Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Social Media should be banned for under 16s

164 replies

Halfmanhalfcake · 05/02/2024 10:00

Off the back of Esther Gheys campaigning about phone use and social media,
I was thinking how bonkers it is that we (as a society) haven't put in stricter controls over social media / internet use for kids yet.

It's as if the technology has developed too quickly, and parents have been left scrabbling around trying to control whatever they can, in what is essentially a completely unregulated cyber world.

I realise that some people are anti nanny-state, but imagine if CBBC started showing snuff films or porn in the middle of some teen drama. When mental health problems in children are soaring, and there is some evidence to show a link to phone / social media use, it seems totally nuts that regulation isn't being enforced at a higher level.

I see grown adults lose all perspective just from being on twitter, how on earth do we think kids can handle it better?

What benefit is it for children under 16 to be on social media? So they can do some tik-tok dance craze? If you want to do a dance just do it in your front room with your mates. To post posey-influencer style images at 13/14? For whose benefit?

I've heard people argue that its unrealistic to think that it can be changed now. Why? My kids are still young so maybe i dont understand.

OP posts:
asterel · 05/02/2024 12:31

@YetMoreNewBeginnings

I teach 18-22 age students, and by that age they are universally telling me they wish they had had more restrictions on their internet and social media / phone use during their teenage years. Many are already doing “digital detoxes” and so on at that age and telling me not to let my kids have phones! Social media seems to be a generalised bad experience for them even when they’ve only had it for a few years.

So it can’t be that there are loads of wonderful positives to it that outweigh the bad stuff, or why do my students already by 18 think that it’s been a uniformly negative experience for them? Doesn’t that suggest that they’d have been better off having less of it, if any? So maybe we adults need to step up and step in.

Oblomov23 · 05/02/2024 12:28

Sorry. Posted by accident.

But. To talk about banning is just utterly ridiculous and it's embarrassing and I certainly don't want to be associated with such nonsense.

I support all sorts of choices. If people want better apps, more restrictions, further development, so parents have more options. Fine.

But banning. No. To even suggest it is ridiculous. I enjoy social media. I don't have any problems with it and neither do my boys and I certainly won't support Ridiculous ideas such as banning because I just think it's silly.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 05/02/2024 12:25

I don't think banning things until an age where teens generally think they know it all is remotely a good idea.

In fact having seen the state a uni mate of my DD1's got into in his first year at uni having been banned/shielded from a lot, I think it's a terrible idea.

I do wish more schools were able to do what my DD4's primary school do/can. The husband of the HT works for CEOP. He does an annual chat at the school for parents and a separate one for the older children as many get mobiles just before going to high school. He puts the fear of god into the parents by showing them how easy it is for people to track kids and/or chat to them through "safe" apps. He teaches people how to use the apps that are most popular with the kids at that point. A local company provide a really nice afternoon tea and school staff very kindly play games with the children so parents are very much tempted to go. And then even the ones only going for the cakes seem to end up learning something helpful. He does similar with the children, but in an age appropriate way.

I've had a lot of grief over the years because other parents felt I was ridiculously strict with phones as the children got older. No phones in bedrooms overnight, any downloads have to be approved from my phone and any contacts added have to be run by me. We checked phones - sometimes often if they were young or something was going on, sometimes less often if there wasn't. We always had a rule where there was no trouble/grief about something I wasn't going to be happy with if it was brought up before I found it on their phone. It made the children feel secure about being open about what was going on as I wasn't going to hit the roof.

The three eldest are all uni age now and two of them have said they feel we should be even tighter on the younger ones because of how bad it is online now. One of them still tells her friends "Urgh my mum is a nightmare and bans my phone at night" when she's home as she finds it hard still to just ignore messages and the likes.

I think a balance of education, age appropriate access, boundaries and trust is needed. It's incredibly difficult to get all of those spot on all of the time. I've been quite lucky that my way has worked well with the elder three - not always perfect, but enough. I just have to hope it works with the younger ones in a similar way (with tweaks along the way as technology and their personalities change!)

Oblomov23 · 05/02/2024 12:25

@Halfmanhalfcake

Oh purlease. I didn't say that: my kids are ok so no comment needed? I never said that.

But you only have to read a few mn threads to know there's tonnes and tonnes of things parents can do. Lists of monitoring, checking, tracking, reading dc's chats if you want to, apps and controls that parents can use if they want to. Talking to your child about it. Might help!

I chose not use any tracking, no monitoring, no restrictions, nothing. But that's because if the character of my ds's and the fact was I never needed to, because they never saw any bullying, never posted anything silly, no dick pics!

Just because I took a relaxed stance, doesn't mean I'm not aware of the issues other parents have had. am

WhiteLily1 · 05/02/2024 12:24

Halfmanhalfcake · 05/02/2024 12:11

Chat about what though? @WhiteLily1 Whats your point?

That it's hard to say to your kids that they can't go on social media? That when they're walking home from school it's impossible to know what they get up to on their phones? That they need SM to meet friends, or because they're complaining to you that their mates are doing a viral video and they can't join in? Fine, but that doesnt negate the need for regulation.

There's just a bit of a throw your arms up attitude like nothing can be done. You know there is LOADS of controls that companies / government can be put on the internet to make it safer? They're choosing not to do this.

More can be done, sure. Parents also need to take far far more responsibility and parental controls and how to use them need to be easier to implement, even more robust so more parents put these in place more.

It’s the banning social media for under 16’s title I was referring to. It’s just not something that would ever be able to happen. That horse has well and truly bolted.
How about we ban all disposable nappies and all formula for babies under 1. We all know disposable nappies are awful for the environment and breastfeeding is proven to be far more beneficial for the baby. I mean I’m being OTT but you get my drift.

I think it’s just hard to get a grip on parenting teenagers until you have one yourself as it’s a completely different ball game.

A bit like someone telling you how to parent a newborn, making judgements and having the answers when they haven’t had one themselves.

asterel · 05/02/2024 12:23

I’d favour just denormalising it in the first instance - schools saying pupils can only bring brick and not smartphones to school, more of making it okay for kids not to have them. I recently went round a mixture of state and independent schools to look at with DD. All the kids at the state comps had (expensive!) smartphones, and the schools also made a big deal about setting them homework online, using apps and so on.

The independent schools all had an anti-smartphone/social media culture, and when you asked the kids who took you round on tours they said that phones aren’t a big deal and it’s quite normal for kids in the school not to have a smartphone or social media before at least year 9. So it obviously can be done. And it’s very telling that expensive independent schools are trying to denormalise smartphones. State schools and parents could easily follow suit and just try to stop normalising the idea amongst parents that every kid must have a smartphone at ten or 11 or they’ll be somehow “left out” or socially inadequate.

(If anything, it’s starting to look like the reverse. Too much time online hampers kids’ lives, social and academic skills and life choices, and will set them back in life, whereas parents and schools who restrict it will end up better adjusted.)

ilovebreadsauce · 05/02/2024 12:21

Anybody who works in a school knows the negative impact sm has on kids MH and hiw much school time is spent dealing with the SM fallout even in upper KS2

cordeliachaseatemyhandbag · 05/02/2024 12:19

I agree

WhiteLily1 · 05/02/2024 12:17

The thing is all the parental controls are there for you to use! Your child can have 20 mins of Instagram on their phone to catch up with mates posts etc for example before it the app turns off.
You can approve every app or not approve.
Your child / teen doesn’t need a laptop in their room with unmonitored safari. If you actually bother to learn the tech (which every parent should!)
then there are so many things you can use, and no, if you know what you are doing, and are around keeping an eye on your teen, it’s not that easy for them just to ‘get around it’
Of course, they can and will see things on other kids phones- can’t get around that one but that’s not where the main damage is done IMO.
It’s being on their own, in their room with unfiltered devices for hours that’s the problem.
And yes, I do have multiple teen children before anyone asks!

Halfmanhalfcake · 05/02/2024 12:14

@Oblomov23 I used that title because thats what Esther Ghey is suggesting. If you read my posts youll see that Im suggesting theres many ways to tackle the problem.

But as long as your kids are alright then theres not a problem, right?

OP posts:
Needmorelego · 05/02/2024 12:11

@asterel I actually agree with you - there is a lot of horrible horrible stuff out there online.
But we can't simply ban it and think it will go away.
I don't have a solution - more education about internet safety?
Maybe giving more giving children and teens better opportunities for self esteem and confidence so they don't go searching out things that lead to inappropriate content.
The current education system is letting so many children down that their mental health, confidence and general happiness is poor - so they are seeking out answers - which leads by just a few clicks to the inappropriate stuff.

Oblomov23 · 05/02/2024 12:11

I'm assuming OP deliberately used a ott and hysterical thread title for effect? What exactly are you suggesting should be done? Ban it? Oh purlease.

Because I've never had any problems with either ds's SM. Eldest is currently at uni. I've never tracked them, monitored them, looked at their phones. Never needed to. No bullying, no nastiness, no problems, nothing. They know my expectations. Most caring parents talk to their dc about what they consider reasonable.

Halfmanhalfcake · 05/02/2024 12:11

Chat about what though? @WhiteLily1 Whats your point?

That it's hard to say to your kids that they can't go on social media? That when they're walking home from school it's impossible to know what they get up to on their phones? That they need SM to meet friends, or because they're complaining to you that their mates are doing a viral video and they can't join in? Fine, but that doesnt negate the need for regulation.

There's just a bit of a throw your arms up attitude like nothing can be done. You know there is LOADS of controls that companies / government can be put on the internet to make it safer? They're choosing not to do this.

OP posts:
WhiteLily1 · 05/02/2024 12:05

Megifer · 05/02/2024 10:40

"My kids are still young so maybe i dont understand."

I think this is a very accurate statement.

Exactly 🤣
OP come back to us when your kids are 15. We can chat then.

asterel · 05/02/2024 12:00

I think people who say (as in this thread) things about how it’s always been like this, they need to find their tribe, it’s got great opportunities on it as well, it’s all about parental control — have NO idea of the kind of content that’s out there.

I use tumblr/various discord servers/other “young” social media as part of a hobby, and I have been sent unsolicited porn involving violence, group sex and very young-looking girls that made me as a fortysomething shocked and physically sick. It’s not remotely like a bit of Jilly Cooper or an old fashioned girlie magazine.

I’ve watched groups of very young women on Discord (young women largely because of the nature of my hobby; I’m sure the same thing happens with young men on gaming sites etc too), be convinced into various kinds of scams and downright harmful nonsense, bizarre ideas and quite dangerous behaviour because of getting into a group mentality on social media sites, especially around mental health, gender issues, self-harm and eating, and no sensible advice or facts gets them out of quite cultish groupthink. Very similar to the pro-eating disorder groups. They suck young people in and become an alternative to real life. I also see the normalisation among them of quite extreme “kink” discourse, where girls in their late teens and early 20s are talking about rape/bdsm/choking and incest fantasies as not just normal forms of sex but cool and edgy.

Because the social media sites use algorithms that target you, you might use Tiktok or Twitter and never see anything like that because you’re a middle-aged woman who likes recipes, kittens and funny videos of women crawling through windows. Your teenage kids don’t get that content - they are targeted with different content.

On a more mundane level, my DD (11) who doesn’t have social media tells me about girls at her school messaging men on Roblox in the middle of the night and “dating” people online that their parents have no knowledge of. School had to deal recently with many of the year 6 kids bullying each other on WhatsApp at 3 and 4am. Now, that sort of bullying stuff might well be easily dealt with by better parental control; but how are you going to stop them seeing content that is damaging and harmful?

Are you going to be sitting there looking at it over their shoulder every literal second they use it? Because if you aren’t, it’s fabulously naive and gullible to think that you are getting parental control over what they can see. And I for one think that if my DD saw even a second of some of the porn I’ve seen - unsolicited - on SM, at 11 YEARS OLD, it would be traumatising and damaging and something you can’t just unsee or easily fix. At 11 I was still reading Malory Towers and watching children’s television (as are my DD and her friends). There’s a big gulf even between 11 year olds and 14 or 15 year olds. I would be very upset if my 15 year old had seen some of the porn that circulates on social media, but it would be less damaging than an 11 year old seeing it. I still don’t think 15 year olds should see that kind of content though!

But bear in mind that if you just use the internet and social media as an adult, you won’t see it yourself and you won’t know what’s out there.

Needmorelego · 05/02/2024 11:58

@CroftonWillow it was via social media that I discovered my hobby group which is now a major part of my life and I talk (online) to people within that hobby from all over the world.
I use Facebook a lot for local events and news and other interest groups and have a lot of fun with it.
My life would be quite boring without social media.
I have no interest in influencer type posts so I don't look at them.

Needmorelego · 05/02/2024 11:54

@CreateHope one daughter age 15 who is autistic.
We are very strict on monitoring.
All our phones (hers, mine, her dads) are linked so we can see what she (and each other) are up to.
We check her laptop regularly.
We did have issues in the past which caused some problems so we are now very very strict.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 05/02/2024 11:50

Halfmanhalfcake · 05/02/2024 10:42

@Megifer but wouldn't you welcome help with managing the content that your child is exposed to? I'm not saying ban phones, or even like esther ghey suggested, have kids phones ( I dont think thats realistic).

I actually think the suggestion of "kids' phones" is far more realistic than the idea of trying to ban social media for kids using ordinary phones. It would be far more enforceable, and I reckon Esther Ghey suggested that precisely because she recognised that simply banning social media for kids under a certain age would never work.

Lots of apps have age limits already. I think WhatsApp is 16 if I remember rightly, and most of the others are around 13. The vast majority of kids have these apps way before the minimum age, so the current restrictions are pretty meaningless in practice.

Personally, I think a lot of it does come back to parenting, and monitoring what your child is doing online, maintaining an open dialogue about what they're seeing/ doing, and teaching them how to stay safe etc. That's much harder and more labour-intensive than saying "we'll just ban it all", but probably the safest option overall - we all know that kids will find ways of circumventing age restrictions when they want to!

InAnotherLifetimeMaybe · 05/02/2024 11:43

CreateHope · 05/02/2024 11:37

@InAnotherLifetimeMaybe nothing “magically happens” but it’s not a huge reach to understand that a 16 yr old would have more maturity than MOST 10 yr olds. I’m blindsided that people don’t get this. The stuff that my DC can access now is way too adult for them - it makes me very sad.

It's the older teens who are having issues and getting into trouble

Not so much '10 year olds'

So at 16 when mumsnetters think it's ok to have SM isn't that going to be the worst time not the best.

Halfmanhalfcake · 05/02/2024 11:42

@Needmorelego The 90s were horrific for women. And Im glad that the tides have turned slightly.

If your 14 year old is doing homework, needing internet access, and whilst theyre doing that they look at porn, anorexia, self harm websites, and then clear their history what are you going to do? Stand over them the entire time theyre doing their homework? Or theyre hanging out after school and their mate shows them that stuff?

Its VERY different to a bonkbuster.

OP posts:
CroftonWillow · 05/02/2024 11:38

Honestly I wish it would be banned for everyone. The evidence is in, it's done/doing far more harm to society than good.

CreateHope · 05/02/2024 11:38

@Needmorelego I missed how old your kids are but good luck with the parental monitoring 😬

Needmorelego · 05/02/2024 11:37

@Halfmanhalfcake are "bonkbuster" books really that different?
I mean a generation of females grew up reading them plus Cosmo etc magazines - giving them a distorted view of sexual relationships, how to "please your man", unrealistic beauty standards, body images etc.
Yes there is extreme stuff on the internet but that's why it's down to parents to monitor.

CreateHope · 05/02/2024 11:37

@InAnotherLifetimeMaybe nothing “magically happens” but it’s not a huge reach to understand that a 16 yr old would have more maturity than MOST 10 yr olds. I’m blindsided that people don’t get this. The stuff that my DC can access now is way too adult for them - it makes me very sad.

CreateHope · 05/02/2024 11:35

@ExtraOnions are you seriously suggesting that social media has no effect on young people’s mental health? 😳

Bloody hell. The naivety from some posters on here is terrifying.

Swipe left for the next trending thread