Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Girls trip abroad - who was in the wrong?

433 replies

Travellinggirly · 05/02/2024 20:35

This happened last year but I’ve realised it has been bothering me ever since and has made me pull back from this particular group of friends so wanted to get some opinions.

So group of Mums went on a trip abroad. This is a longstanding friendship group but one that don’t really see each other that regularly (some individuals see more of each other than others but as a group it’s more special occasions and occasional weekends away).

Anyway on one of the nights there was a big local festival taking place, culminating in a huge fireworks display (think a smaller London NYE set off a bridge to music). Two of the group bailed out early in the evening as felt the streets were getting too busy. Remaining four stayed out and later started to head down to where fireworks were happening. But then as we got nearer some of this group also started making noises about the crowds and wanting to hang back. Decided to go no further. I personally really wanted to see the display as had heard it was meant to be amazing and the spot we had stopped at wasn’t far away from where we needed to be - they had basically stopped at one end of a street and we needed to be the other end but from where we were we couldn’t see the bridge at all.

So I basically said I wanted to carry on so I could see them - no one else wanted to come with me so agreed I would go and they would stay where they were. But then at some point whilst waiting for the fireworks to start I got a message to say it had started to get too busy where they were so they had also headed back to hotel. So basically I was left out alone in a foreign country about half an hours walk from our hotel (probably almost 1am by time I got back).

I think they knew I was upset the next day but I decided not to make an issue out of it and ruin the rest of the trip. The person I was sharing a room with though I did say briefly say to that I was pissed off they left me alone but she basically said it was my decision to stay out.

AIBU to think you don’t leave one friend out on their own in a foreign country and maybe at least one person could have stayed to make sure I got home ok? Or was I being difficult wanting to stay out when clearly no one else did and I should have just left when they did regardless if I wanted to see the fireworks? In my opinion though it would have been such a shame to miss them (and they were amazing). But now I’m left feeling like these aren’t real friends and I’ve started finding excuses to bail out of some of the get togethers. Thanks in advance for any views on this!

OP posts:
HarkHarkBark · 06/02/2024 07:06

I’m a bit puzzled at the gap between ‘left all alone in a foreign country — waah’ and ‘I’m much more brave and into pushing my comfort zone than my timid friends’.

I’m assuming the ‘we prefer coffee shops to bars’ friends were unlikely to have gone on holiday to a Brazilian favela or Kandahar. It does sound rather as though, because you think they’re dull and timid, you also think they should have been content to wait meekly while you did your thing. (I’d have done it too, but wouldn’t have expected anyone to wait — nothing kills the moment like knowing there are four people looking at their watches up the street.)

user1984778379202 · 06/02/2024 07:04

Your friends told you they didn't feel comfortable in the crowds and wanted to get back, but you're now cross that at least one of them didn't wait alone in the street after you'd gone to the bridge, so you could walk back together? As others have said, if you didn't want to end up on your own, you should've compromised and stayed in the group like you think they should've done by hanging around waiting for you to finish your oohs and aahs.

CanaryMary · 06/02/2024 07:03

I think yabu if you wanted to see them and they didn’t then no they shouldn’t have stayed out late waiting for you
that’s more unfair imo
if you didn’t want to be alone you should have stayed in the group

GreyCarpet · 06/02/2024 06:57

I wouldn't have wanted to go to a firework display just because I dont enjoy them and generally avoid places with really huge crowds because I don't like them either!

But I have no problem splitting from a group to do what I want - I'd prefer a pub/bar though to see a live band and have been away on my own for weekends and done that.

If I'd gone off to do my own thing, I wouldn't expect anyone who didn't want to be there to wait for me, though, and, tbh, that would spoil my enjoyment of it because I'd be aware that they were all standing somewhere bored and waiting for me. I'd also be quite happy to travel back to a hotel on my own and would expect someone who felt similarly comfortable doing their own thing to also be happy to do that.

I used to go on walking holidays with some friends of mine and we always had a great time but we were stuck in the middle of nowhere and had to make our own entertainment. I know we'd have been terrible together on a different type of holiday because we were all so different in what we saw as 'fun'.

The suggestions that they should have offered you the option of returning to the hotel with them are a bit surprising as you'd already made it very clear you wanted to stay so would have been unlikely to want to leave.

I think you're right to just decide that these aren't people who have the same idea of a good time on holiday as you and do your own holidays. I don't think you are right in your assessment of what a good time is anymore than they are though. You're just different.

pictoosh · 06/02/2024 06:50

WandaWonder · 05/02/2024 20:44

Alone in a foreign country? What do people who travel alone do?

You are an adult I presume you don't need a chaperone

I think the same. It wouldn't have bothered me...I can sort myself out.

5128gap · 06/02/2024 06:50

For a whole group to decide it was too busy to see the thing you'd gone for, there are 3 possibilities. It really was too busy, dangerously so, so no, you chose to take the risk so that's up to you. Second possibility, your friends are a bunch of wet lettuces and you probably should look for a different group. Third possibility, there's a leader who decided it was too busy and the rest followed, which isn't a great group dynamic.
I think it was pretty obvious when they said they were going back to the hotel they meant just that, so I'm not sure why you thought it meant 'one of us is going to wait in the busy street for you' so I think once you knew their intentions any risk you took by being out alone until 1am was on you.

cuckyplunt · 06/02/2024 06:24

What was the risk if it was that busy?
Hardly going to get raped or murdered in front of hoards of people,
Get over yourself!

dailyduel · 06/02/2024 06:19

If you were my friend, I couldn’t have left you know matter how much I wanted to go back to the accommodation.

Zanatdy · 06/02/2024 06:18

You should have stayed with the group to be honest and in those crowd situations you might not have found them again anyway.

Jl2014 · 06/02/2024 06:17

I really don’t think they should have gone back without you. It was dangerous and that would have annoyed me.

Newchapterbeckons · 06/02/2024 05:51

You decided to go. You can’t expect them to wait around until 1am for you!
If you didn’t want to be alone you wouldn’t have gone off by yourself.

You are an adult. It was your choice to stay with the group or head over alone, you choose the latter, and they were right to respect your autonomy.

helpnohelpno · 06/02/2024 05:41

Op I'm with you I wouldn't have left a friend alone in a foreign country. I would have insisted we waited and walk back together

brightli · 06/02/2024 05:07

I'm usually very much team 'Never leave a friend behind' especially if that involves a lone female walking through the streets alone in the middle of the night, in a foreign country! Doesn't sound safe at all!!

However in this scenario I do not think you can blame your friends and I don't think this is a sign of them being poor friends or not caring about you so I do hope you can move past it emotionally and learn to be close to them again. I definitely think it's forgivable.

Crowds can be very dangerous and certainly can be very uncomfortable and anxiety provoking. I adore fireworks but I wouldn't want to be part of a very large crowd at all and I would have been one of the one trying to get the hell out of there ASAP.

Once you separated off alone, even with best will in the world you may have realistically struggled to all meet back up anyways. But also once you split up you have to accept that you're now separate and dealing with different situations as they come. They found their area getting busy too and plans change and they wanted to go. The decision would be made as a group, to include the people who were part of the group. You left the group by choice. Because you wanted to be solo and suit yourself. And that's what you got to do. They stuck with a group and made group decisions. You can't ask for all the benefits of a group (safety, company, people considering you in their plans) but none of the negatives (considering other people's wants and needs, not getting all your own way).
And people are right, in your ideal scenario one poor friend (who hated the crowds and wanted to go home) would have been left stood ALONE waiting for an hour or so for you, not even able to see the fireworks. Poor them! I agree maybe they could have text you to go option to join them but was that realistic? Would that have required waiting for an hour anyways while you pushed your way back through the crowd to get to them? Maybe they knew there was no chance of that.
I think they were right to all leave and if anything they might all be a little annoyed/put off you to find you're really not a team player. Makes it awkward to go on trips with people who aren't willing to go with the flow of the group ...

HoppingPavlova · 06/02/2024 05:02

You decided to do something no one else wanted to do. You expected them to wait around for you, they didn’t want to. No one was in the wrong here, you got to do what you wanted (and no one else did), and they didn’t have to stand there for ages waiting for one person.

LAMPS1 · 06/02/2024 04:42

You deliberately chose to put yourself in the position of going it alone.
It wasn’t their choice for you to leave them and go it alone, it was yours. Presumably, being an adult, you had weighed up the risks of being stuck in a massive, growing crowd on your own and the risks of walking back alone.

How long did you expect them to wait around for you ? Had they agreed that they would wait a certain time or wait until you had finished wanting to go it alone even if that took hours and hours. Did you really believe that they would still be patiently waiting for you once you decided you had had enough of being alone. Did you consider that the situation could change for them with growing, jostling crowds, whist waiting for you and that they might become uncomfortable with that, as a group. When they messaged to say they were returning to the hotel, did you tell them you suddenly felt vulnerable and would prefer they waited for you?

You feel bad that they left you alone. But they didn’t leave you alone. You left them, giving the signal that you were perfectly fine to be out alone away from them.
You took a risk which backfired as you got a little bit lost and suddenly felt vulnerable no doubt.
You were ok in the end, making it safely back to the hotel thank goodness. But lesson learned I’d say. Put it down to experience OP. And move on.

Emma8888 · 06/02/2024 04:35

I have quite often been in a group abroad where I have wanted to do something different to the group (sometimes I'm ready to go back to the hotel, other times I want to go to another venue or stay out later). I have no issue being alone in a foreign city but if I did I wouldn't leave the group. On occasion people have been drama queens about 'Emma we can't possibly leave you' etc etc. it's frankly irritating to be infantilized. If I tell you I'm fine, believe me, I'm an adult and capable of making my own choices. And for that reason if a friend decided to go off alone I would assume she was comfortable so doing.

Gremlinssofa · 06/02/2024 03:54

You are at fault for being annoyed by it.

They said it was too busy and they didn't want to go into a more crowded area. You were fine with it so went. They were then still not having a good time so wanted to leave and told you they were leaving. You seem to have expected them to have a shitty time waiting for you to decide when you wanted to leave so to escort you back to the hotel.

Don't wander off doing your own thing then expect people to be uncomfortable or pissed off waiting for you to finish your lone enjoyment to walk you back to the hotel.

pleasehelpwi3 · 06/02/2024 03:44

Were you in Mogadishu? Or somewhere really dangerous? Were you drunk? If not, it's not an issue. A shame you feel it's ruined the trip though.

Butchcassidyandthesundancekid · 06/02/2024 03:21

😂 so you wanted them to hang back at the other end of the street, just standing there in the middle of the crowds, waiting for you to have your little jolly and then to be safely escorted back to your hotel room? Or at the very least you expected one of them to be waiting for you at the other end of the street, feeling unsafe while you are having a jolly. YABVU (and selfish).

Ramalangadingdong · 06/02/2024 02:39

It is so selfish to expect them to wait for you till 1 in the morning. What did you expect them to do? Just stand there like lemons just so that you could watch fireworks? They weren’t feeling safe and wanted to go home but you kept them out until they were fed up and went home.

Codlingmoths · 06/02/2024 02:35

Travellinggirly · 05/02/2024 22:04

The last paragraph here hits the nail on the head really. They started the night seeming really up for it, saying how lucky we were to unknowingly have ended up being here for this big festival, seemed in party spirit, we bought the props that everyone has etc. , joined in street dancing but as soon as we got in to the centre they completely wussed out. I’m the first to admit these aren’t the most lively of my friends - more likely to head to a coffee shop on holiday than a bar! I do find it frustrating they don’t let their hair down more and embrace these experiences.

I have close friends like these. If I declared my intention to go out on my own like you did when travelling, I wouldn’t expect them to wait. I’ve announced I’m doing something they don’t want to do, that’s on me. If staying with the group were the important thing I’d have stayed with the group.

garlictwist · 06/02/2024 02:33

It depends on the country but I would have been fine being left alone. It sounds like a safe event and you had a phone and am sure could manage to get back by yourself if you were only half an hour from the hotel

Timeforanewnam · 06/02/2024 02:22

Is this half a story?

a full group of women felt uncomfortable so went home

personally this doesn’t sound like a firework show

odd that all of those felt uncomfortable and you were fine

who would you have liked to stay and feel unsafe for you ?

Garlickit · 06/02/2024 02:01

You were NBU to want to see the display - I'd have wanted too, as well. You were, however, BU to expect the others to hang around waiting for you when they didn't want to.

You're all adults; none of you needs to make yourself uncomfortable to suit others. There's no reason why you couldn't have the experience you wanted - as you did - then made your own way back, as you did.

They could or should have texted you to say they were heading back, but maybe they thought you'd play your face about it?

NaughtybutNice77 · 06/02/2024 01:54

It's really hard to say who's at fault (if anyone) without having full details. If the 'sideline' girls had rang/texted you to say they were feeling uncomfortable with the crowds and were going home now I'd have expected you to respond with either OK see you later, or wait for me, I'm coming back.
If they rang/texted and you didn't answer and they felt 'at risk' I think itscgmfaur game they left.
I'm unsure why you think going it alone late at night into a crowd of festival goers is safe yet walking home isn't. They probably thought you were less risk averse than them and were an adult capable of making your own decisions.
Odd that you're still broading about it. Is this more about you realiseing they're not your tribe?