Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this was a pretty shitty comment?

240 replies

Sad0tter · 05/02/2024 16:40

Travelled on Saturday to see a guy I’ve been seeing for a couple of months. We had a really nice weekend. But unfortunately engineering works on the trains which meant my journey home yesterday was 3.5 hours! The train was rammed and I had to sit on my suitcase in a freezing passageway.

he asked if I got on the train ok and I explained the situation and he basically just said ‘yeah that sounds horrible. Good luck!’ And then ‘if you will live so far away that’s just what you have to put up with!’

I just feel totally rubbish I made the effort to visit now. And basically he’s washed his hands of me and was no longer his concern. I’d just never say that to someone who had travelled all that way.

AIBU?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
HollaHolla · 08/02/2024 11:15

What are you getting from this relationship? Seems like you're doing all the running.....

hummmmm · 08/02/2024 10:54

If you have said you don't like the travelling then it's a red flag that he expects you to do it. I like a train journey, it's guilt-free time to read my book when I can't do any jobs.

He could be limbering up for abuse, only he knows that. Or he likes being at home more than travelling, thinks you're happy with that and said something you didn't find amusing.

You didn't find him funny. If it carries on then he will upset you when he's just playing and you won't like talking to him.

You don't find his humour funny. If that carries on then he will end up walking on eggshells trying not to upset you. If his friends find his humour funny and are similar then they will probably drift from being friends if you end up living together.

It doesn't mean anyone is wrong but perhaps you need to consider if you are good for each other if it continues.

Sjh15 · 07/02/2024 22:23

Op,
this is the sort of message an ex of mine would have sent. I think actually you may be onto something to be having doubts. I can’t even explain it, but do keep it in the back of your mind that he’s said that and how it’s made you feel.

do see if he will come to you next time or the time after.
Isn’t it a red flag that the man drives but makes you get on a train every time?
my ex was an absolute narcissist, but good at hiding it, so insanely clever and witty that at first you never realised it, but comments such as the text you received is exactly the wry of thing he would say

Sad0tter · 07/02/2024 20:11

Mememe9898 · 07/02/2024 20:04

When I met my husband he did 99% of the travelling. I rarely went to see him as he bought a car just so he could travel to me more quickly and I was a poor student so didn’t have any money to buy a car.
I’ve been out of the dating game for over 20 years but my stance when I was dating was that I’m going to be open and honest and if something bothers me I’ll highlight it.
If you are going to spend the rest of your life with someone you need to be 100% true to yourself and not play mind games with each other. All this I’m not texting him as he’s pissed me off business baffles me.
just tell him that what he said annoyed you and if he’s a nice guy that genuinely cares for you he’ll apologise.
All this psycho analysing a partner sounds exhausting to me. The key to a long term relationship is communication. From someone who has been with the same partner for nearly 20 years and we’ve had many ups and downs, the key is communication, respect and compromise. Without that relationships break down 🥴

So having had the chance to reflect, I think it’s more just a feeling that things are starting to feel unbalanced rather than exactly what he said, I think maybe it was intended in a jokey way and landed wrong.

I’m going to see how the weekend goes, but I’m glad I didn’t bring it up as some big intense thing because I think it was just me being overtired and fed up, and a lot of other stuff going on this week.

if it keeps happening and I still feel something is off I will mention it…

OP posts:
Mememe9898 · 07/02/2024 20:04

When I met my husband he did 99% of the travelling. I rarely went to see him as he bought a car just so he could travel to me more quickly and I was a poor student so didn’t have any money to buy a car.
I’ve been out of the dating game for over 20 years but my stance when I was dating was that I’m going to be open and honest and if something bothers me I’ll highlight it.
If you are going to spend the rest of your life with someone you need to be 100% true to yourself and not play mind games with each other. All this I’m not texting him as he’s pissed me off business baffles me.
just tell him that what he said annoyed you and if he’s a nice guy that genuinely cares for you he’ll apologise.
All this psycho analysing a partner sounds exhausting to me. The key to a long term relationship is communication. From someone who has been with the same partner for nearly 20 years and we’ve had many ups and downs, the key is communication, respect and compromise. Without that relationships break down 🥴

Moanyoldmoan · 07/02/2024 19:44

I doubt this is the first inkling OP has had that this guy is not great. My last relationship I always did the travelling, numerous times a week backwards and forwards. He would lay in bed when I left and one morning it was icy and frosty and he didn’t even offer to help me de-ice, threw me out at 6am and didn’t check I was home ok. Several little irks like that started to grate on me and he was indeed extremely selfish

Underestimated4 · 07/02/2024 19:21

Did he say this over text? Actually sounds like a joke/banter to me.

MILTOBE · 06/02/2024 15:31

I wouldn't even tell him it was his turn to visit. It's far better to judge someone by his actions.

I'm not sure why people think this is banter when he could have said he was sorry and he'd visit next time.

ReinNotReignItIn · 06/02/2024 14:38

Unless he said it was his turn now to visit you, there is no way I would continue this relationship. You are rushing around to see him and he’s making zero effort to travel to see you. Anybody can pay for a nice hotel. It takes time and effort to actually go and visit somebody.

You suggest he visits you next time. I would make a decision on the relationship based on his reaction to that.

GhostOrchid · 06/02/2024 14:14

delphi13 · 06/02/2024 09:43

Seems like banter to me. Plus the comment about walking to the train station too. The text is hard for you to tell it's banter because you can't tell tone of voice from text but I might well say something like that to my husband. I think maybe you just have different senses of humour.

You can take the joke about walking to the train station several ways, 1) that he thinks he's too good for you (struggling with seeing that. 2) that he wants to make sure you get there safely but doesn't want to appear to make overbearing and keen 3) it was just a throwaway comment with a bit of humour which is being overanalysed here.

The only point of concern here is that you are doing all the travelling. I would look to get that in balance first and if he won't do his share then I'd be out of there.

Agree with this. It just reads to me that he really likes you, is a bit embarrassed to be sincere about that so deflects it as jokey banter. Maybe the mood change was because he was sad you were leaving? The walk to the shops thing might have been him wanting to maximise his time with you. I would have been amused, but I can see how it could misfire if you’re prone to taking people seriously and literally.

The lack of balance between who travels where seems a bit strange (my DH and I lived in different cities when we met and alternated the travelling every weekend), but maybe there’s a practical reason. Just have a conversation about it. Or if you’re realising you’re not that into him, then drop him.

Sad0tter · 06/02/2024 12:41

Muthaofcats · 06/02/2024 12:35

It’s not a bad thing to trust your instincts - as long as you’re checking yourself at the same time that that is what is really going on - if your instincts are he’s insecure and trying to belittle you then it kind of doesn’t matter if it’s true or not; the relationship is dead in the water regardless.

I don’t really know which kind of men you’re dating, but as someone who (at least formally in my youth!) could describe myself in similar terms to you, I genuinely never once met a man who tried to put me down because I made them insecure ? I guess because I was only dating people who I thought were equally attractive and intelligent and successful so I didn’t view myself as superior to them or them to me? It almost seems a bit weird to view other people in those terms? Or even to view yourself in that way? Certainly by the time you’re actually having a relationship with someone those sorts of considerations would already have been filtered out !?

if not maybe you need to raise your standards?

Edited

I didn’t say that’s what I thought. And I don’t see myself as superior, but nor do I have low standards. I don’t deliberately date men who I think are beneath me. It’s more something that seems to crop up down the line. And it’s not overt, it tends to be pretty subtle.

maybe I’m just not meeting the right men 🤷🏻‍♀️

OP posts:
Muthaofcats · 06/02/2024 12:35

Sad0tter · 06/02/2024 12:00

Yeah I totally get that and honestly, despite everything that happened in my past, I am actually exceptionally laid back. That’s not to say I don’t have boundaries but I’m not needy or clingy, rarely need reassurance about stuff and generally I have a very light hearted approach to things. I did a huge amount of healing and work since my last relationships and I would say I have a balanced approach to stuff. Perhaps a tendency to ‘switch off’ quite suddenly if something doesn’t feel right and I could probably give people the benefit of the doubt a bit more. So I’m aware of that.

It just got me questioning because I am also totally aware of the slippery slope of having an instinct about something and continually ignoring it. More so than the odd comment. I’m not upset by it, more wondering if this is indicative of a bigger issue.

I am very used to men getting weird and insecure around me. I’m pretty attractive, intelligent and work in a well respected profession. I’ve literally had men online flat out refuse to believe I even exist (to the point where they thought I was faking my linked in profile FGS) and must be catfishing.

I’m often totally bemused by it to be honest and don’t have an ego about it particularly (most of the time I work from home in trackies and most certainly wouldn’t turn heads at this precise moment in time, for any positive reasons! 😅) but as I’m sure a lot of women have experienced, when men feel insecure in some way they quite often try to bring you down, and it starts so small, but I’m vigilant to it.

Edited

It’s not a bad thing to trust your instincts - as long as you’re checking yourself at the same time that that is what is really going on - if your instincts are he’s insecure and trying to belittle you then it kind of doesn’t matter if it’s true or not; the relationship is dead in the water regardless.

I don’t really know which kind of men you’re dating, but as someone who (at least formally in my youth!) could describe myself in similar terms to you, I genuinely never once met a man who tried to put me down because I made them insecure ? I guess because I was only dating people who I thought were equally attractive and intelligent and successful so I didn’t view myself as superior to them or them to me? It almost seems a bit weird to view other people in those terms? Or even to view yourself in that way? Certainly by the time you’re actually having a relationship with someone those sorts of considerations would already have been filtered out !?

if not maybe you need to raise your standards?

Sad0tter · 06/02/2024 12:00

Muthaofcats · 06/02/2024 11:41

OP I’m sorry you’ve had abusive partners previously, so I mean this gently, but you have mentioned a few times how you’re hyper sensitive to any hint of abusive behaviour and it did rather make me wonder whether you’re testing your current partner or analysing them through a lens of your previous experience which seems a bit unfair. Yes of course you’re going to be alert to avoiding further abuse but you can’t view every new partner as a potential abuser or you’re going to torpedo potentially promising relationships. Approaching him with positive regard and trust is the best way to get the best from him.

Getting upset about every comment that doesn’t quite ‘land’ or texts all just seems a bit intense to me - if you don’t like something about the dynamic then discuss it outright but reading into every interaction for suggestions of gas lighting or abuse, I don’t know, it would send me running tbh…

So he made a mistake booking the wrong train? Or he thought you wouldn’t mind it taking longer given perhaps he thought you’d think the time together was worth it ? If he’s paying for tickets and organising nice stuff together he seems pretty keen and attentive to me? Is it that he WONT visit you or does it make more sense for you to go to him (Ie more suitable place or work requirements etc )

Edited

Yeah I totally get that and honestly, despite everything that happened in my past, I am actually exceptionally laid back. That’s not to say I don’t have boundaries but I’m not needy or clingy, rarely need reassurance about stuff and generally I have a very light hearted approach to things. I did a huge amount of healing and work since my last relationships and I would say I have a balanced approach to stuff. Perhaps a tendency to ‘switch off’ quite suddenly if something doesn’t feel right and I could probably give people the benefit of the doubt a bit more. So I’m aware of that.

It just got me questioning because I am also totally aware of the slippery slope of having an instinct about something and continually ignoring it. More so than the odd comment. I’m not upset by it, more wondering if this is indicative of a bigger issue.

I am very used to men getting weird and insecure around me. I’m pretty attractive, intelligent and work in a well respected profession. I’ve literally had men online flat out refuse to believe I even exist (to the point where they thought I was faking my linked in profile FGS) and must be catfishing.

I’m often totally bemused by it to be honest and don’t have an ego about it particularly (most of the time I work from home in trackies and most certainly wouldn’t turn heads at this precise moment in time, for any positive reasons! 😅) but as I’m sure a lot of women have experienced, when men feel insecure in some way they quite often try to bring you down, and it starts so small, but I’m vigilant to it.

OP posts:
Clarabell77 · 06/02/2024 11:50

Sounds like a self-centred smart arse to me.

Muthaofcats · 06/02/2024 11:41

OP I’m sorry you’ve had abusive partners previously, so I mean this gently, but you have mentioned a few times how you’re hyper sensitive to any hint of abusive behaviour and it did rather make me wonder whether you’re testing your current partner or analysing them through a lens of your previous experience which seems a bit unfair. Yes of course you’re going to be alert to avoiding further abuse but you can’t view every new partner as a potential abuser or you’re going to torpedo potentially promising relationships. Approaching him with positive regard and trust is the best way to get the best from him.

Getting upset about every comment that doesn’t quite ‘land’ or texts all just seems a bit intense to me - if you don’t like something about the dynamic then discuss it outright but reading into every interaction for suggestions of gas lighting or abuse, I don’t know, it would send me running tbh…

So he made a mistake booking the wrong train? Or he thought you wouldn’t mind it taking longer given perhaps he thought you’d think the time together was worth it ? If he’s paying for tickets and organising nice stuff together he seems pretty keen and attentive to me? Is it that he WONT visit you or does it make more sense for you to go to him (Ie more suitable place or work requirements etc )

Sad0tter · 06/02/2024 11:37

SkySecret · 06/02/2024 11:21

It’s hard to know never having met the guy and not knowing the true context. But to me it reads a bit like he’s one of those cocky types that thinks he’s a bit of a lad, got to play it cool, makes this sort of remark to “keep ‘em keen” when actually, any real man knows that a woman would much prefer a man who is in touch with his feelings and can show them.

Without knowing him it’s hard to tell, but on the whole I’m not into that type of guy. The last cocky bloke I met was my mate’s husband, who turned out to be a total narc and they’re now in a messy divorce.

Well exactly, I’m struggling enough and I know him!

my feeling about it all before the weekend was that he really liked me, way more into me than I was into him. And then there’s a possibility he suddenly felt the need to withdraw for whatever reason and hence the weird comments.

it’s not like it was the first time we slept together so not that. So just a bit strange really. There was nothing really before this point suggesting he wasn’t really keen.

OP posts:
SkySecret · 06/02/2024 11:21

It’s hard to know never having met the guy and not knowing the true context. But to me it reads a bit like he’s one of those cocky types that thinks he’s a bit of a lad, got to play it cool, makes this sort of remark to “keep ‘em keen” when actually, any real man knows that a woman would much prefer a man who is in touch with his feelings and can show them.

Without knowing him it’s hard to tell, but on the whole I’m not into that type of guy. The last cocky bloke I met was my mate’s husband, who turned out to be a total narc and they’re now in a messy divorce.

lifeispainauchocolat · 06/02/2024 10:40

TeaGinandFags · 06/02/2024 09:46

You have done all the work in this relationship and he doesn't appreciate it one tiny bit.

You know the next bit.

So organising and paying for dates and her travel doesn't count as work or effort in your world?

SoapiesChoice · 06/02/2024 10:31

That post was meant to quote your post from "Today 7:36"

But seeing you say in a later post that he does things like book nice accomodation for your weekends maybe he thought the overall plan so good that it was no brainer that you'd still want to go. He should have given a heads up about the disruption as soon as he knew though.

I am glad I am not the one having to work this out because my head was spinning when I tried to work out whether him paying for everything counts as a big share of "effort".

My opinion is that it maybe is? fair that one puts all the travel effort in when it's all funded by the other one... one putting in extra time, travel, the other money but gaining convenience. When it's very early days dating and no financially linked relationship.

But I can see it needs to not become somehow buying the way completely out of needing to consider the other persons wishes. You have NOT given that impression at all though so hopefully it's not like that.

Sounds like you have a handle now on what you want to sound him out about next weekend, feel casual enough about it still to end it if it does cross lines for you, but with a balanced enough view to not jump the gun on that based on guesswork and assumptions. Great!

Good luck!

SoapiesChoice · 06/02/2024 09:50

Now I would have minded THAT! - him keeping the booking knowing about the disruption without discussing it 1st in case I'd rather postpone, or see if could travel 1st train Monday instead. Or him maybe drive part way if the disruption in early part.

I would have wanted to find out why he didn't consult me. I'd maybe become alert for other stuff depending on why he'd felt no need to. (Unless the timing difference was not that big, if the main problem was the overcrowding and if that was not foreseeable).

Maybe that lack of thought and how the journey went has contributed to the generally "flat" feeling. It would concern me more than the comment unless we had argued about it already but not accepted each others' points. In that case, the comment could maybe seem like a dig about minding the booking being made, continuing the argument.

But I do see that you haven't mentioned arguing about it. I'm just saying that part I see the issue for sure.

I now wish I could withdraw my vote and abstain because I stilll think i'd have phoned him immediately to clarify the comment, but I do see the issue with this part.

NoOrdinaryMorning · 06/02/2024 09:46

determinedtomakethiswork · 06/02/2024 09:04

I think you've got reaction has been right with this one. He's utterly selfish.

Wow that's quite a gigantic leap you've made there

TeaGinandFags · 06/02/2024 09:46

You have done all the work in this relationship and he doesn't appreciate it one tiny bit.

You know the next bit.

NoOrdinaryMorning · 06/02/2024 09:45

DojaPhat · 05/02/2024 17:45

The amount of posters, presumably women, suggesting his comment was a bad attempt at humour are really quite baffling. The position the OP was in meant if he couldn't do anything realistically to 'save the day', the only alternative was to sympathise. Not crack a joke about it.

That comment would put me off him, as would dating someone who I'd have to make something of an excursion to visit every so often while still figuring out where it's going.

All in all it sounds as though you're putting in a lot more effort than he is and his communication style doesn't suit you, nor it appears, does he have the requisite emotional intelligence.

🙄

BigBoysDontCry · 06/02/2024 09:43

I'd have thought he was joking with you and replied along similar lines, but you know him better than me.

delphi13 · 06/02/2024 09:43

Seems like banter to me. Plus the comment about walking to the train station too. The text is hard for you to tell it's banter because you can't tell tone of voice from text but I might well say something like that to my husband. I think maybe you just have different senses of humour.

You can take the joke about walking to the train station several ways, 1) that he thinks he's too good for you (struggling with seeing that. 2) that he wants to make sure you get there safely but doesn't want to appear to make overbearing and keen 3) it was just a throwaway comment with a bit of humour which is being overanalysed here.

The only point of concern here is that you are doing all the travelling. I would look to get that in balance first and if he won't do his share then I'd be out of there.