Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Girls trip abroad - who was in the wrong?

433 replies

Travellinggirly · 05/02/2024 20:35

This happened last year but I’ve realised it has been bothering me ever since and has made me pull back from this particular group of friends so wanted to get some opinions.

So group of Mums went on a trip abroad. This is a longstanding friendship group but one that don’t really see each other that regularly (some individuals see more of each other than others but as a group it’s more special occasions and occasional weekends away).

Anyway on one of the nights there was a big local festival taking place, culminating in a huge fireworks display (think a smaller London NYE set off a bridge to music). Two of the group bailed out early in the evening as felt the streets were getting too busy. Remaining four stayed out and later started to head down to where fireworks were happening. But then as we got nearer some of this group also started making noises about the crowds and wanting to hang back. Decided to go no further. I personally really wanted to see the display as had heard it was meant to be amazing and the spot we had stopped at wasn’t far away from where we needed to be - they had basically stopped at one end of a street and we needed to be the other end but from where we were we couldn’t see the bridge at all.

So I basically said I wanted to carry on so I could see them - no one else wanted to come with me so agreed I would go and they would stay where they were. But then at some point whilst waiting for the fireworks to start I got a message to say it had started to get too busy where they were so they had also headed back to hotel. So basically I was left out alone in a foreign country about half an hours walk from our hotel (probably almost 1am by time I got back).

I think they knew I was upset the next day but I decided not to make an issue out of it and ruin the rest of the trip. The person I was sharing a room with though I did say briefly say to that I was pissed off they left me alone but she basically said it was my decision to stay out.

AIBU to think you don’t leave one friend out on their own in a foreign country and maybe at least one person could have stayed to make sure I got home ok? Or was I being difficult wanting to stay out when clearly no one else did and I should have just left when they did regardless if I wanted to see the fireworks? In my opinion though it would have been such a shame to miss them (and they were amazing). But now I’m left feeling like these aren’t real friends and I’ve started finding excuses to bail out of some of the get togethers. Thanks in advance for any views on this!

OP posts:
Tiredmama53 · 06/02/2024 20:29

I think everyone was being unreasonable. Your friends didn't feel safe and so you expecting them to stay out wasn't reasonable but equally no matter how much a friend was being unreasonable I wouldn't leave them in a situation I'd already judged as unsafe.

Ultimately your fault though I think.

Starzinsky · 06/02/2024 19:39

Yeah you decided to go on your own, not sure they would assume you would be so concerned being left on your own.

Lalalalala555 · 06/02/2024 18:27

You were happy to go and watch the fireworks alone and leave the group. That was your decision.

If you wanted to walk back with them, you should have said something.

The problem here is you're expecting people to understand what you want without clearly expressing it.
People are their own people, and people have their own right to determine how to spend their own time and make out what is right and wrong to them in the grey zone things.

Your safety is ultimately your responsibility. You chose to left the group.
You could have mitigated the situation by

  • not leaving the group
  • expressing that you do not feel safe walking back on your own, so would they be prepared to wait for you or give you a heads up if they decide to head back so you can go with them
  • getting a taxi

Your idea of what is safe will differ to others. It's not black and white.

I can see why you're upset, but I think the issue is that if you haven't given clear requests and communication then it's a lesson you need to learn yourself.
If you'd asked your friends that you wanted to walk back with them over watching the fireworks, as you wanted to be safe then fair.

But you expecting four people to ammend their evening to hang around waiting for you, when you chose to leave a group. It's unfair. You are inconveniencing four people. Whereas you could have chosen to not watch the fireworks.

What you did was prioritise watching fireworks over your own safety. And then blame other people for not enabling you to have both. It's not fair to manipulate people and have a strop.

You ask directly before hand for you needs, if they agreed and then left without saying anything then that's unfair.
If they said no, and you watched fireworks anyway and then were pissed, that's on you.

TheSnakeCharmer · 06/02/2024 18:16

None of you were being unreasonable. You were fine to go off on your own to see the fireworks if that was what you really wanted. Presumably no one was pissed off with you for abandoning the group? As you were clearly sufficiently independent to go on and see them by yourself, why should they hang around waiting for you? They were correct to presume that you would also be ok to get home by yourself.

saraclara · 06/02/2024 17:58

I should just thank God youre safe

Oh for goodness sake...

Noglitterallowed · 06/02/2024 17:31

juanitasolis · 06/02/2024 16:48

I wanted to carry on so I could see them - no one else wanted to come with me

at least one person could have stayed to make sure I got home ok?

So basically I was left out alone in a foreign country

Why is your preference more important than theirs? and why is it not ok for you to be out alone in a foreign country but you expect one of the group to stand, alone in a foreign country, and wait for you.

Exactly this!!

juanitasolis · 06/02/2024 16:48

I wanted to carry on so I could see them - no one else wanted to come with me

at least one person could have stayed to make sure I got home ok?

So basically I was left out alone in a foreign country

Why is your preference more important than theirs? and why is it not ok for you to be out alone in a foreign country but you expect one of the group to stand, alone in a foreign country, and wait for you.

HarkHarkBark · 06/02/2024 16:38

NoraBattysCurlers · 06/02/2024 16:35

I’m a bit puzzled at the gap between ‘left all alone in a foreign country — waah’ and ‘I’m much more brave and into pushing my comfort zone than my timid friends’.

Well, the OP was so much braver and adventurous than her "completely wussed out" friends.

Until, the OP wasn't.

Maybe they didn’t go back to the hotel, maybe they went skinnydipping in the river, or went off to do shots in a speakeasy with hoodlums…😀

Noglitterallowed · 06/02/2024 16:36

On a group trip majority rules surely? If you choose otherwise that’s on you TBF

NoraBattysCurlers · 06/02/2024 16:35

I’m a bit puzzled at the gap between ‘left all alone in a foreign country — waah’ and ‘I’m much more brave and into pushing my comfort zone than my timid friends’.

Well, the OP was so much braver and adventurous than her "completely wussed out" friends.

Until, the OP wasn't.

Noglitterallowed · 06/02/2024 16:32

Were you in the middle of a war zone or something? Why was it so dangerous but still you chose there for a holiday? Also you decided to watch the fireworks so yeah you YABU

LouLomumoftwo · 06/02/2024 15:41

tbh i think you were unreasonable to expect other people to hang about when they clearly didn't want to, yes it would have been nice to see some fireworks but are you prepared to throw away years of friendship because you effectively spat the dummy and stick your heels in when everyone else wanted to go home. If i had said i wanted to stay out, and insisted in doing so i'd be well aware that i was being responsible for myself, foreign country or not. You can't play the, 'your not a true friend if you don't do what i want' card and expect all your own way. I've never had this kind of issue because we all compromise on what we do and where and when....... for everyone to enjoy, not just one.

lifeispainauchocolat · 06/02/2024 15:38

Wednesdaysphiltrum · 06/02/2024 11:27

She strongly insinuated they were afraid as the crowds started to build as they all fled, that they weren’t particularly adventurous or seasoned travellers and they were deeply uncomfortable by a collection of people in a country abroad. I wondered why.

I think it's quite normal not to like crowds. I find them really stressful and overwhelming.

toomuchfaff · 06/02/2024 15:28

Travellinggirly · 05/02/2024 20:47

Thank you. It’s been interesting to get some perspective as I’ve been turning this over in my mind for so long.
I agree that out of everyone in the group, they probably see me as the most capable to be left on my own as I’m quite well travelled. I think it was more that our hotel was a bit out of town so it was about half an hour walk on my own after the fireworks at midnight (and I did get a bit lost). I just felt that for me personally in a reversed situation I would NEVER have left any friend out alone abroad, whatever the circumstances.

but you left them, to go off alone.

Was one meant to stay (alone) in case you returned, not knowing when or where you'd gone or if you'd be back, then that person would be alone.

You were unreasonable when the majority wanted to leave and you went off. If you didn't have an ally at that time you should have stayed with the group.

TheCadoganArms · 06/02/2024 15:19

Vonesk · 06/02/2024 14:46

You are right to feel P. Off.
You are right to value your safety.
Theres so much going on here.
Difficult to know whos at fault.
But girls should stick together.
I guess you must have started to panic as it got later and later.
I would too.
I should just thank God youre safe.
And know that you will be safer going forward as you know what to expect from ' friends'
To be honest ,Ive done this to a friend who kept wanting me and trying to get me to stay at parties till 3 am. After telling her lots of times" Im leaving at midnight" she kept ignoring me repeatedly ( Im not saying you did thus) but I just went home and left her.

You are right to value your safety.

I guess you must have started to panic as it got later and later.

I should just thank God youre safe.

So the display was in Mogadishu?

TrustyRusty68 · 06/02/2024 14:58

If they said they’d wait, they should’ve waited. I absolutely wouldn’t have left anyone in that situation on their own.

rookiemere · 06/02/2024 14:52

Yes I suspect if they had messaged and said we want to leave do you want to come with us, OP would have tried to convince them to stay for the fireworks, so the end scenario- OP going home alone - would be the same.

Underestimated4 · 06/02/2024 14:49

If you were the only one wanting to stay out and others didn’t you can’t expect them to stay. They told you they were heading back so if you were so bothered about being on your own you should have left with them. Rather than stay alone to complain afterwards.

Vonesk · 06/02/2024 14:46

You are right to feel P. Off.
You are right to value your safety.
Theres so much going on here.
Difficult to know whos at fault.
But girls should stick together.
I guess you must have started to panic as it got later and later.
I would too.
I should just thank God youre safe.
And know that you will be safer going forward as you know what to expect from ' friends'
To be honest ,Ive done this to a friend who kept wanting me and trying to get me to stay at parties till 3 am. After telling her lots of times" Im leaving at midnight" she kept ignoring me repeatedly ( Im not saying you did thus) but I just went home and left her.

CantDealwithChristmas · 06/02/2024 14:39

TBH, unless this trip was in Kinshasa or Kabul then you were fine to be left alone, and you can't expect the majority to do something they don't want to do just because you wanted them to wait for you.

BlackAldi · 06/02/2024 14:15

YABU, it was your decision and they clearly communicated with you. You need to get over it.

RantyAnty · 06/02/2024 13:43

You're being difficult and precious.

You wanted to see it. They didn't.

You stayed. Nothing happened to you did it?

Let it go.

PumpkinsAndCoconuts · 06/02/2024 13:03

TheCadoganArms · 06/02/2024 11:31

No, but the drama of an event several months old is still playing out with in depth analysis, simmering resentment and the friendship group potentially at risk. All over a split group decision over the viewing of a firework display. It's mad.

Drama? They continued their holiday without any fallout and are apparently still friends. Where’s the drama?

this seems to have come up again in the context of booking an other group holiday, which seems completely reasonable.

ReinNotReignItIn · 06/02/2024 13:02

Wednesdaysphiltrum · 06/02/2024 11:27

She strongly insinuated they were afraid as the crowds started to build as they all fled, that they weren’t particularly adventurous or seasoned travellers and they were deeply uncomfortable by a collection of people in a country abroad. I wondered why.

I don't think it just has to be about 'fear' in the way you imply. When I went to watch the bastille day fireworks and saw the crowd building at the foot of the Eiffel Tower, I was not feeling 100% that evening. I realised it would take me at least 30 mins just to get out of the immediate vicinity and then another 30 mins to walk to the hotel.

Hence I left and walked to a viewpoint halfway to my hotel. It was a practical idea that suited my energy! I was not ‘scared’ for my safety in the crowd but just wanted to get out quickly. I love in Londoners and crowds don’t usually bother me one bit!

rookiemere · 06/02/2024 12:41

OP has decided in her last update that she's probably not a good fit for this group and that seems a sensible decision. I think it's telling that out of 4 other people not a single one wanted to go with her for a closer view of the fireworks in the crowd.
I don't mean there is anything wrong with the OP it's just obvious that what she wants to do is different to this group.