Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Girls trip abroad - who was in the wrong?

433 replies

Travellinggirly · 05/02/2024 20:35

This happened last year but I’ve realised it has been bothering me ever since and has made me pull back from this particular group of friends so wanted to get some opinions.

So group of Mums went on a trip abroad. This is a longstanding friendship group but one that don’t really see each other that regularly (some individuals see more of each other than others but as a group it’s more special occasions and occasional weekends away).

Anyway on one of the nights there was a big local festival taking place, culminating in a huge fireworks display (think a smaller London NYE set off a bridge to music). Two of the group bailed out early in the evening as felt the streets were getting too busy. Remaining four stayed out and later started to head down to where fireworks were happening. But then as we got nearer some of this group also started making noises about the crowds and wanting to hang back. Decided to go no further. I personally really wanted to see the display as had heard it was meant to be amazing and the spot we had stopped at wasn’t far away from where we needed to be - they had basically stopped at one end of a street and we needed to be the other end but from where we were we couldn’t see the bridge at all.

So I basically said I wanted to carry on so I could see them - no one else wanted to come with me so agreed I would go and they would stay where they were. But then at some point whilst waiting for the fireworks to start I got a message to say it had started to get too busy where they were so they had also headed back to hotel. So basically I was left out alone in a foreign country about half an hours walk from our hotel (probably almost 1am by time I got back).

I think they knew I was upset the next day but I decided not to make an issue out of it and ruin the rest of the trip. The person I was sharing a room with though I did say briefly say to that I was pissed off they left me alone but she basically said it was my decision to stay out.

AIBU to think you don’t leave one friend out on their own in a foreign country and maybe at least one person could have stayed to make sure I got home ok? Or was I being difficult wanting to stay out when clearly no one else did and I should have just left when they did regardless if I wanted to see the fireworks? In my opinion though it would have been such a shame to miss them (and they were amazing). But now I’m left feeling like these aren’t real friends and I’ve started finding excuses to bail out of some of the get togethers. Thanks in advance for any views on this!

OP posts:
Stravaig · 07/02/2024 22:59

Your friends felt unsafe on the streets, even in a group, so they acted to ensure their safety. You were included, but you turned down two chances to stay with them.

You felt safer on the streets, although less so on your own, but you chose to prioritise seeing the spectacle over ensuring your safety.

You think they should have ignored their own feelings of vulnerability and risk in order to prevent you from feeling vulnerable or at risk. That's wholly unreasonable. They're not your unpaid bodyguards, ffs! Hire professionals next time.

LibbyL92 · 07/02/2024 22:27

I’ve been in this situation before. There were three of us.

we were in a big city abroad clubbing. I had not been feeling well all trip. Was due an op when I was home.

I specifically said on a fair few occasions that night I wanted to go home.

one really wanted to stay the other also wanted to leave.

the one who wanted to stay keep forcing us to stay out.

anyway, after a while I walk off and left. I was done and was not staying out against my will.

once I approached a taxi, friend number two was behind me. She had also left.

a few hours later friend who we left storms in the room absolutely furious we left her.

still to do this day I stand my ground and say I would not of done anything differently. I was sick, she knew. And I had mentioned I wanted to leave on various occasions. So I did.

friend number two leaving had nothing to do with me.

Bringtheweatherwithyou · 07/02/2024 22:19

1offnamechange · 07/02/2024 22:04

No, but they needed to tell her before she walked off that they weren't going to wait, using their words like grown ups, rather than agreeing they would wait for her and then sneaking off.

  1. They were very uncomfortable with the crowds that gathered.
  2. The OP said she wasn't checking her phone.
  3. The phone reception was poor.
  4. The OP had left her friends in no doubt that she was 'capable' and 'adventurous' enough to go on her own provided her friends stayed close nearby as her safety net
  5. The OP said even if she had read their message, she wouldn't have been able to make her way back to them.
  6. The friends would have ended up waiting, without getting a reply from the OP, for potentially hours until she made her way back to them.
Halfwaytheree · 07/02/2024 22:17

Also it’s really hard to say what I’d do in your situation as it’s unlikely I’d end up being the one that wants to stay out longer than anyone else.

If I were your friends and desperately wanted to go home whilst you went off by yourself, I would have tried to call and message you to let you know that I need to leave and failing that, check if someone was available to meet you and take you home (eg your partner). But if it’s in the middle of the night, in a massive crowd, I can’t find you, you’re not answering your phone, you’re in a foreign country and no one else is on hand to collect you etc - how long do you want me to give to wait for you? Ultimately if I’m by myself waiting for a friend who’s swanned off somewhere by themselves, we’re both in a vulnerable situation

RadiatorHead · 07/02/2024 22:14

You were the annoying friend. I’ve been in groups like this where literally everyone wants to leave and one straggler is stopping everyone leaving. Good on all these women for not pandering to you. You don’t have to like their actions but they’re not wrong for wanting to go home.

Bringtheweatherwithyou · 07/02/2024 22:14

I think you need to decide if you're happier doing more adventurous holidays on your own and that means without thinking/assuming that someone else is going to make sure you're safe and comfortable all the time. Because you have carried resentment for quite a long time that the friends didn't wait for you (although you admitted in the same post that you weren't checking your phone much anyway so they would have been waiting nervously for quite some time). It doesn't sound as if you are really as adventurous as you like to think you are - at least when you don't have a safety net watching out for you. If that is what you need from a holiday companion, you should probably holiday with your mum.....(not joking!).

Halfwaytheree · 07/02/2024 22:09

To be honest I think you’re both in the wrong, but I also think you put yourself in this predicament.

I don’t think women should be left alone to travel home at midnight after an evening out. Lone women are vulnerable so it’s a safety risk.

however the rest of your group obviously felt like there was a safety risk by being out in a massive crowd and they did let you know they weren’t feeling it and wanted to go home/back to the hotel. I personally wouldn’t “force” anyone to stay out longer than they wanted to especially if they’re making noises that they’re not comfortable- so if my friends felt the night is over for them, I’ll be happy to go home with them. there isn’t really a perfect solution in this situation - which person is forced to do something they don’t want to do?

ultimately for me, safety comes first. Fireworks are nice, especially abroad, but it’s not really a major sentimental thing that I’d stay on later for and watch by myself in the middle of a massive crowd with no real transportation to get home. So I would have left it, just to ensure I’m home safe

easylikeasundaymorn · 07/02/2024 22:09

Londonrach1 · 07/02/2024 21:54

Group holiday if everyone goes back you go back. You can't expect everyone to hang around for you. Yabu. However you should have returned to them when they said they going back so not on your own.

have you completely missed the part where OP didn't have the option to do this? At the point she left they said they were going to stay at the other end of the street and wait for her. They didn't send her a message saying they were going in 5 minutes and to come back if she didn't want to be left alone, they sent her one to say they had already left - she couldn't have gone with them.

FrogLion · 07/02/2024 22:05

I wouldn't have left one friend alone even if I didn't like crowds, so if we're on holiday there'd always be two people. In this situation, I would have asked you to come back, then you could have said leave me it's ok, or wait for me to walk together.

1offnamechange · 07/02/2024 22:04

MyGooseisTotallyLoose · 07/02/2024 21:56

GSo they need to do something they don't want to because the op wants to do something different?

No, but they needed to tell her before she walked off that they weren't going to wait, using their words like grown ups, rather than agreeing they would wait for her and then sneaking off.

easylikeasundaymorn · 07/02/2024 22:03

Scalby · 07/02/2024 21:27

You were ok on your own (your decision), but expected at least one of your group to wait for you not to be alright on your own and they were supposed to know this and be at your beck and call? I'm shocked you think anyone else is to blame

come on, there's HUGE a difference to being ok on your own in a set location for a short period of time knowing your friends are very nearby if you need anything, with a plan to walk back to the hotel together, than being completely on your own in a strange place, not realising your friends had gone until it was too late to catch up with them, and having to find your own way home in the middle of the night!

If they had all left at the same time as the first friends to go back to the hotel and OP had decided to stay out your point would be fair, but they told her they would stay and wait for her and then left her! Your post implies her friends needed to be psychic to understand what she wanted, but she literally told them - I'm going to walk to the end of the street to see the fireworks, with the understanding they would wait for her. If they didn't want to the time to tell her would have been then

ilovesushi · 07/02/2024 22:00

It sounds like you had separated from them already and struck out alone. If it was so packed with people surely it would be hard to find each other again in the crush. I would think it was unreasonable to have everyone wait for me in the street outside where they couldn't see anything. But if the walk back was unsafe then yes they were unreasonable.

MyGooseisTotallyLoose · 07/02/2024 21:56

Led921900 · 07/02/2024 21:52

It’s not about that though, the compromise was they would wait at a quieter end of the road and OP would carry on. They totally went back on the agreement and just left her?

GSo they need to do something they don't want to because the op wants to do something different?

Londonrach1 · 07/02/2024 21:54

Group holiday if everyone goes back you go back. You can't expect everyone to hang around for you. Yabu. However you should have returned to them when they said they going back so not on your own.

Led921900 · 07/02/2024 21:52

MyGooseisTotallyLoose · 07/02/2024 21:19

Just checking with all the #teamop posters, so you would see your friends not doing what you want, and dancing to your tune as shit friends?

It’s not about that though, the compromise was they would wait at a quieter end of the road and OP would carry on. They totally went back on the agreement and just left her?

Led921900 · 07/02/2024 21:50

If I had made a promise to a friend to wait at the end of the road whilst she carried on to watch some fireworks I would have waited.
If I had obviously wanted to go back and you went off anyway I’m not sure.

how big and busy were these crowds?

but I think you’re doing the right thing by dialling down the friendship a bit.

Scalby · 07/02/2024 21:27

You were ok on your own (your decision), but expected at least one of your group to wait for you not to be alright on your own and they were supposed to know this and be at your beck and call? I'm shocked you think anyone else is to blame

MyGooseisTotallyLoose · 07/02/2024 21:19

Just checking with all the #teamop posters, so you would see your friends not doing what you want, and dancing to your tune as shit friends?

MyGooseisTotallyLoose · 07/02/2024 21:17

Cakelollipop · 07/02/2024 20:26

They were shit mates IMO. I would have rang you and said I’m going back are you coming cos we will wait so we can walk together. Would never have let a friend walk home alone when we were in a group, regardless of if it was at night or in a foreign country.

Surely being your mates they’d know you well enough to know you wouldn’t like that situation?

Edited

So you'd have been happy to wait about on your own, possibly for hours in a place you felt uncomfortable until your friend had done what they wanted and were ready to be escorted home?

Debtfreegoals · 07/02/2024 21:11

I think since covid people are more anxious with crowds and I wouldn’t feel comfortable doing it in a foreign country. However they shouldn’t have left to walk back alone to the hotel. Regardless if they were frustrated with you that’s not ok

Danielle9891 · 07/02/2024 20:38

YABU
Did you expect them to wait at the end of a street for you to come back? You could have been over an hour. They said they were uncomfortable with the crowds and you chose to go alone.

I've travelled all over the world solo and went to Sydney new year firework display by myself, i really don't see why you were upset. It's different if you were a drunk teenager and they left you at a club but a crowded street is ok, especially as you choose to go.

ShouldIbeLeftWithLess · 07/02/2024 20:33

I might be a little annoyed that I'm essentially be staying out to do something I am no longer enjoying, however, I'd suck it up because no way would I leave a friend on her own at that time and in that kind of setting!

Pomvit · 07/02/2024 20:30

What was your expectation? That they all
waited for you because you wanted to carry on even though they all didn’t?

i think it’s ok to be disappointed that no one wanted to see the fireworks as planned and maybe disappointed nobody chose to go with you. but ultimately you left the group to do what you wanted - they did what they wanted.

5YearsLeft · 07/02/2024 20:27

OP left 11 comments which I’ve read all of, even if I haven’t read the whole thread. But like other posters, I can’t vote until I know which country/city. It pretty much determines who was in the right. OP could be absolutely ridiculous for expecting her friends to “let their hair down” in a dangerous country, or OP’s friends could be ridiculous about crowds that were perfectly safe, in a country that’s known as safe for women, and that included families. Until she says the country, we’ll never know, and I don’t know how anyone can judge.

Cakelollipop · 07/02/2024 20:26

They were shit mates IMO. I would have rang you and said I’m going back are you coming cos we will wait so we can walk together. Would never have let a friend walk home alone when we were in a group, regardless of if it was at night or in a foreign country.

Surely being your mates they’d know you well enough to know you wouldn’t like that situation?