needed. so it isn't really much of a stretch to ask ok, so what does this impaired brain development look like, in a child who has NOT had the right amount of each type of sleep needed for brain development?

And I am asking, like autism? prehaps?

Oh yeah, now I see. You're "just asking questions". Questions that happen to feed into narratives about autism not being a real, unchangable neurological difference, but actually a fault of parents, or something fixable with snake oil. (Those herbal sleep patches Facebook keeps selling me?) Tale as old as time.

Please show me any study where lack of sleep shows deficits in social communication - which remains the core, essential criteria for autism diagnosis.

To add to the anecdata, my autistic DH and DS sleep pretty well. Myself and my probably NT DD sleep awfully.

TomeTome · 06/02/2024 13:28

HotToes · 06/02/2024 12:02

Being autistic is genetic, it's not caused by environment. It's nature not nurture.

I don’t think this is correct. I thought they had found some cases that had a genetic factor but it was a small group so more likely autism was part of their grater disability.

sharptoothlemonshark · 06/02/2024 13:27

PeopleWillAlwaysNeedPlates · 06/02/2024 13:23

Perhaps you could disclose your interest, OP. Are you parenting a ND child or a very poor sleeper?

I've worked in care or education of autistic children, and am aware of how many families seek respite care because of sleep issue, etc, and have often offered respite care myself. ( I am a foster carer as well as a teacher) I had an adopted daughter with ASD who is no longer part of the household - still in touch, but she lives in residential care now

OP posts:
CakedUpHigh · 06/02/2024 13:26

I don't think you're going to have any luck getting anyone to research this. Your hypothesis is extremely flimsy and has no basis in reality. Autistic children can have disordered sleep but it's not usually present in the baby years. Your sample size of 800 seems ok but as most people on here are telling you something totally different where did you find these 800 people?

birdssinging · 06/02/2024 13:25

sharptoothlemonshark · 06/02/2024 13:15

we know sleep is needed for brain development, and that there is several types of sleep and they are all needed. so it isn't really much of a stretch to ask ok, so what does this impaired brain development look like, in a child who has NOT had the right amount of each type of sleep needed for brain development?

And I am asking, like autism? prehaps?

Yes, I do think it is a bit of a stretch to think that, rather than a genetic predisposition causing autism and that possibly resulting in sleep disorders as a symptom, genetic predispositions to sleep both well and badly somehow result in the same neurodevelopmental pathology resulting in autism. A further big flaw is the use of retrospective observation. Parents with children who are diagnosed with autism are more likely to remember and attribute significance to their child's sleeping patterns than those without. What about all those who are not diagnosed with autism who sleep badly as babies (like lots of babies do) or who apparently also sleep very well as babies? What is your model for optimal and appropriate sleep? How many night wakings are normal? How much sleep deprivation is ok? What counts as sleep deprivation? What about babies who sleep well overnight but nap less in the day? What about the latter? What about those who wake up frequently to breastfeed rather than those who have longer undisturbed blocks of sleep? When is this damage happening?

What is your background and reason for this interest OP? If you are genuinely interested and / or speaking due to personal experience you should have done your research and have already realised how many you could upset and offend with this thread. If this is just an interesting thought you've had then I'm not sure why you're doubling down so hard when it's clear your thread is offending people.

sharptoothlemonshark · 06/02/2024 13:24

It is very interesting how many people are reporting an excessive amount of sleep in autistic children, this isn't something I hear much about. I suppose its parents of children who don't sleep who talk about it more, and ask for more help.

However excessive sleep also indicates something not working right, doesn't it, sleep has to be a balance of the right types

OP posts:
PeopleWillAlwaysNeedPlates · 06/02/2024 13:23

Perhaps you could disclose your interest, OP. Are you parenting a ND child or a very poor sleeper?

SleepingStandingUp · 06/02/2024 13:23

sharptoothlemonshark · 06/02/2024 12:24

Interesting how many people are reporting children with ASD who are having very abnormal sleep, but in increased length of sleep, rather than decreased. That also indicates that there is an issue with the balance of types of sleep

Because sleep issues are a symptom / side effect.

The brain changes that lead to autism will be happening in utero. So it's either genetic and caused and there's something heritable in the gametes or it's random mutation but a common one (like Downs Syndrome) or it's caused by something happening in the Mother so it's an epigenetic change.

DiddyRa · 06/02/2024 13:22

Congratulations. You’ve solved it. You can work on a cure for Autism. What’s next on your list. ADHD? Down syndrome?

FFS you are being very unreasonable.

EgonSpengler · 06/02/2024 13:21

My ASD DD slept through solidly from 3 months old. In fact, she slept so much in the daytime that I didn't bother with baby groups until 6 months as I found myself to be the only one singing 'Wind The Bobbin Up' to a comatose child.

ASD is genetic and I can see elements in both mine and my partner's families.

sharptoothlemonshark · 06/02/2024 13:18

fluffycatkins · 06/02/2024 13:14

It would seem very unlikely that autism could be prevented by making sure, through drugs if needed that babies sleep a lot.
Is this what you are suggesting OP?

It is also worth noting that other neurodivergence like ADHD is also associated with poor sleep, perhaps more than autism is.

well, no, I am not advocating sleeping pills for babies, not the current sleeping pills, which don't give a balance of the right type of sleep, even to adults

I am suggesting this is an area that needs more research, and there might be ways of helping babies sleep better, but it isn't researched at the moment, because it isn't a priority.

Interesting suggestion about ADHD too

OP posts:
WilmaWonka · 06/02/2024 13:17

My DTS2 slept from very well from birth all the way up to age 7/8.

In bed by 7pm, no sleep disturbances, unlike his NT twin brother who be up at least once a night from toddlerhood.

Then he couldn’t drop off no matter how much we ran him ragged! Tried melatonin but it only worked for a short period. As an adult now he’s nocturnal and sleeps a lot in the day.

How does that fit in with your hypothesis OP?

NT DD was also a nightmare sleeper. DH used to be worried he’d crash his car on the way to work as he was so sleep deprived as she’d scream for hours.

FanFckingTastic · 06/02/2024 13:17

I hate threads like this. What's implied is that it's somehow the sleep quality (or maternal health, labour choices, food eaten, supplements taken, medication used etc.) that are to blame for neurodiversity. What's also implied is that it's someone's 'fault' - usually the Mothers. Threads like this tend to be really ableist too.

EilonwyWithRedGoldHair · 06/02/2024 13:16

Sunnytimesarecoming · 06/02/2024 12:20

www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7999368/
Basically we don't know yet, but there could be a link between maternal health in pregnancy and some babies developing autism.

There is research showing that HG, pre-eclampsia and induction of labour all lead to an increased risk of the child being autistic. I had all three with DS - though I believe HG increases the risk of pre-eclampsia anyway, and pre-eclampsia is more likely to lead to induction.

(I should say I wasn't diagnosed with HG at the time, however the paediatrician who assessed DS was very interested in that aspect of my pregnancy and put that I'd had HG on her report so she clearly felt it met the criteria.)

Fionaville · 06/02/2024 13:15

My autistic son slept well as a baby and had a good routine. His autism didn't become apparent until 2 to 3 years when his stims became noticeable and his speech was delayed. His sleep only became effected when he got to about 4 or 5. Sleep problems are a symptom, not a cause.

sharptoothlemonshark · 06/02/2024 13:15

birdssinging · 06/02/2024 13:05

So your hypothesis is that those with autism start with a tendency to sleep too much or too little (based on an as of yet unknown correct amount of sleep) and both of these sleep disorders (at a certain threshold? and at a certain point of development?) result in the diagnosis of autism (as opposed to any other neurological or neurodevelopmental conditions?). So babies who don't sleep enough (is that just not enough hours period or does that include those who are very hard to settle but then do sleep?) don't undergo proper brain development and develop autism. Babies who sleep very easily and for long periods also develop autism (is that somehow through the same mechanism?). And somehow we don't see clusters of autism in certain societal groups based on differing sleeping norms but we do see clusters of autism in families. Sounds like there might be a more simple explanation there...

Edited

we know sleep is needed for brain development, and that there is several types of sleep and they are all needed. so it isn't really much of a stretch to ask ok, so what does this impaired brain development look like, in a child who has NOT had the right amount of each type of sleep needed for brain development?

And I am asking, like autism? prehaps?

OP posts:
fluffycatkins · 06/02/2024 13:14

It would seem very unlikely that autism could be prevented by making sure, through drugs if needed that babies sleep a lot.
Is this what you are suggesting OP?

It is also worth noting that other neurodivergence like ADHD is also associated with poor sleep, perhaps more than autism is.

BakedTattie · 06/02/2024 13:10

There’s no such thing as ‘mild’ or ‘severe’ autism op.

you're either autistic or not

IncompleteSenten · 06/02/2024 13:10

sharptoothlemonshark · 06/02/2024 12:43

This is what I am asking, the assumption has always been for decades, probably centuries, that there is a correlation, but correlation does not mean causation

But what if it sometimes does! and we carry on assuming it doesn't?

We still have not identified all the genes related to autism and how they all work and interact so it may well be that one of the genes that causes or predisposes a person to have autism there is also a sleep disorder element and that is why the two so often go hand in hand.
I believe this happens quite often in genes. Gene for x also controls y.

Let's assume there's a gene for autism that is also a gene for extremely disordered sleep. What then? Medicating someone to alleviate the symptoms of a genetic condition won't change the genetic condition.

I have autism. So do both my sons. Our sleep is bloody awful. If we'd been identified as having this theoretical gene at birth and had some sort of theoretical sleep aid would we then not have had autism? Well yes we would. Because help to sleep doesn't alter your genes.

Forgive me for being dense but I struggle sometimes to understand what people mean. Are you saying you think there's something that can be done? Are you saying if we could get good sleep we'd stop being autistic? Are you saying more research into the genetics of autism needs to happen?

TheSnowyOwl · 06/02/2024 13:09

Those who are autistic are born that way. One of my children, who is autistic, slept loads and loads as a baby/toddler/preschooler and it was only when getting towards the end of infant school that they were unable to sleep.

birdssinging · 06/02/2024 13:05

So your hypothesis is that those with autism start with a tendency to sleep too much or too little (based on an as of yet unknown correct amount of sleep) and both of these sleep disorders (at a certain threshold? and at a certain point of development?) result in the diagnosis of autism (as opposed to any other neurological or neurodevelopmental conditions?). So babies who don't sleep enough (is that just not enough hours period or does that include those who are very hard to settle but then do sleep?) don't undergo proper brain development and develop autism. Babies who sleep very easily and for long periods also develop autism (is that somehow through the same mechanism?). And somehow we don't see clusters of autism in certain societal groups based on differing sleeping norms but we do see clusters of autism in families. Sounds like there might be a more simple explanation there...

sparepantsandtoothbrush · 06/02/2024 13:04

And many parents with children who have serious ASD report MASSIVE lack of sleep, well beyond normal

Reported to who exactly?

CakedUpHigh · 06/02/2024 13:03

sharptoothlemonshark · 06/02/2024 12:05

The reasons for massively disrupted sleep could be genetic. And massively disrupted sleep is going to cause some problems in development, isn't it. Why might it not cause autism?

Because autism is present from birth.

Swipe left for the next trending thread