Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Social Media should be banned for under 16s

164 replies

Halfmanhalfcake · 05/02/2024 10:00

Off the back of Esther Gheys campaigning about phone use and social media,
I was thinking how bonkers it is that we (as a society) haven't put in stricter controls over social media / internet use for kids yet.

It's as if the technology has developed too quickly, and parents have been left scrabbling around trying to control whatever they can, in what is essentially a completely unregulated cyber world.

I realise that some people are anti nanny-state, but imagine if CBBC started showing snuff films or porn in the middle of some teen drama. When mental health problems in children are soaring, and there is some evidence to show a link to phone / social media use, it seems totally nuts that regulation isn't being enforced at a higher level.

I see grown adults lose all perspective just from being on twitter, how on earth do we think kids can handle it better?

What benefit is it for children under 16 to be on social media? So they can do some tik-tok dance craze? If you want to do a dance just do it in your front room with your mates. To post posey-influencer style images at 13/14? For whose benefit?

I've heard people argue that its unrealistic to think that it can be changed now. Why? My kids are still young so maybe i dont understand.

OP posts:
Needmorelego · 05/02/2024 11:33

@ArseInTheCoOpWindow well yes all autistic teens are different.
Mine would be very lonely without it.

BoohooWoohoo · 05/02/2024 11:31

InAnotherLifetimeMaybe · 05/02/2024 11:10

The 12 year old of today whose parent smugly states 'they don't have it' .... the problem can hit later. Aged 14/15 is very very different to 12

Or they are gaming online and communicating with randoms. I’ve sat in the room while my ds games and there are young primary kids on Fortnite who happily offer their name and school to random adults who can talk to them . I heard a young primary school kid say that he was home alone- scary stuff.

Halfmanhalfcake · 05/02/2024 11:28

But a bonkbuster is COMPLETELY different to the stuff they can be exposed to on the internet.

I'm not advocating for a total ban, or for an abdication of parental responsibility and communication. Perhaps the age limit thing wouldn't work, but that doesn't mean nothing should be done. And if I'm honest, I find that attitude a bit perplexing - but again I'm missing something?

@SoIRejoined analogy with cars is a great one.

OP posts:
ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 05/02/2024 11:26

Needmorelego · 05/02/2024 10:36

@DoIHaveNameRegret unfortunately as an autistic teen without social media/internet she would probably have a very lonely life.
It's how she has found her "tribe".

My Dd is ASD. She won’t use social media.

Needmorelego · 05/02/2024 11:24

The thing is teens have always done things that aren't completely safe or sensible. Look at frequent comments on Mumsnet about how "in my day" teens would hang around the local rec drinking cheap cider and smoking.
The amount of Mumsnetters who talk of reading"bonkbuster" novels and Cosmopolitan magazine at 12 year old.
It shouldn't (couldn't) be banned. It's impossible.
It's down to parents/guardians to be aware of what their children are doing.

Halfmanhalfcake · 05/02/2024 11:23

thecatsthecats · 05/02/2024 11:19

I am a data privacy and IT specialist and I'm on the fence about this.

On the one hand, I know the laws and the technical controls well. There's plenty of under used control mechanisms.

On the other hand, I've been banging my head against a brick wall with my employers (charities that offer support to the vulnerable) to employ themselves mechanisms, and get nowhere until something happens.

My role as DPO is legally protected, and they are supposed to have a damn good reason for rejecting my instructions.

This is really interesting, why do you think they reject it so much?

OP posts:
InAnotherLifetimeMaybe · 05/02/2024 11:23

And what magically happens when they turn 16?

OrlandointheWilderness · 05/02/2024 11:20

InAnotherLifetimeMaybe · 05/02/2024 11:19

Won't stop her creating an account on a mates phone or simply watching over their shoulder and joining in that way

Kids find a way! People seem to constantly upgrade phones and old phones are simply given away

Then I will deal with that when and if happens. Doesn't mean I should blindly turn all restrictions off and let her get on with it does it!

thecatsthecats · 05/02/2024 11:19

I am a data privacy and IT specialist and I'm on the fence about this.

On the one hand, I know the laws and the technical controls well. There's plenty of under used control mechanisms.

On the other hand, I've been banging my head against a brick wall with my employers (charities that offer support to the vulnerable) to employ themselves mechanisms, and get nowhere until something happens.

My role as DPO is legally protected, and they are supposed to have a damn good reason for rejecting my instructions.

InAnotherLifetimeMaybe · 05/02/2024 11:19

Won't stop her creating an account on a mates phone or simply watching over their shoulder and joining in that way

Kids find a way! People seem to constantly upgrade phones and old phones are simply given away

OrlandointheWilderness · 05/02/2024 11:15

InAnotherLifetimeMaybe · 05/02/2024 11:10

The 12 year old of today whose parent smugly states 'they don't have it' .... the problem can hit later. Aged 14/15 is very very different to 12

That would be me then. I wasn't smug - I was factual. My 12 year old DOESN'T have it. Her internet use is heavily monitored and restricted and I believe that should be the case for all children.
Her internet will continue to be controlled until she is grown up enough to manage it herself, and that will not be at 14/15. That is the condition of her having it.

SoIRejoined · 05/02/2024 11:13

When cars were invented there weren't any safety rules, but gradually as more and more people got killed, we brought in laws, safety measures, the highway code etc. That's what needs to happen with the internet and SM. We don't just throw our hands up and say oh well we can't stop it now. We need to find ways to keep the benefits and lessen the harm, with stricter laws and higher expectations about protecting kids.

RonObvious · 05/02/2024 11:13

Goldensnitchupthejacksie · 05/02/2024 11:09

I don't have a full grasp of what's going on with the internet these days but I'm 36 and when I was a young teenager the internet was the absolute Wild West. I feel like everything is homogenised now and everyone spends their lives on the same handful of websites on repeat.

Late 90s/early 2000s the "internet" was chat forums and the like, endless illegal downloads off Limewire, talking to fuck knows who on Habbo Hotel and the like for hours. My friend and I were in fits of giggles having "cyber sex" with strangers. God knows who was on the other end asking us "ASL"

It's better and worse now. Parents just don't know what their kids are up to now. But neither did my parents then. They didn't have a clue.

You cannot get the genie back in the lamp now. Parents have to wise up. My child is 2 and god knows how things will have changed by the time he's a teenager. We'll just have to wait and see and do what we can in the meantime. He is not allowed a tablet any time soon for a start.

This is so true! I remember when anything you used to search for on the internet would bring back results for porn sites. And no, it wasn't based on my search history - I don't even think that was a thing then. I used to try and search for the most bland, boring things possible, just to see if there was anything that wouldn't result in at least one porn link! You had to be careful not to scroll too far down your search results.

InAnotherLifetimeMaybe · 05/02/2024 11:10

The 12 year old of today whose parent smugly states 'they don't have it' .... the problem can hit later. Aged 14/15 is very very different to 12

Goldensnitchupthejacksie · 05/02/2024 11:09

I don't have a full grasp of what's going on with the internet these days but I'm 36 and when I was a young teenager the internet was the absolute Wild West. I feel like everything is homogenised now and everyone spends their lives on the same handful of websites on repeat.

Late 90s/early 2000s the "internet" was chat forums and the like, endless illegal downloads off Limewire, talking to fuck knows who on Habbo Hotel and the like for hours. My friend and I were in fits of giggles having "cyber sex" with strangers. God knows who was on the other end asking us "ASL"

It's better and worse now. Parents just don't know what their kids are up to now. But neither did my parents then. They didn't have a clue.

You cannot get the genie back in the lamp now. Parents have to wise up. My child is 2 and god knows how things will have changed by the time he's a teenager. We'll just have to wait and see and do what we can in the meantime. He is not allowed a tablet any time soon for a start.

RonObvious · 05/02/2024 11:08

I don't think banning social media is the answer, but I do think that companies need to take more responsibility for what is being shown on their apps. There was an investigation a while back, for example, where they found paedophile groups on Facebook, handed the information to Facebook, and nothing was done. Personally, I allow my kids access to some sites / apps (although not TikTok, Facebook, or Instagram), but keep a close eye on what they are accessing. I would rather navigate with them, rather than ban everything and let them deal with it all as older teens. My daughter has whatsapp, but isn't allowed to join any groups (they are toxic swamps!).

But I also think social media is a bit of a red herring in the case of Brianna Ghey. One of the killers had been accessing the dark web for some time, and that's a whole other ballgame.

Halfmanhalfcake · 05/02/2024 11:07

But self-regulating doesnt stop you from accessing porn, or self-harm websites. I'll just use them for 30 mins Mon- Wed.

OP posts:
Oakstreet · 05/02/2024 11:06

Needmorelego · 05/02/2024 10:55

@Whattodowithit88 how do you define "educational" though.
My daughter goes on forums/chats and has (sometimes very in-depth) discussions on books, films, theatre etc.
Her reading range is amazing - reading books that she has learned about through social media. She discusses authors and genres.
She debates the differences between new and old versions of films and talks about stage plays. She and her online pals will discuss and analyse every detail of a film sometimes 😂
She also watches a billion videos of how to hand rear kittens.

This! Aside from her obsession with skin care yes I hate that. It's absolutely got amazing learning opportunities for kids. Mine is artistic and using graphics too. Very savvy. It's about teaching them to self regulate.

Oakstreet · 05/02/2024 11:02

Halfmanhalfcake · 05/02/2024 10:00

Off the back of Esther Gheys campaigning about phone use and social media,
I was thinking how bonkers it is that we (as a society) haven't put in stricter controls over social media / internet use for kids yet.

It's as if the technology has developed too quickly, and parents have been left scrabbling around trying to control whatever they can, in what is essentially a completely unregulated cyber world.

I realise that some people are anti nanny-state, but imagine if CBBC started showing snuff films or porn in the middle of some teen drama. When mental health problems in children are soaring, and there is some evidence to show a link to phone / social media use, it seems totally nuts that regulation isn't being enforced at a higher level.

I see grown adults lose all perspective just from being on twitter, how on earth do we think kids can handle it better?

What benefit is it for children under 16 to be on social media? So they can do some tik-tok dance craze? If you want to do a dance just do it in your front room with your mates. To post posey-influencer style images at 13/14? For whose benefit?

I've heard people argue that its unrealistic to think that it can be changed now. Why? My kids are still young so maybe i dont understand.

I've seen grown adults lose all perspective watching the BBC and reading the drivel of shit on the MSM. I'm not on twitter, but the world has changed a lot. There are more individual perceptions, not every human has the same viewpoint. The same body or mind. I can't see anyone going back on this. Technology and the digital world is here to stay. We should be teaching children to self regulated. I agree with tik tok ban it for under 16 !

InAnotherLifetimeMaybe · 05/02/2024 11:02

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Hmm... hadn't thought of that. You do have a point

OdeToBarney · 05/02/2024 11:00

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

I have to agree with this. Pro-ana sites for starters. But, it isn't a race to the bottom and I'd welcome some kind of regulation around kids and social media. I see enough problems with social media between adults in my job, let alone kids. I was probably one of the last age groups to get through school before sm really took off, but I'm terrified for my DD's future.

EasternStandard · 05/02/2024 10:59

OrlandointheWilderness · 05/02/2024 10:54

My 12 year old doesn't have social media. It's up to the parents IMO. It's not difficult.

Agree too

Halfmanhalfcake · 05/02/2024 10:59

To all the parents who have a strong handle on managing their kids social media use, that's great. Genuinely. If all parents were like you we probably wouldn't have half the problems we do.But they're not. So what do you do for their kids?

With the best will in the world, it's a bit of an 'I'm alright jack' attitude. Which I do get, when my kids get to that age I hope I can talk with the authority and conviction you do. But that doesn't also mean I don't want the internet / social media to be a safer space for everybody.

OP posts:
BromCavMum · 05/02/2024 10:59

My 15yo has a smart phone, but all SM is blocked through parental controls and on other devices she has access to. When she's 16 we will begin to look at getting her on SM with guidance and advice from me.

DS, 12 only has a dumb phone, and also no SM on other devices. My kids still have friends, still meet up and hang out with others. Kids do not need SM to have a life.

However, I agree that SM companies must do more to protect children. While 16 is not a magic age, it's fair to say that kids under that age are definitely too young for it. Age verification and getting rid of harmful content would be a start.

DojaPhat · 05/02/2024 10:58

@MrsTingly I've never understood that line of argument either - people still smoke so why ban cigarettes, people are still fat so why ban cake? It's just so circular.