Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have told my late teens that I won't be contributing

605 replies

itspurplestripes · 05/02/2024 14:58

.. to their childcare arrangements , if and when they have kids. They were really surprised!
Lone parent here, working full time and intend to retire in about ten years. Ie I'll be relatively young.
It was a light conversation but they fully thought that I would be a part of their childcare set up in time.
I will f course be supportive and help
Out when needed and look forward to

Spending time with my grandkids but travel and renewing relationships and rest are certainly at the top of my list !
AIBU. Or is this the norm/ expectation now?

OP posts:
TheOriginalEmu · 05/02/2024 20:03

MargaretThursday · 05/02/2024 15:05

I think my kids would be surprised if I told them that, even though the older pair are early 20s simply because it wouldn't have occurred to them to consider I would or wouldn't. It would be an odd conversation to have because if they leave it another 10-15 years, I have no idea what I will be doing nor what I might like to do.
It would be something I'd have brought up if either they'd asked, with clearly an eye to ttc in the near future, or maybe some point in pregnancy (not greeting the news with that response either).

The plan might be 10-15 years away. It could be next year. You never know what might happen. It’s best to be upfront and clear I think.

I’ve told my late teen/early twenties kids the same. I have at least one child who will never leave home maybe 2. so I have enough caring duties without babies.

MrsMiddleMother · 05/02/2024 20:02

I absolutely agree op and although my children are still little, it's something I've discussed with family before. I'm of the opinion that you have children, you sort the childcare. I want to actually spend time with my grandchildren, take them out, have sleepovers, babysit and of course I'll be emergency childcare if needed but I'd have no intention of raising them as I feel many grandparents do.

I also want to make sure I treat all my grandchildren equally, which I wouldn't be able to guarantee if I was childcare for say one set of grandkids and then due to age/ability wasn't able to do that for another. It can cause rifts between siblings when you can do more for one set and then not for the other years later and I wouldn't want to cause then if possible.

Daleksatemyshed · 05/02/2024 20:00

@Shodan, that's the word I was looking for but couldn't find- transactional. When did the relationship between DC and their parents stop being one of mutual love and become you do this for me and I'll do this for you? Your parents raise you, pay for everything, love you, help you with house deposits or let you live rent free into adulthood but they're never, ever allowed to say NO? I'm afraid that says far more about selfishness than refusing to be your DGC's daycare. For the record I have no DC but I cared for my DM until she died, not because I owed her anything, but because I loved her.

Risun · 05/02/2024 19:58

@HazelBite Fingers crossed for you.

MamaGhina · 05/02/2024 19:55

I don’t know about norm or expectation but my parents did absolutely nothing to help me. As a result I will be offering for my kids. I know how hard it is with no help and it’s not something I would do to my kids if I was able to.

Risun · 05/02/2024 19:55

For various sad reasons I have no grandchildren.

This could happen to any of you, best not to make assumptions.

Hardbackwriter · 05/02/2024 19:47

I agree with some pp that while there's nothing wrong with not wanting to do any regular childcare phrasing it as 'I've done my time' isn't very pleasant, even if it's meant jokily. It reminds me of people who go on at their children about how horrible giving birth to them was. They might think it's lighthearted but no one really enjoys the 'joke' that their parents resent them.

HazelBite · 05/02/2024 19:46

I used to say to my sons, when they were in their teens and dating that I did not want to be a Grandmother! Two of them are in their 40's and the other two in their 30's and I'm not ( and I don't think I ever will be) a Grandmother.
Be careful OP you may end up like me!

Shodan · 05/02/2024 19:46

There's a very transactional vibe to some of the posts on this thread.

Grandparents will only have a close relationship with the grandchildren if they do regular childcare.
Grandparents can't expect any help in their old age if they don't do regular childcare.

I'm very glad my children aren't so unpleasant. Strange as it may seem, it would make me less inclined to help my children out with their children if they held such opinions.

Ap24 · 05/02/2024 19:39

I think it's fine to be involved as much as you'd like to be. We won't be having any family help with our baby. Our families are also unwilling to travel to visit us. But on the flip side I won't feel obligated to help them in their old age nor do/will we be travelling to visit them regularly.

I'll be helping my child where possible. I want to be the kind of family that supports one another.

5128gap · 05/02/2024 19:38

plinkypink · 05/02/2024 19:25

@Ohlookwhoitis I find it entitled that generations who had it multiple times easier then wash their hands of responsibility to help their children. Pull the ladder up behind you why don't you. It's heartbreaking reading this thread to see the general attitude of grandparents - could have 6 days a week to go on holiday but that's not enough. While your children and grandchildren might never get to go on holiday. People are literally going without having children because of the cost of childcare - a choice the older generations of today rarely had to make.

What generations are you talking about here exactly? I'm a grandmother, but I'm gen X and about 5 years older than some of the mums at DGDs school. I do some childcare for DGC, but also work FT and will continue to do so for another 15 years. If my generation had it easy then I must have been standing in the wrong queue at the time. If you mean the despised 'boomers', well many of that generation are likely to be of an age where childcare would be a real challenge physically. My parents in law are fit and well for their age, but there's no way they would be able to run round after toddlers.

Mamaraisedadoughut · 05/02/2024 19:34

I will be helping if my health and finances allow.
But then DDs plan is to work a job that will require regular international travel, to have children will be hard without robust childcare for fairly extended periods of time.

I'd like to enable her to live her dreams without losing out on motherhood.

But we all have our own lives and decisions to make.

kintra · 05/02/2024 19:32

NewName24 · 05/02/2024 19:27

I asked why your children would think it's the norm, not why the grandparents didn't provide childcare. Did they go to nursery? Surely they were then surrounded by lots of other children who went to nursery

Most dc will only be aware of what their current friends situations are, and have no concept of what children they played alongside in Nursery's circumstances were. Most won't remember that much about Nursery even and of course would have no concept of other children's families' childcare arrangements.

Breakfast club and after school care, then. The situations they would remember. They'd be more familiar with their own situation (and presumably anyone else they attended wraparound care with) than the ones getting collected by granny

Gangshow · 05/02/2024 19:31

Marmite27 · 05/02/2024 15:09

My mum always said this. No problem, we arranged childcare.

Then she back tracked and did provide childcare for my brother. Which feels wildly unfair.

Fair play if this is your choice, just make sure you apply it equally.

Second this. Completely respect the view that they don't want to do childcare, but when it comes down to it they offer for one sibling and not other.

itspurplestripes · 05/02/2024 19:29

@BallaiLuimni The signals that I have and will be sending to my children are that they are loved more than anything in the world and that I adore every hair on their head as I will their children but that I will be their children's Grandmother and all That goes with that and not their regular childminder.

OP posts:
LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 05/02/2024 19:29

Platypuslover · 05/02/2024 19:10

Well that is human extinction ensured thanks to the selfishness brigade.

That is a fatuous and stupid remark. If that's the extent of human intelligence then, bring on the extinction, it's long overdue.

Keychangeoff · 05/02/2024 19:27

Wild idea I know

5128gap · 05/02/2024 19:27

hellywelly3 · 05/02/2024 18:52

My parents said and did this and now I’m expected to help them with old age health problems!

I cared for my father in his old age because he'd been a good loving parent to me all my life. Worked long hours in a gruelling job to support me. Taught me, encouraged me and cared for me, putting me ahead of himself in everything. When he finally got to retire, to expect him to roll up his sleeves and start looking after my babies and toddlers as a condition of me not neglecting him when he became frail and ill would not have sat right with me, to put it mildly.

Keychangeoff · 05/02/2024 19:27

Platypuslover · 05/02/2024 19:10

Well that is human extinction ensured thanks to the selfishness brigade.

Or you know, couples could have the amount of children they can afford to raise ….

NewName24 · 05/02/2024 19:27

I asked why your children would think it's the norm, not why the grandparents didn't provide childcare. Did they go to nursery? Surely they were then surrounded by lots of other children who went to nursery

Most dc will only be aware of what their current friends situations are, and have no concept of what children they played alongside in Nursery's circumstances were. Most won't remember that much about Nursery even and of course would have no concept of other children's families' childcare arrangements.

WithManyTot · 05/02/2024 19:27

You are totally within your rights to do this.

MIL didn't want to commit to help with our DC either. She wanted an a-la-carte approach, do Tuesday 9:30 to 9:35 and Wednesday evenings between Eastenders and Corrie, with everything cancellable at zero notice if something better came along. We obviously made cast iron plans that didn't rely on her in any way. She then got the huff because "She wasn't involved with her Grandchildren"

Be careful what you wish for....

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 05/02/2024 19:27

Restinpeacefavouritecoathanger · 05/02/2024 19:00

My DD is currently one year old and goes to my mother in law four days a week 6-3 to allow me to work, for this we pay her a small amount (approx 1/3rd nursery) as this allowed her to give a morning job up. She has pretty much said she couldn't do it again and we know it's unlikely we will be able to have another based on the childcare costs at nursery.
I know my feelings might change once the difficulty of the first years are over but I've already said I want to be in the right position to be able to contribute to childcare costs but I couldn't do what my MIL does.

That sounds a very difficult situation. Would your mother in law have had the choice not to give up her part time work? I mean, if she hadn't, would you have been able to manage to put your daughter in childcare?

That is the point I was making really and four days a week with such an early start is a lot and for me it wouldn't have been possible. Even for someone who is able, it is a bind if there is no other option for their family member.

Your mother in law has sacrificed a lot and I hope her son pulls his weight in doing things for her.

Notthatcatagain · 05/02/2024 19:25

I cared for my granddaughter when she was small, it was great fun, then her baby sister arrived and 2 of them were not so much fun, some days I was watching the clock, desperately waiting for them to be collected because I was shattered. Help and support is one thing but regular childcare is entirely different

itspurplestripes · 05/02/2024 19:25

Again@kintra my children thought it was the norm because they were surrounded by and friends with children whose GPs provided wraparound care. For the duration of their school
Years.

OP posts:
plinkypink · 05/02/2024 19:25

@Ohlookwhoitis I find it entitled that generations who had it multiple times easier then wash their hands of responsibility to help their children. Pull the ladder up behind you why don't you. It's heartbreaking reading this thread to see the general attitude of grandparents - could have 6 days a week to go on holiday but that's not enough. While your children and grandchildren might never get to go on holiday. People are literally going without having children because of the cost of childcare - a choice the older generations of today rarely had to make.

Swipe left for the next trending thread