Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Doctors right to strike, should it be removed?

737 replies

DistinguishedSocialCommenator · 06/02/2024 09:49

Hello
Several people within our families are doctors. Most started out wanting to care for people, but as time goes on, the reality of money, and spending comes into play for some.

PM Rishi Sunak in a tv interview partly balmed doctors strikes for failing to bring down hospital waiting lists. I rarely agree with a politician but in this case, I know he is right. EG, myself, my OH, one of our children and grandchildren have had their appointments cancelled because of strike impacts. Our children and grandchildren do have private healthcare but those do not cover pre-existing or you end up on the NHS with chorionic conditions.

Our police officers and armed forces personnel are not allowed to strike

AIBU to expect a no-strike agreement for doctors and possibly nurses. If agreed, give them 9 months' notice about no-strike agreements. I honestly believe hardly anyone would leave and those leaving would have possibly left the NHS anyway as some do and go to another country just like we get doctors from abroad. Their pay claims could be easily managed in the same way police/armed forces pay rises are managed as well of those MP's.

Failing to bring down hospital w/l lies with the present government and the growing of these waiting lists, the doctor's strikes have certainly made things a lot worse. We are regularly hearing on our news media about growing waiting lists and people waiting for urgent treatments and the waiting times in A&E departments etc

AIBU to feel that doctors should be made to sign a no-strike agreement with a few month's notice to have the no-strike agreement in place before next winter? Also, have a pay body set up like the ones our MP's enjoy.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
37
Kosenrufugirl · 08/02/2024 13:17

Spacecowboys · 08/02/2024 12:42

I’m all for staff being tied into the nhs for a period of time. But it has to be mutually beneficial. Fees being paid by the nhs (for health related degrees), in exchange for a number of years nhs service as an example. Those who do not want to work in the nhs ( not everyone does) would have the option of paying their own fees.

How would it work in real life? 50% of marriages end up in divorce. What would you want to do about a junior doctor sobbing their heart off because they single handedly covered the job of 2 doctors in the previous 3 shifts (each lasting 14 hours). And now they are having a panic attack at the prospect of going back to the ward . If you think it's not happening I can assure you it does and on a regular basis. So what would you want to do? Force them back to work? To look after your relatives and children?

newnamethanks · 08/02/2024 13:16

Ah, the delightful Mr Green, asset stripper and bankrupt. Let's all take his advice.

Alwaysinthehouse · 08/02/2024 13:15

People don’t seem to understand that pay and conditions are inextricably linked. It’s much easier to tolerate a 12 hour shift with no break if you know you don’t have to come home and clean the house because you can afford a cleaner. If you can afford a takeaway because you’re too exhausted to cook. If you can afford a taxi home from work at 2am because you’re too tired to drive. If conditions aren’t going to improve, then pay has to.

Anyotherdude · 08/02/2024 13:09

@justteanbiscuits I didn’t say get rid of admin, just maybe not have the Management-heavy structure that a lot of HT’s provide.
AFAIK, the Govt asked hospitals who had spare stock to share with those that didn’t - again - an administrative error (or possibly a cynical move to look as if they were being proactive). It’s not just in the NHS, either.
Do you remember when Philip Green said this? OK, I accept he’s a wrong ‘un, but there is a lot of truth in his criticism of the government(s) in general:
https://www.bbc.co.uk/blogs/thereporters/robertpeston/2010/10/green_id_be_bust_if_i_ran_my_b.html

BBC - Peston's Picks: Green: 'I'd be bust if I ran my business the way government does'

Sir Philip Green told me that if he ran his businesses the way the government does, the lights would go out.   What he says he's uncovered is a culture...

https://www.bbc.co.uk/blogs/thereporters/robertpeston/2010/10/green_id_be_bust_if_i_ran_my_b.html

justteanbiscuits · 08/02/2024 13:01

DistinguishedSocialCommenator · 08/02/2024 12:54

Attention all:
I've been thanking quite a few posts in this thread privately, ie via the thanks button as they are informative and sensible and not rude.

Now to the quoted post. On balance, the first great idea to come out of the thread that was not posted by me is mandatory time spent in NHS post qualifications in return for a bursary.

Those who want to leave post qualification without honouring the minimum term contract post qualification could repay the bursary or not take it up initially
Re pay within certain timescales that would be pre-determined..

Edited

Someone who has been completely burnt out by the system will then be left with crushing debt with a timescale to repay? Someone who has been given responsibilities outside of what they should have, causing PTSD?

justteanbiscuits · 08/02/2024 12:59

Anyotherdude · 08/02/2024 12:33

The NHS is run by the Trusts, for the Trusts. If they got rid of many of the administrative grades, had one senior nurse in charge of wards (ie. Matron), added efficiencies in stocking and supply of medical supplies and equipment, the money would be available to pay the Doctors what they should be getting.
When a relative died, he had been so over-stocked with replacement bottles for his drain, that we tried to return a few boxes to the NHS Trust that had supplied them. They said that because they had been distributed, they had to be disposed.
Each item cost £20. Each box contained 20 items, each wrapped and sealed individually.
We had 5 full boxes and one opened box that had to be destroyed: nearly £2,500 of stock. Disposed. Wasted.
Not to mention that more than a 2-month supply had been delivered at a time when Doctors had confirmed that he was days from death.
This is one patient.
Don’t ever forget that the PPE stockpiled in a number of hospitals during the COVID pandemic was out-of-date, and therefore unusable.
The inefficiencies of those that run the NHS need to be investigated before the Government and Hospital Trusts try to push Doctors’ salaries down: it is the wrong target for cost-cutting.

So with no admin, who is going to book appointments, send letters, do the paperwork, arrange transfers, contact relatives, upload data for the government reporting?

the reason you couldn't return the boxes of stuff is, because it left the supply chain, it could no longer be guaranteed as safe or sterile. You could have done anything to it.

And it was the NHS stockpiling PPE they couldn't use? or was it our delightful government providing them with PPE they couldn't use and so could do nothing with it?

DistinguishedSocialCommenator · 08/02/2024 12:57

Spacecowboys · 08/02/2024 12:42

I’m all for staff being tied into the nhs for a period of time. But it has to be mutually beneficial. Fees being paid by the nhs (for health related degrees), in exchange for a number of years nhs service as an example. Those who do not want to work in the nhs ( not everyone does) would have the option of paying their own fees.

Hello
I was posting when you must have posted and only just read your post. I can whole heartedly agree with that

OP posts:
DistinguishedSocialCommenator · 08/02/2024 12:54

justteanbiscuits · 08/02/2024 11:45

So, if we bring in a mandatory contract length for new Doctors, will the Government also give them a bursary so they don't run up hideous debt for training? At the minimum the £9k a year university fee.

What about those that need to leave, not just for a different country / private? Those that want to go into research rather than patient facing? Those that simply can't cope. You can't force people to continue being a Doctor.

Attention all:
I've been thanking quite a few posts in this thread privately, ie via the thanks button as they are informative and sensible and not rude.

Now to the quoted post. On balance, the first great idea to come out of the thread that was not posted by me is mandatory time spent in NHS post qualifications in return for a bursary.

Those who want to leave post qualification without honouring the minimum term contract post qualification could repay the bursary or not take it up initially
Re pay within certain timescales that would be pre-determined..

OP posts:
Spacecowboys · 08/02/2024 12:42

I’m all for staff being tied into the nhs for a period of time. But it has to be mutually beneficial. Fees being paid by the nhs (for health related degrees), in exchange for a number of years nhs service as an example. Those who do not want to work in the nhs ( not everyone does) would have the option of paying their own fees.

Anyotherdude · 08/02/2024 12:33

The NHS is run by the Trusts, for the Trusts. If they got rid of many of the administrative grades, had one senior nurse in charge of wards (ie. Matron), added efficiencies in stocking and supply of medical supplies and equipment, the money would be available to pay the Doctors what they should be getting.
When a relative died, he had been so over-stocked with replacement bottles for his drain, that we tried to return a few boxes to the NHS Trust that had supplied them. They said that because they had been distributed, they had to be disposed.
Each item cost £20. Each box contained 20 items, each wrapped and sealed individually.
We had 5 full boxes and one opened box that had to be destroyed: nearly £2,500 of stock. Disposed. Wasted.
Not to mention that more than a 2-month supply had been delivered at a time when Doctors had confirmed that he was days from death.
This is one patient.
Don’t ever forget that the PPE stockpiled in a number of hospitals during the COVID pandemic was out-of-date, and therefore unusable.
The inefficiencies of those that run the NHS need to be investigated before the Government and Hospital Trusts try to push Doctors’ salaries down: it is the wrong target for cost-cutting.

chocolatenutcase · 08/02/2024 12:10

Regarding burnout of nhs staff. It happens at all stages.
Junior doctors go off to Australia after a couple of years because they are often burnt out from years of hard study at school then 5/6 years a university and 2 years foundation training. They honestly need a break. 18 years olds do not know what it's really like to be a doctor. Tbh if you've not been one, no one does. I've been a junior doctor but 30 years ago and wouldn't pretend to know what it's like to work as one now compared to my T&C.
But look at the other end. Doctors retiring early due to burn out.
It's the same for nurses. Money isn't everything but working conditions, and sense of wellbeing, of being able to do your job properly and care for your patients in the way you know they deserve, are. The stress I experience at work is due to enormous frustration that no matter how hard I work I cannot provide the care my patients deserve due to severe lack of resources. And I've been saying that for years on my annual appraisals.

SerendipityJane · 08/02/2024 12:07

BIossomtoes · 08/02/2024 12:01

It might be a good idea if we wrote off healthcare professionals’ student debt in exchange for a stipulated period of work in the NHS. Although they’re supposed to repay the debt, if they emigrate very few do in practice so there’s a double whammy.

Foreign courts aren't likely to enforce a UK debt. A friend of mine fucked off to the US with a shed load of student debt and hasn't paid a penny in nearly 25 years.

BIossomtoes · 08/02/2024 12:01

It might be a good idea if we wrote off healthcare professionals’ student debt in exchange for a stipulated period of work in the NHS. Although they’re supposed to repay the debt, if they emigrate very few do in practice so there’s a double whammy.

justteanbiscuits · 08/02/2024 11:45

DistinguishedSocialCommenator · 08/02/2024 10:06

Reding almost every post since I initiated this thread, couple of new ideas

I have no reason to believe shortages but you get them in almost every profession as people will go on sick leave etc etc - yes, in hospitals its a matter of life and death - so what is the solution rather than just throwing more of my money (taxpayers) at the NHS? Or training more NHS staff that costs loads only to find they ove to another country that will always pay more and that is historical. This is why I am advocating madatory contract length within the NHS after qualifying and this has been thought about by our gov.

Last point and all will know this is the case but some may choose to ignore. Many have said strikes are/were for the safety of patients. If thats the case, why not accept pay raises offered as nurses have and then strike for safety at work and that of patients?

It you are being honest with yourselves, there is no, IMO easy solution and more than enough money has been directed towards the NHS

What would you do to cut waiting lists and ensure you and patients did not lose out? Personally, I'd have a no-strike agreement, a numbers of years newly qualified staff worked for NHS and look at every contract NHS has with buying items, leasing, renting buildings, hiring of agency staff and changing contracts re the way some consultants worked etc. You can have your say without attacking me as my opinion is as valid as yours.

(I do wish our NHS was the number one in the world but I'm not sure how to get there even with my opinios posted above)

I thank all the hard-working NHS staff that do a great job!!

So, if we bring in a mandatory contract length for new Doctors, will the Government also give them a bursary so they don't run up hideous debt for training? At the minimum the £9k a year university fee.

What about those that need to leave, not just for a different country / private? Those that want to go into research rather than patient facing? Those that simply can't cope. You can't force people to continue being a Doctor.

Scirocco · 08/02/2024 10:58

YABU.

Getonwithitplease · 08/02/2024 10:56

No !

pointythings · 08/02/2024 10:56

@SchoolQuestionnaire thank you for that excellent and sensible private sector perspective.

pointythings · 08/02/2024 10:52

Instead of reposting your previous post in its entirety, you could better use your time in addressing all the things that have been pointed out to you by people who know what they're talking about:

  • the graphic showing how few cancelled procedures are due to strikes
  • the graph showing the rise of waiting lists since 2010

And then maybe you would be able to understand that the problem isn't strikes, it's this government.

SchoolQuestionnaire · 08/02/2024 10:52

DistinguishedSocialCommenator · 06/02/2024 13:21

If that is the case, may I politely ask if those joining to train up as new doctors have their heads buried in the sand? IE not aware of the T&C's and long hours?

TBH, there should be new rules where we the state taxpayers fund new doctors' training to an extent, after qualifying to be made to work for the NHS for an X amount of time and this applies to other NHS staff as well ie nurses etc. Why should taxpayers fork out millions every year for someone to get trained and then go and work in another country without giving something back. That is not an unreasonable expectation!.

If I was going to train in a profession, I'd be naive not to consider, and investigate payscales, prospects, working conditions etc it is really as simple as that.

My idea is not new - this idea was rightly talked about by the respected Mr Jeremy Hunt - see below and why not?

https://www.gponline.com/doctors-face-four-year-mandatory-nhs-service-jeremy-hunt-expands-medical-training/article/1410975

I mean, I did find this quote in the piece so I’m not sure we can take this too seriously.

Mr Hunt will add: ‘From September 2018, we will train up to 1,500 more doctors every year, increasing the number of medical school places by up to a quarter. Of course it will take a number of years before those doctors qualify, but by the end of the next parliament we will make the NHS self- sufficient in doctors.’

I don’t necessarily disagree that there should be a mandatory service period for doctors who have trained in the NHS. I would suggest that it might be interesting to understand more about the demographic of those taking their skills abroad. Moving to another country is a huge undertaking and I’m just not sure that a vast number of newly qualified doctors are doing this. I’d assume (although I don’t know which is why I’d like more info) that it’s those who have had time to become burnt out and disillusioned with the NHS, so a mandatory service period may have very little effect.

I also think that if we are spending such a significant amount of money training doctors then surely it’s in our interests to improve conditions to make it easier to retain them. I work in the private sector and recruitment is expensive. It’s far more cost effective to invest in the team you have so that they actually want to stay. Forcing them to work, either by implementing mandatory service after training or taking away their right to strike in order to cut waiting lists isn’t going to foster a positive working culture.

I’d argue that it’s more important to attract diligent young people with a strong sense of autonomy and the right values to these roles and this may well discourage those sort of people from becoming doctors in the first place. Making the NHS a positive place to work and ensuring it’s workforce feels as appreciated and valued as it actually is would be a far more effective solution long term. I hazard a guess that it would actually save money too.

Kosenrufugirl · 08/02/2024 10:50

DistinguishedSocialCommenator · 08/02/2024 10:06

Reding almost every post since I initiated this thread, couple of new ideas

I have no reason to believe shortages but you get them in almost every profession as people will go on sick leave etc etc - yes, in hospitals its a matter of life and death - so what is the solution rather than just throwing more of my money (taxpayers) at the NHS? Or training more NHS staff that costs loads only to find they ove to another country that will always pay more and that is historical. This is why I am advocating madatory contract length within the NHS after qualifying and this has been thought about by our gov.

Last point and all will know this is the case but some may choose to ignore. Many have said strikes are/were for the safety of patients. If thats the case, why not accept pay raises offered as nurses have and then strike for safety at work and that of patients?

It you are being honest with yourselves, there is no, IMO easy solution and more than enough money has been directed towards the NHS

What would you do to cut waiting lists and ensure you and patients did not lose out? Personally, I'd have a no-strike agreement, a numbers of years newly qualified staff worked for NHS and look at every contract NHS has with buying items, leasing, renting buildings, hiring of agency staff and changing contracts re the way some consultants worked etc. You can have your say without attacking me as my opinion is as valid as yours.

(I do wish our NHS was the number one in the world but I'm not sure how to get there even with my opinios posted above)

I thank all the hard-working NHS staff that do a great job!!

I appreciate your trying to get to the bottom of the issue.

We don't have shortages of IT engineers, financiers or taxi drivers. We have shortages of NHS, science teachers and care home staff. If it's not money than what is it?

Lots of my midwifery colleagues left midwifery and retrained in other fields in the UK. They didn't go abroad. It's often a very painful choice. However for many of my colleagues their health and family lives became more important than trying to deliver good care at the expense of their health amidst poor staffing.

Minimal length of service and no strike clause is not going to work. People will always retain the right to go sick (or commit suicide for that matter). Sickness levels are already very high on NHS. If people know in advance they will be responsible for the money the government has spent on their training many will not start training at all in my honest opinion. Why put yourself in indentured labour? The risk would be too high unless one has rich parents to bail you out.

Also imagine the newspaper coverage when a burned out doctor or a nurse is forced to go to work?

Also you don't want a burnt out doctor or a nurse to look after our nearest and dearest.

I can't comment on procurement etc. I am sure the Trusts are doing what they can already.

As for enough money for NHS. Our population is getting older and unhealthier with each passing year. We can't improve our productivity unless we start tackling underlying causes. Poverty is one of the major determinants of poor health and chronic health conditions. We can't fix NHS without political will and there is none in this Government. For example, they have been burying Child Obesity strategy for a good number of years now. Because it's politically inconvenient.

The nurses and midwives got 5.5% payrise last June (and only after striking). This came after years of below inflation payrises (we got 1% payrise after Covid). Last June inflation was 10.2%. NHS is hemorrhaging staff. If you don't want to pay more taxes perhaps you should start lobbying the Government to spend less on warfare. And to sort out their own procurement procedures

Supernova23 · 08/02/2024 10:45

Nurse here, I was devastated at how quickly we gave up on strike action and caved. By the way, when we did strike, all areas were covered with staffing. If we completely withdrew our labour as in there were no nurses on duty in hospital, thousands of people would die each day. Maybe even 10’s of thousands. Yet apparently a new nurse is only worth 28k a year before tax. And a very senior band 5 nurse is only worth 34k before tax. No wonder people can’t wait to get out. I’d earn more working at Lidl.

DistinguishedSocialCommenator · 08/02/2024 10:39

CLARIFICATION - TYPO - added word " NOT"

DistinguishedSocialCommenator · Today 10:06

Reding almost every post since I initiated this thread, couple of new ideas

I have no reason NOT to believe shortages but you get them in almost every profession as people will go on sick leave etc etc - yes, in hospitals its a matter of life and death - so what is the solution rather than just throwing more of my money (taxpayers) at the NHS? Or training more NHS staff that costs loads only to find they ove to another country that will always pay more and that is historical. This is why I am advocating madatory contract length within the NHS after qualifying and this has been thought about by our gov.

Last point and all will know this is the case but some may choose to ignore. Many have said strikes are/were for the safety of patients. If thats the case, why not accept pay raises offered as nurses have and then strike for safety at work and that of patients?

It you are being honest with yourselves, there is no, IMO easy solution and more than enough money has been directed towards the NHS

What would you do to cut waiting lists and ensure you and patients did not lose out? Personally, I'd have a no-strike agreement, a numbers of years newly qualified staff worked for NHS and look at every contract NHS has with buying items, leasing, renting buildings, hiring of agency staff and changing contracts re the way some consultants worked etc. You can have your say without attacking me as my opinion is as valid as yours.

(I do wish our NHS was the number one in the world but I'm not sure how to get there even with my opinions posted above)

I thank all the hard-working NHS staff that do a great job!!

OP posts:
kintra · 08/02/2024 10:35

@DistinguishedSocialCommenator I have no reason to believe shortages but you get them in almost every profession as people will go on sick leave etc etc - yes, in hospitals its a matter of life and death - so what is the solution rather than just throwing more of my money (taxpayers) at the NHS?

What you call 'throwing money' could also be framed as 'properly investing'. Lack of money does seriously affect care. An example from my own profession - clinical but not doctors. If someone leaves or retires from a post (or dies, tbh, which has happened a few times in the past year), their job is picked over by workforce governance. It is rarely approved like for like, e.g. as a full time, same grade post. It's usually not replaced, banded down a pay grade, or hours are reduced. Please tell me how my colleagues and I are supposed to provide the same service (and actually, let's be honest, management are wanting a better service and asking us to do more and more, see more and more patients) with less staff? This will be replicated across the UK, in multiple professions.

secretnurse · 08/02/2024 10:18

Your opinion is indeed valid as is your right to hold it. It is also misinformed, ignorant and short sighted.

pointythings · 08/02/2024 10:15
  1. It is not legal to strike over anything except pay. You basically have to say it is about pay.
  2. As mentioned a million times already, if you pay people properly, they won't leave for pastures greener. People don't uproot themselves for the fun of it.
  3. A properly paid, properly staffed NHS will run far better than what we have now. The data has been posted on this thread, but you have not acknowledged that at all.
  4. Your opinion is not as valid as anyone else's because you refuse to acknowledge facts when they are presented to you.
Swipe left for the next trending thread