Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Doctors right to strike, should it be removed?

737 replies

DistinguishedSocialCommenator · 06/02/2024 09:49

Hello
Several people within our families are doctors. Most started out wanting to care for people, but as time goes on, the reality of money, and spending comes into play for some.

PM Rishi Sunak in a tv interview partly balmed doctors strikes for failing to bring down hospital waiting lists. I rarely agree with a politician but in this case, I know he is right. EG, myself, my OH, one of our children and grandchildren have had their appointments cancelled because of strike impacts. Our children and grandchildren do have private healthcare but those do not cover pre-existing or you end up on the NHS with chorionic conditions.

Our police officers and armed forces personnel are not allowed to strike

AIBU to expect a no-strike agreement for doctors and possibly nurses. If agreed, give them 9 months' notice about no-strike agreements. I honestly believe hardly anyone would leave and those leaving would have possibly left the NHS anyway as some do and go to another country just like we get doctors from abroad. Their pay claims could be easily managed in the same way police/armed forces pay rises are managed as well of those MP's.

Failing to bring down hospital w/l lies with the present government and the growing of these waiting lists, the doctor's strikes have certainly made things a lot worse. We are regularly hearing on our news media about growing waiting lists and people waiting for urgent treatments and the waiting times in A&E departments etc

AIBU to feel that doctors should be made to sign a no-strike agreement with a few month's notice to have the no-strike agreement in place before next winter? Also, have a pay body set up like the ones our MP's enjoy.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
37
Giv0iw · 08/02/2024 18:13

Have your family members actually told you they are a doctor for the money? The real money is at consultant level. Before all this it's lots of studying, long hours and the best years have of their lives have gone!

Absolutely45 · 08/02/2024 18:03

The facts are simple, it is "mainly" mismanagement of the taxpayer's money and this is why I don't want just more of our money thrown at it

On what basis do you say the main issue is mismanagement? how do you know this?

As far as i can tell, based on evidence from the Kings fund, the issues with the NHS are lack of well maintained estate, lack of equipment and lack of staff.

In their analysis, the NHS compares well on efficiency.

Your ans to all of this is no strike clauses, if you believe the issue is bad management, why would you go after the workforce for a solution? thats illogical, unless you want to see the NHS gone, which i suspect you do.

StrongWhite · 08/02/2024 18:02

Good luck with your private health insurance@DistinguishedSocialCommenator when you need A&E care or you get beyond the diagnostics phase to a chronic condition that's not covered.

And with regard to your username, it is about as accurate a description of your observations as it is to be calling Jeremy Hunt respected.

DistinguishedSocialCommenator · 08/02/2024 17:34

peanutbutter00 · 08/02/2024 16:05

I think everyone should have the right to strike no matter their profession, if conditions get so bad in a workplace or sector changes must be made to stop the need for strikes, in the case of public sector workers the onus must be on the government to make such conditions better.

To debate opinions about allowing or not allowing strikes distracts the focus from the heart of the matter which is poor funding allocation and mis-management

The facts are simple, it is "mainly" mismanagement of the taxpayer's money and this is why I don't want just more of our money thrown at it

It is awful and patients are waiting longer and longer and not just the rich now but possibly millions with health care ins going via private health care and tens of thousands of ordinary people with little savings choosing to go private up to a few thousand pounds and in turn you are getting waiting times to be seen, diagnosed privately as many of the same docs work for the NHS as well.

Our children have private health care but when you take this out, as many are aware, it does not cover pre-existing conditions but some are if there has been no flare-ups, not taking meds and it has been an x number of years - depends on the insurance provider.

OP posts:
peanutbutter00 · 08/02/2024 16:05

I think everyone should have the right to strike no matter their profession, if conditions get so bad in a workplace or sector changes must be made to stop the need for strikes, in the case of public sector workers the onus must be on the government to make such conditions better.

To debate opinions about allowing or not allowing strikes distracts the focus from the heart of the matter which is poor funding allocation and mis-management

pointythings · 08/02/2024 16:04

@blossomtoes that would depend on their length of service and their sickness absence over the preceding 12 months, but that isn't the point, is it? Because that doctor's work would still need to be done, or their clinics/surgeries cancelled. You can't run a service permanently at full stretch. It breaks people. That's what is happening now.

BIossomtoes · 08/02/2024 16:00

Kosenrufugirl · 08/02/2024 13:17

How would it work in real life? 50% of marriages end up in divorce. What would you want to do about a junior doctor sobbing their heart off because they single handedly covered the job of 2 doctors in the previous 3 shifts (each lasting 14 hours). And now they are having a panic attack at the prospect of going back to the ward . If you think it's not happening I can assure you it does and on a regular basis. So what would you want to do? Force them back to work? To look after your relatives and children?

The NHS has a very generous sickness policy. That doctor would be signed off with stress on full pay.

thedankness · 08/02/2024 15:28

@Kosenrufugirl Thank you for that article. The OP thinks that browbeating staff into indentured servitude is a way to improve the service but the opposite is true: look after the staff, train them well, and they will look after the patients. I believe Atul Gawande said that the focus of hospital management should be on improving the ability of staff to do their jobs well - this is how you improve patient care.

Unhappy staff and strikes go hand-in-hand with an under-resourced and poorly managed system. They are a consequence not the cause of a poor service for patients. You need to address the root cause. Unfortunately I think the problems with the NHS are fundamental as the demands are growing year on year. All the politicians suggest is just sticking plasters.

Neurodiversitydoctor · 08/02/2024 15:20

justteanbiscuits · 08/02/2024 13:50

Then you really should understand a hell of a lot better what the realities are.

What happens to the woman who becomes pregnant and wants a career break? Those that breakdown and have to change careers? What about those who, in their FYI years don't get a placement and so go locum? Or those that get a placement that is geographically impossible for them? Those that go into research? What about those that don't pass the exams when they're Junior doctors? Do they get the 5 years they have to work extended?

You want them to pay back £100k? Or just £50k? You liken it to other professions where they might have to pay back £10k maximum on leaving.

And those that do stay the 5 years. Does the NHS pay for the continuing qualifications, or will the Doctors continue having to pay for those? is it added onto the cost they have to pay if they leave?

As you will know you can't " go locum" until you have completed your foundation training. A career break is just that, you remain employed, all that would happen with Drs who don't work for the NHS is that they would get their student loans taken "at source" by HMRC like everyone does now if you are not earning or earning very little you don't pay. It really isn't that complicated.

pointythings · 08/02/2024 15:15

@Kosenrufugirl sadly I fear OP is not open to listening to facts and reason. She has been provided with so much data and has not acknowledged one iota of it. This is what we're up against.

Kosenrufugirl · 08/02/2024 14:40

pointythings · 08/02/2024 14:19

It is the normal for recruitment to band 5/6/7 nursing posts and most medical posts to take at least two rounds of advertising. The number of applicants is regularly 0. The cost to the NHS is huge, both in financial and in manpower terms. The only thing that will get the NHS back on its feet is improving pay and conditions. Beyond that, we need to reverse the huge rise in poverty and deprivation we have had over the last 14 years, in order to improve the general health of the population. Removing the right to strike will achieve none of this.

This!

pointythings · 08/02/2024 14:19

It is the normal for recruitment to band 5/6/7 nursing posts and most medical posts to take at least two rounds of advertising. The number of applicants is regularly 0. The cost to the NHS is huge, both in financial and in manpower terms. The only thing that will get the NHS back on its feet is improving pay and conditions. Beyond that, we need to reverse the huge rise in poverty and deprivation we have had over the last 14 years, in order to improve the general health of the population. Removing the right to strike will achieve none of this.

Kosenrufugirl · 08/02/2024 14:05

Neurodiversitydoctor · 08/02/2024 13:40

This doctor would be rightfully signed off sick. But remain employed by the trust I am not sure what you are suggesting ?

The post is about whether it's a good idea to remove the doctors right to strike as a solution to cancelled appointments. The doctors don't strike because they have nothing better to do. They strike to ensure there are sufficient numbers of doctors to provide safe care. And their pay is a big issue. It's been eroded by 35% since 2010. They are contracted to work 48 hours a week. They do 70 minimum. You don't walk away from the ward chaos just because your time is up. Not if you have the heart of a doctor. There are simply not enough doctors, nurses or midwives around. Young people don't want to put up with crap pay and conditions anymore. So they vote with their feet

Sunshine322 · 08/02/2024 14:00

justteanbiscuits · 08/02/2024 13:50

Then you really should understand a hell of a lot better what the realities are.

What happens to the woman who becomes pregnant and wants a career break? Those that breakdown and have to change careers? What about those who, in their FYI years don't get a placement and so go locum? Or those that get a placement that is geographically impossible for them? Those that go into research? What about those that don't pass the exams when they're Junior doctors? Do they get the 5 years they have to work extended?

You want them to pay back £100k? Or just £50k? You liken it to other professions where they might have to pay back £10k maximum on leaving.

And those that do stay the 5 years. Does the NHS pay for the continuing qualifications, or will the Doctors continue having to pay for those? is it added onto the cost they have to pay if they leave?

They could pay it back in much the same way they do now - deducted from salary as a percentage of earnings. Student debt is an enormous concern for junior drs, it reduces their net pay and is essentially another tax. For many years. From my discussions with junior drs since the strikes started, many would opt for fees being paid in exchange for a period of nhs service. Of course that is my own experiences of talking to my colleagues and doesn’t represent the whole population of junior drs out there. But no one here knows what ‘all’ junior drs would opt to do - perhaps the govt should ask them?

Kosenrufugirl · 08/02/2024 13:50

Sunshine322 · 08/02/2024 13:28

The nhs would pay fees for health care related degrees. Students undertaking those courses would sign an agreement that in exchange for their fees being paid, they will work in the nhs for so many years ( let’s say 5). It’s a simple concept and one that’s used by employers to a certain extent already when they pay for their employees to undertake post graduate study.

The key phrase in your post "they pay their employees ". So their employees already know the conditions they will return into. And their training last 1-2 years, not 7. Furthermore I worked as a health care assistant across 12 wards (including maternity) before I trained as a midwife. I thought I knew what I was getting into. I can assure up suddenly becoming fully responsible for the lives of 8 mothers and 8 babies for the duration of one 12 hour shift was a massive shock to the system (this is on a fully staffed postnatal word). And suddenly being responsible for the life of a mother and a baby on the labour ward - your stress levels are insanein thefirstyear. Thankfully I started a while ago so there was a lot of support around. So many newly qualified leave in the first year, they simply can't cope. Also you are saying the staff should commit for 5 years which sounds reasonable. Except in health care your first 5 years are spent from being a novice to finding your feet. Surely if your house was burgled you would prefer a policeman with 5 years of experience not just out of police academy. It's an unworkable idea even if it sounds good in principle.

justteanbiscuits · 08/02/2024 13:50

Spacecowboys · 08/02/2024 13:43

Ive worked in the nhs since 1999 🤣

Then you really should understand a hell of a lot better what the realities are.

What happens to the woman who becomes pregnant and wants a career break? Those that breakdown and have to change careers? What about those who, in their FYI years don't get a placement and so go locum? Or those that get a placement that is geographically impossible for them? Those that go into research? What about those that don't pass the exams when they're Junior doctors? Do they get the 5 years they have to work extended?

You want them to pay back £100k? Or just £50k? You liken it to other professions where they might have to pay back £10k maximum on leaving.

And those that do stay the 5 years. Does the NHS pay for the continuing qualifications, or will the Doctors continue having to pay for those? is it added onto the cost they have to pay if they leave?

Absolutely45 · 08/02/2024 13:43

What would you do to cut waiting lists and ensure you and patients did not lose out? Personally, I'd have a no-strike agreement, a numbers of years newly qualified staff worked for NHS and look at every contract NHS has with buying items, leasing, renting buildings, hiring of agency staff and changing contracts re the way some consultants worked etc. You can have your say without attacking me as my opinion is as valid as yours

Initially, a big increase in private sector doing operations.
Longer term, better pay and conditions and incentives to get PT AHPs back into FT work, reinstate the bursary and refund loan payments to staff.
Investments with equipment and buildings.

Banning and strikes and making staff become "bonded" workers is just going to ensure staff leave/don't join the NHS.

To pay for all this? well, that £26bn tax cut give away, would have paid for this a few times over.

Spacecowboys · 08/02/2024 13:43

justteanbiscuits · 08/02/2024 13:39

This really does show how little you know and understand health care.

Ive worked in the nhs since 1999 🤣

Neurodiversitydoctor · 08/02/2024 13:40

Kosenrufugirl · 08/02/2024 13:17

How would it work in real life? 50% of marriages end up in divorce. What would you want to do about a junior doctor sobbing their heart off because they single handedly covered the job of 2 doctors in the previous 3 shifts (each lasting 14 hours). And now they are having a panic attack at the prospect of going back to the ward . If you think it's not happening I can assure you it does and on a regular basis. So what would you want to do? Force them back to work? To look after your relatives and children?

This doctor would be rightfully signed off sick. But remain employed by the trust I am not sure what you are suggesting ?

justteanbiscuits · 08/02/2024 13:39

Spacecowboys · 08/02/2024 13:37

What do you mean? A dr who requires time off work due to stress will do so, whether they are tied into the nhs for 5 years or not. Opting to have fees paid and the resulting tie in would be a choice ( with the way I would implement it🤣) . So those wanting the freedom to leave the nhs at any point would still have that.

This really does show how little you know and understand health care.

Spacecowboys · 08/02/2024 13:37

Kosenrufugirl · 08/02/2024 13:17

How would it work in real life? 50% of marriages end up in divorce. What would you want to do about a junior doctor sobbing their heart off because they single handedly covered the job of 2 doctors in the previous 3 shifts (each lasting 14 hours). And now they are having a panic attack at the prospect of going back to the ward . If you think it's not happening I can assure you it does and on a regular basis. So what would you want to do? Force them back to work? To look after your relatives and children?

What do you mean? A dr who requires time off work due to stress will do so, whether they are tied into the nhs for 5 years or not. Opting to have fees paid and the resulting tie in would be a choice ( with the way I would implement it🤣) . So those wanting the freedom to leave the nhs at any point would still have that.

herewegoroundthebastardbush · 08/02/2024 13:36

DistinguishedSocialCommenator · 06/02/2024 13:21

If that is the case, may I politely ask if those joining to train up as new doctors have their heads buried in the sand? IE not aware of the T&C's and long hours?

TBH, there should be new rules where we the state taxpayers fund new doctors' training to an extent, after qualifying to be made to work for the NHS for an X amount of time and this applies to other NHS staff as well ie nurses etc. Why should taxpayers fork out millions every year for someone to get trained and then go and work in another country without giving something back. That is not an unreasonable expectation!.

If I was going to train in a profession, I'd be naive not to consider, and investigate payscales, prospects, working conditions etc it is really as simple as that.

My idea is not new - this idea was rightly talked about by the respected Mr Jeremy Hunt - see below and why not?

https://www.gponline.com/doctors-face-four-year-mandatory-nhs-service-jeremy-hunt-expands-medical-training/article/1410975

See now I know you're trolling. "The respected Jeremy Hunt" 😂 Good one!

Sunshine322 · 08/02/2024 13:28

Kosenrufugirl · 08/02/2024 13:17

How would it work in real life? 50% of marriages end up in divorce. What would you want to do about a junior doctor sobbing their heart off because they single handedly covered the job of 2 doctors in the previous 3 shifts (each lasting 14 hours). And now they are having a panic attack at the prospect of going back to the ward . If you think it's not happening I can assure you it does and on a regular basis. So what would you want to do? Force them back to work? To look after your relatives and children?

The nhs would pay fees for health care related degrees. Students undertaking those courses would sign an agreement that in exchange for their fees being paid, they will work in the nhs for so many years ( let’s say 5). It’s a simple concept and one that’s used by employers to a certain extent already when they pay for their employees to undertake post graduate study.

Swipe left for the next trending thread