Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Doctors right to strike, should it be removed?

737 replies

DistinguishedSocialCommenator · 06/02/2024 09:49

Hello
Several people within our families are doctors. Most started out wanting to care for people, but as time goes on, the reality of money, and spending comes into play for some.

PM Rishi Sunak in a tv interview partly balmed doctors strikes for failing to bring down hospital waiting lists. I rarely agree with a politician but in this case, I know he is right. EG, myself, my OH, one of our children and grandchildren have had their appointments cancelled because of strike impacts. Our children and grandchildren do have private healthcare but those do not cover pre-existing or you end up on the NHS with chorionic conditions.

Our police officers and armed forces personnel are not allowed to strike

AIBU to expect a no-strike agreement for doctors and possibly nurses. If agreed, give them 9 months' notice about no-strike agreements. I honestly believe hardly anyone would leave and those leaving would have possibly left the NHS anyway as some do and go to another country just like we get doctors from abroad. Their pay claims could be easily managed in the same way police/armed forces pay rises are managed as well of those MP's.

Failing to bring down hospital w/l lies with the present government and the growing of these waiting lists, the doctor's strikes have certainly made things a lot worse. We are regularly hearing on our news media about growing waiting lists and people waiting for urgent treatments and the waiting times in A&E departments etc

AIBU to feel that doctors should be made to sign a no-strike agreement with a few month's notice to have the no-strike agreement in place before next winter? Also, have a pay body set up like the ones our MP's enjoy.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
37
kintra · 06/02/2024 13:35

DistinguishedSocialCommenator · 06/02/2024 13:32

In an ideal world, yes!! In the real world, no.
As I said before, I'm aware you can't strike in certain professions and those joining are aware.

If I was younger and wanted to train up as a doctor, TBH, I'd look at the pay and conditions, no-strike clause if any and any madatory working agreements post qualifications and make a decision

Bully for you. It would be interesting to come back to this post in 15 years and compare current T&Cs with the 2039 T&Cs. I suspect they'll be very different (if there even is still an NHS). I mean you're saying yourself they should implement a no-strike clause - someone could have spent the past 10 years studying to be a doctor and you'd spring that on them? I also think this is a pisstake as you're undermining your own argument

republicofjam · 06/02/2024 13:34

DistinguishedSocialCommenator · 06/02/2024 13:21

If that is the case, may I politely ask if those joining to train up as new doctors have their heads buried in the sand? IE not aware of the T&C's and long hours?

TBH, there should be new rules where we the state taxpayers fund new doctors' training to an extent, after qualifying to be made to work for the NHS for an X amount of time and this applies to other NHS staff as well ie nurses etc. Why should taxpayers fork out millions every year for someone to get trained and then go and work in another country without giving something back. That is not an unreasonable expectation!.

If I was going to train in a profession, I'd be naive not to consider, and investigate payscales, prospects, working conditions etc it is really as simple as that.

My idea is not new - this idea was rightly talked about by the respected Mr Jeremy Hunt - see below and why not?

https://www.gponline.com/doctors-face-four-year-mandatory-nhs-service-jeremy-hunt-expands-medical-training/article/1410975

Other than the Tory faithful who exactly is Jeremy Hunt respected by?

DistinguishedSocialCommenator · 06/02/2024 13:34

Kosenrufugirl · 06/02/2024 13:30

The difference is that doctors and nurses ARE leaving the profession.

So are doctors and nurses in other countries that come to the UK to work.

This is not a new scenario and has been the case for years and applies to most countries.

OP posts:
itstooearlytobeawake · 06/02/2024 13:33

Have you ever worked on the wards?
We have no staff, it's dangerous. Doctors/nhs staff various bands we all need paying more to make people actually want to work for us. The low staffing levels are what's dangerous. It's scary.

DistinguishedSocialCommenator · 06/02/2024 13:32

Deathbyfluffy · 06/02/2024 13:28

Everyone should have the right to strike, regardless of job.

In an ideal world, yes!! In the real world, no.
As I said before, I'm aware you can't strike in certain professions and those joining are aware.

If I was younger and wanted to train up as a doctor, TBH, I'd look at the pay and conditions, no-strike clause if any and any madatory working agreements post qualifications and make a decision

OP posts:
Kosenrufugirl · 06/02/2024 13:30

DistinguishedSocialCommenator · 06/02/2024 13:10

Please quote the "human right" you are referring to

When I worked for the council, we had a pay freeze for three years I think. Many banged on about they'd leave. Not a single person left in my department during those three years. I can't recall if it was before the pay freeze or after but car allowances were to be drastically reduced. As our team went to people's homes in a big borough many said they'd work to rule and travel by public transport and I said I would not. Guess what, when the reduction in car allowance came, not a single member of staff that used a car used public transport.

The difference is that doctors and nurses ARE leaving the profession.

LWSnow · 06/02/2024 13:30

DistinguishedSocialCommenator · 06/02/2024 13:26

It's not the front line staff that need sorting,

As I said before and I reiterate, NHS just like other professions always has and will have a turn-over of staff - that is the real world., people do move on

I also reiterate and no one has been able to answer this, are people joining the NHS not aware of what to expect??

My DC started training 11 years ago, still a junior Dr. They expected excellent pay and conditions , which were good at the time they went to uni. I'm not sure they'd have gone if they d have known it would stagnate and conditions worsen.
so absolutely, 11 years ago they did not expect this shit show.

noblegiraffe · 06/02/2024 13:30

My idea is not new - this idea was rightly talked about by the respected Mr Jeremy Hunt

Oh, you are joking, OP!!! This whole thread is just a pisstake because surely no one would seriously call Jeremy “his own rhyming slang” Hunt ‘respected’.

DistinguishedSocialCommenator · 06/02/2024 13:30

Teajenny7 · 06/02/2024 13:22

No. They should be allowed to strike.
Most the younger Doctors and Nurses I know are seriously thinking of going to New Zealand

Hence the mandatory clause that I posted about. Why should we the taxpayers train someone for 5 years and then they go to another country?

I refer you to my post made at 13-16hrs.

People moving jobs and going to another country is nothing new, trust me it happens all over the world hence the professionals we get from Australia , India, New Zealand, ie doctors, nurses, ot's, pt, and radiologists to name a few.

OP posts:
Lassiata · 06/02/2024 13:28

@DistinguishedSocialCommenator suspect you're just on a wind-up here but whatever they join expecting, they SHOULDN'T be working under those conditions. Nor should teachers be working the hours they do for the money they do. Mineral miners in unsafe mines in Africa know what they're getting into but that doesn't make it right.

Deathbyfluffy · 06/02/2024 13:28

Everyone should have the right to strike, regardless of job.

justteanbiscuits · 06/02/2024 13:27

DistinguishedSocialCommenator · 06/02/2024 13:21

If that is the case, may I politely ask if those joining to train up as new doctors have their heads buried in the sand? IE not aware of the T&C's and long hours?

TBH, there should be new rules where we the state taxpayers fund new doctors' training to an extent, after qualifying to be made to work for the NHS for an X amount of time and this applies to other NHS staff as well ie nurses etc. Why should taxpayers fork out millions every year for someone to get trained and then go and work in another country without giving something back. That is not an unreasonable expectation!.

If I was going to train in a profession, I'd be naive not to consider, and investigate payscales, prospects, working conditions etc it is really as simple as that.

My idea is not new - this idea was rightly talked about by the respected Mr Jeremy Hunt - see below and why not?

https://www.gponline.com/doctors-face-four-year-mandatory-nhs-service-jeremy-hunt-expands-medical-training/article/1410975

The government don't fork out millions every year getting people trained. After 5 years at medical school (5 hour drive from his family as accommodation up north is so much cheaper) he has £80k of student debt. This was with substantial help from his parents.

He now faces spending around £3k a year on his continuing education when earning under £30k as an FY1. Plus his professional memberships.

he went into medicine with rose tinted spectacles. As every 18 year old does. I counselled him very very strongly against it.

The whole "they knew what they were getting themselves into" is utter crap. We need to encourage people into medicine, not discourage them.

Lassiata · 06/02/2024 13:26

They are partly striking in protest at unsafe working conditions. If you take away that voice for them, you are making us all less safe.

LWSnow · 06/02/2024 13:26

This is also a feminist issue. As soon as a profession becomes more than 50% female. Employers start to take the piss on pay and conditions. Thankfully these women and men are standing up for themselves.

DistinguishedSocialCommenator · 06/02/2024 13:26

LWSnow · 06/02/2024 12:57

Each strike costs more than paying the requested increase
this is political not financial.
Anyine fancy the American system? That's what we'll get if Drs aren't paid and treated better. They'll al leave and the private health insurers will move in. And actually Drs will be better off, but strangely they are fighting to keep the NHS.

It's not the front line staff that need sorting,

As I said before and I reiterate, NHS just like other professions always has and will have a turn-over of staff - that is the real world., people do move on

I also reiterate and no one has been able to answer this, are people joining the NHS not aware of what to expect??

OP posts:
ilovebreadsauce · 06/02/2024 13:24

Police can't strike, armed forces can't strike, certain government departments like m15 can't strike.

plominoagain · 06/02/2024 13:24

No , police officers are not allowed to strike . That's why we're all leaving instead . And the new ones recruited to great fanfare , are now practically running away in their droves .

Yes , we knew what we signed up for . and now we're signing out .

PictureALadybird · 06/02/2024 13:24

Yes, it should be removed. If they care about people as much as they say they do then they wouldn’t jeopardise patient lives in the first place.

Teajenny7 · 06/02/2024 13:22

No. They should be allowed to strike.
Most the younger Doctors and Nurses I know are seriously thinking of going to New Zealand

Nicebloomers · 06/02/2024 13:22

Fully support the right to strike.

DistinguishedSocialCommenator · 06/02/2024 13:22

Sdpbody · 06/02/2024 13:06

Police officers are not allowed to strike. I think it is really unfair.

When a person joins the police force, they are fully aware of their T&C, right?

OP posts:
justteanbiscuits · 06/02/2024 13:21

SillyBilly1993 · 06/02/2024 10:16

YANBU. I wonder whether the people saying YABU would be happy if a relative of theirs lost their life because a key worker was on strike to get more money?

GPs’ starting salary is £70k, the average nurse earns £37k. They seem like good salaries to me! Ultimately if NHS staff don’t like their jobs and their salaries then they can vote with their feet and leave, which is what the rest of us do.

A GP's starting salary may be £70k. (It isn't because GP salaries aren't controlled by the NHS as the vast vast majority of GP surgeries are individual businesses). But they will have done 5 years at University, and around 6 years of further training on £30k-£40k. They will be paying for their own additional training and exams, and will have been moved all round the country during the FY years with no real say in where they are moved. A GP will also be working 60-70 hours a week with next to zero work life balance. They will also literally have peoples lives in their hands.

DistinguishedSocialCommenator · 06/02/2024 13:21

AnnaMagnani · 06/02/2024 10:51

When I was 18 I thought being a doctor was a vocation.

Now I am 48, and gone through the PTSD, I do not. I think it is a job and a crap one at that.

I don't blame the junior doctors for striking, their lives are miserable and the money they get is not worth it.

If that is the case, may I politely ask if those joining to train up as new doctors have their heads buried in the sand? IE not aware of the T&C's and long hours?

TBH, there should be new rules where we the state taxpayers fund new doctors' training to an extent, after qualifying to be made to work for the NHS for an X amount of time and this applies to other NHS staff as well ie nurses etc. Why should taxpayers fork out millions every year for someone to get trained and then go and work in another country without giving something back. That is not an unreasonable expectation!.

If I was going to train in a profession, I'd be naive not to consider, and investigate payscales, prospects, working conditions etc it is really as simple as that.

My idea is not new - this idea was rightly talked about by the respected Mr Jeremy Hunt - see below and why not?

https://www.gponline.com/doctors-face-four-year-mandatory-nhs-service-jeremy-hunt-expands-medical-training/article/1410975

Doctors face four-year mandatory NHS service as Jeremy Hunt expands medical training

New doctors will be obliged to work for the NHS for a minimum of four years after graduation under plans to expand medical school places by a quarter from 2018.

https://www.gponline.com/doctors-face-four-year-mandatory-nhs-service-jeremy-hunt-expands-medical-training/article/1410975

OP posts:
prescribingmum · 06/02/2024 13:19

DistinguishedSocialCommenator · 06/02/2024 13:10

Please quote the "human right" you are referring to

When I worked for the council, we had a pay freeze for three years I think. Many banged on about they'd leave. Not a single person left in my department during those three years. I can't recall if it was before the pay freeze or after but car allowances were to be drastically reduced. As our team went to people's homes in a big borough many said they'd work to rule and travel by public transport and I said I would not. Guess what, when the reduction in car allowance came, not a single member of staff that used a car used public transport.

That's nice for you but the reality in healthcare is staff are actually leaving, not making empty threats. The countless vacancies up and down the country clearly reflect this. The government are paying out millions for last minute locum shifts each year because the vacancy rate is so high.

The government refused to even come to the table and discuss pay at first. They have shown utter contempt for the staff and yet you are saying it is acceptable for them to remove the right for staff to withdraw their labour.

thedankness · 06/02/2024 13:16

Doctors have a pay review body called the DDRB which has consistently recommended such low uplifts that has resulted in doctors having disproportionate pay erosion in real terms relative to other healthcare workers and private sector workers over the past 15 years. Last year a Tory backbencher also admitted that the supposedly independent DDRB was rigged i.e. the government told them what the budget was before they produced their "independent" report.

The doctors' strikes came about because in 2022 the BMA (the doctors' union) asked the government for pay negotiation but the government refused any talks unless there was a strike mandate brought by the BMA. The government invited the strikes essentially. This is the nature of negotiation with the government.

https://inews.co.uk/news/politics/rishi-sunak-threat-cabinet-revolt-public-
sector-pay-rises-2473529

https://news.sky.com/story/junior-doctors-strike-set-for-march-if-industrial-action-approved-as-unite-confirms-walkout-by-ambulance-workers-12780979

Rishi Sunak faces threat of Cabinet revolt over record public sector pay rises

The PM and Chancellor will make a decision shortly on whether to accept the independent recommendation of pay rises totalling 6% or more for many public-sector workers

https://inews.co.uk/news/politics/rishi-sunak-threat-cabinet-revolt-public-sector-pay-rises-2473529