Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Could autism be caused by lack of sleep?

192 replies

sharptoothlemonshark · 06/02/2024 11:57

I don't mean the disrupted sleep all babies and toddlers put their parents through, I mean serious sleep deprivation at an early age. Or deprivation of one type of sleep.

With everything we now know of the need for adequate sleep for brain development, it makes sense that babies who do not get enough are not going to develop normally neurologically.

And many parents with children who have serious ASD report MASSIVE lack of sleep, well beyond normal

Anybody have any insights into this link? Which way round is the cause and effect? or could it be a vicious circle?

YABU - no, asd cannot be caused by lack of sleep/ my autistic child always slept well etc

YANBU - my autistic child was sleep deprived/ there might be a causal link between lack of sleep and going on to develop ASD

OP posts:
Tooolde · 06/02/2024 20:22

No probabpy not but
Both my dc sleep awful. No sleep for a year for dc1 until cio.
Dc2 didnt sleep till 3.5yrs and even at 9 has been always less than 10h

Both dc asd

Personally i suspect sleeping on back didnt help as reflux etc.
But also exclusive bf.
Teething was hell as even less sleep.

All the asd kids i know dont sleep well.

I think in order
Genetics
Older parents (either)
Prematurity
Smoking in previous generations
Possibly birth injury (ventuouse or forceps)
Parental blood sugar and perhaps baby (rates higher with pcos/diabetes/GD)
Air pollution??
Infections in pregnancy
Meeting more ND people at uni or at work..

hamjamwitch · 06/02/2024 20:17

Some people with autism don't produce enough melatonin. Same with ADHD. So sleep is difficult for them

RainbowZebraWarrior · 06/02/2024 20:12

C8H10N4O2 · 06/02/2024 19:26

For the love of Om. Monozygotic twin studies, even without concordant environments show high 90%s occurrence in the second twin if one has a diagnosis.

One line search in Google will take you to many, many proper peer reviewed studies from reputable scientific institutes along with meta studies repeating these findings.

Its genetic. There may be environmental factors which magnify/reduce effects in some cases but that does not mean environmental causation.

And when it comes to sleep deprivation lets face it - I get grumpy and suffer cognitive impairment when sleep deprived, just like most people.

This.

It has already been stated on this thread that sleep issues can be a feature of Autism, but not a cause. Stated by people with direct knowledge and experience of Autism and how it has either affected them or their children. It is obnoxious to seemingly apportion blame of lack of sleep - and infer therefore that parents are somehow to blame for not trying harder with their Autistic children in this vein - ergo screens, attachment, and any form of parenting in general. (as seems to be the case with the weekly Autism threads)

The AIBU currently stands at 92% You Are Being Unreasonable.

Why is it OK for certain posters to apparently 'idly wonder' about the 'cause' of this particular disability?

Why is it OK to suggest cures and therefore imply eugenics?

Why is it OK that the OP has not stated their intention or motivation behind these threads (given that they have history of similar) It's blatantly click baity, and I'm fairly sure I have enough awareness to realise myself that such titles are, and have been in the past, created specifically to be goady.

Why is it OK that at least half a dozen people have reported this thread, yet nothing has been done about it? Not worthy of deletion? Fair enough, but explain your reasons, MNHQ. Does it not even warrant a message to say something, anything, on behalf of the dozens of people on this thread that are disgusted with the ongoing attitude to Autistic people?

Why is it OK to repeatedly make parents feel like shit about our kids having Autism? We already shoulder the burden of probably passing it on to them unknowingly due to the pattern of many parents being diagnosed after we see traits in our own children. Yes, there's a pattern here. Yes, we are acutely aware, thank you. No, we do not want to go back to the bad old days of sterilising disabled adults. Again, eugenics.

Why is it OK that its always about Autism?

Why is it OK that some people are upset at the rise in diagnosis of Autism? Why and how does it affect them personally? Why do I feel like my life is being questioned? My daughters life is being questioned, and therefore our authenticity is being called into question?

Would MNHQ let this stand if it was questioning the validity or 'cause' of Downs Syndrome, for example?

Note: I specifically used Downs Syndrome in this instance, as I have experience of it. My sibling was born with Downs Syndrome in the 1973. The bigoted attitude and direct questioning of my mother along the lines of "what did you do wrong in your pregnancy?" I thought we had left behind in the 1970's.

I know MNHQ have been monitoring this thread. I reported it at lunchtime and received the ubiquitous "we are looking at it now" then nothing else. Oh but they were quick to delete the post calling out the OP in the strongest terms.

Ask yourself this (OP, and MNHQ) wouldn't you be offended if this felt deeply personal to you? Would you walk away? Or would you get angry and call it out? Why don't you see that it is blatantly offensive? Why don't you see that this is massively offensive?

Stop questioning things you know nothing about, OP. And start protecting disabled people as the law states, MNHQ.

Takacupokindnessyet · 06/02/2024 19:56

If it was categorically genetic, it would be diagnosed by genetic testing but it isn't, it is based on observation amongst other things and there is a vast spectrum of what comes under the diagnosis of autism so while in some cases it will be genetic they're will also be cases where other factors have affected the developing brain and resulted in the same type of characteristics. For example, prematurity, brain haemorrhage, lack of oxygen during infancy, also increase the risk of autism. Perhaps in the future when we know more about the genetics, autism will be further categorised but that level of understanding has not been reached yet.

Tumbleweed101 · 06/02/2024 19:44

I don't know loads about autism but I'm pretty sure with the experience I have had of autistic children that it's a fundamental part of that person, not caused by something such as sleep deprivation.

C8H10N4O2 · 06/02/2024 19:26

Takacupokindnessyet · 06/02/2024 18:35

Autism is not necessarily genetic.
From World health organisation.
"Available scientific evidence suggests that there are probably many factors that make a child more likely to have autism, including environmental and genetic factors."

For the love of Om. Monozygotic twin studies, even without concordant environments show high 90%s occurrence in the second twin if one has a diagnosis.

One line search in Google will take you to many, many proper peer reviewed studies from reputable scientific institutes along with meta studies repeating these findings.

Its genetic. There may be environmental factors which magnify/reduce effects in some cases but that does not mean environmental causation.

And when it comes to sleep deprivation lets face it - I get grumpy and suffer cognitive impairment when sleep deprived, just like most people.

Throckmorton · 06/02/2024 18:58

All I can say is I'm very glad there are proper researchers out there doing proper research into autism, rather than people like the OP trying to make the facts fit their pet theory.

Takacupokindnessyet · 06/02/2024 18:35

Autism is not necessarily genetic.
From World health organisation.
"Available scientific evidence suggests that there are probably many factors that make a child more likely to have autism, including environmental and genetic factors."

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 06/02/2024 18:22

Can we please stop trying to blame parents for their children’s ADHD or autism? It’s really not helpful.

CakedUpHigh · 06/02/2024 18:21

ElonsPsychic · 06/02/2024 17:33

I don't think so. It's interesting thought though.🤔

My hot and unpopular take on ASD is that oftentimes it's connected to early attachment; Mirror neurons etc. it's hereditary because interpersonal relationships that shape us go back multiple generations.

Maybe it's maternal lack of sleep?! How many mothers spend thier child's early years totally tired and poorly resourced? How can any mother on her knees with exhaustion attune to a developing child effectively?! I'd bet places that have a 'village' multi-generational living and observe the needs of early motherhood have less traits of autism showing up in populations.

So you are not being unreasonable! Maternal lack of sleep would be a factor

Not sure what you mean by hot be definitely wildly unpopular and thoroughly debunked along with all the other thoroughly offensive, ableist theories from the good old days when we used to lock up, neglect, sterilise and traumatise the disabled.

IncompleteSenten · 06/02/2024 17:48

ElonsPsychic · 06/02/2024 17:33

I don't think so. It's interesting thought though.🤔

My hot and unpopular take on ASD is that oftentimes it's connected to early attachment; Mirror neurons etc. it's hereditary because interpersonal relationships that shape us go back multiple generations.

Maybe it's maternal lack of sleep?! How many mothers spend thier child's early years totally tired and poorly resourced? How can any mother on her knees with exhaustion attune to a developing child effectively?! I'd bet places that have a 'village' multi-generational living and observe the needs of early motherhood have less traits of autism showing up in populations.

So you are not being unreasonable! Maternal lack of sleep would be a factor

Ahhh. The now very well debunked "refrigerator mother" theory.

Boy am I glad that nasty bastard theory died a death in the end.

pointythings · 06/02/2024 17:47

Well, my two had identical (good) sleep patterns. One is autistic. One isn't. Go figure.

TheShellBeach · 06/02/2024 17:35

So you are not being unreasonable! Maternal lack of sleep would be a factor

No, it wouldn't! That's just nonsense.

ElonsPsychic · 06/02/2024 17:33

I don't think so. It's interesting thought though.🤔

My hot and unpopular take on ASD is that oftentimes it's connected to early attachment; Mirror neurons etc. it's hereditary because interpersonal relationships that shape us go back multiple generations.

Maybe it's maternal lack of sleep?! How many mothers spend thier child's early years totally tired and poorly resourced? How can any mother on her knees with exhaustion attune to a developing child effectively?! I'd bet places that have a 'village' multi-generational living and observe the needs of early motherhood have less traits of autism showing up in populations.

So you are not being unreasonable! Maternal lack of sleep would be a factor

BusyMummy001 · 06/02/2024 16:58

onthisoccasion · 06/02/2024 14:21

I don't like the ASD is a super-power narrative one bit, but I believe our society benefits not suffers by having people whose brains work differently, who can bring other ways of thinking to art, science, technology etc etc I love the way my ASD child's brain works even if some things are harder for them, they don't need bloody curing.

The prevailing view from research is that autism IS genetic (with some research suggesting maternal health might be a contributing factor, not infant sleep), yet you think it's desirable to 'cure' or 'eliminate' autism. Do you think this applies to all genetic disabilities? Because, you know... if you want that the only way to achieve it is to stop people with those heritable conditions having children. Which js, in fact, cough eugenics

Like you I don’t like the ‘superpower’/I’m special narrative, but also hate the general misunderstanding around ASD - not all ASD people have educational needs for instance. Both of children are/have been severely impacted by their ASD leading to significant MH issues in my eldest (also ADHD). The younger one is less troubled and has worked hard on acquiring social skills and anxiety management strategies to have a nearly normal life and is hoping to study medicine eventually. Both did very well in exams, but the eldest is being homeschooled, is now a year behind, as 6th form was a nightmare for them.

I wish their lives were easier, that puberty/school had been easier to navigate, but I love them and value them just as they are.

TheCompactPussycat · 06/02/2024 16:25

sharptoothlemonshark · 06/02/2024 13:15

we know sleep is needed for brain development, and that there is several types of sleep and they are all needed. so it isn't really much of a stretch to ask ok, so what does this impaired brain development look like, in a child who has NOT had the right amount of each type of sleep needed for brain development?

And I am asking, like autism? prehaps?

I think your problem here might be in your assumption that the autistic/ND brain is somehow lacking/undeveloped/wrong and you're assuming the NT brain is properly developed.

How about just considering that there are different types of brain? Neither is "right" or "wrong". Neither is developed or undeveloped. They are just different.

Flowers4me · 06/02/2024 16:20

The idea that 'autism is a superpower' to describe the more able end of the spectrum, I find offensive and ignorant of the comorbidities that this group can also experience. My children may not have learning disabilities but their autism (and physical comorbidities) is a significant disability that is impacting on their ability to work and live independently. There is a lot of diversity across the spectrum but OP did not recognise that and instead used a flimsy argument to suggest that autism could be eradicated if a cause for it was found. If people want a measured debate then the OP should have been clear about why she felt that way and backed up her ideas about 'sleep' with evidence. She didn't so its not surprising that there was a reaction and suggestions that this post was written to provoke and upset others.

onthisoccasion · 06/02/2024 16:11

Sunnytimesarecoming · 06/02/2024 15:29

This is the problem with the current rhetoric. There's no middle ground between 'autism is a superpower' and eugenics. Can we not have decent balanced conversation about the possible co-morbidities and correlating factors of autism. All those who say 'autism is a super power' because you have a very high functioning child realise that there are many autistic children with profound disabilities who will never live independently. Some who are doubly incontinent. There are many in care. Do you think all those many children in care simply because their parents weren't able to cope with a severely disabled child, who have never had an attachment to anyone who wasn't paid to look after them, feel it's a superpower? Do you think my friend who is routinely booted, kicked, hit, bit, punched by her child feels it's a superpower? Do you think my daughter who just wants a friend more than anything and has crippling self esteem feels it's a super power?

Measured debate is fine when focused on informed facts; if the OP had been putting forward credible, peer-reviewed research I expect people would respond differently.

What the OP has done is thrown out a totally spurious hypothesis based on a total of fuck-all, which is extremely unhelpful with regards to understanding autism better, and is also fairly offensive in its thinking. The OPs suggestions are about as conducive to reasoned debate as me saying has anyone considered being called Kevin makes you more likely to have diabetes because there are lots of diabetic Kevins?

Catza · 06/02/2024 15:36

Sunnytimesarecoming · 06/02/2024 15:29

This is the problem with the current rhetoric. There's no middle ground between 'autism is a superpower' and eugenics. Can we not have decent balanced conversation about the possible co-morbidities and correlating factors of autism. All those who say 'autism is a super power' because you have a very high functioning child realise that there are many autistic children with profound disabilities who will never live independently. Some who are doubly incontinent. There are many in care. Do you think all those many children in care simply because their parents weren't able to cope with a severely disabled child, who have never had an attachment to anyone who wasn't paid to look after them, feel it's a superpower? Do you think my friend who is routinely booted, kicked, hit, bit, punched by her child feels it's a superpower? Do you think my daughter who just wants a friend more than anything and has crippling self esteem feels it's a super power?

We can absolutely have a measured discussion about co-morbidities, correlations and confounding variables. Unfortunately, the OP elected to imply direct causality despite having no evidence to support causal relationship or even a hypothesis of mechanistic pathway by which sleep deprivation "causes" autism. She also elected to pick autism specifically, ignoring all the multitude of neurodevelopmental conditions. Why? To stir trouble, I say.

Sunnytimesarecoming · 06/02/2024 15:29

This is the problem with the current rhetoric. There's no middle ground between 'autism is a superpower' and eugenics. Can we not have decent balanced conversation about the possible co-morbidities and correlating factors of autism. All those who say 'autism is a super power' because you have a very high functioning child realise that there are many autistic children with profound disabilities who will never live independently. Some who are doubly incontinent. There are many in care. Do you think all those many children in care simply because their parents weren't able to cope with a severely disabled child, who have never had an attachment to anyone who wasn't paid to look after them, feel it's a superpower? Do you think my friend who is routinely booted, kicked, hit, bit, punched by her child feels it's a superpower? Do you think my daughter who just wants a friend more than anything and has crippling self esteem feels it's a super power?

PeopleWillAlwaysNeedPlates · 06/02/2024 15:05

sharptoothlemonshark · 06/02/2024 13:27

I've worked in care or education of autistic children, and am aware of how many families seek respite care because of sleep issue, etc, and have often offered respite care myself. ( I am a foster carer as well as a teacher) I had an adopted daughter with ASD who is no longer part of the household - still in touch, but she lives in residential care now

Thank you, OP. I am going to take you at your word and assume that you are genuine. Perhaps there is an academic or medical discussion to be had here but it is utterly inappropriate for a parenting forum where most contributors (myself included) are too personally connected to the issue to enable a dispassionate discussion. I am sure there are many other discussion fora out there which would be more appropriate, although they are likely to have higher academic standards of evidence than you have been able to provide on this thread today.

Best wishes to you.

InterstateSpeed · 06/02/2024 15:04

Have you any medical or scientific training past A level?

You think OP was capable of getting A levels? I think the only thing OP achieved at school was being the queen of the mean girls committee and being that student remembered by teachers for annoyingly derailing lessons by chatting shit.

Caerulea · 06/02/2024 14:47

This smells a little bit like the MMR causes autism mindset, like needing to find a reason to explain why their child is 'broken', something to blame rather than accept some ppl just are autistic just like I am blonde & have size 7 feet.

WilmaWonka · 06/02/2024 14:41

I’ve often wondered why with my fraternal twins, one has ASD (between the mild and moderate end of the spectrum) with a mild intellectual disability and the other is NT with a high intellectual ability. We had no ASD in mine and DH’s very large families before DTS2, although DH’s niece was diagnosed a good 10 years later as a young child.

I did read years ago about blood flow to the placenta obviously affecting brain development which may be a cause.

My twin’s placentas were fused together and doctors were confuddled as it looked like only one despite them being fraternal. ASD DS was extremely skinny at birth and looked undernourished (constantly needed feeding as always starving for the first year then he overtook NT DS in weight and height) whereas NT DS was like a sumo wrestler a birth! I’ve always though NT DS definitely got more blood flow than ASD DS.

I’m a vegetarian so blamed myself for a bit thinking I didn’t absorb enough iron to sustain twins, took pregnancy vits but still wouldn’t have absorbed much iron from them. Iron count was never low enough to be prescribed supplements though.

Another thing I read was pregnancies close together depleting nutrition to subsequent pregnancies as I had a stillbirth 2 months before my twins were conceived. Suppose stress and trauma would have had an effect on the body too. Although that doesn’t explain 1st pregnancies resulting in ASD children.

Thyroid function as well. I had symptoms of under active thyroid for years before I was finally given medication. There may be a case for thyroid function testing as a pre-natal check for child bearing age women as there is research that under active thyroid can have an effect on the foetus as needed for brain development. Under active thyroid is apparently more prevalent now as well, more chemicals in environment.

It would be interesting to gather information nationwide from willing mums of ASD children about their pregnancies, diet (any food groups excluded from diet having a correlation), if babies born at lower birthweight etc but that would obviously be very expensive to set up and could be perceived as casting blame I suppose. It would be helpful to exclude possibilities other than genetics though.

TheShellBeach · 06/02/2024 14:40

I'm autistic and my superpower is spotting and reporting goady bollocks threads like this one.