Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Doctors right to strike, should it be removed?

737 replies

DistinguishedSocialCommenator · 06/02/2024 09:49

Hello
Several people within our families are doctors. Most started out wanting to care for people, but as time goes on, the reality of money, and spending comes into play for some.

PM Rishi Sunak in a tv interview partly balmed doctors strikes for failing to bring down hospital waiting lists. I rarely agree with a politician but in this case, I know he is right. EG, myself, my OH, one of our children and grandchildren have had their appointments cancelled because of strike impacts. Our children and grandchildren do have private healthcare but those do not cover pre-existing or you end up on the NHS with chorionic conditions.

Our police officers and armed forces personnel are not allowed to strike

AIBU to expect a no-strike agreement for doctors and possibly nurses. If agreed, give them 9 months' notice about no-strike agreements. I honestly believe hardly anyone would leave and those leaving would have possibly left the NHS anyway as some do and go to another country just like we get doctors from abroad. Their pay claims could be easily managed in the same way police/armed forces pay rises are managed as well of those MP's.

Failing to bring down hospital w/l lies with the present government and the growing of these waiting lists, the doctor's strikes have certainly made things a lot worse. We are regularly hearing on our news media about growing waiting lists and people waiting for urgent treatments and the waiting times in A&E departments etc

AIBU to feel that doctors should be made to sign a no-strike agreement with a few month's notice to have the no-strike agreement in place before next winter? Also, have a pay body set up like the ones our MP's enjoy.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
37
Kosenrufugirl · 07/02/2024 10:07

DistinguishedSocialCommenator · 07/02/2024 09:51

Thank you.
In an ideal world, this would not have happened.
The story you post, it is happening to millions of others and not just the police force staff.

I worked for 2 local councils. We too lost that, had a pay freeze for 3 years I think (can't exactly recall as it was years ago) and lost most of our car allowance, which was called "essential car users allowance" as when staff started the employers knew it was essential to have a car as you could be more effective

Looking back 30 years like what you have said, millions have lost out and contracts are not worth the paper they were written on

Though I'm being affected by final pensions stuff which i dont really understand other than getting lesss - if things stayed the way they were - trust me inflation would be massive and those that left work now or a few years ago and built up a small next egg for rainy days, they money would become worthless with hyper inflation - Just look what happend at 11% inflation

Jeremy Hunt first announced the war on doctors in 2016. There were just about enough doctors to keep patients SAFE on the weekends. He wanted to make the existing doctors workforce stretch themselves over 7 days. E.g. elective surgeries taking place on the weekends. Without paying extra. Even Public Accounts Committee said the Government had "no coherent strategy" how to make 7 days service happen without extra funding. The doctors were already doing 14-15 hours shifts without breaks and they rebelled. The same for nurses. It went all downhill from then. Inflation was 2%. You really need to educate yourself. Dr Clarke wrote a very lucid account of those days in her book Your Life is in My Hands or a Junior Doctor Story. Jeremy Hunt had no guts to even have a public debate with doctors. Even when they resorted to camping 24/7 at the doorstep of his office. The man has so much contempt for NHS, the sooner he is out of Government the better. Looking forward to the election

DistinguishedSocialCommenator · 07/02/2024 09:55

FatPrincess · 07/02/2024 08:15

What I was going to say. If they're told they can't strike and their conditions don't improve (because no inconvenience being caused likely = no action taken) well, they'll just leave or go private/abroad.

That is historical people going abroad and many move abroad as they gfeel there is less crime, less stress as do the many that move to England/UK for a better life as do our doctors, nurses - its swings and roundabouts and always has been and will be.

Look at our PM/Rishi. He had a Green card to move to the USA - are you telling me he is having financial difficulties? Just an example some people will move as they want to move to another country for various reasons,

OP posts:
DistinguishedSocialCommenator · 07/02/2024 09:51

Sdpbody · 07/02/2024 09:38

Do you mean when they joined 20 years ago on very good salaries with 30,000 more police officers with no cyber crimes.

The Police my DH signed up to, is not the current situation. He lost his good final salary that was promised, he lost his 30 years service which is now 35. Every other Public Service can strike for better pay and conditions. The Police can't.

Thank you.
In an ideal world, this would not have happened.
The story you post, it is happening to millions of others and not just the police force staff.

I worked for 2 local councils. We too lost that, had a pay freeze for 3 years I think (can't exactly recall as it was years ago) and lost most of our car allowance, which was called "essential car users allowance" as when staff started the employers knew it was essential to have a car as you could be more effective

Looking back 30 years like what you have said, millions have lost out and contracts are not worth the paper they were written on

Though I'm being affected by final pensions stuff which i dont really understand other than getting lesss - if things stayed the way they were - trust me inflation would be massive and those that left work now or a few years ago and built up a small next egg for rainy days, they money would become worthless with hyper inflation - Just look what happend at 11% inflation

OP posts:
Sdpbody · 07/02/2024 09:38

DistinguishedSocialCommenator · 06/02/2024 13:22

When a person joins the police force, they are fully aware of their T&C, right?

Do you mean when they joined 20 years ago on very good salaries with 30,000 more police officers with no cyber crimes.

The Police my DH signed up to, is not the current situation. He lost his good final salary that was promised, he lost his 30 years service which is now 35. Every other Public Service can strike for better pay and conditions. The Police can't.

FatPrincess · 07/02/2024 08:15

CasperGutman · 06/02/2024 09:57

YABU. We don't have live in a totalitarian communist planned economy where the government decides what jobs people are allocated. If doctors aren't allowed to withdraw their labour temporarily to demonstrate their dissatisfaction with their pay and conditions then ultimately they will leave the profession and we will fail to attract enough good quality entrants.

We already have a shortage of doctors, and it's becoming less and less attractive as a career to go into. Bashing doctors and driving their pay down is not the way to solve any of the issues in the British healthcare system.

What I was going to say. If they're told they can't strike and their conditions don't improve (because no inconvenience being caused likely = no action taken) well, they'll just leave or go private/abroad.

mumsneedwine · 07/02/2024 08:11

And now they also gave to pay back £250,000 in student loan. Not sure how anyone is paying for their 'training'.

FixTheBone · 07/02/2024 08:09

DistinguishedSocialCommenator · 06/02/2024 20:15

Thank you, I appreciate that

I've posted before, it is historical people will want to move to another country for a better life

You may recall years ago nurses started going to Saudia Arbia and Dubia, but it was short-lived.

One of our children as a specialist if IT moved to the USA, they had a great job here but half the pay and their salary is.was in top 5% - however, they did get double the money but the family was in England so returned

Sorry, not "everyone is going the other way." and you in your post has demonstrated that.

I posted at 13-16 today a link re madatory retention of newly qualified staff sdocs on the whole - if we the taxpayers are paying for their training in my view they should work here for x number of years - read my post at 13-16 I think it was and a new item from Jeremey Hunt the then health secretary.

I still dispute that the public 'paid for my training'...

85%+ of my time was spent delivering patient care during my time before being a consultant. That is delivering the same care that the consultant would have done, for half the cost on daytime hours, and a quarter of the cost it would be to have an army of consultants available 24/7 out of hours.

If you're going to tie me to the NHS for 10 years on the premise of we're paying to train you, then I expect to spend my time being trained, not delivering routine service provision.

I don't think you understand just how much extra that would cost.....

mumsneedwine · 07/02/2024 06:40

You can't argue with stupid 🤷‍♀️

Hotsausage2 · 06/02/2024 23:57

I am now sure after reading this that you are just baiting.
you have shown you have zero knowledge of what it is like to work in healthcare and you are just being intentionally vile.
As an NHS senior nurse- go fuck yourself. You are honestly reprehensible in your attitude and I hope to god I never meet you in real life.

marmaladeandpeanutbutter · 06/02/2024 23:50

And GPs salary is often £50k so that's bollocks.

marmaladeandpeanutbutter · 06/02/2024 23:49

Nobody's right to withhold their labour should be removed.

MrsSkylerWhite · 06/02/2024 23:23

Sillybilly1993

GPs’ starting salary is £70k, the average nurse earns £37k. They seem like good salaries to me! Ultimately if NHS staff don’t like their jobs and their salaries then they can vote with their feet and leave, which is what the rest of us do.”

They are, in their thousands. How many more will lose their lives when people are simply no longer willing to spend years and a great deal of money training? or to remain in the UK when they can earn two or three times the salary overseas?

You do realise that becoming a GP is a specialisation, which requires further training after med school is finished, just like any other? £70K and £37K goes nowhere in a city like London, Glasgow, Edinburgh, York, Exeter. Well you name it. These aren’t kids. By the time most GPs are fully qualified, they are generally of the age where most people are thinking of starting families. If they want to buy into a practice, it costs a great deal of money.

bakebeans · 06/02/2024 22:53

YABU.
if you are a from a family of doctors as your say you must clearly understand the absolute shit show that the NHS doctors and nurses and healthcare are in.
I am a nurse and for 20 years and you are the first person from a 'family of doctors' I've ever heard to not want to back docors and NHS staff which makes me think you are far removed from it
The government continue to blame wait lists on strikes but it's is not all down to this.
My adult son was referred to ENT after 4 consultations and eventually referred mid covid.
ENT at our local hospital already had a 9-12 month backlog wait then. Due to a poor referral from the GP he waited 18 months.

I was seen by ENT in 2018. Also pre covid. 5 month wait.

Our local trust waiting list is 18 week wait time for ROUTINE appointments. That means the trust have 18 weeks in which to see a patient. This has been the case since 2015
My daughter was referred to a dermatologist for acne PRE covid. Waiting time 9 months.

Junior doctors approx earn £14.50 an hour! They are saving lives not pushing pens!
NHS wages and pension have reduced over years. Already very little incentive to remain.
GP's are leaving at an increased rate.
I fully support the strike as whether they do or don't. The waiting lists won't go away!

Do you not recall that pre covid, consultants were made to cancel clinics and operations to 'support the wards' due to increased demand of winter pressures?

newlaptop12 · 06/02/2024 22:52

DistinguishedSocialCommenator · 06/02/2024 19:57

"wind up" it looks as though you are on one. Has no one ever thaught you just becuse you disagree with another point of view, you need to put your argument forward without trying to insult the other?

I'm "furious" that NHS staff are striking, just ask those who have had appointments cancelled because of this.

You cite someone moved to Australia - you cite their pay but you fail to mention cost of living. Indeed at different times in our history, different countrys may have better pay, lifestyles etc.

Why do you think we get people, NHS staff doctors/nurses?ot's/pt's/dietitians/radiographers/etc/etc coming to the UK from New Zealand, Australia, South Africa, and India etc etc e tc.

I've asked this question before to those who come out making similar comments like yours as you don't really have an answer to my question. EG, Why are UK citizens still opting to become doctors if it is as bad as you say it is?? Yes, that's right, you like the others don't have an answer.

Because it's a great profession in every other country than the uk. Soeaking to n F2 recently not one person in his year is planning to stay.

Onthepage · 06/02/2024 22:42

You aren’t paying for anything. Why should doctors stay here they have no reason to stay here. They have massive loans, work for nothing in the NHS for years and then get treated like crap having less qualified PAs and AA’s who have a 2yr diploma, for which the junior doctors, are ultimately responsible and who are paid at least 30% to 40% more than them after only 2 years.
Educate yourself!

PostItInABook · 06/02/2024 22:35

RainbowFlutter · 06/02/2024 20:52

Also, you'll reap what you sow. The NHS will be staffed by allied health professionals and the doctors really will leave. Unless you want them to be chained to the NHS, which I'm sure you probably do.

The NHS is haemorrhaging allied health professionals too so good luck with that. 😂

Onthepage · 06/02/2024 21:56

Can’t live on our passion and love for our jobs though can we. Nor can we support our families

mumsneedwine · 06/02/2024 21:08

@DuncinToffee my feelings towards that weasel are not publishable. I hope he never needs A&E. Private hospitals don't have those 😡🤬. He (or his wife) will be making money out of it all somewhere.

mumsneedwine · 06/02/2024 21:00

@StrongWhite it's so sad. The NHS is being destroyed in front of our eyes and doctors seem to be surplus to requirements. Even though they earn less than their assistants. Someone somewhere is making money from this. Not doctors. They can't heat their homes (which they have to change every 4-6 months).

Shortkiwi · 06/02/2024 20:57

I would bail out now, OP.
You clearly haven’t got a clue about doctors’ workloads and their pitiful pay.
I also didn’t cite ‘someone’ moving to Australia in my previous post, I made it clear it’s my daughter - 3rd year junior doctor. Earning double pay there but not got double cost of living, also very well staffed and supported in hospitals there.

StrongWhite · 06/02/2024 20:57

@mumsneedwine when the current Health Minister refers to junior doctors as "trainees as I like to call them" it's pretty clear that the culture of contempt for doctors starts at the top. It trickles down through the filter of a shameful media. A number of the Great British electorate are either too selfish/small-minded/not switched on enough or just can't be bothered to find out what's really going on and believe the rhetoric. Yet there are also many ordinary people who are still very grateful for our medics. Let's hope they vote with that in mind.

thedankness · 06/02/2024 20:56

Last year more than half of new doctors joining the UK medical register were international. However there are problems with relying on a majority immigrant workforce to provide an essential service, especially doctors as it takes so long to reach consultancy. It has been shown that international doctors are more likely to leave the UK than domestic graduates, unsurprisingly as they are a self-selected group that leave for better opportunities and they do not have close ties to the UK. As some of these countries' economies improve we will see doctors return to Pakistan and India for example. This makes your workforce less stable.

Internationally-trained doctors have greater variability in competency when they come to the UK, whereas UK training is relatively standardised. The exam for foreign graduates to enter the UK has been criticised for being too easy - but why would that be looked at when the government is pushing en-masse international recruitment in response to historic poor workforce planning. Many international doctors have English as a second/third language and honestly sometimes don't meet the standard required for such a communication-heavy job. The majority are absolutely great, but these issues cannot be addressed while there is a conflict of interest. The NHS spends money on overseas recruitment, visa sponsorship and bringing international hires up to speed in the NHS to ultimately produce a less predictable and stable workforce. It's not the best solution.

howsaboutit · 06/02/2024 20:56

OP, the manager of the ward I worked on during the nurse’s strikes received an email detailing the minimum “safe staffing” levels they must maintain while the strikes were ongoing.

If nothing else tells you how dire the conditions of the NHS are at the moment, let this be it: the “safe staffing” they wanted to be maintained during the strikes was more nurses than we had on the average day shift.

There aren’t enough staff. It’s as plain and simple as that. They need to improve working conditions to attract staff or else it’s just going to continue to get worse. The government aren’t forthcoming with improvements so we have to strike for them.

RainbowFlutter · 06/02/2024 20:52

Also, you'll reap what you sow. The NHS will be staffed by allied health professionals and the doctors really will leave. Unless you want them to be chained to the NHS, which I'm sure you probably do.