Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this was a pretty shitty comment?

240 replies

Sad0tter · 05/02/2024 16:40

Travelled on Saturday to see a guy I’ve been seeing for a couple of months. We had a really nice weekend. But unfortunately engineering works on the trains which meant my journey home yesterday was 3.5 hours! The train was rammed and I had to sit on my suitcase in a freezing passageway.

he asked if I got on the train ok and I explained the situation and he basically just said ‘yeah that sounds horrible. Good luck!’ And then ‘if you will live so far away that’s just what you have to put up with!’

I just feel totally rubbish I made the effort to visit now. And basically he’s washed his hands of me and was no longer his concern. I’d just never say that to someone who had travelled all that way.

AIBU?

OP posts:
Sad0tter · 06/02/2024 09:41

Wednesdaysphiltrum · 06/02/2024 09:29

It sounds a bit like you’re a convenient visiting shag and he doesn’t actually care much about you.

I wouldn’t go that far. He’s organised and paid for a weekend away this week to a 5* hotel. I mean yes he gets a nice weekend away too but I wouldn’t go so far as saying I’m just an easy shag 🙄

OP posts:
NoOrdinaryMorning · 06/02/2024 09:41

Tinkerbyebye · 05/02/2024 16:46

Do you really see a future with him after that attitude?

because I wouldn’t be seeing him again

This is ridiculously OTT! He was obviously just being playful & was joking around. Why do some people have such a disposable attitude towards relationships?! No wonder it's so rare for couples to last these days if the tiniest sign of anything that isn't gushing, unwavering worship of the ground you walk on, results in being dumped 😕

Wednesdaysphiltrum · 06/02/2024 09:29

It sounds a bit like you’re a convenient visiting shag and he doesn’t actually care much about you.

determinedtomakethiswork · 06/02/2024 09:04

I think you've got reaction has been right with this one. He's utterly selfish.

Sad0tter · 06/02/2024 08:51

SoapiesChoice · 06/02/2024 08:45

Also sorry if my advice hit a completely bum note!

I'm coming from place of a 30+ year relationship that has not always been plain sailing. Sometimes I take things the wrong way nowadays based on how he used the same words a lot in an extended bad patch. It's only from talking it out that I realised that he genuinely was puzzled at my initially very hurt reactions to certain phrases when he was using them completely differently these days.

I have learnt to immediately question how he means things before reacting, and he is learning to make certain, ought to normally be fine, phrases no-go because they are now triggering.

So, when assuming you were talking about building a potential long term relationship I was trying to say that open communication is key.

My dating was so long ago that there was no internet and not even any texting. So we always had verbal tone to go by. I find it a minefield trying to make tone clear in writing. So that also coloured how strongly I urged you to "just talk".

Anyway, I hope you have lots of fun times coming your way whether it's with that guy or not 🙂.

And I hope no engineering works on your route next weekend!!!🍀🤞

no don’t worry I appreciate all the advice. I agree with you, I find texting hard to navigate sometimes. And I’m aware that given my past I do have the potential to be over sensitive, understandably, but equally don’t want to ignore my instincts on things.

I think this weekend it makes sense to just have an open discussion about how things going to work going forward and if there’s the slightest resistance at balancing things out then that’s my answer, and to be honest I actually feel totally ok with that. So maybe I’m not actually too bothered about him 🤷🏻‍♀️

OP posts:
SoapiesChoice · 06/02/2024 08:45

Also sorry if my advice hit a completely bum note!

I'm coming from place of a 30+ year relationship that has not always been plain sailing. Sometimes I take things the wrong way nowadays based on how he used the same words a lot in an extended bad patch. It's only from talking it out that I realised that he genuinely was puzzled at my initially very hurt reactions to certain phrases when he was using them completely differently these days.

I have learnt to immediately question how he means things before reacting, and he is learning to make certain, ought to normally be fine, phrases no-go because they are now triggering.

So, when assuming you were talking about building a potential long term relationship I was trying to say that open communication is key.

My dating was so long ago that there was no internet and not even any texting. So we always had verbal tone to go by. I find it a minefield trying to make tone clear in writing. So that also coloured how strongly I urged you to "just talk".

Anyway, I hope you have lots of fun times coming your way whether it's with that guy or not 🙂.

And I hope no engineering works on your route next weekend!!!🍀🤞

LookItsMeAgain · 06/02/2024 08:39

I've read the thread and I think that his comment is giving you the right feelings about him.
He could drive to yours but decides against it making you take the train to see him. Why would someone not want to make your life easier and not have to face these public transport issues if they have their own mode of transport and could use it to get to see you. It seems very one sided there.
His comment about staying in bed that followed is (I hate to say it) giving me the ick. I can't quite put my finger on why it is but it is. I mean as the conversation was going it wasn't going to be the next obvious thing to discuss or mention.
Transport works both ways as does respect. He is making you do all the running and guess what, when you tell him in clear language that you had to sit on your suitcase in a draughty corridor of the train he didn't immediately say "Oh, that's terrible. I'll drive to you next so that you don't have to do that again for a while".
I don't know if you replied to his message that he sent yesterday but I'd give him a bit of distance and if he doesn't pick up on how he has behaved, then I'd cut him loose.

JCLV · 06/02/2024 08:31

I dunno. Something obviously doesn’t feel right to you. I would see how this weekend pans out and go with your gut feeling.

SoapiesChoice · 06/02/2024 08:27

Oops sorry that i took a different intent for the thread. See lol! It's harder in text 😂

As for asking him, well we just differ in approach then I think.

I would think that if you admit to him (not by text) where your head has been, then you will get some cues from how he responds.

True it's unlikely he'll say "yes I meant you made your bed, you have to lie in it" even if he did mean that.

But as he probably didn't mean that he'll probably be able to reassure you PLUS he might think more sensitively next time.

As someone who tries to ask, not assume, your reply to me reads (to me) more like when a guy is cheating and needs to caught in the act to be sure.

But this is just about communication style. You will not find a perfect guy same as no perfect women exist. So even if he was a bit thoughtless in his wording... people adapt to each other as part of getting closer.. he possibly has no idea you took that so badly and, if he cares about you, he would want to know that about you.

What I'm trying to say, as gently as possible, is that it's totally understandable for you to be wary based in past experiences. But it sounds as though you think any guy is fixed in his ways so all you can do is appraise with no influence. But successful relationships are built from getting to learn what matters more to a specific partner than to others etc.

You also say you don't want to bring it up in case a convo does show him to be uncaring type. Wouldn't you want to find that out sooner rather than later?

But maybe I have that wrong too, perhaps you just want to enjoy it while it's fun and "when the fun stops, stop"? If so then I apologise for assuming something else entirely.

Gonnagetgoingreturnsagain · 06/02/2024 08:15

OP, as @TotalAbsenceOfImperialRaiment says, aren’t there any decent men where you live? What do you want from life now? In a rush to meet and marry someone and have DC or?

Personally for me, I wouldn’t travel to see miles to see a man, though I’ve done this but where we both travelled to see the other, in the past.

TotalAbsenceOfImperialRaiment · 06/02/2024 08:12

Are there no men in your own neck of the woods?

Sad0tter · 06/02/2024 08:05

smilingeleanor · 06/02/2024 07:59

I actually think the earlier comment about walking you to the station was worse - it was this that probably made his latter comment irk you more - plus the lack of travel effort is really off

like - i'm a great guy but don't think i'm putting myself out solely for you - it's a comment which puts you in your place and shows he is always centering himself. Would he have walked you to the station if he didn't need something from the shop? Why the need ti tell you that? Even if it's a 'joke' it shows some unconscious thinking on his part. Thinks he's quite a catch doesn't he

I think i'd see if he will make a proper effort and come to you - if you can be arsed at this point

Yeah I agree with this totally. It was a bit like, I’m not even doing it for you, I’m just doing it because I need to highlight what a great guy I am. It was a weird thing to even mention. And again, these things seem small, but you pick up on them for a reason.

my instinct is to just pull way back now. I will still see him this weekend, but I think I need to observe quite closely. It’s not unusual when a guy feels like he’s ‘got’ you, to revert to how they just naturally are and stop trying. It kind of feels a bit like that.

OP posts:
CryptoFascist · 06/02/2024 08:05

Often the things we have to work harder for, we value more.

He sounds like he's taking you for granted, you need to be assertive and tell him that after this weekend he's going to travel to you. Are you travelling to see him every weekend though, or are you also taking some weekends for yourself? If you're seeing him every weekend it gives the impression that you don't have a life and are making him too much of a priority.

smilingeleanor · 06/02/2024 07:59

I actually think the earlier comment about walking you to the station was worse - it was this that probably made his latter comment irk you more - plus the lack of travel effort is really off

like - i'm a great guy but don't think i'm putting myself out solely for you - it's a comment which puts you in your place and shows he is always centering himself. Would he have walked you to the station if he didn't need something from the shop? Why the need ti tell you that? Even if it's a 'joke' it shows some unconscious thinking on his part. Thinks he's quite a catch doesn't he

I think i'd see if he will make a proper effort and come to you - if you can be arsed at this point

breezesin · 06/02/2024 07:48

I can see this both ways…

Although why you’re doing all the travelling and him all the paying seems a bit strange. Why isn’t it more equal?

Sad0tter · 06/02/2024 07:46

SoapiesChoice · 06/02/2024 07:41

@Sad0tter

It's not too late to ask.

If you feel you have been semi-ghosting him compared to usual pattern of contact then I'd start by apologising for that and acknowledging that you should have just asked him about it. I'd even admit if I felt a bit daft for not asking in the 1st place... to make it clear I hadn't already convicted him and wasn't already halfway to dumping, and to set a non-confrontational tone.

But NOT BY TEXT!!

Let him hear from your tone of voice that you realise it was probably not meant badly. And let his tone of voice reassure you too, assuming it does turn out to be the mountain from a molehill that it sounds like to some of us.

Obviously you can just break it off if you want to. But, if you dump every future potential guy the 1st time you aren't sure how to take a text, you will probably eventually miss a keeper by giving up at the 1st (tiny) communication hurdles.

ETA I just read your latest post... of course the results are polarised because none of us have any tone from him to go by. So some will judge him, be wary with you, based on their own experiences. Some others will from their own great experiences expect it to be nothing.

But whether you were unreasonable to feel a bit put out isn't the key point is it? I did click YABU but I don't think you were unreasonable to wonder about it. I clicked that to vote for it being unreasonable to write him off without just asking him.

Because isn't the thread really about what to do next? Not to vote on your feelings?

Edited

In fairness, I didn’t ask if I should dump him over this, I asked if I was being unreasonable thinking it was a bit of a shitty comment 😅

if it’s an indicator of a bigger problem in general then essentially I would just be paying very close attention to what happens in the next couple of weeks. I actually think it would be more intense to bring it up, because agreed, it might be nothing, but it also might be an indicator of how he’s not really that interested unless it’s all convenient for him.

there’s no point asking about that because he won’t actually admit to it if that’s his genuine feeling about the whole thing.

OP posts:
EdgarAllenRaven · 06/02/2024 07:42

So he knew about the really long delays and booked ticket anyway…? That changes things, of course he should have checked you were still happy to go.
He needs to make an effort to visit you now for sure, I wouldn’t be going there again in a hurry, let him do the travelling

SoapiesChoice · 06/02/2024 07:41

@Sad0tter

It's not too late to ask.

If you feel you have been semi-ghosting him compared to usual pattern of contact then I'd start by apologising for that and acknowledging that you should have just asked him about it. I'd even admit if I felt a bit daft for not asking in the 1st place... to make it clear I hadn't already convicted him and wasn't already halfway to dumping, and to set a non-confrontational tone.

But NOT BY TEXT!!

Let him hear from your tone of voice that you realise it was probably not meant badly. And let his tone of voice reassure you too, assuming it does turn out to be the mountain from a molehill that it sounds like to some of us.

Obviously you can just break it off if you want to. But, if you dump every future potential guy the 1st time you aren't sure how to take a text, you will probably eventually miss a keeper by giving up at the 1st (tiny) communication hurdles.

ETA I just read your latest post... of course the results are polarised because none of us have any tone from him to go by. So some will judge him, be wary with you, based on their own experiences. Some others will from their own great experiences expect it to be nothing.

But whether you were unreasonable to feel a bit put out isn't the key point is it? I did click YABU but I don't think you were unreasonable to wonder about it. I clicked that to vote for it being unreasonable to write him off without just asking him.

Because isn't the thread really about what to do next? Not to vote on your feelings?

Zonder · 06/02/2024 07:39

I'd feel a bit put out too. Banter and fun is good but you want someone who also can sympathise a bit and be kind when you've had a tough time.

Sad0tter · 06/02/2024 07:36

Just in response to those saying I’ve had a sense of humour fail - it isn’t because I’m too ‘intense’ and can’t take a joke. We do usually have a playful repartee with one another and it would make sense that that was a joke from his perspective.

but equally you have to read the room. He also booked the tickets, realised before me that the journey would be longer and didn’t then double check that was still ok. He just assumed I would still come. So in that context, the ‘joke’ kind of fell flat and it would have been appropriate to just reiterate the extra effort on my part was appreciated.

I’m also conscious of ‘jokes’ sometimes hinting at a general underlying feeling or attitude to things, and I am just wary of it as it can be a form of gaslighting. They use humour to essentially make you feel a bit shit and then turn it on you for ‘not being able to take a joke’. I appreciate I will be extra sensitive to that, so that’s why I was querying it.

the responses have been pretty polarised, so I don’t think it was unreasonable to feel a bit put out by it.

OP posts:
Redpaisley · 06/02/2024 07:31

lifeispainauchocolat · 06/02/2024 07:04

Everything you've said just makes me think he's joking and you don't quite get his sense of humour.

It's exactly the kind of thing DH and I would say to each other - and did at the beginning of our relationship when he did all the travelling as I was still learning to drive.

But if you don't feel like it's right for you then that's totally okay.

But here she is doing all the travelling and not because one party has a car and the other is learning to drive.

Gonnagetgoingreturnsagain · 06/02/2024 07:31

Testina · 06/02/2024 00:45

So he’s yet to make any effort at all to travel to you 🤨

In a relationship where travelling is involved it should always be equal, is my opinion. Or you get one person doing all the running and the other gets complacent .

As a pp said, I’d see how you feel after this weekends date.

Redpaisley · 06/02/2024 07:29

Sad0tter · 05/02/2024 17:17

I dunno to be honest 😂 he’s kind of mentioned travelling here but when he makes plans they’re always closer to him.

Given this and the other comments he made, he sounds self centred.

redxlondon · 06/02/2024 07:26

I’d read his response as flirting if it was someone I was seeing. If you take it negatively, maybe just break it off…

lifeispainauchocolat · 06/02/2024 07:04

Everything you've said just makes me think he's joking and you don't quite get his sense of humour.

It's exactly the kind of thing DH and I would say to each other - and did at the beginning of our relationship when he did all the travelling as I was still learning to drive.

But if you don't feel like it's right for you then that's totally okay.