Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Doctors right to strike, should it be removed?

737 replies

DistinguishedSocialCommenator · 06/02/2024 09:49

Hello
Several people within our families are doctors. Most started out wanting to care for people, but as time goes on, the reality of money, and spending comes into play for some.

PM Rishi Sunak in a tv interview partly balmed doctors strikes for failing to bring down hospital waiting lists. I rarely agree with a politician but in this case, I know he is right. EG, myself, my OH, one of our children and grandchildren have had their appointments cancelled because of strike impacts. Our children and grandchildren do have private healthcare but those do not cover pre-existing or you end up on the NHS with chorionic conditions.

Our police officers and armed forces personnel are not allowed to strike

AIBU to expect a no-strike agreement for doctors and possibly nurses. If agreed, give them 9 months' notice about no-strike agreements. I honestly believe hardly anyone would leave and those leaving would have possibly left the NHS anyway as some do and go to another country just like we get doctors from abroad. Their pay claims could be easily managed in the same way police/armed forces pay rises are managed as well of those MP's.

Failing to bring down hospital w/l lies with the present government and the growing of these waiting lists, the doctor's strikes have certainly made things a lot worse. We are regularly hearing on our news media about growing waiting lists and people waiting for urgent treatments and the waiting times in A&E departments etc

AIBU to feel that doctors should be made to sign a no-strike agreement with a few month's notice to have the no-strike agreement in place before next winter? Also, have a pay body set up like the ones our MP's enjoy.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
37
ginnybag · 09/02/2024 11:14

No,

But if they do, it should be only with a legal agreement that all public sector workers receive the higher of either the % benefits increase, the % min wage increase or the % mp wage increase each year.

This would immediately stop the devaluation of their roles and guarantee at least the same chunk as the people agreeing the pay rises. Job done.

Tevion1213 · 09/02/2024 11:11

Yes I agree they shouldn't be allowed to strike I say this, as somebody who works in healthcare for pittiful pay and hours but we don't strike as its human beings.

SerendipityJane · 09/02/2024 10:41

Customers can strike too - ask Rosa Parkes. Although I can imagine some posters here happily telling her she wasted her time.

And voters can "strike". In some cases by not voting ever for a certain party ever.

(Not voting at all is obviously signalling you are happy to be arse-fucked and don't care what implement is used)

thedankness · 09/02/2024 10:38

@DistinguishedSocialCommenator Your suggestions all include lots more money and investment in the NHS, which is what you said you were opposed to upthread.

thedankness · 09/02/2024 10:36

The police are not allowed to strike, yet I don't see how that has benefited the service whatsoever? Everyone knows the police are so stretched that many crimes go uninvestigated. Part of the problem with the misogyny and sex offenders in the police is because they are so understaffed they can't be highly selective for the best applicants. The police force isn't competitive or attractive enough.

literalviolence · 09/02/2024 10:33

I guess that went hand in hand with a commitment to no change teems and conditions so that the contract Dr's interested into never changed. That would need to include wages keeping track with inflation, not increasing the pension age, no forced change of job role, not suddenly making staff pay to park at their work place. For the older Dr's, that would be a massive bill for the NHS.

DistinguishedSocialCommenator · 09/02/2024 10:20

Thank you
@pointythings

I've declared already re mandatory contracts and bursaries. and no strike agreements

Point one is fundamentally flawed, IE people are already waiting to see private health care needs as in certain areas/sectors waiting lists but nowhere near as long as NHS. Often the same docs/consultants also work in the NHS.

I recommend we send people to Norway/Finland and a couple of their countries within a couple of hours' flight from the uk for HC needs, EG diagnosis test, ops - this option is offered and people can decide if to go there or stay and there will be many cant travels but many that could.

We least hospital ships and I believe one or two have state-of-the-art scanning machines etc.

Health education is important and this must be included more so in our schools as well as financial responsibility and HC responsibility

NB: Ensure there is a decent stand-by list of 2/4 hours where appoints have been cancelled for one reason or another and stand-by people can utilise which otherwise would have been a wasted appointment

In our major cities, about 4 of them, have central units that only scan people a bit like a production line that is fully supported by newly trained staff that can easily ID urgent needs and progress them

We need to reduce budget on our armed services and redirect it toward the NHS as many billions are wasted a year, we don't need two carriers and we dont need to increase our front-line fighter jets by 200% as recently talked about.

Reduced the number of tanks as in modern warfare is not great.

Half the number of MP's and abo,lish the Lords and give the money to NHS.

Get more people back into work as there are a few that can work and wont work.

Sell the BBC and channel 4 and use that money towards the NHS units as I stated and their support.

Raise VAT on every item that costs more than 500 pounds RRP to 30% and use the money towards NHS and education re better health for all. (Most washing machines, driers, fridges, tv's, sofas, beds, clothing, food, and eating out cost m a lot less than 500. A bit like the new tax that was introduced many years ago on cars costing RRP 40k plus

OP posts:
pointythings · 09/02/2024 09:56

You have already had the answer around reducing waiting lists, you just don't want to hear it. It's this:

  1. Short term, fund catchup procedures in the private sector.
  2. Pay doctors and nurses properly, I.e. not less than they were getting in 2010.
  3. Invest in eradicating poverty to improve the general health of the population.

Alongside this, fully restore bursaries for nurses and scrap their tuition fees, reform student finance and fund NHS trusts so that they can afford safe staffing, because this will reduce the strain on staff and improve retention.

Remove the need to strike, it's as simple as that. The Tories keep going on about 'back to square one' - well, I remember 2010. Things were not perfect, but they were infinitely better than they are now.

Everyone should have the right to strike, including police and military, because it is the only way of holding the government to account. You say you're not a Conservative - your seeking the race to the bottom doesn't suggest this is the case.

NerdyIsMyMiddleName · 09/02/2024 09:55

I work with these striking doctors (though not a doctor). They always cover urgent services, and if we think that something urgently needs their attention, they've made it clear we can talk to them.

We're fully behind them, they've been totally shafted over recent years, and if they're not striking then they'll be handing in their notice permanently, which is worse!

I'm not even going to go into what I think of the scapegoating of hospital staff by the government for their own failings and mismanagement.

DistinguishedSocialCommenator · 09/02/2024 09:46

YoureALizardHarry11 · 09/02/2024 00:57

If they lose the right to strike they should be suitably rewarded for accepting that clause, else you will have nobody bothering to train in medicine for the crap pay, crap work conditions and no right to strike for change. Absolutely stupid idea. YABU.

"stupid idea" "no one bothering to train.."

Please let's get real. A precedence has already been set re no strikes contract, look at our police force. Are you telling me no one is joining the police force or armed services? The same is often said about police pay as per your post but please do let me know if we are not getting a daily influx of new staff in the police and armed forces.

Left to me, I paid all NHS staff , police, armed services and other important working groups a million pounds a week but it does not work like that as we live in the real world

Your post is fundamentally flawed for the reason I have posted above.

How would you reduce waiting lists and why is the government not doing this as obsv they want to win the next election

OP posts:
YoureALizardHarry11 · 09/02/2024 00:57

If they lose the right to strike they should be suitably rewarded for accepting that clause, else you will have nobody bothering to train in medicine for the crap pay, crap work conditions and no right to strike for change. Absolutely stupid idea. YABU.

Britneyfan · 09/02/2024 00:18

@DistinguishedSocialCommenator you have a very funny way of “thanking” NHS staff is all I will say!

Southeastmumma · 08/02/2024 23:31

It really depends if you want any doctors to continue to work in the NHS, or for there to be an NHS for them to work in. If you are happy for the UK to move to entirely private healthcare aside from an emergency system mainly staffed with non doctors, crack on and continue thinking it's a good idea to remove the right to strike.

Kosenrufugirl · 08/02/2024 23:17

DistinguishedSocialCommenator · 08/02/2024 21:44

Lol. I've said it before and say it again, I have no time for any politician.
I have never supported a single political party as they look after themselves first and everyone else comes last.

I suggest that you start getting political. Because everything in life is politics. From the permitted additives in your loaf of bread to the age you can start drawing your pension to the protection your money enjoy in your bank account- all of this is governed by laws. And laws are made by the law-makers, another name for politicians. Strike laws are made by politicians and could only be cancelled by politicians if enough of the public vote for it. Your thread is incredibly political whether you realise it or not

Kosenrufugirl · 08/02/2024 23:07

anonhop · 08/02/2024 21:07

@kintra

But...it kind of is? I accept it's a legal right, I'm arguing from a moral and philosophical standpoint that's it's wrong to break a contract you've signed.

Doctors regularly do the jobs of 2 doctors with all the implications for patients' safety. Because there aren't enough of them. Is it what they sign up for? Very often they don't get to choose which Trust they go to, they are posted as a result of their training. Even if they knew the Trust had staff shortages, by your logic it would be better if no doctor signed up unless decent work conditions are guaranteed

StrongWhite · 08/02/2024 22:13

DistinguishedSocialCommenator · 08/02/2024 21:41

Read my post, we dont have it our children do and we used private and paid cash ie our moeny direct as wanted results quickly - we are no fools and aware how A& E works and I've stated in the thread several times I thank NHS staff for their hard work

Thank you

Same principle unless you have limitless funds as you get older and less healthy.

The irony of your assertion of not being a fool when every single sentence you write just screams the opposite.

DontLeanOnTheKeyboard · 08/02/2024 21:46

If all the NHS staff, all prison staff, Armed Forces and Police voted with their feet, what’s going to happen, OP? Why on God’s earth would anyone want to work in a field where you don’t get regular breaks, go to the loo, you have rest days cancelled at short notice - people say ‘they knew what they were getting into’ - that doesn’t make it ok.

The MP Pay body awarded them something like 14% mid austerity where no public services received a pay rise for 3 years!

The ‘protections’ you mention the police having - they can’t be made redundant. That’s it, otherwise they are subject to the same employment lawyers.

Awful attitude, OP. Oh and ps - the wait lists started growing through Covid and then dramatically when the Tories removed some of the treatment targets. And allowed qualified people to leave, which they did, having got sick of being treated like shit and always being at fault for failings a properly funded NHS wouldn’t have.

DistinguishedSocialCommenator · 08/02/2024 21:44

Chylka · 08/02/2024 18:19

Is it just me, or are there loads of threads at the moment that are probably being started by Tory HQ…

Lol. I've said it before and say it again, I have no time for any politician.
I have never supported a single political party as they look after themselves first and everyone else comes last.

OP posts:
DistinguishedSocialCommenator · 08/02/2024 21:41

StrongWhite · 08/02/2024 18:02

Good luck with your private health insurance@DistinguishedSocialCommenator when you need A&E care or you get beyond the diagnostics phase to a chronic condition that's not covered.

And with regard to your username, it is about as accurate a description of your observations as it is to be calling Jeremy Hunt respected.

Read my post, we dont have it our children do and we used private and paid cash ie our moeny direct as wanted results quickly - we are no fools and aware how A& E works and I've stated in the thread several times I thank NHS staff for their hard work

Thank you

OP posts:
pointythings · 08/02/2024 21:28

So @anonhop what would you prefer? That doctors and nurses leave the UK, or go and work in LIDL, leaving patients ever more at risk of cancelled operations, unsafe care, medication errors? Aside from the fact that the right to strike is a legal right and the fact that your moral argument only holds water if employers (in this case the government) also act morally (and they are not - they have ignored the recommendations of pay review bodies, for instance) - the end absoslutely does justify the means.

mumsneedwine · 08/02/2024 21:23

What contract ? Doctors are employed by a Trust, not the NHS. Their contracts end every few years and they have to reapply for jobs.

Notonthestairs · 08/02/2024 21:22

They aren't breaking a contract. There is a statutory immunity (provided that the union follows our incredibly prescriptive legislation).

BIossomtoes · 08/02/2024 21:21

anonhop · 08/02/2024 21:07

@kintra

But...it kind of is? I accept it's a legal right, I'm arguing from a moral and philosophical standpoint that's it's wrong to break a contract you've signed.

That works both ways. Employers are breaking employees’ contracts all the time in the NHS. Particularly doctors who work hundreds of hours of unpaid overtime.

StrongWhite · 08/02/2024 21:21

anonhop · 08/02/2024 20:53

@StrongWhite

Not really. It's a point about the ends not justifying the means. In other words, just because something achieves something good, doesn't mean it's a moral thing to do.

Breaking a contract you signed is immoral.

I think it is for the healthcare professionals to decide whether the ends justify the means as they are the only ones that really understand the severity of the situation and its danger to life. I can't see how anyone could deem just accepting working conditions where patients are put in danger to be more 'moral' than taking a public stance against it. Suggests that you don't have much of an understanding of what's going on at all.

anonhop · 08/02/2024 21:07

@kintra

But...it kind of is? I accept it's a legal right, I'm arguing from a moral and philosophical standpoint that's it's wrong to break a contract you've signed.

Swipe left for the next trending thread