Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think middle schools should be introduced in the UK?

270 replies

Serrina · 05/02/2024 16:05

The transition from primary school to high school is very difficult for a lot of children at 11 and there's very little preparation for it. Somehow they're expected to jump from a nurturing primary school environment - which is often like a second home to many children, and spending the day in their own classroom with their own teacher and all their friends, then all of a sudden to a regimental high school system of registration, then having to go to different classes at various points in the day, with little more than a couple of minutes to get from one class to another and being penalised if they're "late" despite the fact the next class may be at the opposite end of a huge building than their previous one.

They have to get used to not just one new teacher, but several. Uniform rules are generally stricter, blazers aren't allowed to be removed no matter how hot it is, and in early September when school starts it usually is still quite hot.
Teachers in high school generally aren't as kind as primary school ones, if a child is upset or distressed they're expected to just "get on with it" they aren't comforted and reassured as they would be in primary.

P.E. lessons are more regimental, and you're expected to shower afterwards which is distressing particularly for many girls at this stage, as they are going through many changes and might not feel comfortable with this.

You're penalised for not having the right equipment on the right days, which isn't such a big deal in primary schools.

They're only 11. They've come straight from the school they've attended since they were 4 years old, and all of a sudden they're sharing a building for more than 6 hours a day with 15 and 16 year olds. And high school children can be brutal.

I know Year 6 is meant to be the "preparation year" but I don't think it's enough. They're still very much in a primary school environment. And outside of maybe one or two induction days, they don't have much help with the transition at all. I think this is one thing our cousins across the pond get right in terms of the education system, by having middle schools (previously called junior high schools) as a kind of in-between stage to help ease them in. I really think this kind of system would be beneficial here.

OP posts:
notknowledgeable · 06/02/2024 10:53

Needmorelego · 06/02/2024 09:35

@notknowledgeable I think what I was trying to say is that the current Year 7s may seem immature compared to those in the past but an 11 year old of the 1930s would still be at an elementary school (as they were called back then) or one in the 70s at a middle school so very different environments so they would have matured differently.
But we (society) give children less freedom and responsibilities than in the past so they are being babied a lot.
We've babied them (eg - no walking to primary school by themselves until at least Year 6 etc) but then thrusting them into a very intense secondary system and expecting them suddenly to be mature.

But what I am saying is that the current year 7 are unbelievably, jaw droppingly, stunningly immature compared to year 7 from 5 (FIVE!!) years ago.

It is very easy indeed to compare for anyone who has been in education more than 5 years

Needmorelego · 06/02/2024 10:51

@IvorTheEngineDriver the old style "failed" because the introduction of the national curriculum key stages didn't match the year groups that middle schools had.

IvorTheEngineDriver · 06/02/2024 10:27

We had a 3 tier system in the 80s. It was deemed a failure. How would a new one be any better?

MoonWoman69 · 06/02/2024 10:24

I went from primary school to middle school aged 10/11 in 1979/80. I didn't actually know they didn't exist any more, but I loved my time there. Sadly we moved away and I went straight into high school when we moved. I knew no-one at all, as we moved 80 miles away, but I can happily say, they were the best years of my life!

Needmorelego · 06/02/2024 10:20

@puncheur most middle schools in America are up to age 14 - with 9th Grade in High School.
For many years the pattern was Grades 7-9 (so age 12 - 15) was "Junior High" and then 3 years of High School but most areas have changed to the Middle School format which is Grade 6 - 8 (ages 11 - 14) and then 4 years of High School.
It varies though all over America. There's no standard.
Some even have Primary (Kindergarten to grade 2 or 3), Intermediate (3 or 4 - 5), Middle (6 - 8) and then High (9 - 12) !

Willyoujustbequiet · 06/02/2024 10:04

puncheur · 06/02/2024 09:42

It's not an American import. Lots of areas in the UK have middle schools - I went to one in the 80s. It's only recently that they have been got rid of in some areas.

I'm surprised that people aren't aware lots of areas still have them.

Willyoujustbequiet · 06/02/2024 10:03

We still have middle schools here and they work very well.

Lowest pupil to teacher ratio in the country and the schools are excellent. Dc only has 8 in the class.

puncheur · 06/02/2024 10:01

@DocOck US middle schools go through to 9th grade (age 15). I'm pretty sure that is not what she is suggesting.

Londonnight · 06/02/2024 09:53

There is still a middle school system where I live in Staffordshire. It uses the three tier system. Children go to high school in year 9 [ 13 yrs old ]. My son went through this system and I feel it is much better than transitioning at 11.

DocOck · 06/02/2024 09:51

When my DC were in Year 6 they were more than ready for secondary school. Most kids are.

@puncheur pretty sure that's a different type of middle school to what the OP is suggesting, which is an American style. Middle school here in the 80s was not for 11+, it was KS2.

puncheur · 06/02/2024 09:42

quisensoucie · 06/02/2024 08:02

For heaven's sake how much more pampering?
Generations of children in the UK have survived the change; so many positive benefitscsuch as learning to organise your own time, thinking for yourself etc.
And wanting another bloody american import? No thank you!

It's not an American import. Lots of areas in the UK have middle schools - I went to one in the 80s. It's only recently that they have been got rid of in some areas.

Needmorelego · 06/02/2024 09:42

@user1477391263 yes I think people have got confused about what the OP was suggesting.
The idea would be for Key Stage 3 (Yrs 7 -9 so ages 11-14) to be Middle schools - not going back to the 1960s/70s concept ones.

Merrow · 06/02/2024 09:41

Our school had a corridor that was for the secondary 1 students (so year 7 in England? 1st year of secondary) that the older students weren't supposed to go to. And that worked well. The teachers came to us for a year except for music I think. Then in 2nd year you did all the moving around classrooms when you were more familiar with the school and all the students in your year.

mealideas2024 · 06/02/2024 09:39

We have a middle school where I live. It works well! The "younger kids" have a much smoother transition to senior school and there's also less social issues.

Nofilteritwonthelp · 06/02/2024 09:37

I went to one and didn't really see the point, it just meant two stressful changes!

aloysiusflyte · 06/02/2024 09:36

When I went to school in the 80s and 90s it was a three tier system and we spent reception,1,2,3 in first school, 4,5,6,7 in middle school and 8,9,10,11 in high school so 4 years in each.
Seemed to work well but there's no way that local authorities could go back to that now as they knocked down/repurposed a lot of the middle schools in my area.
The only issue I ever had with it was that by the end of Year 7 we had definitely outgrown middle school but I suppose that was right for the transition to high school.

Needmorelego · 06/02/2024 09:35

@notknowledgeable I think what I was trying to say is that the current Year 7s may seem immature compared to those in the past but an 11 year old of the 1930s would still be at an elementary school (as they were called back then) or one in the 70s at a middle school so very different environments so they would have matured differently.
But we (society) give children less freedom and responsibilities than in the past so they are being babied a lot.
We've babied them (eg - no walking to primary school by themselves until at least Year 6 etc) but then thrusting them into a very intense secondary system and expecting them suddenly to be mature.

user1477391263 · 06/02/2024 09:34

“MIddle school” in America means something completely different.

It’s another word for junior high school and is for kids aged 12 to about 15. It’s not a late-primary school for nine-year-olds.

sashh · 06/02/2024 09:32

They already exist in some places. I think in rural areas where children have to travel a long way to high school they can be a good idea.

But one problem is that teachers in middle schools don't have to be trained in secondary education so your child's French teacher might be a primary school teacher with A Level French.

I think a better idea would be to go for 'grades' like the US does (but not their HSC)where children can move throught he system at a faster or slower rate than the majority.

notknowledgeable · 06/02/2024 09:27

ilovebreadsauce · 06/02/2024 09:25

I think rhe vast majority of kids are more than ready for seconday school at 11. A few might not be but hou need to go with the majority

And the ones that aren't are not helped by holding them back and delaying their development still further

ilovebreadsauce · 06/02/2024 09:25

I think rhe vast majority of kids are more than ready for seconday school at 11. A few might not be but hou need to go with the majority

AnnPerkins · 06/02/2024 09:25

We are in a three tier area that has begun the transition to two tier. DS went to middle school from Y5-8. When the transition was done in a neighbouring LEA (sneaked through contrary to the outcome of the consultation) they closed the middle schools and for a while it was quite messy. There were 'deserts' leaving some children without a local choice from Y9.

There are two middle schools in this area, the one DS went to is big and like a secondary - 970 pupils, 240 in Y5. It was a big change from the 125 pupil village school, and getting the school bus at age 9 seemed rather daunting. Students move around the school for lessons. DS was happy there.

The other one was smaller and more like a primary. The smaller one has now converted to secondary, but without a sixth form.

DS is now in Y10 at upper school in the same academy chain as his middle so lots of crossover and it made the transition from Y8 to Y9 easy. He was really excited to go there. It is massive, (1700 students Y9-13, 420 in Y9). I just looked at the 2022 exam results and they are better than the mixed secondary over the county border but worse than the boys' secondary.

One reason given for the transition to two tier was the difficulty in recruiting teachers in middle schools. The plan was to convert both DS's old middle and current upper to all-through 4-19 schools. Our village's school would have to find room to add two classrooms for Y5-6, probably taking some of the playground away.

It has been paused due to the LEA fucking up the finances, to the fury of the academy chain. Luckily the timeline wouldn't have affected DS anyway but some friends are pissed off because they don't know whether their younger children will be able stay at the middle school through to Y13 or have to move at Y9.

notknowledgeable · 06/02/2024 09:25

Needmorelego · 06/02/2024 09:22

@notknowledgeable but for an 11 year old from - say the 1950s - would have gone to a secondary modern school and it would have been a very different experience. Smaller schools and the eldest pupils were 15.
An 11 year old in the 1930s wouldn't have even changed schools at 11.
An 11 year old in the 70s could have been in one if the "new" 3 tier system so at middle school when 11.
So you can definitely compare generations of 11 year olds. Their experiences have been so different

Edited

I dont really know what your saying. I am saying that in our experience, maturity has fallen off a cliff edge in recent years - we don't need to build new schools to cater for the retarded emotional growth in our children, we need to tackle to retarded emotional growth in our children!

Needmorelego · 06/02/2024 09:22

@notknowledgeable but for an 11 year old from - say the 1950s - would have gone to a secondary modern school and it would have been a very different experience. Smaller schools and the eldest pupils were 15.
An 11 year old in the 1930s wouldn't have even changed schools at 11.
An 11 year old in the 70s could have been in one if the "new" 3 tier system so at middle school when 11.
So you can definitely compare generations of 11 year olds. Their experiences have been so different

MermaidEyes · 06/02/2024 09:15

MimiGC · 06/02/2024 08:55

Have two kids going/just gone through secondary school in UK, neither has ever been expected to shower at school. Don't think the schools (two different ones) even had showers. So if you have a child worried about that, you may be able to reassure them on that score.

I was going to say this, in my kids school there is no way on earth they'd have time to shower, change and get to their next lesson halfway across campus in time.