Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have told my late teens that I won't be contributing

605 replies

itspurplestripes · 05/02/2024 14:58

.. to their childcare arrangements , if and when they have kids. They were really surprised!
Lone parent here, working full time and intend to retire in about ten years. Ie I'll be relatively young.
It was a light conversation but they fully thought that I would be a part of their childcare set up in time.
I will f course be supportive and help
Out when needed and look forward to

Spending time with my grandkids but travel and renewing relationships and rest are certainly at the top of my list !
AIBU. Or is this the norm/ expectation now?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Icantbedoingwithit · 10/02/2024 22:17

Restinpeacefavouritecoathanger · 10/02/2024 17:16

Well I'm sorry you feel sad. If you read my post however she couldn't do it again she loves it with my current daughter but she wouldn't feel able to do it again when she is older.

Yeah sounds like she loves it! Up every morning at 6am to take your child because you won’t pay childcare. Sounds like a fab life for her.

Mary46 · 10/02/2024 17:49

I wouldnt do full T. Really ties your week. Would be happy to help a bit. My mother never helped. Had reared her own. It was hard though at times seeing friends with good backup. I dont need babysitters now as older.

Restinpeacefavouritecoathanger · 10/02/2024 17:16

Icantbedoingwithit · 05/02/2024 20:50

I think that is very sad. You drop your child to your MIL at 6 am four days a week. She has made noises that she is not able for it and you admit you couldn’t do what she does and yet you still send her. God love that poor woman.

Well I'm sorry you feel sad. If you read my post however she couldn't do it again she loves it with my current daughter but she wouldn't feel able to do it again when she is older.

Kendodd · 09/02/2024 09:06

Kittylala · 08/02/2024 23:45

My grandparents were on hand for childcare. They took us for fun days out. They were a big part of my childhood memories. My parents worked. I'm saddened and resentful because my parents do nothing with mine. But never have I expected to use them for childcare. My grandparent wouldn't have seen it as 'childcare'. It's life. My parents are babyboomers and they unfortunately do.

I'd be very happy to do childcare. I expect it's unlikely though because my children might choose not to have children and if they do would likely live hundreds (thousands) of miles away. I loved it when my children were little, reliving it with grandchildren would be great. Honestly, so many of these 'lve done my time' type comments. I think it's quite sad seeing children as such a chore. I wonder if they just had them because that's what you do. I'm glad young people can choose, without so much judgement, to not have children these days. It's just a shame so many who would like children feel they can't, it would be unfair and irresponsible, because they don't have enough money.

Kittylala · 08/02/2024 23:45

My grandparents were on hand for childcare. They took us for fun days out. They were a big part of my childhood memories. My parents worked. I'm saddened and resentful because my parents do nothing with mine. But never have I expected to use them for childcare. My grandparent wouldn't have seen it as 'childcare'. It's life. My parents are babyboomers and they unfortunately do.

JayJayEl · 08/02/2024 23:25

itspurplestripes · 07/02/2024 22:04

Tbh the only women.. and i stress women .. that I know who provide childcare to their grandkids like this .. wear this as a type of badge of honour . That they think they are superior or some such nonsense. There's definitely an air of martyrdom that they love. A sort of validation. They look fucked . They can't run 5 m after their grandkids but still
Wear that badge as if it gives them some sort of honour .
In my view it's really not . It's martyrdom through fear of saying no. A generational expectation and I'm fucked if I subscribe to that. I think they know it's abuse of inter generational family relationships but for their own self esteem, do this despite slowly dying through pure exhaustion and a fear of not fulfilling a generational expectation despite working or slaving all of their lives . More fool them I say. Martyrs .

Wow! I initially agreed with your original point - different strokes for different folks and all that. However, this comment is incredibly offensive. It reads to me as a projection of your guilt at not wanting to provide childcare. And - I stress - you are absolutely right in not wanting to provide childcare if that is not for you. But this comment is utterly vitriolic, and offensive towards those grandparents that do want to provide childcare, and who more often than not take pleasure in it.

TeenyTinyWiney · 08/02/2024 14:04

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

kintra · 08/02/2024 13:58

LuckySantangelo35 · 08/02/2024 13:48

@TeenyTinyWiney

what do you mean?

op doesn’t want to be a martyr….and you think that’s…a bad thing?! Are you a misogynist?

The nasty judgement of other women is a bad thing. Obviously, but you knew that

LuckySantangelo35 · 08/02/2024 13:48

@TeenyTinyWiney

what do you mean?

op doesn’t want to be a martyr….and you think that’s…a bad thing?! Are you a misogynist?

TeenyTinyWiney · 08/02/2024 13:45

itspurplestripes · 07/02/2024 22:04

Tbh the only women.. and i stress women .. that I know who provide childcare to their grandkids like this .. wear this as a type of badge of honour . That they think they are superior or some such nonsense. There's definitely an air of martyrdom that they love. A sort of validation. They look fucked . They can't run 5 m after their grandkids but still
Wear that badge as if it gives them some sort of honour .
In my view it's really not . It's martyrdom through fear of saying no. A generational expectation and I'm fucked if I subscribe to that. I think they know it's abuse of inter generational family relationships but for their own self esteem, do this despite slowly dying through pure exhaustion and a fear of not fulfilling a generational expectation despite working or slaving all of their lives . More fool them I say. Martyrs .

Yikes - showing your true colours here I think 😬🤢

T1Dmama · 08/02/2024 12:49

Wow! While I can see that not all grandmas want to look after their grandchildren, and some physically/mentally can’t… I think OP you are being horrible … to describe those who do so nastily is vile!
you do you but don’t be so vile about others who enjoy looking after their grandchildren.
There is absolutely nothing lighthearted about your last update, just pure nastiness!

Jennick · 08/02/2024 11:31

You have it hard as a single parent, you enjoy your latter years ,you and your children make choices re having children .I love having my grandkids but that's my choice x

Plantlady10 · 08/02/2024 10:28

I would say most people wouldn't expect grandparents to be part of regular childcare these days, purely because with retirement age ever increasing most grandparents are still working full time! So its not even a discussion point. My children will be teenagers before my mum retires, so way past the childcare years.

She does see them very regularly though and has been amazing in babysitting whenever we need/want, and the relationship they have because of this is lovely to see.

Outthedoor24 · 08/02/2024 10:12

@teeneedanser I'd agree with that.

They are also things that are likely to happen soon after each other and have a financial impact on the person in the middle.

If they've struggled with the financial impact of having to pay for childcare, to keep their job, and career without help.

The aim is so they can earn decent money once kids are beyond the childcare stage.

That is also when women should be making sure they save for retirement and their own future.

Giving that up to care for an elder parent then becomes an even bigger ask. And caring for parents often is a slow drip of a process, it starts with occasional things like changing curtains, fixing things.

teeneedanser · 08/02/2024 00:37

itspurplestripes · 07/02/2024 17:54

But here we go again ... Equating care of your children's children to care of parent by children in their older age... if you were so inclined....
Not t an interest to me but if you were going to have a transaction of care , surely it would be parents raising their kids, kids minding their parents in older ago, no?

I'd say raising your kids is an obligation - it's not like you have a choice. Offering childcare to grandchildren or minding parents in older age is a choice so I can see how they might be thought of as a trade.

CruCru · 08/02/2024 00:19

This is an interesting thread. I’m rather struck by the difference in responses to another thread a few weeks ago - an OP had had a baby and her MIL (who was a difficult person) had stopped taking her medication to get the OP’s husband to look after her. She was 64 and a bunch of people on that thread said that, of course, she was elderly and would have to go into a care home.

On this thread, people are talking about people (women) in their 70s having sole care of toddlers.

I know that there are older people who climb mountains and run marathons. But most don’t. My Mum was quite disabled in her mid 60s as she was waiting for a double hip replacement. By the time it came, it took her 15 minutes to walk from one end of her house to the other. No way could she safely look after a small child. Then, a couple of years later, she was carer for my Dad. When he died, she got cancer (cured now). Relying on grandparents to do childcare risks that their circumstances change suddenly.

Someone upthread said that it would cause resentment if people had to “family plan” to suit Granny. In fairness I know quite a few people with 4+ age gaps because they couldn’t afford nursery for more than one child. It’s fairly common to family plan so your life isn’t impossible.

Redragtoabull · 07/02/2024 23:16

You have had your kids, you've done your bit. To commit to being a part of weekly childcare is not a good thing in my experience, not directly but with our Mum agreeeing to have my nephew twice a week, it caused an awful atmosphere in the family for 18 months. My Mum didn't think of how her very many appointments would affect the agreed days, so caused a big rift, and oh, the calls I had from them both just had me at my wits end as it was relentless. So, I'm with you OP, keep it to days out on your terms unless there's an emergency and you can help, but definitely don't agree to be part of the childcare regime. And how fantastic you are able to retire quite young and will be able to enjoy all the trappings of working hard over the years!

itspurplestripes · 07/02/2024 22:04

Tbh the only women.. and i stress women .. that I know who provide childcare to their grandkids like this .. wear this as a type of badge of honour . That they think they are superior or some such nonsense. There's definitely an air of martyrdom that they love. A sort of validation. They look fucked . They can't run 5 m after their grandkids but still
Wear that badge as if it gives them some sort of honour .
In my view it's really not . It's martyrdom through fear of saying no. A generational expectation and I'm fucked if I subscribe to that. I think they know it's abuse of inter generational family relationships but for their own self esteem, do this despite slowly dying through pure exhaustion and a fear of not fulfilling a generational expectation despite working or slaving all of their lives . More fool them I say. Martyrs .

OP posts:
Tumbleweed101 · 07/02/2024 21:24

I've told my children I want to be a proper grandparents- ie taking them for occasional weekends/school hols to do fun things like baking, trips to park. I'm also happy to see them with their parents. I'm not willing to offer regular childcare. I've been a single parent to four children and I work in a nursery. I'm done with caring for children. It's also possible I will change my mind once grandchildren arrive!

BruFord · 07/02/2024 21:18

kintra · 07/02/2024 19:06

@Fluorescentgem at that stage I'll feel too old to do more than a bit of occasional babysitting or days out.

How can you know this? Lots of people in their 60s are still active and capable. Don't write yourself off before you even get there. Now, if you just don't want to, that's fair enough.

This is a really interesting thread to read as a childfree person/slight fence sitter. It sounds like most of you didn't really enjoy raising children.

@kintra That's the point though, grandparents have already raised their children and been through that stage in life. They may have loved it, but they also may not want to do it again.

I'd like to be somewhat involved if I become a GP, but I’m not sure how much. I’m nearly 50 with teenagers and there’s a lot that I want to achieve in the next 30 years that’s not child-centered. Even though I love being a Mum, it was the right life choice for me.

Ap24 · 07/02/2024 20:23

Duchydutch · 07/02/2024 07:12

Completely agree, the younger generation believe they’re entitled to free grandparent childcare with no regard that the grandparents might want to enjoy their retirement.

All of us? That's a bit of a generalisation. We won't be expecting or wanting any free childcare.

Vroomfondleswaistcoat · 07/02/2024 19:55

kintra · 07/02/2024 19:06

@Fluorescentgem at that stage I'll feel too old to do more than a bit of occasional babysitting or days out.

How can you know this? Lots of people in their 60s are still active and capable. Don't write yourself off before you even get there. Now, if you just don't want to, that's fair enough.

This is a really interesting thread to read as a childfree person/slight fence sitter. It sounds like most of you didn't really enjoy raising children.

A lot of us here were single parents. When you've single handedly raised kids with no input from the other parent and quite often without family help, yes, you can see how hard it is but I think you think "well, if I could do it, anyone can." It also can mean that we've had less time to spend on ourselves during our child raising years and want to have a bit of time doing what WE want, without having to be too tied to school holidays/pick up time etc.

Doesn't mean we will cast our children off with no help whatsoever, just that we think we deserve a little bit of TLC for ourselves rather than being on call 24/7 as some seem to be.

AhNowTed · 07/02/2024 19:44

kintra · 07/02/2024 19:06

@Fluorescentgem at that stage I'll feel too old to do more than a bit of occasional babysitting or days out.

How can you know this? Lots of people in their 60s are still active and capable. Don't write yourself off before you even get there. Now, if you just don't want to, that's fair enough.

This is a really interesting thread to read as a childfree person/slight fence sitter. It sounds like most of you didn't really enjoy raising children.

Sorry but that's a ridiculous statement to make.

Just because I don't want to raise babies and toddlers all over again in my 60s having worked all my life, does not mean I didn't enjoy raising my children.

And to your other point, just because I am active in my 60s, does not make me prime candidate to raise children all over again.

kintra · 07/02/2024 19:06

@Fluorescentgem at that stage I'll feel too old to do more than a bit of occasional babysitting or days out.

How can you know this? Lots of people in their 60s are still active and capable. Don't write yourself off before you even get there. Now, if you just don't want to, that's fair enough.

This is a really interesting thread to read as a childfree person/slight fence sitter. It sounds like most of you didn't really enjoy raising children.

Beetlebumz · 07/02/2024 19:04

Why do you presume they will have children? Many young people are deciding against it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread