Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Doctors right to strike, should it be removed?

737 replies

DistinguishedSocialCommenator · 06/02/2024 09:49

Hello
Several people within our families are doctors. Most started out wanting to care for people, but as time goes on, the reality of money, and spending comes into play for some.

PM Rishi Sunak in a tv interview partly balmed doctors strikes for failing to bring down hospital waiting lists. I rarely agree with a politician but in this case, I know he is right. EG, myself, my OH, one of our children and grandchildren have had their appointments cancelled because of strike impacts. Our children and grandchildren do have private healthcare but those do not cover pre-existing or you end up on the NHS with chorionic conditions.

Our police officers and armed forces personnel are not allowed to strike

AIBU to expect a no-strike agreement for doctors and possibly nurses. If agreed, give them 9 months' notice about no-strike agreements. I honestly believe hardly anyone would leave and those leaving would have possibly left the NHS anyway as some do and go to another country just like we get doctors from abroad. Their pay claims could be easily managed in the same way police/armed forces pay rises are managed as well of those MP's.

Failing to bring down hospital w/l lies with the present government and the growing of these waiting lists, the doctor's strikes have certainly made things a lot worse. We are regularly hearing on our news media about growing waiting lists and people waiting for urgent treatments and the waiting times in A&E departments etc

AIBU to feel that doctors should be made to sign a no-strike agreement with a few month's notice to have the no-strike agreement in place before next winter? Also, have a pay body set up like the ones our MP's enjoy.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
37
mumsneedwine · 07/02/2024 21:16

30% pay restoration (not a pay rise) will put doctors salaries back to where they were in 2010. Take home pay for an F1 is currently lower than it was in 2010, so imagine how much less that is taking inflation in to account.
Less doctors will then leave to either go abroad or do something else. More doctors means more appointments means the waiting lists go down.
It's so simple. But beyond our PM. But hey, he likes to insult bereaved parents.

Figmentofmyimagination · 07/02/2024 20:56

Striking is also exceptionally high risk for unions - remember eg the NUM, whose assets were all seized. Break the incredibly cumbersome balloting rules in the tiniest way and you will be in court fighting off an injunction. And this is the only place where the law still insists the union funds a postal ballot - imagine how complicated and expensive it is to run an unchallengeable postal ballot of tens of thousands of members - the gov refuses to countenance online ballots - wonder why - all to make it as difficult and expensive as possible for the union to meet the threshold for a valid ballot. Whenever that threshold is crossed nowadays, it is the clearest possible signal that people really have reached the end of their tether.

DistinguishedSocialCommenator · 07/02/2024 20:53

Absolutely45 · 07/02/2024 20:11

@DistinguishedSocialCommenator
PM Rishi Sunak in a tv interview partly blamed doctors strikes for failing to bring down hospital waiting lists. I rarely agree with a politician but in this case, I know he is right

The waiting list has hardly risen since these strikes started, it was still over 7m.

Just as it was almost 4m pre Covid.

He is just blaming others for what is his parties fault plus why didn't he settle far earlier in the case of Nurses etc?
Why hasn't he settled the Jnr Docs dispute? its costed the NHS more in agency fees than in extra pay.

Other European countries don't have 7m on lists, just the UK.

No strike agreements don't work, lets have a working environment where strikes aren't required.

Edited

I'll take your word for it.
So how will a 30% pay rise help the waiting lists?
If the mass of NHS strikes the public will have to endure hardly affected waiting lists,,, what is the "hardly" figure please?

Why do you feel Rushi is putting a block?

OP posts:
Sapphire387 · 07/02/2024 20:45

Hard disagree. The NHS needs a serious funding increase. Doctors deserve to be paid well, as do all NHS staff. Denying people their fundamental rights is not the answer. Look at who has created this situation. It's the Tory party.

TrixieFatell · 07/02/2024 20:44

You can care for people and want to be paid a fair wage. The two are not mutually exclusive and the first is used to shame skilled professionals into working in unsafe and stressful working conditions and feel.happy about it

Everyone should have the right to strike. The NHS have been shouting for years the terrible working conditions and unsafe staffing levels. It is infuriating the only time people care about those is during a strike.

Figmentofmyimagination · 07/02/2024 20:42

The truth is that the UK has the most restrictive strike laws in the developed world. Striking is an extremely complicated and administratively very costly way of trying to negotiate pay. Nobody wants to strike. If there really was a genuinely independent pay body, free to set binding pay awards without interference from central government, especially the treasury, clearly this would be preferable to striking. However, this will never happen, because the treasury can never resist interfering and impoding the pay they want. This is why prison officers etc need the right to strike and why there is no alternative to the right to strike for doctors and midwives.

chocolatenutcase · 07/02/2024 20:21

This infographic explains very clearly how many hospital appointments are cancelled and by who. The number cancelled by the strikes is tiny
In comparison to other reasons. As a PP has said many many appointments are cancelled due to lack of staff available. The strikes are all about safe staffing levels. This week a colleague of mine and her husband - GP and hospital consultant told me they were moving to Canada for a better work life balance. She didn't say for better pay.

Doctors right to strike, should it be removed?
Absolutely45 · 07/02/2024 20:11

@DistinguishedSocialCommenator
PM Rishi Sunak in a tv interview partly blamed doctors strikes for failing to bring down hospital waiting lists. I rarely agree with a politician but in this case, I know he is right

The waiting list has hardly risen since these strikes started, it was still over 7m.

Just as it was almost 4m pre Covid.

He is just blaming others for what is his parties fault plus why didn't he settle far earlier in the case of Nurses etc?
Why hasn't he settled the Jnr Docs dispute? its costed the NHS more in agency fees than in extra pay.

Other European countries don't have 7m on lists, just the UK.

No strike agreements don't work, lets have a working environment where strikes aren't required.

Neurodiversitydoctor · 07/02/2024 20:10

SillyBilly1993 · 06/02/2024 10:16

YANBU. I wonder whether the people saying YABU would be happy if a relative of theirs lost their life because a key worker was on strike to get more money?

GPs’ starting salary is £70k, the average nurse earns £37k. They seem like good salaries to me! Ultimately if NHS staff don’t like their jobs and their salaries then they can vote with their feet and leave, which is what the rest of us do.

Yes that is what they are doing.

OrigamiOwls · 07/02/2024 20:10

Their pay claims could be easily managed in the same way police/armed forces pay rises are managed as well of those MP's

Police officers pay isn't managed by a committee like MPs pay is. It's negotiated, the same way doctors, train drivers etc do. Every year the police federation have to negotiate with the government for a pay rise, which has been well below inflation for at least the last ten years (apart from this last year when there was a better pay rise, likely because the government was predicting civil unrest). The Fed never (baring last year) manage to get a decent pay rise because they have nothing to use as a stick - officers can't strike and the govt know this, so what bargaining chip do the fed have?

Domino20 · 07/02/2024 20:03

youmustrememberthis · 07/02/2024 20:00

But they don't.

It was removed from the police ages ago

I know, that doesn't mean I don't think that they should have it though.

youmustrememberthis · 07/02/2024 20:00

Domino20 · 06/02/2024 09:52

Everybody should have the legal right to withdraw their labour.

But they don't.

It was removed from the police ages ago

marmaladeandpeanutbutter · 07/02/2024 19:57

On the lack of skilled staff:

Today I spoke with two doctors who explained to me that there is a huge and deliberately created bottleneck for GP training places. At the same time there is a lack of GPs all over the country. Anyone could see that some of these skill shortages have been created on purpose. We are also the only country in the world which has opened its training schemes to any doctor from any country, so that our home grown staff are competing for jobs. What an absolute cock up. I'm absolutely praying the Tories don't get back in.

notthatthis · 07/02/2024 18:02

Jovacknockowitch · 06/02/2024 09:57

Good luck recruiting. Crap wages, long hours, lack of money in the NHS and then no right to strike too. Yeah, that’d really improve morale and sort out the waiting lists.

This thread is from the same people who brought you a million VAT threads recently.

😂My sentiments exactly

Pippa12 · 07/02/2024 18:00

Unfortunately your post shows lack of understanding.

Appointments and operations are cancelled every day due to lack of skilled staff, not just on strike days.

Beds are now placed in the middle of bays due to lack of capacity. This creates on average 7 beds on a ward, 7 extra patients to care for, further increasing an unmanageable work load. But there is still not enough beds, so appointments/operations cancelled.

Many trusts are currently not recruiting into vacant posts due to lack of funding. Up and coming newly qualified nurses are unemployed… no joke! Have a look on the nhs website how many band 5 jobs there are in your area and consider the huge uni intakes that qualify every six months!!! Unfilled vacancies means cancelled appointments/operations.

I could go on and on but it just falls on deaf ears.

The strikes are about patient safety, because this cannot go on. Waiting lists are absolutely huge, A&E waits embarrassingly astronomical… the bottom line is there IS NOT ENOUGH STAFF BECAUSE THE PAY IS RUBBISH AND WORKING CONDITIONS ARE AWFUL!!!

Take away the right to strike. Literally and I mean literally hardly any nurses truly striked anyway as they genuinely cannot afford to forgo a days pay.

PROFESSIONALS ARE SCREAMING FROM THE ROOF TOPS THAT YOUR APPOINTMENTS AND OPERATIONS WILL STILL BE CANCELLED BECAUSE THERE IS NOT ENOUGH STAFF, FUNDING OR BEDS TO FACILITATE THE POPULATION!!!!

But yeah… probs best to just take away the right to strike 😂😂😂

Purplesilkpyjamas · 07/02/2024 17:25

Kosenrufugirl · 07/02/2024 14:08

At Purplesilkpyjamas.... Apologies, the previous post is in response to the DistinguishedSocialCommenator's post

No worries. I did a double take then realised we are on the same side. The ignorance is breathtaking. I have only seen such nasty posts about doctors once before. It was from a very twisted person who had failed to get into medical school.

Kosenrufugirl · 07/02/2024 14:08

At Purplesilkpyjamas.... Apologies, the previous post is in response to the DistinguishedSocialCommenator's post

Kosenrufugirl · 07/02/2024 14:04

Purplesilkpyjamas · 07/02/2024 13:20

I bet your job did not involve even 10% of the difficult decisions doctors make alongside the risk of causing death or serious harm if you made a mistake.

Were you attending trauma calls or crash calls when you were in your 20s?

Your attitudes are disgusting.

What I find most difficult about my job is putting one foot in front the other at 4 o'clock in the morning with my brain screaming for a well overdue break after 8 hours on the feet, still 4 hours to go and the ward sister saying "I have no one to break relieve you". Whist the decisions I make might well affect my patients to the the rest of their lives, whether for better or worse. If I make a mistake ultimately the Trust's insurance will pay. The trouble is I don't want to make mistakes so I am focusing hard while physically and mentally exhausted. How does this compare to a stressful corporate or a supermarket job? As for our pensions- we do have generous pensions. We just don't live long enough to enjoy them. I no longer believe you have doctors in your family. You wouldn't be writing this kind of posts if you did.

Purplesilkpyjamas · 07/02/2024 13:20

DistinguishedSocialCommenator · 07/02/2024 10:31

Hello
Thank you.
Many people are taking early retirement, me and my OH left work age 50+ but below 55 as work everywhere is getting harder and harder its not just the NHS. Our children and their OH's in my OH all worked in the private sector, trust me, its cut-throat out there - you often don't get the nice pensions, sick leave etc and if they feel you are under-performing, out you go - millions leave their job every year for one reason or another and some can manage to work better than others

I left because we had our first grandchild as we did not want them being looked after by strangers. Where I worked, some had a lot of difficulties with the changes and thankfully and some others did not as we all have different capacity, etc - Yes, if they had worked in the private sector, most would have left

Do you know anyone working for a supermarket, ask them about the turnover in that or the hospitality trade - all jobs are difficult

Ideally, everyone should be paid more, have longer hols and work in a very safe environment for themselves and their customers/patients - money is always the crux of things. If I was your PM, I'd award NHS staff inflation plus 50% pay rise - but then the police, coucil workers and everyone else would want something like that -

I bet your job did not involve even 10% of the difficult decisions doctors make alongside the risk of causing death or serious harm if you made a mistake.

Were you attending trauma calls or crash calls when you were in your 20s?

Your attitudes are disgusting.

Kosenrufugirl · 07/02/2024 10:38

DistinguishedSocialCommenator · 07/02/2024 10:31

Hello
Thank you.
Many people are taking early retirement, me and my OH left work age 50+ but below 55 as work everywhere is getting harder and harder its not just the NHS. Our children and their OH's in my OH all worked in the private sector, trust me, its cut-throat out there - you often don't get the nice pensions, sick leave etc and if they feel you are under-performing, out you go - millions leave their job every year for one reason or another and some can manage to work better than others

I left because we had our first grandchild as we did not want them being looked after by strangers. Where I worked, some had a lot of difficulties with the changes and thankfully and some others did not as we all have different capacity, etc - Yes, if they had worked in the private sector, most would have left

Do you know anyone working for a supermarket, ask them about the turnover in that or the hospitality trade - all jobs are difficult

Ideally, everyone should be paid more, have longer hols and work in a very safe environment for themselves and their customers/patients - money is always the crux of things. If I was your PM, I'd award NHS staff inflation plus 50% pay rise - but then the police, coucil workers and everyone else would want something like that -

I lived in Canada for 4 years. Public sector jobs are the most coveted over there. Incidentally Canada isn't known for bombing out remote parts of the world at every opportunity.

Kosenrufugirl · 07/02/2024 10:32

DistinguishedSocialCommenator · 07/02/2024 10:15

What did Jeemey say when you complained to him? For the record, I'm no poltician and have no time for any politician as I don't trust them.

However, I'm aware that strikes in this sector hurt many people and worse.

As per my OP, I've clearly stated who could look after NHS pay deals but no one takes note of that as something like that would work as it works for MP's.

The trouble with this Government is that they IGNORED independent pay review for NHS staff. And this was before Covid with inflation 2%. It's this Government that got NHS into this mess. There is no shortage of IT engineers, financiers, accountants or truck drivers in this country. Because their pay is determined by the market and the private enterprise pays the going rate to ensure they have the work force. NHS pay is set by the Government. So one has to know enough about politics if one wants to understand the issue. Even now the Government is refusing us the right to work in conditions where we can SAFELY look after our patients. Strike has always been the last resort. However if the Government isn't engaging in good faith talks what else can we do? Do you honestly think my brain is functioning at my full capacity at 7:30 am when I have spent the previous 12 hours on my feet without a tea break? Never mind 1 hour break as per Health and Safety? Just because my colleagues had decided enough is enough and left the profession? We are bright people on NHS. We can multi task, we can communicate, we can deal with emergencies. All we are asking is to pay us enough money to ensure enough staff is available to provide SAFE care.

DistinguishedSocialCommenator · 07/02/2024 10:31

Kosenrufugirl · 07/02/2024 10:16

Hi I am an NHS midwife. My colleagues are not going abroad. The older ones are taking early retirement. The younger ones are retraining to be something else. The competition for midwifery courses is 20 applicants to a place. Followed by a gruelling 3 year course. 10-15% of newly qualified midwives leave within a year. Lots leave within 10 years when they look at their work/life balance. You mentioned earlier that you worked for the Council and when the pay and conditions was changed nobody left. Well, I can assure you the NHS staff are voting with their feet

Hello
Thank you.
Many people are taking early retirement, me and my OH left work age 50+ but below 55 as work everywhere is getting harder and harder its not just the NHS. Our children and their OH's in my OH all worked in the private sector, trust me, its cut-throat out there - you often don't get the nice pensions, sick leave etc and if they feel you are under-performing, out you go - millions leave their job every year for one reason or another and some can manage to work better than others

I left because we had our first grandchild as we did not want them being looked after by strangers. Where I worked, some had a lot of difficulties with the changes and thankfully and some others did not as we all have different capacity, etc - Yes, if they had worked in the private sector, most would have left

Do you know anyone working for a supermarket, ask them about the turnover in that or the hospitality trade - all jobs are difficult

Ideally, everyone should be paid more, have longer hols and work in a very safe environment for themselves and their customers/patients - money is always the crux of things. If I was your PM, I'd award NHS staff inflation plus 50% pay rise - but then the police, coucil workers and everyone else would want something like that -

OP posts:
LevelledPeach · 07/02/2024 10:16

You can really tell a lot about someone by their views on collective action.

Of course they should maintain their right to withdraw their labour.
We already have some of the most regressive, anti-trade union laws amongst western democracies.

Rights are only ever temporarily granted, never permanently given.
To argue that workers should have less rights and remove their ability of collective bargaining through withdrawal of labour, is, quite frankly, appalling.

Every in work benefit you have has been fought for. The idea of surrendering our ability to demand fair pay and better conditions is on reminiscent of a Victorian mill owner.

Kosenrufugirl · 07/02/2024 10:16

DistinguishedSocialCommenator · 07/02/2024 09:55

That is historical people going abroad and many move abroad as they gfeel there is less crime, less stress as do the many that move to England/UK for a better life as do our doctors, nurses - its swings and roundabouts and always has been and will be.

Look at our PM/Rishi. He had a Green card to move to the USA - are you telling me he is having financial difficulties? Just an example some people will move as they want to move to another country for various reasons,

Hi I am an NHS midwife. My colleagues are not going abroad. The older ones are taking early retirement. The younger ones are retraining to be something else. The competition for midwifery courses is 20 applicants to a place. Followed by a gruelling 3 year course. 10-15% of newly qualified midwives leave within a year. Lots leave within 10 years when they look at their work/life balance. You mentioned earlier that you worked for the Council and when the pay and conditions was changed nobody left. Well, I can assure you the NHS staff are voting with their feet

DistinguishedSocialCommenator · 07/02/2024 10:15

Kosenrufugirl · 07/02/2024 10:07

Jeremy Hunt first announced the war on doctors in 2016. There were just about enough doctors to keep patients SAFE on the weekends. He wanted to make the existing doctors workforce stretch themselves over 7 days. E.g. elective surgeries taking place on the weekends. Without paying extra. Even Public Accounts Committee said the Government had "no coherent strategy" how to make 7 days service happen without extra funding. The doctors were already doing 14-15 hours shifts without breaks and they rebelled. The same for nurses. It went all downhill from then. Inflation was 2%. You really need to educate yourself. Dr Clarke wrote a very lucid account of those days in her book Your Life is in My Hands or a Junior Doctor Story. Jeremy Hunt had no guts to even have a public debate with doctors. Even when they resorted to camping 24/7 at the doorstep of his office. The man has so much contempt for NHS, the sooner he is out of Government the better. Looking forward to the election

What did Jeemey say when you complained to him? For the record, I'm no poltician and have no time for any politician as I don't trust them.

However, I'm aware that strikes in this sector hurt many people and worse.

As per my OP, I've clearly stated who could look after NHS pay deals but no one takes note of that as something like that would work as it works for MP's.

OP posts: