Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To consider studying medicine at 43?

116 replies

PurpleOrchid42 · 05/02/2024 16:32

And with 2 ND kids, aged 6 and 2? Is this completely unrealistic? Or is it possible to live that dream?

OP posts:
RainbowFlutter · 05/02/2024 21:23

I'm a great believer in nothing being impossible. I would definitely say it wouldn't be worth it though. Most junior doctors are unhappy with their living and working conditions and we're talking about a group of people who have already sacrificed a lot to get through the exams to get there. So, not generally a bunch of moaners.

Your family life will suffer. Your children will miss you. Don't do it OP. Most 54 year olds are planning retirement at 60 in medicine. Being on the wards on call in your 40s and 50s; I wouldn't wish it on my enemy.

BintuBintu · 05/02/2024 21:22

onanotherday · 05/02/2024 21:07

I'm going to buck the trend here...I taught (Primary to A level) for 30 years...retrained in Social Work in my 50s...it was exhausting and exilerating..and I was a single parent of ND kids. I didn't have shift work, but did out of hours and weekends. It will be very hard but unless you try what have you to lose and teaching certainly makes for great resilience.

Something like this is achievable and realistic, if not hard work.

Medicine is going to be extremely hard (at any age, let alone 40 with 2 children) and is an all round terrible idea.

MILTOBE · 05/02/2024 21:21

It seems really egotistical actually to think you are not like everyone else - you can do it despite not studying for twenty years, despite not having the energy of a twenty year old, despite having dependents who need a reliable presence at home, despite knowing you wouldn't bring in any kind of a wage and would also have a student loan, or pay out a hell of a lot of money not to, and despite knowing you'd have to move around the country. It's so unrealistic it's laughable.

unexpectediteminthebraggingarea · 05/02/2024 21:19

My mum should have been a doctor. She was easily bright enough but her parents thought she should focus on finding a husband and having babies. Once we were nearly grown and she was 40 she retrained as a nurse. She's found it really satisfying. After building experience in various areas she became a nurse specialist and also did her prescribing course, and does lots of teaching now in her specialism. She's hugely knowledgeable and finds it really satisfying.

Similarly the two medical professionals who have really become valued people in mine and my children's lives are our specialist nurses. We all have complex conditions and have regular contact with our specialist nurses and we absolutely value them.

Cormoran · 05/02/2024 21:18

In my 20s I did plenty of night work in clubs and with little or no sleep, I was sharp and functional the next day. Now in my 50s, if for some reason I have a sleepless night, either because I am flying on a red eye or an event, I feel so sick the following days.
I wouldn't be able to do night shifts again. A junior doctor gets the worst shifts.

Faffertea · 05/02/2024 21:17

I’m a GP partner, train GP trainees in practice and teach graduate entry medicine at a medical school too. I’m (very) late 30s and have ND son aged 11.

I would hate to dissuade anyone who really wanted it away from medicine. It is a hard job and the NHS is particularly difficult at the moment but it’s still, mostly, a job I live. I work 3 days a week in practice, one at the university and still log on from home at the weekend to keep on top of things. I couldn’t do it when my son was younger.

Realistically though I think it may be too late. Undergraduate medicine is hardcore, full in and demanding. Graduate entry medicine even more so. Foundation and Specialty training is also incredibly difficult and while some specialties like GP are better for hopefully being able to train more locally, being a GP is not an easy job to do if you’re not suited to it, as I’m sure you know if you’re married to or related to one.

I would also think about whether being an ANP or PA is right if what you really want is medicine. ANPs and PAs while important parts of healthcare team are not doctors and some of the students I teach have gone to medical school after PA/nursing because what they want is to be doctors. Other areas of allied health e.g OT or areas like medical research, genetic counselling or pharmaceuticals might be worth looking at too.

Stoufer · 05/02/2024 21:14

Sorry, had to finish previous post abruptly. What I wanted to say that with ND children things can go very very horribly wrong at school and socially (especially in secondary school), and they need a lot of time, encouragement and support (from parents). I have found that things are always much more difficult for my dc if I am not there, or if I can’t give them time. Each child will have their own challenges, whether ND or not, but I have found that navigating years 9-11 (gcse years) and years 5-8 (transition and early secondary sch) with an ND child to be quite labour intensive. And I do not know how I (or they) would have coped if I had had to work full time / outside the home. It may be different for other families with ND, but I have been so thankful that I have been able to step back from work during these periods. I think retraining in something like medicine would put you (and your family) under too much pressure. Sorry.

Yesnosorryplease · 05/02/2024 21:09

It's not impossible, nothing is. But it would likely be unpleasant, expensive, exhausting, relationship testing etc and mean you would largely be an absent parent for big chunks of your dc's childhood.

You would be doing your course with an overwhelming majority of high functioning, highly competitive but lacking life experience 18 year olds. You would be unlikely to have true peers and you would be the one not joining in with the pub golf etc. Med school is an endless merry go round of high stakes assessments, placements in difficult to get to places and an awful lot of observing other people at work whilst feeling a bit stupid and a lot in the way in the early years. Being really bad at something or observing without input is much harder for adults than teens.

Working as a doctor, especially as a junior Dr is unenviable. You don't have much say over where you get a job, much less when you have time off. My cousin couldn't get time off for her own wedding! And you'll get paid less than you were on as a teacher for ages. Staying up all night, knowing if you forget something or don't concentrate properly a patient could be harmed is intense and night shifts can shorten your life! Switching from days to nights, covering weekends and Christmas, missing birthdays etc....its your kids who would bear a lot of the impact.

Really, just why would you?!

onanotherday · 05/02/2024 21:07

I'm going to buck the trend here...I taught (Primary to A level) for 30 years...retrained in Social Work in my 50s...it was exhausting and exilerating..and I was a single parent of ND kids. I didn't have shift work, but did out of hours and weekends. It will be very hard but unless you try what have you to lose and teaching certainly makes for great resilience.

WandaWonder · 05/02/2024 21:06

I would love to study medicine but it is easy to say in my head there is no way on this planet I would become a doctor the 18 hour days the weird shifts no chance

I am very thankful people do it though!

FixTheBone · 05/02/2024 21:04

The main reason not to is the likelihood of having to uproot your entire family 3 or 4 times in the next 10-12 years.

Once when you get into med school
Again when you get into foundation
Again into core training
Again into specialty training
And potentially again when you get a permanent job.

The location of any or all of these career stages may be out of your control and you could literally end up going to Newcastle Uni, doing a foundation programme in London, core training in Birmingham and specialty training in Yorkshire (with placements in hull, Bradford, Scarborough, Leeds, then Airedale) before getting a permanent job in Manchester.

I'd say you'd be better doing PA training, but hopefully we doctors will get our act together and shut that con down.

Remaker · 05/02/2024 21:03

A friend did it and they are now training to be a consultant in their 50s. They have no regrets. But no partner or kids, which makes a huge difference.

khaa2091 · 05/02/2024 21:03

I would consider looking at the Physicians Associate Programmes. You should be able to undertake postgrad study if your first degree is biology and the training is faster and more fixed.

LadyWithLapdog · 05/02/2024 21:01

DNs doing medicine at the moment. It’s tough, and they’re only early 20s. Can’t imagine older and with young kids.

Bluewallss · 05/02/2024 21:00

It’s possible. One of the best doctors I’ve ever worked with qualified later in life. I just wouldn’t encourage you to do it. It’s a fucking shit show. You’re going to be treated like shite. If you’re interested in healthcare go the nursing/ahp route then you can do a masters for a ACP. You will be treated slightly better, earn a bit more and have more career options.

Stoufer · 05/02/2024 20:56

No, don’t do it. I have ND dc, and if you think it gets easier as they get older, in some ways it does, but in other ways it really really doesn’t.

FloofCloud · 05/02/2024 20:55

How about an optician?

olympicsrock · 05/02/2024 19:57

Hell no . I’m a 45 year old consultant.

Pythonesque · 05/02/2024 19:55

Reading through I see someone has just mentioned genetic counselling - depending on what you find interesting that could be an area that you might enjoy and there's certainly increasing demand.

I'm roughly the age you would be doing foundation posts if you went down this path, and have recently tried getting back into clinical work having fallen out of it when my children were babies (long story). In applying for jobs I'm acknowledging that getting back into formal training (I'd got as far as postgrad exams) is unrealistic for me at this point, if I can get anywhere I'd be hoping for a part-time staff grade somewhere. But I absolutely recognise the drive to be useful somehow.

Good luck finding a sensible route forward for your only personal satisfaction.

thislittlecourgette · 05/02/2024 19:25

Salacia · 05/02/2024 19:10

I feel like I post the same doom and gloom on all of these threads…

Don’t do it. Medical school is the easy bit. Working as a doctor in the NHS is frequently dreadful - you’re unable to give a decent standard of care as the system consistently undercuts you. You’re treated like a child. You have very little control over your life - where and when you work for example. You’re not seen as an actual person by the NHS/HEE but a name on a rota who can be moved around at whim. I’ve had colleagues who were denied leave for their own weddings (I was denied leave for my grandpa’s funeral). Or who were given a weeks notice that their next job was not where they were told it would be but is in fact in another hospital hours away from where they’ve arranged to start renting etc. Look at the doctor forums on Reddit for more horror stories (or all the previous threads on here about retraining).

The conditions are increasingly awful and the pay does not match the level of responsibility - hence why we’re striking, emigrating or just plain quitting in huge numbers. At one point I felt like I started every interaction with a patient with an apology for something that wasn’t really my fault. Accepting abuse from patients and relatives is routine (and what I’ve faced is nothing compared to what my non-white colleagues have received). I’ve also seen quite a lot of staff bullying. Even the shorter training programmes like GP would still require you to be working a full on call hospital rota (and it seems to be a national pastime to hurl abuse at primary care at the moment). Plus exams don’t finish with medical school so whatever you choose training wise you’ll need to juggle your family with the hours and then coming home to revise (your exams will cost you thousands of pounds to sit too).

I’m in a non-clinical specialty now and I suppose I’m happy - it still isn’t worth what a medical career has done to my mental health.

I’ve been privileged to be there for some of the most important moments in peoples lives and I do appreciate how lucky I am to have had that opportunity but I wouldn’t do medicine if I had my time again. The good in no way outweighs the bad (although medical school itself was fantastic).

To be honest I struggle to recommend any career in the NHS but I’d look at allied health roles - perhaps something like occupational therapy or genetic counselling - the NHS website has some great careers resources. How are you with maths/programming? Bioinformatics is going to be a huge growth area for the future (although it’s not a clinical/patient facing role there are still a lot of interesting problem solving aspects to it).

I certainly can’t agree with this post enough.

Salacia · 05/02/2024 19:10

I feel like I post the same doom and gloom on all of these threads…

Don’t do it. Medical school is the easy bit. Working as a doctor in the NHS is frequently dreadful - you’re unable to give a decent standard of care as the system consistently undercuts you. You’re treated like a child. You have very little control over your life - where and when you work for example. You’re not seen as an actual person by the NHS/HEE but a name on a rota who can be moved around at whim. I’ve had colleagues who were denied leave for their own weddings (I was denied leave for my grandpa’s funeral). Or who were given a weeks notice that their next job was not where they were told it would be but is in fact in another hospital hours away from where they’ve arranged to start renting etc. Look at the doctor forums on Reddit for more horror stories (or all the previous threads on here about retraining).

The conditions are increasingly awful and the pay does not match the level of responsibility - hence why we’re striking, emigrating or just plain quitting in huge numbers. At one point I felt like I started every interaction with a patient with an apology for something that wasn’t really my fault. Accepting abuse from patients and relatives is routine (and what I’ve faced is nothing compared to what my non-white colleagues have received). I’ve also seen quite a lot of staff bullying. Even the shorter training programmes like GP would still require you to be working a full on call hospital rota (and it seems to be a national pastime to hurl abuse at primary care at the moment). Plus exams don’t finish with medical school so whatever you choose training wise you’ll need to juggle your family with the hours and then coming home to revise (your exams will cost you thousands of pounds to sit too).

I’m in a non-clinical specialty now and I suppose I’m happy - it still isn’t worth what a medical career has done to my mental health.

I’ve been privileged to be there for some of the most important moments in peoples lives and I do appreciate how lucky I am to have had that opportunity but I wouldn’t do medicine if I had my time again. The good in no way outweighs the bad (although medical school itself was fantastic).

To be honest I struggle to recommend any career in the NHS but I’d look at allied health roles - perhaps something like occupational therapy or genetic counselling - the NHS website has some great careers resources. How are you with maths/programming? Bioinformatics is going to be a huge growth area for the future (although it’s not a clinical/patient facing role there are still a lot of interesting problem solving aspects to it).

Kerfuffleplunk · 05/02/2024 19:10

I would look at something lower key…I’m currently trying to get a ND teen through GCSEs and it’s a job in itself! I think you have to try and project what home life is going to be like in another 10 yrs for you, I had no concept of what teenage life would be when my own kids were 6 and 2 respectively! Perhaps see a careers advisor, I’m sure there are many rewarding careers you could move into with the qualifications you already have.

Crushed23 · 05/02/2024 18:58

Just today I was thinking of a way I could move to America and do a prestigious MBA in my mid-30s and child-free. I concluded that it was a ridiculous idea! 5 years of medical school in one’s mid to late 40s is just as silly, I’m afraid.

I can empathise though - I would love an intellectual challenge and I do miss studying. I dream about the excitement of starting a new degree with like minded people.

FloofCloud · 05/02/2024 18:50

I also have 2 ND children, a bit older, and they'd struggle with the crazy hours and lack of structure to my job. Also I'm 51 now and peri menopausal - many days I feel like a zombie with foggy brain and generally shattered - I couldn't go into work full time like I used to so WFH 3 days and 2 days in the office - my colleague is a consultant doctor, same age as me, and she's constantly stressed and never gets a good break
Honestly, I wouldn't for these reasons
Good luck if you chose to do it through

toomuchfaff · 05/02/2024 18:39

there was a recent post in a similar vein, not sure if you can search it but there was 100s pages of people (mainly medical professionals) telling this woman she was absolutely ridiculous to contemplate it...